Commissioned Research
Top 9 Best AI Dubbing Software of 2026

GITNUXSOFTWARE REVIEW

AI In Industry

Top 9 Best AI Dubbing Software of 2026

Compare ai dubbing software options for video creators, outlining tool differences and use cases with details on Deepdub, Papercup, and Veed.io.

19 min readUpdated Editorially scoped research
How we ranked these tools
01Editorial Scope

Vendors set the topic, but our editors set the inclusion criteria and the evaluation framework before research starts.

02Source Research

Search agents gather the source set and the review record, including transcriptions of video reviews and podcasts.

Read our full methodology →

Framework: Features 40% · Ease 30% · Value 30%

Gitnux may earn a commission through links on this page. This does not influence our reviews. Editorial policy

AI dubbing software turns a source video into multilingual audio tracks with speech synthesis and timed alignment, which changes delivery speed and localization cost for video teams. This comparison helps operators weigh voice quality, supported languages, editing controls, and deployment fit when selecting tools like Maestra for production use.

Maestra is the best pick for content teams doing multilingual dubbing in the browser because its unified transcription, translation, voiceover, and subtitle workspace lets you edit localized output without jumping tools, while Veed.io-3 fits smaller teams that want dubbing plus in-editor visual and caption revisions together.

Editor’s top 3 picks

Three quick recommendations before you dive into the full comparison below — each one leads on a different dimension.

Editor pick
1

Maestra

Integrated transcription, translation, voiceover, and subtitle workspace for editing multilingual media without switching production tools.

Best for: Fits when content teams need browser-based multilingual dubbing with transcription and subtitle editing in one workflow.

2

Papercup

Editor pick

Managed AI dubbing workflow combining custom voices, editorial review, and broadcast delivery for large content libraries.

Best for: Fits when broadcasters and publishers need managed multilingual localization across recurring video catalogs.

3

Veed.io

Editor pick

AI dubbing inside Veed.io’s full browser editor, allowing translated voice tracks and visual revisions in one workflow.

Best for: Fits when content teams need fast multilingual video localization with integrated editing and caption revision.

Comparison Table

1
MaestraBest overall
enterprise
9.5/10
Overall
2
enterprise
8.7/10
Overall
3
8.6/10
Overall
4
enterprise
8.5/10
Overall
5
8.1/10
Overall
6
7.7/10
Overall
7
7.5/10
Overall
8
enterprise
7.0/10
Overall
9
6.9/10
Overall
#1

Maestra

enterprise

AI dubbing software that translates videos and generates multilingual voice tracks.

9.5/10
Overall
Features9.5/10
Ease of Use9.5/10
Value9.5/10
Standout feature

Integrated transcription, translation, voiceover, and subtitle workspace for editing multilingual media without switching production tools.

AI dubbing tools commonly combine translation, voice synthesis, and subtitle workflows, while Maestra adds browser-based editing across audio, video, and captions. Its workspace supports transcription, translation, voiceover generation, subtitle creation, and multilingual media export in one project.

Speaker detection and editable scripts help teams revise timing and wording before delivery. The broad workflow suits content teams, but advanced production pipelines may require external finishing tools.

Pros
  • +Combines transcription, translation, voiceover, and subtitle editing in one browser workspace
  • +Supports many source-target language pairings for recurring localization work
  • +Editable transcripts let reviewers correct wording before synthesized audio export
  • +Exports dubbed media and subtitles for common publishing workflows
Cons
  • –Voice customization is less granular than specialist voice-cloning products
  • –Advanced lip-sync control is not a central workflow
  • –Large projects may require manual review of speaker changes and timing
  • –Enterprise governance and API details are less prominent than the editing interface
Use scenarios
  • Localization teams

    Multilingual episode dubbing with aligned dialogue

    Review-ready dubbed dialogue alignment

  • Film and post teams

    Replacement dialogue for edited scenes

    Faster scene audio placement

Show 2 more scenarios
  • Creators and publishers

    Caption cleanup for web and socials

    Consistent web and social captions

    Creators correct transcripts, adjust caption timing cues, and export consistent caption files for publishing.

  • Course publishers

    Translated captioning for lectures

    Accessible caption files

    Education teams turn recorded lessons into edited, translated, exportable captions for accessibility needs.

