
GITNUXSOFTWARE REVIEW
Cybersecurity & Information SecurityTop 9 Best Simulated Phishing Services of 2026
Editorial roundup comparing simulated phishing services and where they fit for security teams, with tradeoffs and selection notes for review.
How we ranked these tools
Vendors set the topic, but our editors set the inclusion criteria and the evaluation framework before research starts.
Agents extract product evidence with provenance, then collect written reviews and transcribe video reviews and podcasts.
Framework: Features 40% · Ease 30% · Value 30%
Gitnux may earn a commission through links on this page. This does not influence our reviews. Editorial policy
GuidePoint Security is the best pick for security teams that want managed phishing simulation execution because its service-led campaign governance pairs scenario design with controlled runs and remediation-ready reporting, while Kroll is a strong alternative for teams needing governed, consistent simulations across units with handoff-aligned remediation workflows.
Editor’s top 3 picks
Three quick recommendations before you dive into the full comparison below — each one leads on a different dimension.
GuidePoint Security
Service-led campaign governance pairs scenario design with controlled execution and remediation-ready reporting for awareness operations.
Best for: Fits when security teams want managed phishing simulation execution and behavior-focused remediation reporting.
Kroll
Editor pickManaged delivery with governance-oriented campaign operations and remediation handoff rather than configuration-only tooling.
Best for: Fits when security teams need managed, governed phishing simulations with consistent execution across units.
Optiv
Editor pickManaged delivery that coordinates campaign design, scheduling, and measurement follow-through across recurring programs.
Best for: Fits when security teams need managed phishing simulations with steady execution and governance across groups.
Comparison Table
GuidePoint Security
specialistProvides social engineering testing that measures employee exposure to phishing and impersonation.
Service-led campaign governance pairs scenario design with controlled execution and remediation-ready reporting for awareness operations.
GuidePoint Security delivers managed phishing simulation campaigns with scenario authoring, click and credential capture paths, and reporting designed for security awareness operations. The service favors tight campaign governance, including controlled rollout patterns and behavior-based reporting for remediation and follow-up.
It is a strong fit for teams that want automation around campaign execution while keeping most setup effort under a service-led operating model. Integration depth is present through enterprise directory and learning workflows, but the overall experience depends on the agreed operating process rather than self-service configuration alone.
- +Managed campaign operations reduce internal overhead for email simulation rollout
- +Scenario workflows support both click tracking and credential-harvesting paths
- +Behavior-focused reporting helps prioritize remediation and follow-up sessions
- +Enterprise workflow integration supports common identity and learning patterns
- –Service-led onboarding means less self-serve experimentation than DIY tools
- –Template and scenario changes can require coordination rather than instant edits
- –Advanced governance requires clear responsibilities between security and operators
- –Admin visibility into every low-level delivery and capture control can be limited
Security awareness operations teams
Simulated phishing alert ownership workflows
Consistent response ownership
Security governance risk teams
Control gap evidence via phishing simulation
Ranked remediation priorities
Show 2 more scenarios
Cloud security architecture teams
Assess cloud posture using simulation governance
Prioritized cloud security fixes
Cloud and identity-linked execution supports posture review inputs tied to documented security improvements.
Infrastructure security teams
Zero-trust segmentation test phasing
Documented segmentation decisions
Phased simulated phishing helps evaluate workload dependencies before enforcing segmentation changes to limit lateral movement.
Best for: Fits when security teams want managed phishing simulation execution and behavior-focused remediation reporting.
Kroll
enterprise_vendorRuns social engineering and phishing assessments as part of its cybersecurity consulting services.
Managed delivery with governance-oriented campaign operations and remediation handoff rather than configuration-only tooling.
Kroll supports phishing simulation campaign planning that can include both click tracking and credential-capture style exercises, with results used to drive user-level remediation. Program delivery is positioned for centralized administration, which matters for teams managing multiple business units and recurring measurement windows. The service model also fits environments where IT and security must coordinate identity and delivery constraints rather than only configuring templates.
