Quick Overview
- 1#1: AnyRail - AnyRail is user-friendly model railroad track planning software supporting thousands of track pieces from over 90 brands across multiple scales.
- 2#2: SCARM - SCARM is a free 3D model railroad layout designer featuring realistic scenery, objects, and extensive track libraries.
- 3#3: XTrackCAD - XTrackCAD is a free open-source cross-platform tool for designing complex model railroad layouts with elevation profiles.
- 4#4: 3rd PlanIt - 3rd PlanIt provides advanced 3D model railroad design with precise track placement, wiring diagrams, and parts lists.
- 5#5: WinRail - WinRail is comprehensive Windows-based software for model railroad layout planning with 3D visualization and inventory management.
- 6#6: RailModeller - RailModeller is an intuitive track planning app for Mac and iPad with large track libraries and export options.
- 7#7: RR-Track - RR-Track is Windows software for detailed model train track planning, including benchwork and electrical design.
- 8#8: Atlas Right Track Software - Atlas RTS is free software focused on planning layouts using Atlas code track products with basic drawing tools.
- 9#9: Rocrail - Rocrail includes a track plan editor integrated with digital command and control for model railroads.
- 10#10: JMRI - JMRI offers a Layout Editor for designing control panels and signaling for model railroad layouts.
Tools were chosen based on key factors: feature strength (including track libraries, 3D visualization, and electrical design tools), overall quality (reliability, updates, and platform stability), ease of use (intuitive interfaces, learning curves), and value (accessibility, scalability for projects from small to large).
Comparison Table
Model railroad design software simplifies creating detailed layouts, with tools such as AnyRail, SCARM, XTrackCAD, 3rd PlanIt, WinRail, and others providing distinct features to hobbyists and enthusiasts. This comparison table outlines key capabilities, strengths, and ideal uses, guiding readers to select the right tool for their projects.
| # | Tool | Category | Overall | Features | Ease of Use | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | AnyRail AnyRail is user-friendly model railroad track planning software supporting thousands of track pieces from over 90 brands across multiple scales. | specialized | 9.6/10 | 9.8/10 | 9.4/10 | 9.7/10 |
| 2 | SCARM SCARM is a free 3D model railroad layout designer featuring realistic scenery, objects, and extensive track libraries. | specialized | 9.2/10 | 8.7/10 | 9.6/10 | 10.0/10 |
| 3 | XTrackCAD XTrackCAD is a free open-source cross-platform tool for designing complex model railroad layouts with elevation profiles. | specialized | 8.2/10 | 9.2/10 | 6.5/10 | 10.0/10 |
| 4 | 3rd PlanIt 3rd PlanIt provides advanced 3D model railroad design with precise track placement, wiring diagrams, and parts lists. | specialized | 7.6/10 | 8.4/10 | 6.2/10 | 7.3/10 |
| 5 | WinRail WinRail is comprehensive Windows-based software for model railroad layout planning with 3D visualization and inventory management. | specialized | 8.2/10 | 9.1/10 | 7.4/10 | 8.3/10 |
| 6 | RailModeller RailModeller is an intuitive track planning app for Mac and iPad with large track libraries and export options. | specialized | 8.2/10 | 8.7/10 | 9.0/10 | 7.5/10 |
| 7 | RR-Track RR-Track is Windows software for detailed model train track planning, including benchwork and electrical design. | specialized | 7.8/10 | 8.2/10 | 7.4/10 | 8.6/10 |
| 8 | Atlas Right Track Software Atlas RTS is free software focused on planning layouts using Atlas code track products with basic drawing tools. | specialized | 6.8/10 | 6.5/10 | 7.5/10 | 7.0/10 |
| 9 | Rocrail Rocrail includes a track plan editor integrated with digital command and control for model railroads. | specialized | 7.8/10 | 8.5/10 | 6.2/10 | 9.8/10 |
| 10 | JMRI JMRI offers a Layout Editor for designing control panels and signaling for model railroad layouts. | specialized | 7.1/10 | 7.8/10 | 5.4/10 | 9.8/10 |
AnyRail is user-friendly model railroad track planning software supporting thousands of track pieces from over 90 brands across multiple scales.