Best for: Fits when content teams need browser-based multilingual dubbing with transcription and subtitle editing in one workflow.

#2

Papercup

enterprise

Enterprise AI dubbing for media companies.

8.7/10
Overall
Features8.7/10
Ease of Use8.7/10
Value8.7/10
Standout feature

Managed AI dubbing workflow combining custom voices, editorial review, and broadcast delivery for large content libraries.

Papercup targets broadcasters, publishers, and entertainment teams that need repeatable localization for large video libraries. Its workflow covers script preparation, translated voice generation, speaker assignment, audio mixing, and delivery review. Teams can request custom voice creation and use editorial controls to correct wording, pronunciation, and timing before release.

The main tradeoff is that higher-quality output depends on review and production oversight, especially for names, specialist terminology, and emotional dialogue. Papercup fits publishers localizing documentaries, news archives, and factual programming where consistent language coverage matters more than instant self-service output.

Pros
  • +Supports recurring multilingual video localization at publisher scale
  • +Custom voice creation supports consistent channel or program identity
  • +Human review options address pronunciation and translation corrections
  • +Broadcast-focused workflows support professional media delivery
Cons
  • –Editorial review remains necessary for complex dialogue and proper names
  • –Self-service controls are less transparent than creator-focused tools
  • –Custom production workflows may require coordination with Papercup specialists
  • –Coverage for niche languages and formats may require separate validation
Use scenarios
  • Broadcast content teams

    Localizing factual programming

    Expanded language distribution

  • Streaming publishers

    Adapting video catalogs

    More localized titles

Show 2 more scenarios
  • News organizations

    Publishing multilingual reports

    Faster international publishing

    News teams can prepare translated voice tracks for international audiences while retaining review over names and terminology.

  • Media localization vendors

    Managing client dubbing projects

    Consistent project delivery

    Localization teams can combine automated voice production with human corrections across repeated client deliverables.

Best for: Fits when broadcasters and publishers need managed multilingual localization across recurring video catalogs.

#3

Veed.io

SMB

Online video editor offering AI translation and dubbing.

8.6/10
Overall
Features8.6/10
Ease of Use8.6/10
Value8.6/10
Standout feature

AI dubbing inside Veed.io’s full browser editor, allowing translated voice tracks and visual revisions in one workflow.

Veed.io lets users select source and target languages, generate translated voice tracks, and revise the resulting video inside the same timeline editor. Users can adjust subtitles, replace sections manually, add branded layouts, and export platform-specific cuts. Its browser-based workflow reduces handoffs between transcription, translation, audio editing, and final delivery.

The tradeoff is limited control compared with specialist dubbing suites for detailed speaker adaptation, phoneme-level correction, or complex multi-speaker scene mapping. Veed.io fits marketing teams localizing short product videos, social clips, training segments, and creator content that need rapid review rather than broadcast-grade ADR control.

Pros
  • +Combines AI dubbing, subtitle editing, and video production in one browser workspace
  • +Supports multiple target languages from a single uploaded video
  • +Provides timeline-based manual correction after automated voice generation
  • +Exports branded versions for social, training, and marketing channels
Cons
  • –Specialist dubbing controls are thinner for complex multi-speaker productions
  • –Voice customization is less granular than dedicated voice-cloning applications
  • –Long-form localization can require substantial browser rendering and review time
  • –Advanced production workflows may still need a separate NLE
Use scenarios
  • Social media teams

    Localize campaign videos

    More language-ready campaign assets

  • Online course creators

    Translate instructional modules

    Localized course catalog

Show 2 more scenarios
  • Marketing departments

    Adapt product announcements

    Faster regional publishing

    Marketers produce regional video variants with translated narration, captions, layouts, and channel-ready aspect ratios.

  • Content agencies

    Deliver multilingual client edits

    Fewer production handoffs

    Agencies manage dubbing, visual changes, caption adjustments, and exports within shared browser-based production workflows.

Best for: Fits when content teams need fast multilingual video localization with integrated editing and caption revision.

#4

Deepdub

enterprise

AI dubbing platform for entertainment and media.

8.5/10
Overall
Features8.5/10
Ease of Use8.5/10
Value8.5/10
Standout feature

Enterprise localization workflow combining automated dubbing with voice adaptation and professional review for serialized media catalogs.

