
GITNUXSOFTWARE REVIEW
Cybersecurity & Information SecurityTop 10 Best Email Phishing Software of 2026
Compare email phishing software options for IT and security teams, weighing tools like KnowBe4 for fit, features, and tradeoffs.
How we ranked these tools
Vendors set the topic, but our editors set the inclusion criteria and the evaluation framework before research starts.
AI search agents find sources, extract figures with provenance, and aggregate written reviews. They also transcribe video reviews and podcasts.
Framework: Features 40% · Ease 30% · Value 30%
Gitnux may earn a commission through links on this page. This does not influence our reviews. Editorial policy
Barracuda Email Protection is the best pick for security teams that need gateway-level phishing suppression because its policy-driven message handling inspects attachments and URLs with quarantine or enforcement tied to delivery flow, whereas Hornetsecurity suits SMB teams that want phishing simulations tightly aligned with email security administration for cleaner rollout.
Editor’s top 3 picks
Three quick recommendations before you dive into the full comparison below — each one leads on a different dimension.
Barracuda Email Protection
Policy-driven message handling at the gateway, including attachment and URL inspection with quarantine and enforcement modes tied to delivery flow.
Best for: Fits when security teams need inbound phishing suppression at the gateway and rely on separate tooling for training simulations.
KnowBe4
Editor pickRepeat-offender tracking connects future risk decisions to prior user report and click behavior across campaigns.
Best for: Fits when security teams run repeated phishing simulations and want consistent remedial training paths.
Hornetsecurity
Editor pickTight operational alignment between phishing simulations and Hornetsecurity email security administration workflows.
Best for: Fits when email security teams want phishing simulation linked to mailbox policy governance and group rollout.
Comparison Table
Barracuda Email Protection
enterpriseEmail security suite with phishing defense, awareness training, and incident response.
Policy-driven message handling at the gateway, including attachment and URL inspection with quarantine and enforcement modes tied to delivery flow.
Barracuda Email Protection focuses on stopping phishing at the mail gateway with policy-based scanning, message quarantine, and user notifications tied to delivery outcomes. The product emphasizes URL and attachment inspection and integrates with directory sources so policy can follow group membership.
It also supports operational controls such as audit-style reporting, configurable enforcement modes, and workflow alignment with inbound and outbound mail paths. Administrators get a governance-first approach rather than a training-only phishing simulation workflow.
- +Gateway enforcement combines attachment and URL inspection with quarantine decisions
- +Directory-backed policy targeting reduces per-user exceptions and tuning drift
- +Delivery-focused reporting links actions to specific message handling outcomes
- +Configurable enforcement modes support staged rollout without removing protection
- –Phishing simulation and awareness workflows are not the primary focus
- –Admin tuning can require ongoing governance to avoid false positive pressure
- –Automation and API-based campaign injection options are limited versus simulation specialists
- –Granular user-risk scoring for training is not available as a core workflow
Security teams
Detect spoofed phishing with URL controls
Lower exec impersonation risk
Email administrators
Filter inbound messages at the gateway
Less phishing before delivery
Show 2 more scenarios
Security administrators
Apply policy controls to outbound mail
More controlled outbound flow
Enforce threat and policy scanning on outbound messages to reduce misuse and malware propagation.
Email security administrators
Manage quarantine and false positives
Fewer quarantine handling tickets
Use category-based quarantine policies with controlled release workflows to reduce manual helpdesk work.
Best for: Fits when security teams need inbound phishing suppression at the gateway and rely on separate tooling for training simulations.
KnowBe4
enterprisePhishing simulation and security awareness training platform.
Repeat-offender tracking connects future risk decisions to prior user report and click behavior across campaigns.
KnowBe4 is built around scheduled simulated phishing campaigns and follow-on remedial training, which supports repeat learning loops instead of one-time testing. The system can target users from directory synchronization, and it can run both link-based and attachment-based phishing templates without changing separate tools. Campaign analytics track susceptibility and engagement signals over time, which supports governance review for security and HR alignment.
A tradeoff is that deeper customization of templates and training paths increases admin overhead and makes changes harder to version across multiple locations. KnowBe4 works well when security teams need a predictable monthly cadence with consistent templates, plus remediation assignment when users click or fail to report.
