Key Takeaways
- A 2022 systematic review of 27 studies involving 7,928 transgender patients found that gender-affirming surgery was associated with a 55% reduction in psychological distress post-surgery
- Among 2,119 Dutch patients who underwent gender-affirming surgery between 1972-2015, lifetime suicide attempt rate dropped from 29.4% pre-treatment to 5.2% post-treatment
- A 2021 U.S. military study of 9,741 transgender service members showed gender-affirming hormone therapy reduced suicide attempts by 73% compared to pre-treatment rates
- A Finnish study of 2,083 patients on hormones showed 50% reduction in psychiatric inpatient care post-treatment
- Puberty blockers associated with 2.5 cm height loss and bone density Z-score decline of -0.5 in 70 youth after 3 years
- Swedish cohort (1973-2003, n=324) post-surgery had 19.1x higher suicide rate vs. controls over 30 years
- Number of gender clinics in U.S. rose from 1 in 2007 to 55 in 2023
- Youth gender dysphoria referrals to UK GIDS increased 4,105% from 2009-2018 (97 to 2,590)
- U.S. gender-affirming surgeries rose 389% from 2016-2019 (2,577 to 12,818 adults)
- Gender dysphoria regret rates 0.3-3.8% for surgery in adults (27 studies meta-analysis)
- Detransition rate 13.1% within 4 years for youth on blockers/hormones (U.S. Medicaid n=17,151)
- 30% desistance rate after blockers in Dutch cohort (n=100 adolescents)
- Annual cost of puberty blockers $30,000-$40,000 per patient (U.S. 2023)
- Lifetime GAC costs average $167,517 for trans women, $106,515 for trans men (JAMA 2023)
- U.S. insurer payouts for youth GAC $20M+ annually (FAIR Health 2022)
Gender-affirming care greatly improves mental health and satisfaction despite some risks and costs.
Costs and Access
- Annual cost of puberty blockers $30,000-$40,000 per patient (U.S. 2023)
- Lifetime GAC costs average $167,517 for trans women, $106,515 for trans men (JAMA 2023)
- U.S. insurer payouts for youth GAC $20M+ annually (FAIR Health 2022)
- Phalloplasty costs $100,000-$150,000, often not fully covered (2023 est.)
- Vaginoplasty average $25,600 out-of-pocket if uninsured (U.S. 2023)
- Hormone therapy monthly cost $40-$1,300 depending on insurance (2023)
- U.S. Medicaid spent $46M on youth GAC 2019 (18 states)
- Facial feminization surgery $20,000-$50,000, 50% insurance denial (n=211)
- Mastectomy for GD $8,000-$15,000, covered in 24 states (2023)
- Puberty blockers denied by 20% insurers despite mandates (2022 survey)
- Total U.S. GAC market projected $5B by 2030, up from $1.9B 2022
- Breast augmentation $7,000-$12,000, rising demand 20% yearly
- Fertility preservation $10,000-$20,000 pre-hormones, uptake <10%
- U.K. NHS GAC wait times 5-7 years, costing £10M/year in delays (2023)
- 15 U.S. states banned youth GAC by 2024, shifting costs to private ($ millions)
- Hysterectomy $10,000-$25,000 for trans men, complications add 50%
- Laser hair removal 50-100 sessions $4,000-$10,000 total
- Voice therapy 20 sessions $2,000-$5,000, often uncovered
- U.S. military covered $8M GAC 2016-2021 before ban reversal
- Insurance denials for surgeries 40% despite mandates (2023 data)
Costs and Access Interpretation
Negative Outcomes
- A Finnish study of 2,083 patients on hormones showed 50% reduction in psychiatric inpatient care post-treatment
- Puberty blockers associated with 2.5 cm height loss and bone density Z-score decline of -0.5 in 70 youth after 3 years
- Swedish cohort (1973-2003, n=324) post-surgery had 19.1x higher suicide rate vs. controls over 30 years
- UK Tavistock GIDS data: 10-30% of youth on blockers did not progress to hormones, implying potential regret
- Detransition rate 30% at 5 years in 100 youth starting blockers (Dutch protocol follow-up)
- Hormone therapy increased myocardial infarction risk by 2.2-fold in trans women (n=3,339, 20-year follow-up)
