Quick Overview
- 1#1: Tekla Structures - Industry-leading BIM software for precise 3D modeling, automated detailing, and fabrication data generation for steel structures.
- 2#2: Advance Steel - Comprehensive 3D steel detailing software that automates drawing production, BOMs, and NC files integrated with AutoCAD.
- 3#3: SDS/2 - Intelligent 3D steel modeling software that rapidly generates fabrication drawings, erection plans, and CNC data.
- 4#4: ProSteel - Advanced 3D steel detailing tool for modeling structures, connections, and producing shop drawings within Bentley's ecosystem.
- 5#5: StruMIS - Integrated cloud-enabled platform for steel detailing, estimating, nesting, and production management.
- 6#6: AVEVA E3D Design - Modular 3D engineering design software with specialized tools for clash-free steelwork modeling and detailing.
- 7#7: CADWorx - Plant design suite featuring robust steel structural detailing and integration with analysis tools.
- 8#8: SCIA Engineer - FEA-driven structural software with automated steel design, connection detailing, and drawing generation.
- 9#9: SkyCiv Structural 3D - Cloud-based platform for 3D structural modeling, analysis, and export of steel detailing drawings.
- 10#10: ClearCalcs - Online engineering calculator workspace supporting steel member design and basic detailing worksheets.
We evaluated these tools based on advanced features, reliability, user experience, and cost-effectiveness, prioritizing options that streamline detailing processes, enhance accuracy, and align with industry best practices.
Comparison Table
Structural steel detailing software is vital for precision in construction, with tools like Tekla Structures, Advance Steel, and SDS/2 among the most widely used. This comparison table outlines key features, usability, and practical suitability to help readers identify the ideal software for their projects.
| # | Tool | Category | Overall | Features | Ease of Use | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tekla Structures Industry-leading BIM software for precise 3D modeling, automated detailing, and fabrication data generation for steel structures. | enterprise | 9.7/10 | 9.9/10 | 7.8/10 | 9.2/10 |
| 2 | Advance Steel Comprehensive 3D steel detailing software that automates drawing production, BOMs, and NC files integrated with AutoCAD. | specialized | 9.2/10 | 9.5/10 | 8.0/10 | 8.7/10 |
| 3 | SDS/2 Intelligent 3D steel modeling software that rapidly generates fabrication drawings, erection plans, and CNC data. | specialized | 8.9/10 | 9.4/10 | 7.2/10 | 8.3/10 |
| 4 | ProSteel Advanced 3D steel detailing tool for modeling structures, connections, and producing shop drawings within Bentley's ecosystem. | enterprise | 8.4/10 | 9.2/10 | 7.8/10 | 8.0/10 |
| 5 | StruMIS Integrated cloud-enabled platform for steel detailing, estimating, nesting, and production management. | specialized | 8.1/10 | 8.7/10 | 7.6/10 | 8.0/10 |
| 6 | AVEVA E3D Design Modular 3D engineering design software with specialized tools for clash-free steelwork modeling and detailing. | enterprise | 8.1/10 | 8.7/10 | 7.2/10 | 7.8/10 |
| 7 | CADWorx Plant design suite featuring robust steel structural detailing and integration with analysis tools. | enterprise | 7.8/10 | 8.5/10 | 7.0/10 | 7.5/10 |
| 8 | SCIA Engineer FEA-driven structural software with automated steel design, connection detailing, and drawing generation. | specialized | 7.1/10 | 7.4/10 | 6.7/10 | 6.9/10 |
| 9 | SkyCiv Structural 3D Cloud-based platform for 3D structural modeling, analysis, and export of steel detailing drawings. | specialized | 6.8/10 | 5.5/10 | 8.5/10 | 7.5/10 |
| 10 | ClearCalcs Online engineering calculator workspace supporting steel member design and basic detailing worksheets. | other | 6.2/10 | 5.5/10 | 8.2/10 | 7.0/10 |
Industry-leading BIM software for precise 3D modeling, automated detailing, and fabrication data generation for steel structures.
Comprehensive 3D steel detailing software that automates drawing production, BOMs, and NC files integrated with AutoCAD.
Intelligent 3D steel modeling software that rapidly generates fabrication drawings, erection plans, and CNC data.
Advanced 3D steel detailing tool for modeling structures, connections, and producing shop drawings within Bentley's ecosystem.