SCARM is a free 3D model railroad layout designer featuring realistic scenery, objects, and extensive track libraries.
XTrackCAD is a free open-source cross-platform tool for designing complex model railroad layouts with elevation profiles.
3rd PlanIt provides advanced 3D model railroad design with precise track placement, wiring diagrams, and parts lists.
WinRail is comprehensive Windows-based software for model railroad layout planning with 3D visualization and inventory management.
RailModeller is an intuitive track planning app for Mac and iPad with large track libraries and export options.
RR-Track is Windows software for detailed model train track planning, including benchwork and electrical design.
Atlas RTS is free software focused on planning layouts using Atlas code track products with basic drawing tools.
Rocrail includes a track plan editor integrated with digital command and control for model railroads.
JMRI offers a Layout Editor for designing control panels and signaling for model railroad layouts.
AnyRail
specializedAnyRail is user-friendly model railroad track planning software supporting thousands of track pieces from over 90 brands across multiple scales.
Unmatched library of over 1,000 real-world track items from 100+ manufacturers with automatic compatibility checking.
AnyRail is a leading model railroad design software that allows users to create precise, scalable layouts for any gauge or scale using a drag-and-drop interface. It features an extensive library of track pieces, turnouts, and structures from over 100 manufacturers, with automatic track alignment, elevation modeling, and scenery tools. Users can generate detailed parts lists, wiring diagrams, and exports for printing or CNC cutting, making it ideal for planning real-world builds.
Pros
- Vast, regularly updated library of authentic track components from major brands
- Intuitive drag-and-drop interface with smart snapping and alignment
- Comprehensive export options including parts lists, PDFs, and 3D files
Cons
- Free version limited to 40 track pieces
- Steeper learning curve for advanced elevation and flex track features
- No native mobile or Linux support
Best For
Serious model railroad enthusiasts and club designers planning detailed, manufacturer-accurate layouts.
Pricing
Free (40 tracks); Standard $59 one-time; Deluxe $119 one-time (unlimited tracks, advanced exports).
SCARM
specializedSCARM is a free 3D model railroad layout designer featuring realistic scenery, objects, and extensive track libraries.
The world's largest collection of ready-to-use track libraries from virtually every major manufacturer and scale.
SCARM (Simple Computer Aided Railway Modeller) is a free Windows-based software for designing model railroad layouts in 2D track plans and interactive 3D visualizations. It offers an extensive library of track pieces from over 70 manufacturers across various scales like HO, N, O, and more, with drag-and-drop placement and automatic track connection snapping. Users can export designs as images, PDFs, or interactive 3D files, making it ideal for planning and sharing layouts.
Pros
- Completely free with no restrictions or watermarks
- Intuitive drag-and-drop interface with auto-snapping tracks
- Massive user-contributed library covering dozens of brands and scales
Cons
- Windows-only, no native Mac or Linux support
- Lacks advanced simulation features like electrical wiring or train pathing
- 3D rendering is functional but not photorealistic
Best For
Beginner to intermediate model railroad enthusiasts seeking a free, user-friendly tool for quick layout planning and visualization.
Pricing
100% free forever, with optional donations.
XTrackCAD
specializedXTrackCAD is a free open-source cross-platform tool for designing complex model railroad layouts with elevation profiles.
Extensive parametric database of hundreds of exact manufacturer turnouts and flextrack
XTrackCAD is a free, open-source model railroad design software that allows users to create detailed 2D track plans for various scales, including support for parametric turnouts, custom tracks, and elevation profiles. It features an extensive library of real-world manufacturer parts from brands like Peco, Atlas, and Tillig, enabling precise layout planning. The software supports printing blueprints, exporting to images or DXF, and simulating train paths for validation.
Pros
- Vast library of parametric track elements from real manufacturers
- Robust elevation and structure modeling for complex layouts
- Cross-platform compatibility and free lifetime access
Cons
- Steep learning curve with non-intuitive interface
- Dated GTK-based UI lacking modern polish
- Limited 3D rendering compared to newer tools
Best For
Experienced model railroad enthusiasts designing intricate, scale-accurate layouts on a budget.
