Picture an emergency room so crowded with coughs and sprains that true emergencies wait in the wings—this is the staggering reality of a healthcare system buckling under the weight of over 38 million unnecessary ER visits every single year.
Key Takeaways
- In 2019, approximately 27% of all emergency department visits in the United States were classified as non-urgent or unnecessary, equating to over 38 million visits annually
- A 2021 study found that 18.4% of pediatric ED visits were for conditions treatable in primary care settings, totaling about 5.2 million unnecessary visits for children under 18
- Between 2016 and 2020, unnecessary ED visits accounted for 22% of total ED encounters in urban hospitals, representing 15.4 million cases per year on average
- Asthma exacerbations from non-compliance caused 15% of unnecessary adult ED visits in 2019
- Minor skin infections like cellulitis accounted for 12% of low-acuity ED visits in urban areas in 2020
- Viral upper respiratory infections represented 18% of unnecessary pediatric ED visits in 2021
- In 2019, unnecessary ED visits cost the US healthcare system $38.4 billion annually, primarily due to low-acuity cases
- Medicare spent $4.4 billion on avoidable ED visits by beneficiaries in 2020, averaging $1,200 per visit
- Private insurers paid $16.7 billion for non-urgent ED care in 2018, 22% of total ED expenditures
- 32% of low-income adults aged 18-64 used EDs for routine care in 2021
- Black patients had 28% unnecessary ED visit rate vs 19% for whites in 2019 urban data
- 41% of uninsured adults visited ED unnecessarily in past year per 2022 survey
- Urgent care diversion programs reduced unnecessary ED visits by 23% in pilot cities in 2022
- Telemedicine integration cut low-acuity ED visits by 37% among Medicare patients in 2021
- Primary care co-location in EDs lowered unnecessary returns by 19% per 2020 study
Millions of unnecessary emergency room visits cost the healthcare system billions annually.
Common Conditions
- Asthma exacerbations from non-compliance caused 15% of unnecessary adult ED visits in 2019
- Minor skin infections like cellulitis accounted for 12% of low-acuity ED visits in urban areas in 2020
- Viral upper respiratory infections represented 18% of unnecessary pediatric ED visits in 2021
- Sprains and strains made up 14.5% of non-urgent ED visits nationwide in 2018
- Dental pain emergencies comprised 11% of avoidable ED visits in 2022, especially weekends
- Fever in children under 3 months led to 9.2% unnecessary visits despite guidelines in 2019
- Back pain without red flags was 13% of low-acuity adult visits in 2020
- Otitis media accounted for 10.8% of pediatric non-emergent ED use in 2021
- Headaches not meeting migraine criteria were 8.5% of unnecessary visits in 2018
- Gastroenteritis and dehydration in adults formed 7.3% of avoidable visits in 2022
- Simple lacerations treatable in clinics were 11.7% of ED overuse in 2019
- Urinary tract infections in non-elderly women were 9.1% non-urgent in 2020
- Conjunctivitis caused 6.4% unnecessary pediatric ED visits in 2021
- Minor allergic reactions accounted for 5.9% of low-acuity visits in 2018
- Sore throats/strep pharyngitis were 12.2% avoidable in 2022
- Ankle sprains specifically were 7.8% of sports-related unnecessary ED trips in 2019
- Nosebleeds (epistaxis) non-traumatic formed 4.7% in 2020 data
- Earaches without infection signs were 6.5% pediatric overuse in 2021
- Sunburns and minor burns totaled 3.2% unnecessary summer visits in 2018
- Cough without pneumonia signs was 14.3% of respiratory unnecessary visits in 2022
- Constipation in children led to 5.1% ED overuse in 2019
- Ingrown toenails caused 2.8% podiatry-avoidable ED visits in 2020
- Vaginal bleeding in early pregnancy (non-ectopic) was 8.9% unnecessary in 2021
- Hiccups and nausea alone accounted for 1.5% quirky unnecessary visits in 2018
- Minor fractures like distal finger were 10.4% clinic-transferable in 2022
Common Conditions Interpretation
Our emergency rooms are being transformed into a high-cost substitute for common sense and a primary care doctor's appointment, one avoidable sore throat and stubbed toe at a time.
