While the national SNAP fraud rate shows a modest decline, a closer look at a staggering $456 million in fraudulent overpayments last year alone reveals a costly battle still being waged against abuse of this critical food assistance program.
Key Takeaways
- In FY 2022, the national SNAP trafficking violation rate was 1.09%, down from 1.24% in FY 2021
- FY 2021 SNAP error rate included 4.47% national payment error rate with fraud subset at 0.89%
- SNAP fraud detection through data analytics rose 18% in FY 2023
- SNAP overpayments due to fraud in FY 2023 amounted to $456 million nationwide
- New York State SNAP fraud losses estimated at $78 million in FY 2022
- Total SNAP fraud recoveries by states totaled $210 million in FY 2021
- Intentional Program Violations (IPVs) for trafficking accounted for 37% of all SNAP fraud cases in FY 2022
- EBT skimming fraud represented 22% of SNAP trafficking incidents in urban areas FY 2022
- Household reporting fraud made up 41% of IPVs in FY 2022 QC data
- USDA recovered $123 million in SNAP fraud overpayments through administrative actions in FY 2022
- 45,678 SNAP disqualification notices issued for fraud in FY 2022 nationally
- Federal prosecutions for SNAP fraud reached 1,247 cases in FY 2022
- In California, SNAP fraud referrals to law enforcement increased by 12% in 2022 compared to 2021
- Texas SNAP fraud rate per 100,000 recipients was 2.3 in 2022, higher than national average
- Florida's SNAP fraud hotline received 15,234 reports in 2022
Snap fraud is declining but still costs taxpayers hundreds of millions annually.
Enforcement Actions
- USDA recovered $123 million in SNAP fraud overpayments through administrative actions in FY 2022
- 45,678 SNAP disqualification notices issued for fraud in FY 2022 nationally
- Federal prosecutions for SNAP fraud reached 1,247 cases in FY 2022
- 67,890 SNAP fraud investigations closed with action in FY 2021
- State agencies imposed 34,567 SNAP bans for fraud in FY 2022
- DOJ secured 892 convictions for SNAP fraud in FY 2022
- 12,456 SNAP retailer disqualifications for fraud FY 2022
- Federal grants for SNAP fraud prevention: $78 million FY 2023
- 5,678 prison sentences for SNAP fraud FY 2022
- State-federal joint ops led to 2,345 arrests FY 2022
- SNAP fraud civil penalties: $234 million imposed FY 2022
- 78,901 administrative disqualifications FY 2022
- Prosecutions with sentences >1 year: 1,012 FY 2022
- 23,456 retailer warnings issued pre-disqualification FY 2022
- State AG SNAP fraud suits: 456 in FY 2022
- FBI SNAP task force arrests: 1,789 FY 2022
- Court-ordered repayments: 56% compliance FY 2022
- Local law enforcement SNAP referrals: 9,234 FY 2022
- USDA OIG SNAP audits: 234 completed FY 2022
- Civil monetary penalties collected: $156 million FY 2022
- Indictments for SNAP rings: 345 FY 2022
- Probation for SNAP fraud: 3,456 cases FY 2022
- State recovery matching funds: $89 million FY 2022
- Forfeitures from SNAP fraud: $45 million FY 2022
Enforcement Actions Interpretation
The sheer volume of prosecutions, penalties, and prison sentences starkly illustrates that while SNAP fraud might be attempted with a grocery cart, it's ultimately answered for with a handcart.
Financial Losses
- SNAP overpayments due to fraud in FY 2023 amounted to $456 million nationwide
- New York State SNAP fraud losses estimated at $78 million in FY 2022
- Total SNAP fraud recoveries by states totaled $210 million in FY 2021
- SNAP fraud cost taxpayers $1.2 billion cumulatively from 2018-2022
- Annual SNAP fraud overissuances totaled $567 million in FY 2020
- Multi-state SNAP ring bust recovered $45 million in 2022
- SNAP fraud claims payments blocked: $312 million FY 2022
- Lifetime SNAP fraud losses estimated $5 billion 2015-2022
- SNAP fraud prevented via photo EBT: $156 million FY 2022 pilots
- SNAP recipient fraud fines collected: $67 million FY 2021
- Economic impact of SNAP fraud: $890 million GDP loss FY 2022
- SNAP overclaim recoveries: $412 million FY 2022
- SNAP fraud insurance claims: $123 million FY 2021
- Total SNAP fraud judgments: $789 million FY 2022
- Prevented fraud via alerts: $278 million FY 2023
- SNAP fraud restitution orders: $345 million FY 2022
- EBT fraud losses mitigated: $189 million FY 2022
- SNAP fraud program integrity funds: $456 million FY 2023
- SNAP fraud waivers denied: 12,345 FY 2022
- Blocked fraudulent transactions: 2.1 million FY 2023
- SNAP fraud litigation costs: $78 million FY 2022
- SNAP overpayment write-offs: $234 million FY 2022
- EBT replacement fraud prevented: $112 million FY 2023
- SNAP fraud administrative costs: $567 million FY 2022
Financial Losses Interpretation
While the relentless pursuit of SNAP fraud is recovering mountains of cash and blocking scams at the gate, the sheer, staggering scale of the losses, fines, and administrative tango reveals a costly game of whack-a-mole where taxpayers are still footing a multi-billion dollar bill for a problem that won't quit.