Deepdub provides automated dubbing for video content with source-target language pairing, speaker-aware voice generation, and preservation of original background audio. Its workflow can accommodate scripted and unscripted material, including multi-speaker scenes that require voice assignment and timing control. Enterprise teams can also use professional localization services when generated output needs editorial or performance refinement.

Pros
  • +Enterprise workflow supports recurring multilingual content operations
  • +Speaker-aware voice adaptation improves character consistency
  • +Preserves background audio during localized production
  • +Human review options support broadcast-quality finishing
Cons
  • –Managed production workflows can exceed lightweight creator needs
  • –Self-service controls are less central than enterprise coordination
  • –Complex projects may require editorial review before release
  • –Output quality depends on source dialogue and timing clarity
Use scenarios
  • Streaming content teams

    Localizing episodic video catalogs

    Consistent multilingual releases

  • Broadcast localization departments

    Preparing regional broadcast versions

    Faster regional delivery

Show 2 more scenarios
  • Corporate learning teams

    Localizing training video libraries

    Broader learner access

    Organizations create dubbed versions of instructional content for distributed workforces without rerecording every lesson.

  • Global media studios

    Managing multi-language content launches

    Centralized localization control

    Studios combine automated generation with review services for coordinated releases across several territories and formats.

Best for: Fits when media teams need repeatable multilingual localization for series, training libraries, or branded video.

#5

Wavel AI

SMB

AI dubbing and subtitle platform.

8.1/10
Overall
Features8.1/10
Ease of Use8.0/10
Value8.2/10
Standout feature

Speaker-oriented narration voice workflows for producing language-specific voice assets for localized content teams.

Wavel AI turns a source video into dubbed audio and time-aligned subtitles through an end-to-end dubbing workflow. It focuses on producing repeatable language-market outputs for teams that need batch localization rather than one-off edits.

Pros
  • +Batch-oriented dubbing workflow for localized video libraries
  • +Exports localized deliverables with matching subtitles and voice tracks
  • +Speaker-focused voice output workflow for localized narration needs
  • +Supports production reuse across marketing and training catalogs
Cons
  • –More limited advanced editing control than NLE-first video tools
  • –Tighter fit for dubbing workflows than for general video translation
Use scenarios
  • Localization teams

    Dub library episodes for new markets

    Multilingual episodes ready for publishing

  • Marketing teams

    Create dubbed versions of promos

    Localized campaign deliverables produced

Show 2 more scenarios
  • Training content teams

    Localize onboarding lesson videos

    Multilingual training media delivered

    Instructional videos receive translated voiceovers and matching subtitle tracks for multilingual learners.

  • Localization producers

    Generate narration voice assets

    Reusable language-specific audio files

    Teams create language-specific narration audio outputs for later editing and integration.

Best for: Fits when localization teams need repeatable multilingual dubs and subtitle files for batch releases.

#6

Kapwing

SMB

Browser-based video editor with AI dubbing tools.

7.7/10
Overall
Features7.7/10
Ease of Use7.7/10
Value7.7/10
Standout feature

AI dubbing output stays editable alongside captions and social templates in the same editor.

Kapwing targets video creators and small teams that need AI dubbing inside a broader web editor workflow. It generates translated audio for videos while keeping editing steps like trimming, captions, and layout changes in one place.

Pros
  • +Dubbing and editorial adjustments happen in one web workflow
  • +Template tools for social formats speed up localized republishing
  • +Batch-oriented editing supports fast iteration across multiple clips
  • +Caption generation and editing stays near the dubbing output
Cons
  • –Limited control for advanced audio post-production and stem exports
  • –Speaker-specific mapping is weak for multi-speaker scenes
  • –Script-level review tools for pronunciation tuning are not granular
  • –Batch throughput can slow when exporting high-length videos
Use scenarios
  • Global marketing teams

    Localize campaign videos into new languages

    Publish ready multilingual campaign videos

  • Educators and internal comms

    Fix captions and then dub segments

    Deliver clearer, localized instruction

Show 2 more scenarios
  • Social creators

    Create localized meme and short clips

    Post faster localized social assets

    Creators translate and dub short videos, then reuse templates to generate multiple variants.

  • Learning content teams

    Produce multilingual course video collections

    Maintain a multilingual course library

    Teams batch caption and dubbing settings across instructional recordings for consistent exports.