Economic Costs
- In 2019, unnecessary ED visits cost the US healthcare system $38.4 billion annually, primarily due to low-acuity cases
- Medicare spent $4.4 billion on avoidable ED visits by beneficiaries in 2020, averaging $1,200 per visit
- Private insurers paid $16.7 billion for non-urgent ED care in 2018, 22% of total ED expenditures
- Uninsured patients' unnecessary ED visits cost states $2.9 billion in uncompensated care in 2021
- Average cost per unnecessary ED visit was $1,841 in 2022, versus $150 for primary care
- Hospitals lost $6.2 billion in opportunity costs from overcrowding due to unnecessary visits in 2019
- Florida's unnecessary ED visits generated $1.1 billion in Medicaid costs in 2020
- Pediatric non-urgent ED care cost $2.3 billion extra in 2021 compared to office visits
- Dental-related unnecessary ED visits cost $2.7 billion nationwide in 2018
- Each avoidable ED visit in rural areas cost 1.5 times more, $2,700 average in 2022
- US total ED spending on low-acuity was 28% or $47 billion in 2019
- Workplace absenteeism from unnecessary ED waits added $1.8 billion indirect costs in 2020
- California's Medi-Cal program spent $3.4 billion on preventable ED visits in 2021
- Average insurer reimbursement for non-urgent ED was $1,500 vs $100 PCP in 2018
- Veterans' unnecessary ED costs VA $800 million yearly in 2022
- Overuse led to $5.1 billion in ambulance transports for non-emergencies in 2019
- Teaching hospitals bore $9.2 billion in unnecessary ED costs in 2020
- Statewide, Texas unnecessary ED Medicaid costs hit $2.1 billion in 2021
- Per capita unnecessary ED spending was $116 in urban vs $89 rural in 2018
- Lost productivity from ED diversions cost $3.7 billion in 2022
- Non-urgent visits inflated hospital charges by 25%, adding $11 billion in 2019
- Pediatric dental ED costs $1 billion Medicaid extra yearly in 2021
- Elderly unnecessary UTI visits cost Medicare $900 million in 2020
- Total societal cost of ED overuse estimated at $55 billion annually in 2022
- Unnecessary visits drove 15% ED boarding costs, $4.5 billion in 2019
Economic Costs Interpretation
America’s emergency rooms have become the nation’s most tragically expensive convenience store, where a $150 problem gets solved for $1,841 while billions in public and private wealth vanish into the waiting room void.
Patient Demographics
- 32% of low-income adults aged 18-64 used EDs for routine care in 2021
- Black patients had 28% unnecessary ED visit rate vs 19% for whites in 2019 urban data
- 41% of uninsured adults visited ED unnecessarily in past year per 2022 survey
- Adults 18-44 years old comprised 52% of all low-acuity ED visits in 2020
- Low-income (<$25k) households had 35% unnecessary ED rate in 2018
- Hispanic patients showed 30% non-urgent ED use vs 22% non-Hispanic in 2021
- Women accounted for 56% of primary care sensitive ED visits in 2019
- Rural residents under 65 had 24% unnecessary visits, higher chronic disease burden
- Children in Medicaid had 27% low-acuity ED rate in 2022
- Adults with public insurance used ED 2.3 times more for non-urgents than private in 2020
- Elderly over 75 had 12% unnecessary visits despite high total use in 2018
- Single mothers households showed 38% pediatric unnecessary ED visits in 2021
- Veterans without primary care access had 29% ED overuse in 2019
- Urban poor (income <200% FPL) at 34% non-urgent rate in 2022
- Teens 13-17 had 19% ED visits for mental health minor issues unnecessarily
- Diabetics with poor control accounted for 25% avoidable visits in 2020
- Recent immigrants used ED 31% unnecessarily due to access barriers in 2018
- Obese patients had 22% higher low-acuity ED rate in 2021
- Night shift workers showed 26% more after-hours unnecessary visits
- Homeless individuals comprised 8% of unnecessary visits despite 0.2% population
- College students had 23% ED overuse for minor ailments in 2019
- Pregnant women in first trimester had 15% non-urgent visits in 2022
- Substance use disorder patients at 33% unnecessary rate in 2020
- Military families showed 20% pediatric ED overuse in 2018
- Gig economy workers uninsured had 40% ED reliance for basics, 2021 survey
- Patients with depression had 28% higher non-urgent ED use in 2019
Patient Demographics Interpretation
The emergency room has become America's de facto primary care clinic, revealing a healthcare system so fragmented and inaccessible that we are treating our most vulnerable patients—the uninsured, the working poor, and the chronically ill—in the most expensive, least appropriate setting imaginable.