- +Campaign scheduling supports recurring simulation cycles without manual re-launches
- +Template library covers multiple phishing formats for varied training objectives
- +Remedial training can be tied to user outcomes for faster behavior correction
- +User-level reporting supports tracking repeat offenders across campaigns
- –Multi-team setup needs careful RBAC planning to avoid broad access
- –Template customization depth increases maintenance work for administrators
- –Advanced targeting relies on directory sync quality and ongoing data hygiene
- –Link and attachment simulation tuning can require iterative configuration
Security awareness leaders
Monthly simulations with automated remediation
Higher report and compliance rates
IT directory admins
Directory-synced targeting for campaigns
Reduced manual user management
Show 2 more scenarios
Security governance teams
RBAC and audit-friendly admin control
Stronger review and accountability
Role-based access limits who can configure campaigns and training while retaining change history.
HR training coordinators
Consistent awareness learning paths
Repeatable training processes
Remedial training assignments standardize responses to risky outcomes across departments.
Best for: Fits when security teams run repeated phishing simulations and want consistent remedial training paths.
Hornetsecurity
SMBEmail security and awareness platform with phishing simulation capabilities.
Tight operational alignment between phishing simulations and Hornetsecurity email security administration workflows.
Hornetsecurity runs email phishing simulation campaigns and supporting awareness workflows from its security awareness tooling. Campaign creation supports both link-based and attachment-based scenarios, with templates and guided configuration for recurring runs.
Administration centers on controlled rollout to groups, tracking of report behavior, and campaign analytics tied to outcomes like click and submit activity. The strongest differentiator is how the service fits into Hornetsecurity email security operations, pairing simulation visibility with mailbox protection and policy governance context.
- +Campaign analytics include report button and recipient outcome tracking
- +Supports both link-based and attachment-based phishing simulation scenarios
- +Group-based targeting supports staged rollout across departments
- +Fits into Hornetsecurity email security governance workflows
- –Advanced scenario customization depth is narrower than some simulation-first vendors
- –Integrations beyond directory sync and common identity patterns can be limited
- –Reporting and remedial training tuning takes more admin effort than expected
- –APIs for deep external campaign automation are not as broadly exposed
Compliance messaging teams
Apply gateway policies for protected delivery
Consistent handling of sensitive email
Records compliance teams
Retain and trace business email
More accessible email records
Show 2 more scenarios
Microsoft 365 administrators
Administer tenant-wide email protections
More consistent tenant controls
Manage centralized security administration to apply email security controls consistently across Microsoft 365.
IT and security teams
Block spam, malware, and phishing at the gateway
Fewer harmful messages delivered
Route mail through a managed gateway to classify and block phishing, suspicious senders, and malware.
Best for: Fits when email security teams want phishing simulation linked to mailbox policy governance and group rollout.
Hoxhunt
enterpriseAdaptive phishing training and employee threat reporting platform.
Outcome-driven remediation that changes the user learning path based on report and click behavior.
Hoxhunt is built for teams that want automation around susceptibility and follow-up learning rather than one-off simulations. Campaigns can be scheduled repeatedly, and results can drive remedial training paths for users who click or fail to report. The reporting view connects campaign outcomes back to individual behavior so repeat offenders can be identified.
- +Interactive learning flows tied to campaign outcomes
- +Repeat-offender tracking across scheduled simulations
- +Role-based access controls with auditable admin actions
- +Clear report and click analytics per campaign and user
- –Workflow customization requires up-front setup decisions
- –Some advanced template customization is limited to configuration
- –Deep identity mapping depends on integration quality
- –Large-scale rollout can require careful group targeting
Security awareness managers
Run recurring phishing simulations by department
Lower repeat offender rate
Security operations teams
Investigate susceptibility trends across users
Faster targeting of training
Show 2 more scenarios
IT and IAM administrators
Sync groups for campaign eligibility
Less manual user management
Identity and group integration keeps who receives simulations aligned to access needs.
GRC and compliance teams
Govern who can launch campaigns
Stronger operational accountability
Admin roles and audit logs support controlled operations for phishing simulation management.
Best for: Fits when security teams want outcome-driven follow-up training with governed admin access.
Cofense PhishMe
enterprisePhishing detection, simulation, reporting, and response software.
PhishMe phishing report button workflow turns user reports into actionable signals tied to campaign outcomes.
Cofense PhishMe runs credential-harvesting and link-based phishing simulations with campaign scheduling and per-user targeting. It couples simulations with an end-user phishing report button workflow so reported messages can be triaged without relying only on mailbox rules. Campaign analytics track report rates and click behavior by group and campaign, which supports follow-up training assignments and operational review cycles. It also provides guidance for handling simulated messages so they do not disrupt incident response workflows.
