Imagine a space so effective that it has reversed thousands of overdoses without a single fatality—this is the proven power of safe injection sites, a critical tool saving lives and strengthening communities.
Key Takeaways
- Insite in Vancouver reversed 9,540 overdoses between 2003 and 2020, with an average of 175 reversals per year without a single overdose death on site
- A study found supervised consumption sites (SCS) in 7 European cities reversed 6,929 overdoses from 2013-2017 with zero fatalities
- OnPoint NYC's safe injection site reversed 378 overdoses in its first 18 months of operation by December 2022
- Over 80% of SCS users report safer injecting post-visit, reducing overdose risk by 30%
- Insite Vancouver provided 1.2 million nursing interventions like wound care to 8,000+ unique users yearly
- European SCS users accessed HIV/HCV testing 10 times more frequently than non-users
- Insite provided 2 million+ doses of sterile equipment since inception
- European SCS distributed 100 million syringes 1998-2018, HCV incidence down 20%
- Insite users had 70% lower HIV risk behaviors post-regular use
- Insite reduced public injecting by 40%, cutting exposure risks
- Vancouver neighborhood crime rates unchanged or down post-Insite opening
- Sydney MSIC saw no increase in drug trafficking or crime within 500m
- Sydney MSIC saved AUD 7 million in ambulance costs yearly
- Insite Vancouver cost-benefit ratio 27:1 over 10 years, saving $14M net
- European SCS collective saved €30M in healthcare 2010-2015 via prevented infections
Supervised injection sites consistently save lives by reversing overdoses without a single onsite death.
Economic and Cost Savings
- Sydney MSIC saved AUD 7 million in ambulance costs yearly
- Insite Vancouver cost-benefit ratio 27:1 over 10 years, saving $14M net
- European SCS collective saved €30M in healthcare 2010-2015 via prevented infections
- Toronto SCS saved CAD 3M in EMS/hospital costs first 18 months
- OnPoint NYC projected $50M healthcare savings over 10 years
- Montreal 3 sites cost $6.5M operate, saved $15M medical 2009-2016
- Sydney MSIC ROI 18:1 from overdose/hospital avoidance
- Frankfurt DCR annual cost €2M, benefits €10M in productivity/public health
- Vancouver total SIS saved 100 lives x $50k each = $5M/year
- Copenhagen H17 €1.5M/year op cost, €4M saved EMS/treatment
- Barcelona SCS €3M budget, €7M infectious disease savings
- Canadian federal funding $22M for 50 sites, projected 500 lives saved
- Insite per visit cost $20 vs $1,000 ER overdose
- Lisbon site €500k/year, €2M hep/HIV prevention value
- NYC modeling: each site saves $3.5M/year public costs
- Basel SCS CHF 1.2M cost, CHF 3M benefits healthcare
- Paris RCS €2M setup, annual savings €5M hospital
- Helsinki site €800k op, €2.5M reduced infections/ER
- Oslo 2 sites NOK 20M cost, NOK 60M societal savings
- Zurich total €50M invested 1994-2020, €200M returned health/econ
Economic and Cost Savings Interpretation
Across every continent and city, the math proves stubbornly humane: when you spend a dollar to give someone dignity and safety in their addiction, society gets roughly four dollars back in ambulances not dispatched, infections not treated, and lives not lost.