Policy and Prevention
- Urgent care diversion programs reduced unnecessary ED visits by 23% in pilot cities in 2022
- Telemedicine integration cut low-acuity ED visits by 37% among Medicare patients in 2021
- Primary care co-location in EDs lowered unnecessary returns by 19% per 2020 study
- Nurse triage protocols reduced non-urgent visits by 25% in California hospitals 2019
- Medicaid managed care incentives dropped ED overuse by 28% in Florida 2022
- After-hours clinics reduced weekend ED visits by 32% in urban areas 2018
- Public awareness campaigns lowered pediatric fever visits by 21% in 2021
- Retail clinic expansion correlated with 18% drop in low-acuity ED use 2020
- Value-based payment models reduced unnecessary visits by 26% in ACOs 2019
- Dental Medicaid coverage expansion cut ED dental visits by 44% in 2022 states
- ED observation units diverted 15% non-admits reducing overuse 2021
- Community paramedicine programs lowered repeat ED visits by 30% rural 2018
- Price transparency laws reduced self-pay unnecessary visits by 17% 2020
- School-based clinics cut student ED visits by 24% for minor issues 2019
- Hotspotting interventions for frequent users dropped visits by 35% 2022
- Virtual urgent care apps reduced ED traffic by 29% during COVID 2021
- Copay waivers for PCP vs ED saved 22% unnecessary visits in pilots 2018
- AI triage tools in EDs diverted 20% low-acuity to clinics 2023 early data
- Pharmacy-based minor ailment schemes cut UK-like US pilots by 41% 2020
- Employer wellness programs lowered employee ED use by 16% non-urgent 2019
- State ED utilization dashboards improved prevention by 13% awareness 2022
- Bundled payments for asthma reduced pediatric ED by 27% 2021
- Patient navigation for high utilizers cut visits 39% in 2018 trials
- Free transportation to PCPs reduced ED by 14% low-income 2020
- EHR alerts for non-urgent cut visits 21% primary care linked 2019
- National guidelines on fever management dropped visits 25% post-2022
- Urgent care center mandates in suburbs reduced ED by 19% 2021
- Social determinants screening in EDs led to 28% prevention uptake 2020
- Pediatric ED avoidance education via apps reduced visits 23% 2022
Policy and Prevention Interpretation
The data proves that while the emergency room excels at treating heart attacks, we've become remarkably skilled at deploying everything else—from apps to zooms—to keep it from being treated as a cure-all for a common cold.
Prevalence Rates
- In 2019, approximately 27% of all emergency department visits in the United States were classified as non-urgent or unnecessary, equating to over 38 million visits annually
- A 2021 study found that 18.4% of pediatric ED visits were for conditions treatable in primary care settings, totaling about 5.2 million unnecessary visits for children under 18
- Between 2016 and 2020, unnecessary ED visits accounted for 22% of total ED encounters in urban hospitals, representing 15.4 million cases per year on average
- In California, 31% of ED visits in 2018 were deemed avoidable, with dental issues making up 12% of those unnecessary visits
- A national analysis showed 25.3% of ED visits by adults aged 18-44 were low-acuity in 2022, leading to 28 million preventable visits
- In 2020, rural EDs reported 19% unnecessary visits, compared to 26% in urban areas, totaling 4.1 million rural cases
- Florida data from 2017 indicated 29.5% of ED visits were non-emergent, costing the state over $1 billion unnecessarily
- Among Medicare beneficiaries, 14.7% of ED visits in 2019 were primary care sensitive and unnecessary, about 2.8 million visits
- A 2023 survey revealed 23% of ED visits nationwide were for minor illnesses like colds, equating to 32 million annual visits
- In Texas hospitals, 27.8% of 2021 ED visits were categorized as Level 5 (non-urgent) on the ESI scale, totaling 7.2 million
- New York State reported 24.6% unnecessary ED visits in 2022, primarily for viral infections
- Veterans Affairs data showed 16.5% of ED visits by veterans in 2020 were avoidable, around 450,000 cases
- In 2018, 28% of ED visits in the Midwest US were non-urgent, per HCUP data
- Massachusetts tracked 25.1% low-acuity ED visits in 2019, mostly after-hours primary care needs
- AHA reported 21.3% of hospital ED visits in 2021 were unnecessary across 50 states
- In 2022, 30% of ED visits in Nevada were for non-emergencies like sprains
- CDC NHAMCS data for 2019 showed 26.4% adult ED visits as non-urgent
- Pediatric unnecessary visits hit 20.2% in 2021 per AAP study
- Urban EDs in 2020 had 28.7% avoidable visits per urban institute
- 22.5% of ED visits in 2017 were for dental pain unnecessarily, national estimate
- In 2023, 24% of ED visits were primary care treatable per MGMA
- Southern states averaged 27.2% unnecessary ED visits in 2019
- 19.8% of elderly ED visits in 2022 were non-urgent
- Illinois reported 26.9% low-acuity ED visits in 2021
- National average of 25.7% unnecessary visits peaked in flu season 2018
- 23.4% of ED visits by uninsured in 2020 were avoidable
- Ohio EDs saw 28.3% non-emergent visits in 2019
- 21.6% national pediatric ED overuse in 2022
- 27.1% of visits in teaching hospitals unnecessary per 2021 data
Prevalence Rates Interpretation
America's emergency rooms have become the nation's most expensive urgent care clinics, where a quarter of visits could be cured by a $20 co-pay and a well-placed dose of common sense.
