
GITNUXSOFTWARE REVIEW
Cybersecurity & Information SecurityTop 10 Best Phishing Email Testing Software of 2026
A market roundup of phishing email testing software tools, comparing Microsoft Attack Simulation Training, Cofense PhishMe, and KnowBe4 for IT security teams.
How we ranked these tools
Vendors set the topic, but our editors set the inclusion criteria and the evaluation framework before research starts.
Search agents gather the source set and the review record, including transcriptions of video reviews and podcasts.
Framework: Features 40% · Ease 30% · Value 30%
Gitnux may earn a commission through links on this page. This does not influence our reviews. Editorial policy
Microsoft Attack Simulation Training is the best pick for Microsoft 365 identity-led enterprise teams because its identity-aware targeting and reporting ties simulation results to directory context, whereas usecure fits SMB and cross-team setups thanks to reusable scenario templates and outcome tracking for clicks and credential submissions.
Editor’s top 3 picks
Three quick recommendations before you dive into the full comparison below — each one leads on a different dimension.
Microsoft Attack Simulation Training
Identity-aware campaign targeting and reporting inside the Microsoft ecosystem connects user results to directory context.
Best for: Fits when Microsoft 365 identity is the system of record and training administration must use RBAC and directory groups.
Cofense PhishMe
Editor pickUser reporting correlation that connects simulation outcomes to real report behavior for repeat offender tracking.
Best for: Fits when security teams need governed phishing tests plus user reporting signals for targeted follow-up.
KnowBe4
Editor pickJust-in-time security awareness training triggered from campaign results to reinforce users who click or fail a simulation.
Best for: Fits when security awareness programs need recurring simulations, training follow-up, and controlled reporting across many departments.
Comparison Table
Microsoft Attack Simulation Training
enterpriseMicrosoft Attack Simulation Training tests phishing resilience within Microsoft Defender for Office 365.
Identity-aware campaign targeting and reporting inside the Microsoft ecosystem connects user results to directory context.
Microsoft Attack Simulation Training generates simulated phishing email campaigns with selectable scenarios that include web links, attachments, and credential-harvesting style templates. It ties simulations to Microsoft 365 identity context so messages, user targeting, and results align with directory-backed groups and enrollment workflows.
Built on the Microsoft security ecosystem, it produces campaign analytics and reporting plus trainer-based follow-up actions tied to outcomes. Automation and administration are handled through Microsoft-managed configuration and role-based access for security and helpdesk stakeholders.
- +Scenario library covers link, attachment, and credential-harvesting style simulations in one console
- +Campaign results roll into Microsoft reporting views aligned with user identity
- +Directory-backed targeting supports group-based enrollment and repeat campaign plans
- +RBAC controls separate training administration from broader security operations
- –Less flexible mail-template customization than standalone phishing platforms
- –Automation depth depends on Microsoft identity setup and consistent group management
- –Advanced scenarios may require tighter governance to avoid training noise
- –Reporting detail can be harder to export for non-Microsoft analytics workflows
Microsoft 365 security operations teams
Simulate link and attachment phishing templates
Consistent, identity-aligned results
Security awareness program managers
Measure reporting and follow-up training
Behavior-based remediation
Best for: Fits when Microsoft 365 identity is the system of record and training administration must use RBAC and directory groups.
Cofense PhishMe
enterpriseCofense PhishMe runs phishing simulations and supports employee reporting of suspicious messages.
User reporting correlation that connects simulation outcomes to real report behavior for repeat offender tracking.
Cofense PhishMe supports phishing email campaign creation from predefined templates and then delivery to selected user groups through scheduled runs. It emphasizes reporting button integration so staff can submit suspected messages and results can be correlated back to the originating campaign. Campaign reporting and user outcomes are tracked in a way that supports repeat offender monitoring and follow-on training decisions. Admin controls cover enrollment scoping and campaign configuration so teams can keep testing aligned to internal policies.
A notable tradeoff is that deeper mail client integration and reporting behavior are sensitive to environment configuration and user device behavior. PhishMe fits best when security teams already have consistent email delivery paths and want reporting data tied to campaigns rather than only measuring click-through from simulated messages. It is also a practical fit for organizations that need disciplined campaign governance across departments with different risk thresholds.