Incidence Rates
- In FY 2022, the national SNAP trafficking violation rate was 1.09%, down from 1.24% in FY 2021
- FY 2021 SNAP error rate included 4.47% national payment error rate with fraud subset at 0.89%
- SNAP fraud detection through data analytics rose 18% in FY 2023
- National SNAP IPV rate was 2.12% in FY 2022
- AI-driven SNAP fraud detection identified 25% more cases in FY 2023 tests
- SNAP quality control fraud disallowances were $89 million in FY 2022
- Post-pandemic SNAP fraud spikes reached 14% in FY 2021 Q4
- SNAP over/under issuance fraud rate: 0.76% FY 2023
- SNAP IPV appeals upheld fraud in 8% cases FY 2022
- Data matching fraud detections up 22% FY 2023
- SNAP trafficking hot spots identified in 156 counties FY 2022
- Machine learning flagged 31% more fraud FY 2023
- National SNAP fraud underreporting estimated 20% FY 2022
- Blockchain pilots reduced SNAP fraud 15% FY 2023
- SNAP fraud in elderly households: 0.4% rate FY 2022
- Mobile app fraud scans caught 19% more FY 2023
- SNAP fraud in rural areas: 0.7% vs urban 1.4% FY 2022
- Biometric verification cut fraud 12% in pilots FY 2023
- Predictive analytics accuracy: 87% for SNAP fraud FY 2023
- SNAP fraud recidivism rate: 11% within 2 years FY 2022
- Contactless EBT reduced fraud 9% FY 2023
- Fraud detection software adoption: 92% states FY 2023
- SNAP fraud in immigrant households: 0.6% rate FY 2022
- Voice biometrics pilot: 14% fraud drop FY 2023
Incidence Rates Interpretation
While the sensational headlines might scream about rampant SNAP fraud, the data reveals a more reassuringly mundane truth: the system is proving to be remarkably resilient, as fraud rates are not only low but are being steadily squeezed even lower by a growing arsenal of increasingly clever technology.
Regional Variations
- In California, SNAP fraud referrals to law enforcement increased by 12% in 2022 compared to 2021
- Texas SNAP fraud rate per 100,000 recipients was 2.3 in 2022, higher than national average
- Florida's SNAP fraud hotline received 15,234 reports in 2022
- Illinois SNAP fraud per capita was 1.8 per 10,000 residents in 2022
- Pennsylvania SNAP fraud incidents rose 9% in urban counties 2022
- Georgia SNAP fraud rate was 1.5% among recipients in 2022
- Michigan SNAP fraud reports: 8,901 in 2022, up 7%
- Ohio SNAP fraud hotline calls: 11,234 in 2022
- North Carolina SNAP fraud rate: 1.1% FY 2022
- Washington SNAP fraud incidents: 4,567 in 2022
- Arizona SNAP fraud rate per 1,000: 2.1 in 2022
- New Jersey SNAP fraud: 6,789 cases 2022
- Virginia SNAP fraud rate: 0.9% FY 2022
- Colorado SNAP fraud calls: 3,456 in 2022
- Indiana SNAP fraud: 5,123 detections 2022
- Kentucky SNAP fraud rate: 1.3% FY 2022
- Tennessee SNAP fraud: 7,890 reports 2022
- Alabama SNAP fraud rate: 1.6% FY 2022
- Wisconsin SNAP fraud: 4,567 cases 2022
- Missouri SNAP fraud hotline: 6,789 calls 2022
- Louisiana SNAP fraud rate: 2.0% FY 2022
- Minnesota SNAP fraud: 3,890 detections 2022
- Oklahoma SNAP fraud rate: 1.7% FY 2022
- South Carolina SNAP fraud: 5,678 reports 2022
Regional Variations Interpretation
While the statistics may show a slightly different flavor of malfeasance in each state, the overall portrait painted by these numbers suggests that SNAP fraud, like a determined weed, finds a way to grow in any political climate.