Best for: Fits when creators localize marketing or training videos and need quick in-editor dubbing plus caption edits.

#7

Dubverse

SMB

AI dubbing and voiceover generation platform.

7.5/10
Overall
Features7.5/10
Ease of Use7.5/10
Value7.5/10
Standout feature

Script-driven voice casting workflow helps keep dialogue choices consistent across multilingual episodes.

Dubverse is positioned for creators who need production-style AI dubbing across multiple languages without staying in a full video editor. It centers on generating localized audio tracks and pairing them with timed text outputs so post teams can assemble deliverables faster.

Pros
  • +Script-led voice selection supports consistent character performances
  • +Exports localized audio and accompanying timed text for editing
  • +Batch-style workflow fits recurring multilingual publishing cycles
  • +Project organization helps keep multi-language releases aligned
Cons
  • –Advanced control over audio stems is limited for post-heavy pipelines
  • –Quality can vary when speech is fast or acoustics are complex
Use scenarios
  • Dubbing producers and localization teams

    Maintain character voice continuity

    More consistent voice choices

  • Small post-production teams

    Prepare timed dialogue for edits

    Fewer manual alignment steps

Show 2 more scenarios
  • International content publishers

    Run weekly multilingual release batches

    Repeatable localization cycle

    Publishers process clips into coordinated dubbed audio and caption deliverables on a repeatable cycle.

  • Video localization teams

    Localize episodic series catalogs

    Less manual timing work

    Teams apply the same script and voice-casting approach across episodes to reduce retiming work.

Best for: Fits when video creators need repeatable dubbed audio plus timed text for frequent releases.

#8

HeyGen

enterprise

AI video generation with translation and dubbing features.

7.0/10
Overall
Features7.0/10
Ease of Use7.0/10
Value7.0/10
Standout feature

Synchronized on-screen presenter movement timed to dubbed audio for consistent multilingual delivery.

HeyGen is an AI dubbing and multilingual video localization tool that couples voice generation with synchronized on-screen presentation so creators can ship dubbed versions without filming again. Core workflows include script-based dubbing, language switching with generated audio tracks, and timed subtitle outputs aligned to the source video.

Pros
  • +Script-to-multilingual dubbing workflow with synchronized presentation timing
  • +Batch-oriented production fits repeatable localization runs for video teams
  • +API support supports automation of dubbing jobs in larger pipelines
  • +Subtitle generation supports localized delivery alongside dubbed audio
Cons
  • –Audio and video export controls are less granular than editor-centric dubbing suites
  • –Lip alignment quality varies more with source footage than with studio-clean takes
  • –Voice asset management adds overhead for teams with many speakers
Use scenarios
  • Social media and content marketing teams

    Localized short-form campaign variants

    More consistent localized variants

  • Video operations and developer teams

    API-driven dubbing batch runs

    Higher-volume production with less assembly

Show 2 more scenarios
  • Product marketing and ecommerce teams

    Presenter-led explainer localization

    Publishable demos without filming

    Teams transform scripts into multilingual demo videos without reshooting presenters for each market.

  • Localization and global communications teams

    Multilingual dubbing with subtitles

    Localized versions with consistent delivery

    Teams adapt source videos into target languages while delivering aligned subtitles for each version.

Best for: Fits when marketing teams need repeatable multilingual presenter videos with dubbing and subtitles.

#9

Rask AI

SMB

Video localization and dubbing platform.

6.9/10
Overall
Features6.9/10
Ease of Use6.9/10
Value6.9/10
Standout feature

Voice cloning that can maintain a consistent character voice across a dubbed series.

Rask AI turns a source video into dubbed audio by combining translation output with synthesized speech and timed delivery. It is geared toward batch dubbing workflows for creators and localization teams that need repeatable language production across many assets.

Pros
  • +Batch dubbing workflow reduces repeated setup across many videos
  • +Voice cloning support helps keep character voices consistent
  • +Multilingual outputs are organized for quick review rounds
  • +Works well for both full episodes and short-form uploads
Cons
  • –Lip-sync quality depends heavily on input clarity and shot pacing
  • –Finer-grained audio stem control is limited for complex post pipelines
Use scenarios
  • media localization teams

    Localize episodic video dialogue

    Localized episode audio ready

  • video producers

    Dub with synchronized performance

    Aligned speech audio delivered

Show 2 more scenarios
  • education teams

    Localize training narration

    Multilingual training media produced

    Translate narrated lessons into additional languages with dubbed voice options for accessibility.