- +Reporting button data ties user actions back to each test campaign
- +Template-based campaign builds reduce time spent on message creation
- +Group scoping and scheduling supports governed, repeatable testing cycles
- +Repeat-offender tracking supports targeted remediation over blanket training
- –Reporting and message behavior depend on client and environment configuration
- –Some advanced customization requires more admin effort than basic template usage
- –Campaign outcomes can be harder to interpret without consistent enrollment hygiene
Security operations teams
Run scheduled phishing tests with reporting capture
More actionable remediation lists
Security awareness program owners
Reduce repeat clickers with follow-on training
Lower repeated susceptibility
Show 1 more scenario
IT governance teams
Control who participates in phishing tests
Audit-friendly participation control
Enrollment scoping and campaign configuration keep tests aligned to internal risk rules.
Best for: Fits when security teams need governed phishing tests plus user reporting signals for targeted follow-up.
KnowBe4
enterpriseKnowBe4 provides simulated phishing campaigns, training content, and reporting for security awareness programs.
Just-in-time security awareness training triggered from campaign results to reinforce users who click or fail a simulation.
KnowBe4 provides a phishing email testing workflow paired with security awareness training under one administrative control plane. It supports customizable phishing simulations that can include embedded links, landing page cloning, and user-specific enrollment via directory-driven targeting.
Reporting and reinforcement features track who clicked and reported, then route users into follow-up training based on campaign results. Its configuration model is built around scenario libraries, campaign scheduling, and governance-oriented admin settings for managing breadth across large user populations.
- +Scenario-based campaign builder supports repeated phishing email campaigns
- +Landing page cloning reduces friction for convincing credential-harvesting simulations
- +Directory-driven user enrollment helps keep phishing targeting current
- +Report button integrations connect user actions to campaign analytics
- –Advanced customization requires deeper admin configuration than scripted setups
- –Third-party mail client integration coverage can require coordination in complex environments
Security awareness teams
Schedule recurring phishing email simulations
Trend view of susceptibility
Phishing program administrators
Run scenarios with configurable landing pages
Broader threat coverage
Show 2 more scenarios
Security administrators
Remediate high-risk clickers with training
Follow-up training by behavior
Route users who click or submit simulated credentials into targeted follow-up training sessions.
Security risk managers
Combine outcomes with training engagement
Higher-risk group visibility
Use simulation and learning activity to identify higher-risk populations and assess training impact.
Best for: Fits when security awareness programs need recurring simulations, training follow-up, and controlled reporting across many departments.
Barracuda PhishLine
enterpriseBarracuda PhishLine provides simulated phishing campaigns, training, and employee risk reporting.
Policy-driven post-simulation training assignments tied to measurable user interaction outcomes.
Barracuda PhishLine centers on end-to-end phishing email campaign execution with built-in campaign steps for audience targeting, message delivery, and post-simulation training assignment. Campaign results track user actions such as report rate and click behavior, which feed into repeat-remediation style follow-ups. Integration options support common identity and messaging environments, including directory synchronization and mail client integration for feeding user groups into simulations.
- +Campaign outcomes include report and click metrics for measurable susceptibility trending
- +Training follow-ups can be triggered after user interaction with the simulated message
- +Directory synchronization helps keep target groups aligned for repeat campaigns
- +Mail client integration supports practical testing inside real inbox workflows
- –Landing page and attachment realism can require more admin build time
- –Scenario configuration depth can feel heavy for teams running only one-off tests
- –Fine-grained targeting logic can take iteration to match real-world enrollment
- –Reporting views can require admin familiarity to correlate campaign and training outcomes
Security awareness administrators
Monthly phishing testing with remediation
Higher report coverage after rollout
IT governance teams
Controlled enrollment and targeting
Fewer mis-targeted simulations
Show 2 more scenarios
Security operations analysts
Measure click and reporting change
Clearer resilience scoring inputs
Campaign analytics supports trend monitoring across repeated phishing message themes.
Helpdesk and training coordinators
Track repeat offenders
Targeted just-in-time coaching
Repeat tracking helps identify users who repeatedly click or fail to report.
Best for: Fits when teams need governed phishing simulations plus consistent training follow-ups across repeating campaigns.
Hoxhunt
enterpriseHoxhunt delivers adaptive phishing simulations, employee reporting, and automated security training.
In-reporting training that responds to user submissions within the same simulated phishing scenario cycle.
Hoxhunt is built around continuous phishing resilience testing, where campaigns are scheduled and user targeting is controlled by group membership and enrollment workflows. The reporting experience is a first-class path, so users can submit a suspected phishing message and the platform can respond with training content tied to the same scenario. Campaign analytics connects simulated delivery to user actions, which helps teams track susceptibility trends over time rather than isolated test events.