- +Phishing report button workflow connects user behavior to triage signals
- +Credential-harvesting simulation supports controlled end-to-end assessment
- +Campaign analytics track report rate and click behavior by group
- +Configuration supports repeatable scheduling for consistent measurement
- –Remedial impact depends on how training assignments connect internally
- –Advanced targeting setup needs governance and steady admin ownership
- –Template customization can be constrained versus fully custom simulation flows
- –User reporting outcomes vary if end-user training reduces report friction
Security operations teams
Triage user-reported suspicious emails
Faster investigation routing
Security awareness program owners
Run scheduled simulations by cohort
Measurable program trends
Show 2 more scenarios
IT governance teams
Standardize templates and approvals
Consistent measurement
Controlled campaign configuration limits template sprawl across departments and business units.
Regional security leaders
Address repeat-offender behaviors
Targeted remediation focus
Analytics support follow-up on users who repeatedly click or fail to report simulated messages.
Best for: Fits when security teams need measurable simulation plus a report-to-triage workflow.
Proofpoint Security Awareness Training
enterprisePhishing simulation, security education, and risk-based awareness software.
Phishing report button handling connects user reports to campaign outcomes and drives follow-on learning assignments.
Proofpoint Security Awareness Training targets security teams that need phishing simulation with reporting and follow-up learning in one workflow.
- +Integrated phishing report workflows feed measurable outcomes into remediation
- +Remedial training can be triggered from simulated campaign results
- +Identity and directory synchronization reduce repeated onboarding work
- +Campaign analytics support decision-making on click and repeat risk
- –Admin setup requires careful governance to keep templates aligned with policy
- –Automation depth depends on integration choices for email delivery and identity
- –Template customization can be time-intensive for nonstandard creative needs
- –Scoring behaviors can be granular, which increases tuning overhead for new admins
Security awareness teams
Run scheduled phishing simulations
Repeatable phishing engagement view
Phishing program administrators
Maintain template-based phishing scenarios
Updated lures for each group
Show 2 more scenarios
Security and learning administrators
Assign lessons tied to simulations
Training linked to simulation activity
Deliver security lessons alongside phishing exercises and track learner progress and completion.
Compliance program owners
Track completion and attestations
Easier evidence collection
Manage required learning status and user attestations in the same workflow as phishing exercises.
Best for: Fits when enterprises need end-to-end phishing simulation plus remedial training with identity-driven administration.
NINJIO
SMBSecurity awareness training with phishing simulations and short-form lessons.
Built-in simulation scheduling and reporting workflow that ties simulated delivery outcomes to user reporting signals.
NINJIO targets email phishing simulation and awareness workflow with an emphasis on campaign creation, delivery, and results tracking for security teams. The workflow supports common phishing formats like link and attachment simulations, plus recurring campaign scheduling and user-level outcome reporting.
- +Supports link and attachment phishing simulations within repeatable campaign runs
- +Campaign analytics track delivery and user interaction outcomes for security review
- +Includes mechanisms for driving user reporting behavior from simulated emails
- +Scheduling supports recurring campaigns without rebuilding every run
- –Admin setup requires careful alignment of delivery and reporting workflows
- –Integration and automation surface is narrower than suites built for deep mail-system orchestration
- –Template coverage and customization depth can feel limited for complex brand variants
- –Role governance controls appear less granular than enterprise awareness governance needs
Security and IT teams
Create recurring phishing campaigns
Measured susceptibility by cohort
Security operations teams
Assess click and report behavior
Visibility into reporting behavior
Show 2 more scenarios
Security awareness program owners
Trigger training after failures
Reinforcement after exposure
Connect training sequences to simulated failures with additional lessons and knowledge checks.
Security and compliance administrators
Assign different campaigns by department
Role-based learning paths
Assign campaign sets and learning paths to departments, roles, or cohorts with different risk patterns.
Best for: Fits when a security team needs repeatable phishing simulations with actionable reporting and scheduled follow-ups.
Microsoft Attack Simulation Training
enterprisePhishing simulation and user training within Microsoft Defender for Office 365.
Tenant-integrated campaign governance with Entra ID permissions and Microsoft 365-aligned reporting views.
Microsoft Attack Simulation Training pairs Microsoft 365-based delivery with role-based workflows for building simulated phishing campaigns and tracking outcomes. The product lets security teams create link, attachment, and credential-harvesting style simulations using templates and custom content, then route results into user reporting and follow-up training tasks.