  • content creators

    Multilingual short-form dubbing

    Multilingual versions published

    Convert social clips into multilingual versions with dubbed voices and review-ready exports.

Best for: Fits when video creators or localization teams need batch multilingual dubs with consistent cloned voices.

Conclusion

After evaluating 9 ai dubbing software, Maestra stands out as our overall top pick — it scored highest across our combined criteria of features, ease of use, and value, which is why it sits at #1 in the rankings above.

Our Top Pick
Maestra

Use the comparison table and detailed reviews above to validate the fit against your own requirements before committing to a tool.

Frequently Asked Questions About Ai Dubbing Software

How do Deepdub, Papercup, and Veed.io handle speaker-aware dubbing for multi-speaker scenes?
Deepdub supports speaker-aware voice generation and can assign voices across multi-speaker scenes while preserving timing control for serialized media. Papercup adds speaker assignment plus delivery review, which helps catch naming and pronunciation issues before broadcast output. Veed.io focuses on translating and dubbing tracks with timeline editing, so complex character voice continuity usually needs more manual checks in the editor.
Which tools provide an API for connecting dubbing jobs to render pipelines?
HeyGen exposes a developer-facing API for connecting dubbing jobs to external render workflows. Deepdub supports enterprise localization workflows that fit into managed production pipelines, though it is more commonly used as a service layer than a creator-first API surface. Veed.io centers on a browser editor and export workflow, so API-first automation is less central than in HeyGen.
How does subtitle timing get produced and edited across Veed.io, Maestra, and Rask AI?
Veed.io generates localized voice tracks and provides subtitle outputs aligned to the source timeline, then lets editors revise subtitles directly in the same workspace. Maestra combines transcription, translation, and editable subtitle creation in a browser project, which reduces handoffs between tools. Rask AI generates dubbed audio with timed delivery and produces subtitle files for downstream post-production edits.
What breaks when a workflow needs broadcast-grade delivery control instead of quick creator edits?
Veed.io can lag behind broadcast-grade control for tasks like detailed speaker adaptation and phoneme-level correction because it prioritizes integrated editing for faster revision. Papercup can cover those needs more consistently through editorial review steps for wording, pronunciation, and timing. Deepdub can also suit serialized media delivery, but it expects the production workflow to run through its localization process rather than one-off experimentation.
How does voice consistency differ between Rask AI and Deepdub for recurring multilingual series?
Rask AI targets batch dubbing with voice cloning workflows that maintain a consistent character voice across episodes. Deepdub supports speaker-aware voice adaptation and repeats localized releases for series and training libraries through an enterprise localization workflow. Papercup also supports custom voice creation with editorial correction, which helps maintain consistency across a long-running catalog.
When does background audio preservation matter, and which tools address it more directly?
Deepdub explicitly aims to preserve original background audio while generating translated voice tracks, which helps keep location ambience consistent across languages. Veed.io supports timeline editing and layout changes, but background preservation is not its primary distinguishing capability. Papercup focuses on managed localization where audio mixing and delivery review are part of the production workflow.
How do admin controls and project governance show up across HeyGen and Papercup?
HeyGen includes configuration options for reusable assets and controlled voice usage within project workflows, which supports team standardization. Papercup treats editorial review and voice correction as workflow governance for broadcasters and publishers managing large libraries. Deepdub fits teams that need a managed localization workflow for recurring releases rather than lightweight creator governance.
Which tool setups work better for creator-led NLE or timeline workflows, and which require a more managed process?
Veed.io is designed for timeline editing inside the browser, so it fits creator-led localization where captions and layout edits happen in the same place. Maestra supports a browser project that combines transcription, translation, and voiceover plus subtitle editing, which reduces tool switching for content teams. Deepdub and Papercup align more with managed localization workflows where review and production steps influence final output quality.
Where does lip sync and timing control typically land for HeyGen compared with Dubverse and Kapwing?
HeyGen couples synchronized on-screen presentation with dubbed audio and timed subtitle outputs, which supports presenter-style multilingual delivery. Dubverse pairs localized audio tracks with timed text outputs for post-team assembly, which suits script-driven workflows but depends more on downstream editing for final timing polish. Kapwing focuses on in-editor dubbing with caption edits, so detailed timing control across complex scenes may require more manual adjustment.