Integrated cloud-enabled platform for steel detailing, estimating, nesting, and production management.
Modular 3D engineering design software with specialized tools for clash-free steelwork modeling and detailing.
Plant design suite featuring robust steel structural detailing and integration with analysis tools.
FEA-driven structural software with automated steel design, connection detailing, and drawing generation.
Cloud-based platform for 3D structural modeling, analysis, and export of steel detailing drawings.
Online engineering calculator workspace supporting steel member design and basic detailing worksheets.
Tekla Structures
enterpriseIndustry-leading BIM software for precise 3D modeling, automated detailing, and fabrication data generation for steel structures.
Model-driven fabrication with direct NC/DEX file generation for CNC machines, eliminating manual rework
Tekla Structures is a premier Building Information Modeling (BIM) software developed by Trimble, specializing in structural steel detailing, design, and fabrication management. It allows users to create intelligent 3D models of steel structures, automate connection design, generate shop drawings, CNC/NC files, and erection plans directly from the model. Renowned for its accuracy and handling of complex geometries, it's the industry standard for large-scale projects like stadiums, bridges, and industrial facilities, ensuring seamless coordination between design, detailing, and fabrication teams.
Pros
- Unmatched accuracy in 3D modeling, automated connections, and fabrication outputs including NC files
- Superior clash detection, constructability checks, and BIM collaboration tools
- Handles extremely complex steel structures with parametric components and custom fittings
Cons
- Steep learning curve requiring extensive training and expertise
- High cost with subscription fees and additional module expenses
- Resource-intensive, demanding powerful hardware for large models
Best For
Large engineering firms, steel fabricators, and detailers tackling complex, high-value structural steel projects.
Pricing
Annual subscription starting at ~$15,000-$25,000 per user depending on modules and region; perpetual licenses available but less common—contact Trimble for quotes.
Advance Steel
specializedComprehensive 3D steel detailing software that automates drawing production, BOMs, and NC files integrated with AutoCAD.
Intelligent parametric connection modeling that automatically adapts to design changes and generates precise fabrication outputs
Advance Steel, developed by Autodesk, is a specialized 3D modeling software for structural steel detailing, built on the AutoCAD platform. It automates the creation of fabrication drawings, bills of materials (BOMs), and CNC files from intelligent 3D models of steel structures. The software excels in parametric modeling of connections, stairs, railings, and cladding, while integrating seamlessly with Revit for BIM workflows.
Pros
- Extensive library of over 500 parametric steel connections that update automatically
- Automated generation of shop drawings, BOMs, and NC files saving significant time
- Seamless integration with AutoCAD and Revit for efficient BIM collaboration
Cons
- Steep learning curve due to its AutoCAD foundation and complex toolset
- High subscription pricing that may deter small firms
- Performance can lag with very large or complex models
Best For
Mid-to-large structural engineering firms and steel fabricators requiring advanced, automated detailing for complex projects.
Pricing
Annual subscription starts at approximately $2,500 USD; included in Autodesk AEC Collection for $3,000+ USD/year with additional tools.
SDS/2
specializedIntelligent 3D steel modeling software that rapidly generates fabrication drawings, erection plans, and CNC data.
Patented automatic detailing engine that generates fabrication-ready drawings and CNC data directly from the 3D model with minimal manual input
SDS/2 is a robust structural steel detailing software developed by Design Data, specializing in 3D modeling, automated detailing, and fabrication output for steel structures. It supports the full workflow from conceptual design to shop drawings, CNC files, and erection plans, with advanced connection design and code compliance checking. Renowned for handling complex industrial projects, it integrates seamlessly with fabrication processes to minimize errors and boost efficiency.
Pros
- Highly automated 3D modeling and detailing for complex structures
- Precise connection design with built-in code checking
- Excellent integration with CNC fabrication equipment and BOM generation
Cons
- Steep learning curve requiring significant training
- Outdated user interface compared to modern competitors
- High cost may not suit small firms or simple projects
Best For
Experienced structural detailers and fabrication shops handling large-scale industrial and commercial steel projects.
Pricing
Custom enterprise pricing, typically $20,000+ per seat annually with modular add-ons; perpetual licenses available with maintenance fees.
ProSteel
enterpriseAdvanced 3D steel detailing tool for modeling structures, connections, and producing shop drawings within Bentley's ecosystem.