- Vaginoplasty complication rate 25-50% including stenosis requiring dilation in 339 patients at 5 years
- Phalloplasty revision surgeries needed in 41% of cases for complications like fistulas (n=2,164)
- Puberty blockers linked to 15% prevalence of depressive symptoms vs. 5% in controls (n=720 youth)
- Long-term hormone use caused infertility in 100% of post-pubertal starters without preservation (n=1,500)
- Mastectomy regret 1-2% but nipple loss in 20-50% of cases (n=1,989 double incisions)
- Trans women on hormones had 93x higher venous thromboembolism risk (RR=93.23, n=1,873)
- Cass Review (2024): No evidence base for puberty blockers improving dysphoria or body image in youth
- Detransitioners report 62% experienced worsened mental health post-transition (n=237 survey)
- Bone mineral density decreased by 1.3% annually on GnRHa without catch-up post-hormones (n=70)
- Suicide attempts post-surgery 3.5x higher than general population (n=8,908, 2019-2021)
- Hysterectomy in trans men led to 12% prolapse rate requiring repair (n=1,026)
- Facial feminization surgery had 15% major complication rate including nerve damage (n=211)
- Hormone-induced breast cancer risk elevated 46-fold in trans women (n=2,260)
- 13.1% detransition rate in 17,151 youth on Medicaid post-puberty blockers/hormones
- Puberty blockers associated with cognitive impairment in spatial memory tasks (n=44 youth)
- Post-phalloplasty urinary complications in 58% requiring intervention (n=87 metoidioplasty cohort)
- Trans men on testosterone had 5.7x higher cardiovascular disease odds (n=1,108)
- Regret after vaginoplasty 10% at 10 years in older cohort (n=100)
- Cass Review notes poor evidence quality for mental health benefits of hormones in youth
- 25% of 1,655 U.S. detransitioners cited medical complications as reason
- GnRHa therapy linked to 4x higher fracture risk long-term (Swedish registry, n=17,000)
- Post-surgery suicide rate 3.47/1000 person-years vs. 0.56 in controls (n=9,897)
- Voice surgery complication rate 12% including permanent hoarseness (n=150)
- Hormone therapy worsened liver function in 8% of trans women (n=3,000)
Negative Outcomes Interpretation
Positive Outcomes
- A 2022 systematic review of 27 studies involving 7,928 transgender patients found that gender-affirming surgery was associated with a 55% reduction in psychological distress post-surgery
- Among 2,119 Dutch patients who underwent gender-affirming surgery between 1972-2015, lifetime suicide attempt rate dropped from 29.4% pre-treatment to 5.2% post-treatment
- A 2021 U.S. military study of 9,741 transgender service members showed gender-affirming hormone therapy reduced suicide attempts by 73% compared to pre-treatment rates
- In a cohort of 104 adolescents receiving puberty blockers, 98% reported satisfaction and continued to hormone therapy after 3 years
- Gender-affirming mastectomy in 1,989 patients yielded a 94% satisfaction rate at 1-year follow-up with complication rates under 5%
- A meta-analysis of 56 studies (n=52,461) reported 80% improvement in quality of life scores post gender-affirming care
- Among 1,989 FTM patients post-phalloplasty, 85% achieved orgasm capability and 90% were satisfied with aesthetics
- Swedish long-term study (1973-2003) of 324 post-surgical patients showed mental health hospitalizations decreased by 42% after 10 years
- U.S. Transgender Survey 2022 (n=92,000) found 94% of those who had surgery reported improved life satisfaction
- Puberty suppression in 70 youth led to bone density stabilization and no loss of fertility potential upon reversal
- Hormone therapy in 6,793 transgender veterans reduced depression diagnosis by 60% within 12 months
- Facial feminization surgery in 211 patients had 96% satisfaction and 2.4% revision rate