- +Role-based admin controls integrate with Microsoft Entra ID tenancy
- +Campaign reports track simulation outcomes and remediation training signals
- +Template-driven creation supports link and attachment simulation variants
- +Centralized governance views reduce operational drift across teams
- –Customization depth for advanced phishing formats is less flexible than specialist tools
- –Operational setup across mail delivery and tenant permissions adds initial effort
- –Automation options can require more manual sequencing than API-first platforms
- –Granular per-user remediation workflows may feel constrained for edge cases
Security awareness managers
Run recurring phishing simulations with role routing
Improved user reporting and training
Microsoft 365 security teams
Align simulations with Entra ID permissions
Tenant-controlled simulation administration
Show 2 more scenarios
Incident response and SOC leads
Measure click behavior across user groups
Lower susceptibility in key teams
Compare simulation performance and user follow-up completion by department to identify high-risk areas.
IT administrators
Use templates for link credential harvesting
Standardized phishing test coverage
Deploy repeatable scenarios that reuse approved templates and custom content safely within M365.
Best for: Fits when Microsoft 365 tenants need governed phishing simulations tied to identity and centralized reporting.
Phished
SMBAutomated phishing simulation and security awareness platform.
Follow-up campaign scheduling for repeat-offender tracking based on prior user outcomes.
Phished builds simulated phishing scenarios by combining templates with campaign configuration, then delivers them on a schedule.
- +Template workflow supports rapid build of link and attachment simulations
- +Campaign analytics track report rate and click-through outcomes
- +Repeat scheduling enables follow-up training for recurring failures
- +Exports support security review workflows without extra tooling
- –Admin configuration can require careful coordination across campaign variants
- –Automation depth depends on available integration points rather than full API coverage
- –User-level result actions are limited compared with training-first suites
- –Advanced mailbox testing and delivery validation are not central to workflows
Security operations teams
Validate anti-phishing user recognition
Evidence of user reporting
Security awareness teams
Maintain a recurring training cadence
Measurable user responses
Show 2 more scenarios
HR and IT teams
Onboard new employees with standard exercises
Consistent onboarding awareness
Use standardized phishing exercises and assigned learning to introduce new employees to expected email behavior.
Security operations teams
Test clicks and credential submission steps
Visibility into failure points
Measure user responses across simulated messages, landing pages, and credential-submission steps.
Best for: Fits when security teams want campaign analytics and repeat simulations with minimal training-system dependency.
PhishingBox
SMBPhishing simulation, awareness training, and campaign management software.
Repeat-offender tracking ties ongoing susceptibility patterns to campaign reporting for targeted remediation.
PhishingBox is an email phishing simulation and phishing awareness training solution with templates, scheduling, and measurable campaign outcomes. Its core workflow centers on creating simulated phishing emails, sending them to targeted groups, and collecting user actions like clicks and report button usage.
- +Campaign analytics connect user actions to follow-up training
- +Repeat behavior tracking helps identify users who keep clicking
- +Role-based campaign targeting supports segmented awareness programs
- +Template-based creation speeds up simulated phishing rollout
- –Limited automation depth for complex approval and provisioning workflows
- –Integration coverage can feel narrow for advanced identity and mail injection setups
- –Reporting granularity may not match teams needing deep per-template audit trails
- –Attachment and credential-harvesting scenarios may require more manual tuning
Security awareness admins
Run scheduled phishing email campaigns
Measurable campaign outcomes
Security teams
Track clicks and report button usage
Action-level awareness signals
Show 2 more scenarios
IT security managers
Review campaign analytics for remediation
Targeted remediation decisions
Use analytics and repeated behavior tracking to decide which remedial training actions to run next.
Training program owners
Iterate awareness programs from results
Improving awareness over time
Map configuration and reporting to iterative training cycles instead of one-off simulations.
Best for: Fits when security teams run recurring simulated phishing campaigns and need clear click and report metrics.
Conclusion
After evaluating 10 email phishing software, Barracuda Email Protection stands out as our overall top pick — it scored highest across our combined criteria of features, ease of use, and value, which is why it sits at #1 in the rankings above.
Use the comparison table and detailed reviews above to validate the fit against your own requirements before committing to a tool.
Frequently Asked Questions About Email Phishing Software
How do Cofense PhishMe and Proofpoint Security Awareness Training handle user-reported phishing events?
When should Microsoft Attack Simulation Training be chosen over Hoxhunt for tenant administration and governance?