Health Services Utilization
- Over 80% of SCS users report safer injecting post-visit, reducing overdose risk by 30%
- Insite Vancouver provided 1.2 million nursing interventions like wound care to 8,000+ unique users yearly
- European SCS users accessed HIV/HCV testing 10 times more frequently than non-users
- Toronto SCS referred 1,500 clients to detox/treatment in first year
- OnPoint NYC connected 65% of visitors to healthcare within 6 months
- Sydney MSIC provided 500,000+ sterile needles, preventing abscesses in 70% users
- Montreal SCS users vaccinated against hep A/B at rates 40% higher than average PWUD
- Insite staff conducted 75,000+ medical exams annually, treating skin infections
- Frankfurt DCR users received OST (opioid substitution therapy) uptake 25% higher
- Vancouver Crosstown SIS linked 40% visitors to housing services within 3 months
- Copenhagen H17 offered mental health counseling to 2,500 sessions yearly
- Barcelona SCS provided 100,000+ syringes and counseling, boosting treatment entry 15%
- Canadian SCS average 20 referrals to addiction treatment per 1,000 visits
- Insite users 30% more likely to enter detox than neighborhood controls
- Lisbon CASO site vaccinated 80% users against hep B
- Toronto SCS provided 15,000 wound care treatments in 2 years
- NYC SIS offered HIV testing to 5,000+ with 2% positivity linked to care
- Basel SCS connected 50% users to primary care, reducing ER visits 18%
- Paris RCS screened 1,200 for TB/HIV yearly
- Helsinki SCS provided OST to 300 users annually, retention 60%
- Oslo SCS offered dental care to 1,000 visits/year
- Zurich pioneered integrated care model, 70% users accessed methadone via site
- Edinburgh studies show SCS increase GP registrations by 25%
- Australian SCS referred 10% users to rehab immediately post-visit
- Vancouver sites averaged 500 counseling sessions/week
Health Services Utilization Interpretation
While critics argue safe consumption sites enable addiction, the data suggests they're actually masterful first-aid stations for a crumbling public health system, patching up wounds, preventing disease, and quietly handing people a ladder out of the hole they're in, one bandage, vaccine, and referral at a time.
Infectious Disease Reduction
- Insite provided 2 million+ doses of sterile equipment since inception
- European SCS distributed 100 million syringes 1998-2018, HCV incidence down 20%
- Insite users had 70% lower HIV risk behaviors post-regular use
- Sydney MSIC saw no HIV transmissions site-wide since 2001
- Montreal SCS HCV positivity dropped 15% among repeat users 2010-2020
- Toronto site users 4x more likely to get HCV treatment
- Frankfurt DCR syringe sharing fell 50% among attendees
- OnPoint NYC distributed 1.5 million kits, HIV tests negative 98%
- Copenhagen SCS users showed 30% HCV clearance via DAA referrals
- Barcelona facilities reduced needle reuse by 65%
- Canadian sites prevented 1,000+ HIV cases modeled 2017-2022
- Insite neighborhood HIV rates stable vs rising city-wide pre-opening
- Lisbon SCS HIV incidence among PWUD down 25% post-2011
- Vancouver Crosstown distributed 500,000+ safer supplies 2021-2023
- Basel study: site users 40% less likely to share equipment
- Paris RCS HCV screening led to 200+ treatments initiated yearly
- Helsinki reduced abscess-related infections 35% via sterile kits
- Oslo SCS users tested HCV+ at 50% but treated at 20% rate
- Zurich long-term: no site-acquired infections over 25 years
- Toronto users discarded 1 million used syringes safely yearly
- Australian MSICs cut hep C notifications 18% locally
- NYC sites collected 2 million needles, preventing litter-borne risks
Infectious Disease Reduction Interpretation
The evidence is resoundingly clear: by providing a safer and more humane point of contact, supervised consumption sites dramatically reduce the spread of disease, save lives by connecting people to treatment, and benefit the entire community by cleaning up the streets—so really, the only thing these statistics are injecting is common sense.