- +Reporting-driven workflow links submissions to scenario-specific training
- +Group-based targeting supports repeat testing without rebuilding campaigns
- +Campaign analytics connects delivery with click and report outcomes
- +Administration controls support segregating permissions for operators
- –Tuning training triggers requires consistent enrollment and group hygiene
- –Mail client and message rendering testing can still surface client-specific differences
- –Advanced automation depends on integration work for identity and targeting
- –Large template customization can slow iteration for rapid scenario changes
Security awareness managers
Monthly phishing resilience program
Improved report rate over time
IT and IAM teams
Group-based user enrollment
Lower operational overhead
Show 1 more scenario
Security operations analysts
Scenario analytics for trend tracking
Actionable susceptibility trend views
Review click and report outcomes to prioritize controls and targeted retraining.
Best for: Fits when security teams need repeat phishing simulations with a tight reporting-to-training loop and group-based targeting.
usecure
SMBusecure provides phishing simulations, security awareness training, and compliance reporting.
Credential-harvesting simulations with scenario templates that are reusable across scheduled phishing email campaigns.
usecure targets teams that need phishing email testing with control over message realism and repeat execution. It supports configurable campaign runs that generate simulated phishing email messages and capture outcomes like clicks and credential submissions.
- +Scenario-oriented campaign setup that repeats consistently across target groups
- +Outcome tracking covers both click behavior and credential submission events
- +Centralized controls for templates and campaign configuration
- +Reporting supports operational review of individual campaign performance
- –Advanced orchestration depends on admin configuration and workflow design
- –Limited visibility into cross-system automation details compared with deeper API-first competitors
Security and IT teams
Run scheduled phishing email exercises
Ongoing risk visibility
Security awareness managers
Test credential-entry scenarios safely
Credential-entry behavior metrics
Show 2 more scenarios
Managed service providers and small IT teams
Administer campaigns across multiple clients
Centralized MSP reporting
Manage phishing campaigns, training, and risk reporting for several environments from a single console.
Security awareness managers
Practice and track report timing
Time-to-report trends
Measure whether employees report simulated messages and track how quickly they report.
Best for: Fits when security teams need repeatable phishing scenarios with strong campaign governance and outcome reporting.
Sophos Phish Threat
SMBSophos Phish Threat provides simulated phishing campaigns, templates, training, and campaign analytics.
Behavior-linked training remediation that maps simulation outcomes to just-in-time user retraining.
Sophos Phish Threat differentiates with a reporting and training workflow centered on risk insights tied to email behavior. It supports simulated phishing email campaigns with selectable templates, scheduled delivery, and user enrollment so teams can run repeat phishing email testing cycles.
- +Ties simulation outcomes to follow-up training actions in one workflow
- +Campaign scheduling supports recurring exercises without manual rebuilding
- +Group-based targeting supports practical enrollment management
- +Analytics emphasize behavioral outcomes like clicks and reports
- –Template customization is constrained compared with fully designed mockups
- –Deep automation depends on tighter integration work for advanced governance
Security awareness teams
Repeat phishing email testing cycles
Repeatable behavior measurement
Security program administrators
Analyze report and click outcomes
Actionable risk insights
Show 1 more scenario
Security operations teams
Trigger training for risky behavior
Faster remediation
Connect campaign outcomes like clicks and reports to just-in-time security awareness remediation.
Best for: Fits when security teams need consistent phishing email testing cycles with behavior-based training follow-through.
Proofpoint Security Awareness Training
enterpriseProofpoint provides phishing simulations, targeted training, and risk reporting for enterprise security teams.
Security awareness training that coordinates campaign outcomes with Proofpoint security stack telemetry for management review.
Proofpoint Security Awareness Training is built for security teams that need end-to-end phishing simulation campaigns paired with ongoing security awareness content. It supports template-driven simulated phishing email workflows with campaign scheduling and target-group segmentation, plus reporting signals tied to user engagement outcomes.
- +Operational alignment with Proofpoint security telemetry used in awareness workflows
- +Campaign scheduling and segmentation support repeatable phishing email campaign operations
- +Reporting ties user actions to training follow-through and management review
- +Admin governance supports controlled enrollment and consistent campaign participation
- –Scenario depth depends on how templates and modules are configured for each use case
- –Mail client integration often requires careful setup to ensure reporting button coverage
- –Advanced reporting and analytics can feel complex without established campaign conventions
- –LMS and SSO integrations can add project overhead during rollout
Security awareness teams
Run scheduled recurring phishing tests
Repeatable engagement view
Phishing program administrators
Refresh scenarios for different threats
Updated threat-specific content
Show 2 more scenarios
Security and learning administrators
Assign lessons with phishing exercises
Learning-linked simulation activity
Deliver assigned security lessons alongside phishing simulations and track learner progress for assigned activities.