Tools reviewed

Primary sources checked during evaluation.

Referenced in the comparison table and product reviews above.

How to Choose the Right Ai Dubbing Software

We look for differences that show up immediately in real dubbing work: how well the voice adapts, how clean the audio comes out, and how much control you get over timing and formatting. The biggest separator is usually configuration controls, because that determines how consistently you can reproduce results across files.

Voice preservation controls

Why it matters

Voice preservation controls matter because AI dubbing often shifts tone, age, and emotion. Strong controls help you keep the original speaker identity while still translating or syncing the performance.

How to check

Upload a short clip with a clear speaker and run a dubbing preview for the same target language twice using different voice strength or similarity sliders. Compare emotion consistency and how the cadence sounds in the first 10–20 seconds.

Lip sync timing accuracy

Why it matters

Lip sync timing accuracy matters when you’re dubbing video, not just audio. If timing drifts, the dub feels post-produced and hurts viewer trust.

How to check

Pick a scene with visible mouths and quick syllables, then test at least two timing modes (automatic vs manual offset). Scrub playback and note whether key consonants land on the same mouth movements.

Output audio quality

Why it matters

Output audio quality affects intelligibility and sibilance, especially on names, numbers, and dense dialogue. If compression artifacts or robotic artifacts appear, you’ll hear it even in short samples.

How to check

Render the same 30–60 second line to the main output format and listen for distortion on s, t, and voiced consonants. Ask for downloadable clips from the demo and compare waveform smoothness and perceived clarity.

Subtitle and text formatting handling

Why it matters

Subtitle and text formatting handling matters because dubbing workflows often require matching subtitles to translated lines. Bad segmentation creates out-of-sync captions or broken line breaks.

How to check

Provide an SRT or VTT and request a sample run that updates timing and text. Check whether speaker turns, punctuation, and line breaks remain usable after the dub.

Pronunciation and naming support

Why it matters

Pronunciation and naming support matter for real content: brand names, people, locations, and technical terms. Better tools let you steer pronunciation without redoing the whole script.

How to check

Use a test script that includes 10–20 proper nouns and numbers. See whether the product offers per-word or glossary-style corrections and whether results improve after you change just those entries.

Configuration controls

Why it matters

Configuration controls matter because dubbing projects rarely stay one-off. Fine configuration makes results repeatable across batches and across different roles or voice profiles.

How to check

During the demo, ask where you set output parameters (voice profile behavior, timing strictness, formatting rules). Then rerun the same input with changed parameters and confirm what is saved as defaults vs what resets each run.

Red flags

  • Voice outputs drift in emotion or identity after reruns despite the same settings
  • Lip sync previews show consistent mouth-mismatch during fast dialogue
  • Subtitle timing changes require manual rework for basic SRT/VTT files

Fit by situation

  • If you dub short dialogue scenes for video releases, prioritize Lip sync timing accuracy.
  • If you’re translating content with many proper nouns and numbers, prioritize Pronunciation and naming support.
  • If you run repeated dubbing batches across projects, prioritize Configuration controls.
Commissioned Research

Funding and competing interests

This study was co-funded by several of the vendors assessed in it. No single vendor funded it. Funders could propose the market studied.

They had no role in selecting vendors, setting or weighting criteria, analysing data or drawing conclusions, and they received the same factual-accuracy check as every other vendor assessed.

Market definition, inclusion rules and criteria weights were fixed by an editor before research began and did not change afterwards. Editorial process →

Keep exploring

FOR SOFTWARE VENDORS

Not on this list? Let’s fix that.

Our best-of pages are how many teams discover and compare tools in this space. If you think your product belongs in this lineup, we’d like to hear from you—we’ll walk you through fit and what an editorial entry looks like.

Apply for a Listing

WHAT THIS INCLUDES

  • Where buyers compare

    Readers come to these pages to shortlist software—your product shows up in that moment, not in a random sidebar.

  • Editorial write-up

    We describe your product in our own words and check the facts before anything goes live.

  • On-page brand presence

    You appear in the roundup the same way as other tools we cover: name, positioning, and a clear next step for readers who want to learn more.

  • Kept up to date

    We refresh lists on a regular rhythm so the category page stays useful as products and pricing change.