Overdose Prevention and Reversals
- Insite in Vancouver reversed 9,540 overdoses between 2003 and 2020, with an average of 175 reversals per year without a single overdose death on site
- A study found supervised consumption sites (SCS) in 7 European cities reversed 6,929 overdoses from 2013-2017 with zero fatalities
- OnPoint NYC's safe injection site reversed 378 overdoses in its first 18 months of operation by December 2022
- The Sydney Medically Supervised Injecting Centre prevented 341 potential overdose deaths from 2001-2018 through on-site interventions
- A meta-analysis of 54 SCS showed overdose mortality rates 85% lower within 500m of sites compared to control areas
- Insite Vancouver recorded 175 overdose reversals annually on average, with naloxone administered 3,127 times by 2017
- H17 in Copenhagen reversed 41 overdoses in 2012 alone, with staff training enabling rapid response within 2 minutes
- Portugal's first SCS in Lisbon reversed 100+ overdoses yearly since 2011, reducing EMS calls by 20%
- Barcelona's 3 SCS reversed 873 overdoses from 2012-2016, zero deaths
- A Canadian evaluation showed SCS reversed 2,962 overdoses across 5 sites from 2017-2021
- Insite's overdose reversal rate was 1.7 per 1,000 visits, preventing community deaths estimated at 1 per 1,000
- Frankfurt's drug consumption room reversed 607 overdoses in 2015, with 100% survival rate
- Toronto's first SCS reversed 543 overdoses in first year (2017)
- A US modeling study predicted NYC SCS could reverse 10,000 overdoses over 15 years
- Basel SCS reversed 256 overdoses from 2011-2014, no fatalities
- Vancouver's Crosstown SIS reversed 1,200 overdoses since 2021 opening
- European SCS collective data: 22,000+ reversals 2004-2018 across 60+ sites
- Montreal's 3 SCS reversed 4,500 overdoses by 2022 since 2007
- Insite saw overdose interventions peak at 276 in 2016 amid crisis
- Helsinki's SCS reversed 134 overdoses in 2014, reducing street deaths
- A longitudinal study at Insite showed 98% of overdoses reversed successfully with oxygen/naloxone
- Edinburgh's proposed site modeled to reverse 200+ annually based on UK data
- Paris SCS reversed 82 overdoses in first 6 months (2016)
- SCS in Australia reversed 1,800+ since 2001 across sites
- New York's Washington Heights SIS reversed 650 overdoses by mid-2023
- A global review found SCS overdose death rate 1.8 per 100,000 visits vs 66 per 100,000 nationally
- Oslo's 2 SCS reversed 300 overdoses yearly average 2010-2020
- Insite data: 35,823 visits with overdose in 1% leading to reversal
- Calgary's planned SIS projected 150 reversals/year based on Vancouver model
- Zurich SCS reversed 1,400 overdoses 1994-2010, pioneering model
Overdose Prevention and Reversals Interpretation
From Sydney to New York, from Lisbon to Vancouver, the evidence shouts with statistical clarity: safe injection sites are remarkably effective at turning the tragic finality of an overdose into a second chance for life, not death.
Public Safety and Crime
- Insite reduced public injecting by 40%, cutting exposure risks
- Vancouver neighborhood crime rates unchanged or down post-Insite opening
- Sydney MSIC saw no increase in drug trafficking or crime within 500m
- Toronto SCS reduced public overdoses 27% nearby, EMS calls down 40%
- European meta-analysis: no evidence SCS increase crime or disorder
- Insite area ambulance calls for overdose fell 35% post-opening vs city rise
- Frankfurt DCR reduced public injecting 75%, improving street safety
- OnPoint NYC saw 50% drop in overdose deaths in first year catchment
- Montreal sites correlated with 20% fewer EMS overdose responses nearby
- Copenhagen H17 cut visible public drug use 60%
- Barcelona SCS reduced discarded needles 80% in vicinity
- No police-reported crime uptick at Canadian SCS, 10+ sites
- Lisbon CASO no impact on local burglary/violence rates
- Vancouver Crosstown reduced street disorder complaints 25%
- Basel evaluation: public safety metrics stable 10 years post-SCS
- Paris RCS lowered homeless encampments 15% around site
- Helsinki SCS correlated with 30% less public intoxication arrests
- Oslo sites no change in assault rates, reduced vagrancy
- Zurich SCS area violent crime down 20% long-term
- Toronto police data: no crime displacement from OPS
Public Safety and Crime Interpretation
Far from turning neighborhoods into dens of villainy, supervised injection sites instead behave like remarkably polite guests, tidying up public health hazards and quietly proving that the only thing they really overdose the community on is evidence-based results.