Which tool provides repeat-offender tracking that connects future targeting to prior report and click outcomes?
What breaks if email phishing simulation depends on directory synchronization, when directory groups change frequently?
How does Barracuda Email Protection differ from phishing simulation platforms like Cofense PhishMe for attachment and URL handling?
Which platform supports both link-based and attachment-based simulation while keeping admin rollout controlled by groups?
How do Cofense PhishMe and Phished structure follow-up campaigns for users who fail the initial simulation?
When do security teams use Hoxhunt’s credential-harvesting scenario templates instead of generic phishing templates?
What integration patterns matter most when tying simulation analytics into existing email and identity operations?
Tools reviewed
Primary sources checked during evaluation.
Referenced in the comparison table and product reviews above.
How to Choose the Right Email Phishing Software
Options differ most in how well they drive controlled phishing tests and convert results into actionable follow-up. Look for strong criteria on attack-path coverage, reporting that matches how people actually get hit, and admin controls that let us run and govern campaigns without breaking our email flow.
Simulation coverage by message type
Why it matters
Simulation coverage by message type matters because real incidents come from multiple angles, not one. When coverage is narrow, our tests can miss the specific failure mode we are trying to reduce.
How to check
Ask the vendor to show configurable setups for at least common message forms (for example, links and attachments) in a single workflow. Then request a demo with a fresh template that includes both the message body and the delivery hook they use to trigger tracking.
Safe targeting and delivery throttles
Why it matters
Safe targeting and delivery throttles keep tests from becoming a production problem. They also reduce confounding results when too many users get similar emails at once.
How to check
In the demo, find controls to limit audience (individuals, groups, or filters) and to cap how quickly emails are sent. Verify the product can prevent test mail from leaving the intended scope before it runs a live campaign.
Track events with verifiable granularity
Why it matters
Track events with verifiable granularity matters because weak tracking makes metrics misleading and follow-up hard to justify. We want to separate reading, clicking, and credential submission events clearly enough to act.
How to check
Request a sample report view after a small test run and ask which events are recorded automatically versus requiring specific message instrumentation. Then ask what happens when users open in different clients (for example, mobile vs desktop) and whether the report still reflects outcomes consistently.
API and automation for campaign workflow
Why it matters
API and automation for campaign workflow matter when we need repeatable tests and consistent governance. Without it, we end up relying on manual steps that drift across months.
How to check
Ask for the API calls or automation options used to create campaigns, assign recipients, and pull results. In the demo, show an example where an admin triggers a new campaign and then retrieves a report without clicking through every screen.
RBAC and audit logs for admin actions
Why it matters
RBAC and audit logs for admin actions matter because multiple teams often participate in testing. We need clear separation of duties and traceability for who changed templates, targeting, and campaign settings.
How to check
Request role options and what actions each role can perform (create, approve, launch, and export results). Then ask to view an audit log entry for a campaign change, including the actor and timestamp, using a real example from the demo.
Red flags
- Reports that only show clicks without tying events to the exact test message type
- No meaningful controls to cap audience and sending rate during a campaign
- Admin workflows that rely on manual steps with no API or audit trail
Fit by situation
- If we need to test different click and attachment behaviors, prioritize simulation coverage by message type.
- If multiple teams will run tests over time, prioritize RBAC and audit logs for admin actions.
- If we manage repeat campaigns via automation, prioritize API and automation for campaign workflow.
Funding and competing interests
This study was co-funded by several of the vendors assessed in it. No single vendor funded it. Funders could propose the market studied.
They had no role in selecting vendors, setting or weighting criteria, analysing data or drawing conclusions, and they received the same factual-accuracy check as every other vendor assessed.
Market definition, inclusion rules and criteria weights were fixed by an editor before research began and did not change afterwards. Editorial process →
- Review · 2026 · Cybersecurity Information SecurityPhishing Testing Software
- Review · 2026 · Cybersecurity Information SecurityEmail Anti Spam Software
- Review · 2026 · Cybersecurity Information SecurityPhishing Campaign Software
- Review · 2026 · Cybersecurity Information SecurityPhishing Training Software
- Review · 2026 · SecuritySecure Email Gateway Software
Keep exploring
Comparing two specific tools?
Software Alternatives
See head-to-head software comparisons with feature breakdowns, pricing, and our recommendation for each use case.
Explore software alternatives→In this category
Cybersecurity & Information Security alternatives
See side-by-side comparisons of cybersecurity & information security tools and pick the right one for your stack.
Compare cybersecurity & information security tools→