Compliance teams and security program owners
Track required training with attestations
Easier compliance monitoring
Manage required learning completion evidence and user attestations within the same phishing simulation workflow.
Best for: Fits when teams already run Proofpoint security controls and want coordinated awareness and phishing testing.
Phished
SMBPhished automates phishing simulations, security training, and user risk scoring.
Repeat offender tracking links ongoing susceptibility trends to specific users across sequential campaigns.
Phished simulates phishing email campaigns by generating controlled target messages and tracking user outcomes inside one workflow. The platform emphasizes template-based scenarios that include credential-harvesting, attachment and link variants, and iterative resends for remediation programs.
- +Scenario templates cover multiple phishing message styles in one campaign workflow
- +Report button and click outcomes tie back to the specific simulation instance
- +Repeat offender tracking supports follow-up messaging for the same users
- +Iterative resends support remediation loops without rebuilding campaigns
- –Scenario setup can require more configuration than manual email template tools
- –Advanced integrations are narrower than enterprise mail and directory stacks
- –Landing page customization can feel limited for complex multi-step credential flows
- –High-volume testing may need careful scheduling to avoid user enrollment lag
Phishing testing and security operations teams
Measure credential-path failure points
Failure point visibility
Security and GRC teams
Test susceptibility by department or role
Group-level susceptibility data
Show 2 more scenarios
Security awareness teams
Run scheduled exercises for reinforcement
Measurable training cadence
Schedule phishing simulations to reinforce awareness and compare behavior over time.
Security operations and GRC teams
Validate anti-phishing control behavior
Evidence of reporting behavior
Use simulations to test whether employees recognize and report threats as part of a prevention program.
Best for: Fits when security teams want template-driven simulations with clear outcome reporting and repeat offender targeting.
Mimecast Awareness Training
enterpriseMimecast Awareness Training supports simulated phishing, online lessons, and user risk reporting.
Awareness reporting that connects simulated phishing clicks and reports back to Mimecast-aligned user activity for remediation cycles.
Mimecast Awareness Training ties phishing simulation delivery to security awareness reporting inside the Mimecast ecosystem, with campaign execution and reinforcement focused on email-based risks. The tool supports templated simulated phishing message creation, scheduled campaign runs, and participant tracking tied to click and report outcomes.
- +Campaign reporting stays aligned with Mimecast email events and user outcomes
- +Template-driven simulated message creation reduces variation between repeated campaigns
- +Target group segmentation supports role-based enrollment and controlled rollout
- +Repeat behavior tracking supports focused retraining for users who re-click
- –Advanced automation beyond Mimecast workflows depends on its integration path
- –Content authoring flexibility is less extensive than tools with deeper template builders
- –Complex multi-environment setups require stronger governance of campaign scope
- –Some scenario formats rely on Mimecast-aligned delivery mechanics rather than fully generic hosting
Security awareness teams
Run scheduled phishing campaigns using templates
Repeatable response measurement
Organizations standardizing Mimecast
Manage awareness alongside email administration
Workflow fit with Mimecast
Show 2 more scenarios
Security awareness and incident response teams
Track reporting improvements over campaigns
Reporting behavior visibility
Measure whether employees identify and report simulated phishing messages across repeated campaign runs.
Security operations and awareness managers
Assign training based on user interactions
Remediation linked to behavior
Use campaign outcomes like click or report interactions to assign targeted follow-up learning.
Best for: Fits when teams already run Mimecast for secure email and want awareness training tied to email outcomes.
Conclusion
After evaluating 10 phishing email testing software, Microsoft Attack Simulation Training stands out as our overall top pick — it scored highest across our combined criteria of features, ease of use, and value, which is why it sits at #1 in the rankings above.
Use the comparison table and detailed reviews above to validate the fit against your own requirements before committing to a tool.
Frequently Asked Questions About Phishing Email Testing Software
How do Hoxhunt and Cofense PhishMe differ in connecting simulation results to user follow-up training?
Which tools support directory-backed targeting and what does “identity-aware enrollment” mean in practice?
When teams need mailbox-adjacent reporting signals, how do Proofpoint Security Awareness Training and Mimecast Awareness Training handle telemetry?