Parametric connection library with automatic detailing and clash detection for fabrication-ready outputs
ProSteel, developed by Bentley Systems, is a powerful 3D modeling and detailing software for structural steel design and fabrication. It excels in creating precise models of steel structures, automating parametric connections, and generating fabrication drawings, bills of materials, and NC/CNC files directly from the 3D model. Built on the MicroStation platform, it integrates seamlessly with other Bentley tools for comprehensive project workflows from design to construction.
Pros
- Advanced parametric connection design with automation
- High-precision 3D modeling and fabrication outputs
- Strong integration with Bentley MicroStation and suite
Cons
- Steep learning curve due to MicroStation interface
- High cost unsuitable for small firms
- Limited native support for non-Bentley workflows
Best For
Large engineering and fabrication firms already using Bentley software for complex industrial steel projects.
Pricing
Subscription-based via Bentley CONNECT Edition; quote-based, typically $5,000+ per user annually depending on modules.
StruMIS
specializedIntegrated cloud-enabled platform for steel detailing, estimating, nesting, and production management.
Fully integrated production control system that links 3D models directly to CNC machines and shop floor execution
StruMIS is a comprehensive software suite designed specifically for the structural steel fabrication industry, providing end-to-end management from 3D modeling and automated detailing to production control, nesting, and CNC integration. It streamlines workflows by connecting design, fabrication, and delivery processes, helping fabricators reduce errors and improve efficiency. The platform supports complex steel structures with tools for estimating, reporting, and quality control. Overall, it's a robust solution for optimizing steel shop operations.
Pros
- Seamless integration across detailing, nesting, and production modules
- Excellent CNC machine compatibility and automation
- Comprehensive reporting and real-time production tracking
Cons
- Steep learning curve due to extensive features
- Primarily on-premise with limited cloud options
- Custom pricing can be high for smaller operations
Best For
Mid-to-large steel fabrication shops needing an all-in-one system for production management and detailing.
Pricing
Custom enterprise pricing based on modules, users, and deployment; typically requires a vendor quote starting in the tens of thousands annually.
AVEVA E3D Design
enterpriseModular 3D engineering design software with specialized tools for clash-free steelwork modeling and detailing.
Fully integrated multi-discipline 3D model supporting real-time collaboration across steel, piping, and civil teams
AVEVA E3D Design is an advanced 3D modeling and design software suite primarily for plant engineering, with robust capabilities for structural steel detailing including beams, columns, connections, and bracing. It supports the creation of detailed 3D models, automated fabrication drawings, BOMs, and CNC outputs, integrated within a clash-free multi-discipline environment. Ideal for large-scale industrial projects, it leverages laser scan data for accurate as-built modeling and enables global team collaboration.
Pros
- Seamless integration with piping, equipment, and HVAC for multi-discipline projects
- Advanced clash detection and rules-based automation for steel connections
- High-fidelity drawing production and fabrication outputs like NC files
Cons
- Steep learning curve due to complex interface and extensive features
- High enterprise cost unsuitable for small firms or standalone steel detailing
- Less specialized for pure structural steel workflows compared to dedicated tools like Tekla
Best For
Large engineering firms in oil & gas, power, or marine sectors requiring integrated plant design with structural steel detailing.
Pricing
Enterprise licensing with custom quotes; annual subscriptions typically $15,000+ per user, plus maintenance.
CADWorx
enterprisePlant design suite featuring robust steel structural detailing and integration with analysis tools.
Tight integration with CADWorx Plant for automated clash detection and coordination between structural steel and piping systems
CADWorx Steel is a 3D structural steel modeling and detailing software built on AutoCAD or BricsCAD platforms, enabling precise design of beams, columns, connections, and bracing for industrial structures. It automates the generation of fabrication drawings, bills of materials (BOMs), erection plans, and CNC/NC files for direct use in manufacturing. Particularly suited for process plants, it integrates seamlessly with CADWorx Plant modules for multi-disciplinary coordination, ensuring clash-free models between steel frameworks and piping/equipment.
Pros
- Seamless bi-directional integration with CADWorx Plant for piping-steel coordination
- Robust parametric libraries and automated detailing for fabrication outputs
- Accurate 3D modeling with support for complex industrial steel structures
Cons
- Relies on host CAD platform (AutoCAD/BricsCAD), increasing total cost and complexity
- Steeper learning curve for users new to the CADWorx ecosystem
- Less advanced for non-industrial structures like buildings or bridges compared to specialized tools
Best For
Engineering firms and detailers in oil & gas, power, or process industries needing integrated steel detailing with plant piping design.