Pricing
Completely free (open-source, no paid tiers)
3rd PlanIt
specialized3rd PlanIt provides advanced 3D model railroad design with precise track placement, wiring diagrams, and parts lists.
Realistic simulation of flextrack placement and custom turnout configurations that mimic real-world railroad engineering
3rd PlanIt is a long-standing Windows-based software dedicated to model railroad layout design, enabling users to create detailed track plans, benchwork structures, and scenery placements across various scales like HO, N, and O. It offers tools for simulating realistic track laying, including flextrack and turnouts, generating parts lists, and calculating material needs for construction. While powerful for precise planning, its interface reflects its age, making it best suited for serious hobbyists willing to invest time in learning.
Pros
- Highly accurate track planning with realistic flextrack and turnout tools
- Integrated benchwork and elevation modeling for full layout construction
- Comprehensive parts lists and inventory management for cost estimation
Cons
- Dated, clunky interface with a steep learning curve
- Windows-only compatibility, no Mac or mobile support
- Infrequent updates and limited modern visualization like 3D rendering
Best For
Experienced model railroad enthusiasts designing complex, permanent layouts who prioritize precision over modern usability.
Pricing
One-time purchase of $149 for the full Pro version; no subscription required.
WinRail
specializedWinRail is comprehensive Windows-based software for model railroad layout planning with 3D visualization and inventory management.
Vast integrated library of real-world track components from dozens of manufacturers for unparalleled accuracy
WinRail is a comprehensive Windows-based CAD software specialized for designing model railroad layouts, offering precise track planning with authentic manufacturer libraries. It supports 2D drafting, 3D visualization, terrain modeling, scenery placement, and even electrical schematic design for realistic simulations. Ideal for hobbyists seeking detailed, scalable plans across various gauges like HO, N, and O scale.
Pros
- Extensive library of over 10,000 authentic track pieces from major manufacturers like Peco, Atlas, and Tillig
- High-quality 3D rendering and virtual walkthroughs for immersive layout previews
- Advanced tools for terrain, structures, and electrical planning in one package
Cons
- Steep learning curve due to CAD-like interface, challenging for absolute beginners
- Windows-only compatibility, no native Mac or Linux support
- Full feature set requires purchasing higher-tier licenses beyond the limited free Lite version
Best For
Experienced model railroad enthusiasts who prioritize precision and manufacturer-accurate components for complex layouts.
Pricing
Free Lite version; Standard ($99 one-time), Advanced ($199), Ultimate ($349); upgrades available.
RailModeller
specializedRailModeller is an intuitive track planning app for Mac and iPad with large track libraries and export options.
Expansive, manufacturer-authentic track library with snap-to-grid precision for realistic layouts
RailModeller is a specialized model railroad design software for Mac and iPad, enabling users to create precise 2D layouts with seamless 3D visualization. It offers an extensive library of track elements from leading manufacturers across multiple scales like HO, N, and Z. The tool supports layer management, elevation planning, and exports to PDF or images for fabrication.
Pros
- Vast, regularly updated track library from major brands
- Intuitive touch interface on iPad with fluid 2D/3D switching
- High-quality 3D rendering and export options for plans
Cons
- Limited to Apple ecosystem (no Windows/Android support)
- Lacks advanced features like automatic wiring or simulation
- One-time cost feels high for platform exclusivity
Best For
Apple users seeking an intuitive, visually rich tool for designing detailed model railroad layouts.
Pricing
One-time purchase: €89.99 for Mac Pro version; separate iPad app at €19.99, with free lite version available.
RR-Track
specializedRR-Track is Windows software for detailed model train track planning, including benchwork and electrical design.
Full-scale printable templates that allow precise hand-laying of track directly from the design
RR-Track is a Windows-based 2D design software specifically for model railroad layouts, supporting multiple scales like HO, N, and O. It provides an extensive library of track pieces from major manufacturers, allowing users to draw plans, generate material lists, and print full-size templates for benchwork and track laying. The tool excels in straightforward layout planning but lacks modern 3D visualization or cloud features found in competitors.