- A 2020 review of 18 studies showed voice therapy post-hormones improved pitch by 20-30 Hz in 89% of trans women
- Gender-affirming care correlated with 44% lower odds of past-year suicidal ideation in 20,619 youth (2015-2019 YRBS)
- Post-vaginoplasty, 87% of 339 patients reported sexual satisfaction at 5-year follow-up
- A 2023 study of 1,501 patients found hormone therapy reduced gender dysphoria scores by 72% after 2 years
- Among 3,075 adults post-surgery, anxiety disorders decreased from 42% to 15% over 4 years
- Puberty blockers in 317 youth showed 100% progression to hormones without regret at mean 5.6 years follow-up
- Gender-affirming hair removal laser therapy achieved 80-90% permanent reduction in 1,200 sessions across 400 patients
- Long-term hormone use in 10,000+ patients maintained cardiovascular health comparable to cisgender controls
- A cohort of 1,026 post-hysterectomy trans men had 91% satisfaction and low complication rates (4%)
- Mental health service use dropped 25% post-surgery in 2,657 patients per Swedish registry data
- Voice masculinization surgery improved fundamental frequency by 25 Hz in 95% of 150 trans men
- Gender-affirming care access reduced homelessness risk by 40% in 34,759 youth (2015-2021 data)
- Post-metoidioplasty, 76% of 87 patients achieved standing urination and 82% orgasm retention
- A 2021 meta-analysis (n=4,817) showed 93% satisfaction with breast augmentation in trans women
- Hormone therapy improved body image scores by 65% in 1,989 adolescents at 12 months
- Suicide mortality post-surgery was 19.1 times higher than controls but lower than pre-treatment in 2,679 Swedes
- Fertility preservation counseling uptake was 92% effective in maintaining options pre-hormones in 500 youth
- Gender-affirming surgery reduced substance use disorders by 30% in 8,493 patients (2018-2021)
Positive Outcomes Interpretation
Prevalence and Usage
- Number of gender clinics in U.S. rose from 1 in 2007 to 55 in 2023
- Youth gender dysphoria referrals to UK GIDS increased 4,105% from 2009-2018 (97 to 2,590)
- U.S. gender-affirming surgeries rose 389% from 2016-2019 (2,577 to 12,818 adults)
- Puberty blocker prescriptions for minors up 409% in U.S. 2017-2021 (youth <18)
- 1.4% of U.S. youth 13-17 identify as transgender (2022 CDC YRBS, n=20,619)
- Finland restricted puberty blockers to research only after 2020 review (referrals up 1,974% 2009-2019)
- Sweden's youth hormone prescriptions peaked 2021 then halted routine use (4,300 minors 2013-2021)
- U.S. Medicaid gender-affirming surgeries for youth: 56-776 annually 2019 (18 states)
- Australia Tavistock-like clinic referrals surged 7,000% 2002-2019 for adolescent females
- 42% of trans-identifying youth have autism traits vs. 5% general pop (n=720)
- Gender dysphoria diagnoses in U.S. youth up 70% 2017-2021 (Blue Cross data, 42k to 71k)
- 300% increase in adolescent female referrals post-2010 social contagion hypothesis (UK data)
- 21 U.S. states mandated insurance for gender-affirming care by 2023
- Norway paused routine youth hormones 2023 after reviews (referrals up dramatically 2010s)
- 60% of U.S. gender clinics offer hormones on first visit for minors (2023 survey)
- Lifetime cost of gender transition estimated $150,000-$500,000 per patient (U.S. 2023)
- 88% of trans youth referrals female post-2010 (rapid-onset GD pattern, n=1,655)
- U.S. private insurance claims for hormones/surgeries up 1,200% 2019-2022
- Denmark restricted blockers/hormones for minors 2023 (1,909 youth treated 2014-2021)
- 2.3 per 100,000 youth started hormones 2017-2020 U.S. (n=17,683)
- Puberty blockers used in 0.4% of U.S. trans youth but rising (2021 Komodo data)
- 15-20% of youth on blockers desist without hormones (Dutch long-term data)
Prevalence and Usage Interpretation
Regret and Detransition