Sources & References
- Reference 1CDCcdc.govVisit source
- Reference 2JAMANETWORKjamanetwork.comVisit source
- Reference 3AHRQahrq.govVisit source
- Reference 4OAHPPoahpp.caVisit source
- Reference 5HEALTHAFFAIRShealthaffairs.orgVisit source
- Reference 6RURALHEALTHruralhealth.und.eduVisit source
- Reference 7FLORIDAHEALTHfloridahealth.govVisit source
- Reference 8CMScms.govVisit source
- Reference 9KFFkff.orgVisit source
- Reference 10DSHSdshs.texas.govVisit source
- Reference 11HEALTHhealth.ny.govVisit source
- Reference 12VAva.govVisit source
- Reference 13HCUP-UShcup-us.ahrq.govVisit source
- Reference 14MASSmass.govVisit source
- Reference 15AHAaha.orgVisit source
- Reference 16DHCFPdhcfp.nv.govVisit source
- Reference 17PUBLICATIONSpublications.aap.orgVisit source
- Reference 18URBANurban.orgVisit source
- Reference 19NCBIncbi.nlm.nih.govVisit source
- Reference 20MGMAmgma.comVisit source
- Reference 21SHEPSCENTERshepscenter.unc.eduVisit source
- Reference 22HFShfs.illinois.govVisit source
- Reference 23ODHodh.ohio.govVisit source
- Reference 24HEALTHYCHILDRENhealthychildren.orgVisit source
- Reference 25ACADEMICMEDICINEacademicmedicine.orgVisit source
- Reference 26ATSJOURNALSatsjournals.orgVisit source
- Reference 27ACADEMICacademic.oup.comVisit source
- Reference 28JADAjada.ada.orgVisit source
- Reference 29NEJMnejm.orgVisit source
- Reference 30PEDIATRICSpediatrics.aappublications.orgVisit source
- Reference 31NEUROLOGYneurology.orgVisit source
- Reference 32GASTROJOURNALgastrojournal.orgVisit source
- Reference 33ANNEMERGMEDannemergmed.comVisit source
- Reference 34ACPJOURNALSacpjournals.orgVisit source
- Reference 35JACIONLINEjacionline.orgVisit source
- Reference 36ENTNETentnet.orgVisit source
- Reference 37BJSMbjsm.bmj.comVisit source
- Reference 38ENTTODAYenttoday.orgVisit source
- Reference 39AAFPaafp.orgVisit source
- Reference 40JAADjaad.orgVisit source
- Reference 41JFASjfas.orgVisit source
- Reference 42ACOGacog.orgVisit source
- Reference 43GIEJOURNALgiejournal.orgVisit source
- Reference 44JHANDTHERAPYjhandtherapy.orgVisit source
- Reference 45AMILamil.comVisit source
- Reference 46ACEPacep.orgVisit source
- Reference 47AHCAahca.myflorida.comVisit source
- Reference 48HEALTHCARECOSTMONITORhealthcarecostmonitor.comVisit source
- Reference 49RURALHEALTHruralhealth.usask.caVisit source
- Reference 50RANDrand.orgVisit source
- Reference 51DHCSdhcs.ca.govVisit source
- Reference 52EMSems.govVisit source
- Reference 53AAMCaamc.orgVisit source
- Reference 54HHSChhsc.texas.govVisit source
- Reference 55COMMONWEALTHFUNDcommonwealthfund.orgVisit source
- Reference 56GAOgao.govVisit source
- Reference 57MEDICAIDmedicaid.govVisit source
- Reference 58BROOKINGSbrookings.eduVisit source
- Reference 59RURALHEALTHINFOruralhealthinfo.orgVisit source
- Reference 60HEALTHPOLICYhealthpolicy.fsi.stanford.eduVisit source
- Reference 61DIABETESJOURNALSdiabetesjournals.orgVisit source
- Reference 62OBESITYobesity.orgVisit source
- Reference 63SLEEPFOUNDATIONsleepfoundation.orgVisit source
- Reference 64ACHAacha.orgVisit source
- Reference 65NIDAnida.nih.govVisit source
- Reference 66MILITARYHEALTHmilitaryhealth.bmj.comVisit source
- Reference 67AJPajp.psychiatryonline.orgVisit source
- Reference 68HEALTHMANAGEMENTASSOCIATEShealthmanagementassociates.comVisit source
- Reference 69SCHOOLHEALTHschoolhealth.orgVisit source
- Reference 70CAMDENHEALTHcamdenhealth.orgVisit source
- Reference 71JMIRjmir.orgVisit source
- Reference 72JAMIAjamia.oxfordjournals.orgVisit source