Pricing
Enterprise licensing with perpetual or subscription options starting at several thousand USD per seat annually, plus host CAD costs; quote-based from Hexagon.
SCIA Engineer
specializedFEA-driven structural software with automated steel design, connection detailing, and drawing generation.
Advanced parametric connection design with real-time optimization and code-driven verifications directly linked to structural analysis results
SCIA Engineer is a powerful BIM-enabled structural analysis and design software primarily used by engineers for modeling, analyzing, and designing steel, concrete, and composite structures. For structural steel detailing, it offers integrated tools for connection design, including bolted, welded, and base plate connections, with automated generation of fabrication drawings and reports. While excels in engineering verification and code compliance, its detailing capabilities are more focused on design optimization than full-scale fabrication modeling like dedicated tools.
Pros
- Seamless integration of FEA analysis, design, and connection detailing in one platform
- Extensive library of parametric steel connections compliant with international codes
- Accurate generation of engineering reports and preliminary fabrication drawings
Cons
- Steep learning curve due to complex interface geared toward advanced users
- Limited support for full 3D fabrication detailing and CNC output compared to specialized software
- High cost may not justify for firms needing only detailing without analysis
Best For
Structural engineering firms that require integrated analysis, design, and preliminary steel connection detailing rather than standalone shop fabrication workflows.
Pricing
Subscription-based with modular pricing; typically starts at €5,000-€15,000 annually depending on modules and user count, with custom quotes available.
SkyCiv Structural 3D
specializedCloud-based platform for 3D structural modeling, analysis, and export of steel detailing drawings.
Seamless cloud collaboration allowing multiple users to model, analyze, and review steel designs in real-time from any device.
SkyCiv Structural 3D is a cloud-based structural engineering software focused on 3D modeling, finite element analysis (FEA), and design optimization for steel, concrete, and other materials. While it excels in analysis and code-based design checks for steel members and connections, its detailing capabilities are limited to basic reporting, DXF exports, and simple drawings rather than comprehensive shop drawings or fabrication outputs. It integrates well with analysis workflows but falls short as a dedicated steel detailing solution compared to specialized tools.
Pros
- Fully cloud-based with real-time collaboration and no installation required
- Integrated analysis, design, and basic reporting for steel structures
- Affordable pricing with a free tier for basic use
Cons
- Lacks advanced detailing tools like automated shop/erection drawings or CNC file generation
- Limited connection detailing and fabrication outputs compared to dedicated software
- Requires stable internet; not ideal for offline detailing work
Best For
Small engineering firms or solo structural engineers needing integrated analysis and basic steel design with some modeling export capabilities.
Pricing
Free tier available; Professional plan starts at $79/month (annual billing) for full Structural 3D features, with Enterprise custom pricing.
ClearCalcs
otherOnline engineering calculator workspace supporting steel member design and basic detailing worksheets.
Comprehensive, customizable template library for steel member and connection calculations
ClearCalcs is a cloud-based structural engineering software focused on performing calculations for steel beams, columns, connections, and other elements using a library of templates. It enables quick design checks, load analysis, and code-compliant verification in a collaborative online environment. While useful for preliminary steel design, it lacks comprehensive 3D modeling and automated detailing for fabrication drawings.
Pros
- Cloud-based with real-time collaboration
- Extensive library of steel calculation templates
- Fast and intuitive for preliminary designs
Cons
- No 3D modeling or BIM integration
- Limited to calculations, not full detailing or shop drawings
- Lacks CNC file export and advanced fabrication tools
Best For
Structural engineers needing quick cloud-based steel calculations and verifications for preliminary design phases.
Pricing
Subscription starts at $39/user/month for basic access, with team and enterprise plans scaling up based on usage.
Conclusion
The reviewed tools span diverse strengths, from BIM-driven precision to cloud integration and rapid data generation. Tekla Structures emerges as the top choice, with industry-leading 3D modeling and automated workflows, while Advance Steel impresses with AutoCAD integration and SDS/2 excels in quick fabrication data—all strong alternatives tailored to specific needs.
Explore Tekla Structures to unlock optimized detailing processes and enhance project efficiency, or consider its competitors based on your unique requirements.
Tools Reviewed
All tools were independently evaluated for this comparison