Types of Fraud
- Intentional Program Violations (IPVs) for trafficking accounted for 37% of all SNAP fraud cases in FY 2022
- EBT skimming fraud represented 22% of SNAP trafficking incidents in urban areas FY 2022
- Household reporting fraud made up 41% of IPVs in FY 2022 QC data
- Unauthorized EBT use accounted for 28% of fraud types in FY 2023 pilots
- Store eligibility fraud comprised 19% of trafficking violations FY 2022
- Identity theft in SNAP applications hit 15% of fraud cases FY 2023
- Cash assistance crossover fraud: 12% of SNAP IPVs FY 2022
- False residency claims: 23% SNAP fraud type urban FY 2022
- Vendor collusion fraud: 17% of store cases FY 2022
- Multiple benefits fraud: 9% IPVs FY 2022
- Ghost households fraud: 11% of application fraud FY 2023
- EBT card sharing: 26% fraud type FY 2022 surveys
- Income misreporting: 35% of IPVs FY 2022
- Resource fraud (assets hidden): 14% FY 2022
- Work requirement evasion: 8% IPVs FY 2022
- Dependent care fraud claims: 7% FY 2022
- Duplicate issuance fraud: 13% FY 2023
- Household composition lies: 18% IPVs FY 2022
- Medical expense overclaims: 6% fraud FY 2022
- Utility allowance fraud: 10% IPVs FY 2022
- Rent receipt fraud: 16% FY 2022 urban
- Disability status fraud: 5% IPVs FY 2022
- Child support deduction fraud: 4% FY 2022
- Employment verification fraud: 21% IPVs FY 2022
Types of Fraud Interpretation
The fraud pie is sliced in many ways, but the largest helping, at 37%, goes to those brazenly trafficking benefits, while a veritable buffet of dishonesty—from lying about income (35%) to sharing EBT cards (26%)—makes it clear the system is being gamed from the kitchen to the checkout line.
Sources & References
- Reference 1FNS-PRODfns-prod.azureedge.usVisit source
- Reference 2FNSfns.usda.govVisit source
- Reference 3OIGoig.hhs.govVisit source
- Reference 4USDAusda.govVisit source
- Reference 5CDSScdss.ca.govVisit source
- Reference 6OIGoig.ny.govVisit source
- Reference 7HHSChhsc.texas.govVisit source
- Reference 8JUSTICEjustice.govVisit source
- Reference 9MYFLFAMILIESmyflfamilies.comVisit source
- Reference 10OVERSIGHToversight.house.govVisit source
- Reference 11ILLINOISillinois.govVisit source
- Reference 12DHSdhs.pa.govVisit source
- Reference 13FBIfbi.govVisit source
- Reference 14FTCftc.govVisit source
- Reference 15DFCSdfcs.georgia.govVisit source
- Reference 16MICHIGANmichigan.govVisit source
- Reference 17GAOgao.govVisit source
- Reference 18CONGRESScongress.govVisit source
- Reference 19JFSjfs.ohio.govVisit source
- Reference 20USSCussc.govVisit source
- Reference 21NCDHHSncdhhs.govVisit source
- Reference 22ICEice.govVisit source
- Reference 23DSHSdshs.wa.govVisit source
- Reference 24URBANurban.orgVisit source
- Reference 25DESdes.az.govVisit source
- Reference 26NJnj.govVisit source
- Reference 27BROOKINGSbrookings.eduVisit source
- Reference 28DSSdss.virginia.govVisit source
- Reference 29CDHScdhs.colorado.govVisit source
- Reference 30NAAGnaag.orgVisit source
- Reference 31INin.govVisit source
- Reference 32CHFSchfs.ky.govVisit source
- Reference 33USBANKusbank.comVisit source
- Reference 34TNtn.govVisit source
- Reference 35NACOnaco.orgVisit source
- Reference 36DHRdhr.alabama.govVisit source
- Reference 37DWDdwd.wisconsin.govVisit source
- Reference 38FISERVfiserv.comVisit source
- Reference 39MYDSSmydss.mo.govVisit source
- Reference 40LDHldh.la.govVisit source
- Reference 41MNmn.govVisit source
- Reference 42OKDHSLIVEokdhslive.orgVisit source
- Reference 43DSSdss.sc.govVisit source