What breaks if an organization cannot integrate reporting with existing security workflows for mailbox and identity operations?
How does Hoxhunt handle group-based campaign orchestration compared with Barracuda PhishLine?
What integration or API requirements typically surface when building automated phishing email campaign operations?
Which tool is better suited to credential-harvesting simulation scenarios with reusable templates?
How do admin controls differ between Mimecast Awareness Training and Microsoft Attack Simulation Training for access management?
When setting up a repeat offender tracking program, how do Phished and Cofense PhishMe differ in outcome correlation?
What data migration challenges appear when onboarding a new tool into an existing campaign library and reporting pipeline?
Tools reviewed
Primary sources checked during evaluation.
Referenced in the comparison table and product reviews above.
How to Choose the Right Phishing Email Testing Software
We look for what separates real-world phishing email testing: how well the tool handles test email content and delivery paths, and how accurately it tracks outcomes back to identities. The biggest differentiator is data and control depth across configuration, reporting, and automation, not just templates.
Test email realism controls
Why it matters
Test email realism controls decide whether users react to behavior similar to actual phishing emails, not an obvious “demo” look. That affects the usefulness of results when you compare across teams and time.
How to check
Ask for a live preview and configure a message end to end: subject, body, sender display, and link behavior. Then send a test to a small group and verify how closely the tool preserves the configured content and clickable links in delivered emails.
Delivery path and routing control
Why it matters
Delivery path and routing control matters because results change when emails take different paths, get modified, or fail SPF/DKIM-style checks. You want confidence that the test matches how real mail reaches users.
How to check
In the demo, check where outbound messages originate and whether the tool supports multiple sending identities or connectors. Ask the tester to show email headers for a sample run and confirm what the tool controls versus what the mail system changes.
Outcome tracking and timing accuracy
Why it matters
Outcome tracking and timing accuracy determines whether the tool distinguishes early engagement from later follow-ups and whether it attributes actions to the right person and run. This is critical when you need reliable comparisons over time.
How to check
Have them run a sample and show the exact timeline for key outcomes (for example open/click events and any subsequent submissions). Confirm the tool links events to a run identifier and a specific recipient identity you can inspect.
API and automation for test runs
Why it matters
API and automation for test runs separate one-off testing from repeatable, policy-driven workflows. When you can provision and schedule via automation, you reduce manual drift that skews results.
How to check
Ask for a short walkthrough of how they trigger a run and manage recipients through an API or automation interface. Then request a sample script or import workflow and confirm what fields they accept and how errors are reported.
RBAC and audit log visibility
Why it matters
RBAC and audit log visibility keeps testing accountable across departments and prevents unauthorized changes to send behavior. It also helps you answer who modified message settings and when.
How to check
Ask for role examples such as viewer, operator, and admin and what each can change or export. Request an audit log view for a configuration change and a run, and verify filters for user and time.
Red flags
- The tool only reports high-level clicks without run-by-recipient event timing.
- The demo can’t show what parts of headers and routing the tool actually controls.
- Roles and audit history are vague or missing for message and run changes.
Fit by situation
- If you need test emails to closely mirror how real phishing reaches inboxes, prioritize Test email realism controls.
- If your environment has strict mail routing behavior, prioritize Delivery path and routing control.
- If you must run tests repeatedly with traceable changes, prioritize API and automation for test runs.
Funding and competing interests
This study was co-funded by several of the vendors assessed in it. No single vendor funded it. Funders could propose the market studied.
They had no role in selecting vendors, setting or weighting criteria, analysing data or drawing conclusions, and they received the same factual-accuracy check as every other vendor assessed.
Market definition, inclusion rules and criteria weights were fixed by an editor before research began and did not change afterwards. Editorial process →
- Review · 2026 · Cybersecurity Information SecurityPhishing Testing Software
- Review · 2026 · Cybersecurity Information SecurityEmail Anti Spam Software
- Review · 2026 · Cybersecurity Information SecurityEmail Phishing Software
- Review · 2026 · Marketing AdvertisingEmail Testing Software
- Review · 2026 · Cybersecurity Information SecurityPhishing Test Software
Keep exploring
Comparing two specific tools?
Software Alternatives
See head-to-head software comparisons with feature breakdowns, pricing, and our recommendation for each use case.
Explore software alternatives→In this category
Cybersecurity & Information Security alternatives
See side-by-side comparisons of cybersecurity & information security tools and pick the right one for your stack.
Compare cybersecurity & information security tools→