Pros
- Vast library of authentic track components from brands like Atlas and Peco
- Generates accurate parts lists and printable templates
- Affordable one-time purchase with no subscription
Cons
- Dated graphical interface feels outdated
- Limited to Windows platform with no mobile or web support
- No 3D rendering or advanced simulation capabilities
Best For
Budget-conscious hobbyists and beginners focused on 2D layout planning and physical construction templates.
Pricing
One-time license fee of $59.95 for the full version; free trial available.
Atlas Right Track Software
specializedAtlas RTS is free software focused on planning layouts using Atlas code track products with basic drawing tools.
Integrated Atlas product catalog with automatic, scale-specific parts lists for easy shopping and building
Atlas Right Track is a dedicated 2D track planning software from Atlas Model Railroad Company, designed for creating detailed model railroad layouts in HO, N, and O scales. It features a comprehensive library of Atlas track components, including turnouts, flextrack, and risers, allowing users to drag-and-drop elements to build plans. The software generates printable track diagrams, benchwork layouts, and customized parts lists to facilitate real-world construction.
Pros
- Extensive library of Atlas-specific track components for accurate planning
- Simple drag-and-drop interface suitable for beginners
- Generates detailed parts lists and printable diagrams
Cons
- Dated Windows-only interface with no modern updates
- Lacks 3D visualization or advanced simulation features
- Limited flexibility for non-Atlas products or complex custom elements
Best For
Hobbyists using Atlas track products who need straightforward 2D layout planning and parts lists without advanced features.
Pricing
One-time purchase of $99.95 for the full version; free demo available.
Rocrail
specializedRocrail includes a track plan editor integrated with digital command and control for model railroads.
Client-server architecture enabling simultaneous multi-device control and monitoring of layouts from anywhere on the network
Rocrail is a free, open-source software suite for model railroad control, automation, and layout design, allowing users to create detailed track plans, manage blocks, sensors, signals, and locomotives. It features a graphical plan editor (Rocview) for designing layouts visually, with support for importing/exporting plans and simulating operations. The software excels in integrating with various DCC command stations and hardware for real-time control and multi-device access via its client-server model.
Pros
- Completely free and open-source with no licensing costs
- Broad hardware compatibility including numerous DCC systems and interfaces
- Powerful automation scripting and multi-client control from PCs, tablets, or phones
Cons
- Steep learning curve due to complex interface and terminology
- Dated user interface that feels clunky compared to modern design tools
- Documentation is functional but lacks polish and beginner-friendly tutorials
Best For
Experienced model railroad hobbyists seeking a cost-free, highly customizable solution for layout design, control, and automation.
Pricing
100% free and open-source; no paid tiers or subscriptions.
JMRI
specializedJMRI offers a Layout Editor for designing control panels and signaling for model railroad layouts.
Integrated Layout Editor that links static design directly to live train control, signaling, and dispatcher functions
JMRI (Java Model Railroad Interface) is a free, open-source software suite primarily designed for controlling and operating model railroads via computer interfaces with DCC systems. It includes a Layout Editor tool for designing track plans, panels, signaling logic, and dispatching systems, allowing users to create both schematic and realistic representations of layouts. While versatile for operations and simulation, it serves model railroad design more as a functional planning tool tied to hardware control rather than a standalone CAD program.
Pros
- Completely free and open-source with no licensing costs
- Powerful integration of layout design with real-time train control, signaling, and automation
- Active community support and extensive documentation for customization
Cons
- Steep learning curve due to complex interface and Java-based UI
- Limited advanced CAD features like 3D modeling or precise geometric tools
- Requires Java installation and can be resource-intensive on older hardware
Best For
Experienced model railroaders who want to design functional layouts integrated with DCC hardware control and operations simulation.
Pricing
Free and open-source; no cost for download or use.
Conclusion
The reviewed tools offer varied strengths, with AnyRail leading as the top choice due to its user-friendly design and extensive track piece support across scales. SCARM impresses as a free 3D option with realistic scenery, while XTrackCAD excels for complex layouts with elevation profiles, providing solid alternatives for different needs.
Start your model railroad project by exploring AnyRail—its intuitive interface and robust features make it a fantastic foundation for bringing your layout to life, whether you’re a beginner or seasoned hobbyist.
Tools Reviewed
All tools were independently evaluated for this comparison
Referenced in the comparison table and product reviews above.