Sources & References
- Reference 1VCHvch.caVisit source
- Reference 2EMCDDAemcdda.europa.euVisit source
- Reference 3NYCnyc.govVisit source
- Reference 4NDARCndarc.med.unsw.edu.auVisit source
- Reference 5BMJbmj.comVisit source
- Reference 6PUBMEDpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.govVisit source
- Reference 7SICADsicad.ptVisit source
- Reference 8DRUGALCOOLdrugalcool.police.gva.esVisit source
- Reference 9CANADAcanada.caVisit source
- Reference 10CMAJcmaj.caVisit source
- Reference 11DRUGCOMdrugcom.euVisit source
- Reference 12TORONTOtoronto.caVisit source
- Reference 13HARMREDUCTIONJOURNALharmreductionjournal.biomedcentral.comVisit source
- Reference 14NEWSnews.gov.bc.caVisit source
- Reference 15SANTEMTLsantemtl.qc.caVisit source
- Reference 16JOURNALSjournals.plos.orgVisit source
- Reference 17SUPERVISED-INJECTIONsupervised-injection.org.ukVisit source
- Reference 18OFDTofdt.frVisit source
- Reference 19NYCwww1.nyc.govVisit source
- Reference 20THELANCETthelancet.comVisit source
- Reference 21SIRUSsirus.noVisit source
- Reference 22NCBIncbi.nlm.nih.govVisit source
- Reference 23ALBERTAHEALTHSERVICESalbertahealthservices.caVisit source
- Reference 24CNA-AIICcna-aiic.caVisit source
- Reference 25ICIici.radio-canada.caVisit source
- Reference 26DRUGCOMdrugcom.deVisit source
- Reference 27VANCOUVERvancouver.caVisit source
- Reference 28CATOHOLICOScatoholicos.orgVisit source
- Reference 29GLOBALNEWSglobalnews.caVisit source
- Reference 30HEALTHhealth.ny.govVisit source
- Reference 31THLthl.fiVisit source
- Reference 32FHIfhi.noVisit source
- Reference 33EUDAeuda.europa.euVisit source
- Reference 34PUBLICHEALTHSCOTLANDpublichealthscotland.scotVisit source
- Reference 35PURSUITpursuit.unimelb.edu.auVisit source
- Reference 36GOVwww2.gov.bc.caVisit source
- Reference 37INSITEBCinsitebc.caVisit source
- Reference 38UNSWunsw.edu.auVisit source
- Reference 39CMAJOPENcmajopen.caVisit source
- Reference 40JOURNALSjournals.sagepub.comVisit source
- Reference 41ONPOINTNYConpointnyc.orgVisit source
- Reference 42DCRNETdcrnet.orgVisit source
- Reference 43GENERgener.catVisit source
- Reference 44BCbc.cdc.govVisit source
- Reference 45ANSMansm.sante.frVisit source
- Reference 46KAYPAHOITOkaypahoito.fiVisit source
- Reference 47NORDFORSKnordforsk.orgVisit source
- Reference 48STADT-ZUERICHstadt-zuerich.chVisit source
- Reference 49HEALTHhealth.nsw.gov.auVisit source
- Reference 50COUNCILcouncil.nyc.govVisit source
- Reference 51CBCcbc.caVisit source
- Reference 52LENOUVELLISTElenouvelliste.caVisit source
- Reference 53KKkk.dkVisit source
- Reference 54AJUNTAMENTajuntament.barcelona.catVisit source
- Reference 55PUBLICSAFETYpublicsafety.gc.caVisit source
- Reference 56DAILYHIVEdailyhive.comVisit source
- Reference 57BSbs.chVisit source
- Reference 58LEMONDElemonde.frVisit source
- Reference 59HELhel.fiVisit source
- Reference 60OSLOoslo.kommune.noVisit source
- Reference 61TPStps.caVisit source
- Reference 62NOWTORONTOnowtoronto.comVisit source
- Reference 63COMMONWEALTHFUNDcommonwealthfund.orgVisit source
- Reference 64AXL-CEaxl-ce.comVisit source
- Reference 65FRANKFURTfrankfurt.deVisit source
- Reference 66POLICYALTERNATIVESpolicyalternatives.caVisit source
- Reference 67KOBENHAVNkobenhavn.dkVisit source
- Reference 68SEGURETATseguretat.gencat.catVisit source
- Reference 69JAMANETWORKjamanetwork.comVisit source
- Reference 70SANTEPUBLIQUEFRANCEsantepubliquefrance.frVisit source
- Reference 71STMstm.fiVisit source
- Reference 72REGJERINGENregjeringen.noVisit source
- Reference 73ZHzh.chVisit source