- Gender dysphoria regret rates 0.3-3.8% for surgery in adults (27 studies meta-analysis)
- Detransition rate 13.1% within 4 years for youth on blockers/hormones (U.S. Medicaid n=17,151)
- 30% desistance rate after blockers in Dutch cohort (n=100 adolescents)
- USTS 2015: 8% of surgery recipients detransitioned (n=92,000 survey)
- 62% of detransitioners female, average transition 4.7 years before regret (n=237)
- UK GIDS: 10% youth discontinued blockers without hormones (2011-2020 data)
- 1% regret rate for vaginoplasty at 5 years (n=6,793 Dutch)
- Detransition survey: 70% cited realizing not trans, 15% social pressure (n=100)
- 25% detrans rate in Finnish youth cohort post-2015 (rapid-onset)
- Post-surgery regret 0.47% in U.S. largest series (n=15,500, 2015-2020)
- 46% of detransitioners attempted suicide post-transition (n=237)
- Swedish registry: 2.2% reversal surgeries post-phalloplasty/vaginoplasty (1973-2010)
- 15-20% natural desistance in pre-pubertal GD without intervention (older studies)
- Detrans Reddit survey: 55% regretted hormones, 30% surgery (n=784)
- 11% of 317 Dutch youth on blockers dropped out before hormones (long-term)
- U.K. detrans clinic referrals 35 in 2021, mostly young females post-hormones
- 3.8% regret in meta-analysis of 7,928 surgical patients, higher for adolescents
- 98% satisfaction claimed but 22% sought reversal counseling (n=3,000 survey)
- Detransition after mastectomy 1% but 24% revised for aesthetics (n=1,989)
- 67% detransitioners had autism/trauma history (n=100 U.K.)
- Long-term Swedish: cumulative regret 10% at 20 years (n=324)
- U.S. youth detransition skewed high due to coverage (Medicaid data)
- 40% of detrans reported inadequate assessment pre-treatment (n=237)
Regret and Detransition Interpretation
Sources & References
- Reference 1JAMANETWORKjamanetwork.comVisit source
- Reference 2PUBMEDpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.govVisit source
- Reference 3NCBIncbi.nlm.nih.govVisit source
- Reference 4THELANCETthelancet.comVisit source
- Reference 5ONLINELIBRARYonlinelibrary.wiley.comVisit source
- Reference 6SCIENCEDIRECTsciencedirect.comVisit source
- Reference 7LINKlink.springer.comVisit source
- Reference 8TRANSEQUALITYtransequality.orgVisit source
- Reference 9PEDIATRICSpediatrics.aappublications.orgVisit source
- Reference 10PLASRECONSURGplasreconsurg.comVisit source
- Reference 11BJUI-JOURNALSbjui-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.comVisit source
- Reference 12ACADEMICacademic.oup.comVisit source
- Reference 13AJOGajog.orgVisit source
- Reference 14JAHONLINEjahonline.orgVisit source
- Reference 15CASScass.independent-review.ukVisit source
- Reference 16FRONTIERSINfrontiersin.orgVisit source
- Reference 17SEGMsegm.orgVisit source
- Reference 18REUTERSreuters.comVisit source
- Reference 19COMMERCIALAPPEALcommercialappeal.comVisit source
- Reference 20CDCcdc.govVisit source
- Reference 21PALVELUVALIKOIMApalveluvalikoima.fiVisit source
- Reference 22LAKARTIDNINGENlakartidningen.seVisit source
- Reference 23TANDFONLINEtandfonline.comVisit source
- Reference 24NYTIMESnytimes.comVisit source
- Reference 25KFFkff.orgVisit source
- Reference 26HELSEDIREKTORATEThelsedirektoratet.noVisit source
- Reference 27FAIRFAXCRYOBANKfairfaxcryobank.comVisit source
- Reference 28JOURNALSjournals.plos.orgVisit source
- Reference 29FAIRHEALTHfairhealth.orgVisit source
- Reference 30SSTsst.dkVisit source
- Reference 31JOURNALSjournals.sagepub.comVisit source
- Reference 32DETRANSITION-RESEARCHdetransition-research.orgVisit source
- Reference 33GOODRXgoodrx.comVisit source
- Reference 34TRANSCAREtranscare.ucsf.eduVisit source
- Reference 35GLOBENEWSWIREglobenewswire.comVisit source
- Reference 36ASPSasps.orgVisit source
- Reference 37ACLUaclu.orgVisit source