A tradeoff appears in the degree of hands-on work required for operational alignment, since strong outcomes depend on agreed campaign rules, tracking expectations, and reporting distribution. Kroll fits situations where internal teams want the simulation run with tight governance, like regulated organizations that need consistent methodology and controlled rollout timing. Organizations that only need fast template-based testing often find the coordination overhead heavier than a pure self-serve approach.
- +Managed campaign execution with governance-focused operational control
- +Credential-harvesting simulation workflows aligned to user remediation
- +Behavior reporting designed for repeatable baseline and follow-up cycles
- +Program administration approach supports multi-team rollout rules
- –Integration and execution success depends on coordinated internal stakeholders
- –Less suited to teams needing rapid self-serve template iteration
Security program managers
Run recurring phishing cycles with governance
Repeatable measurement and remediation rhythm
IT and IAM teams
Coordinate delivery constraints for identity
Fewer campaign disruption events
Show 1 more scenario
Compliance and risk owners
Demonstrate consistent security awareness outcomes
Clearer accountability for training gaps
Centralized administration supports structured reporting that maps behavior to training follow-through.
Best for: Fits when security teams need managed, governed phishing simulations with consistent execution across units.
Optiv
enterprise_vendorDelivers social engineering assessments and security awareness services for enterprise clients.
Managed delivery that coordinates campaign design, scheduling, and measurement follow-through across recurring programs.
Optiv delivers phishing simulation campaigns with operational support around content selection, scenario pacing, and measurement used for baseline-versus-follow-up outcomes. It is most credible when a security team needs consistent delivery across multiple user groups and recurring scheduling instead of one-off template runs.
A key tradeoff is that managed execution and program governance tend to reduce how much control internal teams can exert over every low-level campaign setting. Optiv fits situations where an organization needs dependable stakeholder coordination, such as rolling out business email compromise and spear-phishing simulations while maintaining reporting discipline.
- +Managed campaign execution helps keep simulation calendars consistent
- +Scenario coverage includes link-based and attachment-based phishing patterns
- +Measurement and reporting support baseline and follow-up effectiveness checks
- +Program governance reduces ad hoc changes that break comparability
- –Tighter internal control over every setting can be harder during managed delivery
- –Full integration depth depends on how identity and reporting workflows are structured
Security awareness leads
Run ongoing BEC simulations
Cleaner baseline and trend visibility
IT and identity integration teams
Tie users to access workflows
Less scope drift across users
Show 2 more scenarios
Compliance and audit stakeholders
Maintain repeatable measurement
More defensible training outcomes
Optiv operationalizes consistent campaign configurations to support comparable baseline-versus-follow-up measurement.
Security program managers
Segment risky user groups
Better user-risk prioritization
Optiv uses click and report behavior to inform targeted training assignments and pacing decisions.
Best for: Fits when security teams need managed phishing simulations with steady execution and governance across groups.
Coalfire
specialistDelivers social engineering penetration tests with phishing and physical security components.
Credential-harvesting simulation is handled as a governed workflow tied to coordinated follow-up outcomes.
Coalfire fits teams that want managed phishing simulation campaigns with governance controls aligned to security program reporting. The engagement typically covers campaign design, template selection for phishing email, and coordination of delivery behaviors that map to internal policies. Reporting is geared toward security stakeholders who need consistent measurement between baseline and follow-up campaigns rather than only per-user outcomes.
- +Governance-minded campaign operations for security-led programs
- +Supports credential-harvesting simulation workflows and follow-up design
- +Security-focused reporting cadence for baseline versus follow-up comparison
- +Structured rollout coordination reduces policy drift across campaigns
- –Less self-serve agility than software-first phishing simulation platforms
- –Integration automation depends on engagement scoping rather than plug-and-play
- –Template and scenario iteration can move slower than ad hoc changes
- –Operational handoffs require clear internal ownership for best results
Security program managers
Baseline and follow-up phishing readiness
Consistent measurement across cycles
IT operations leaders
Credential-harvesting simulations with constraints
Lower policy and process risk
Show 1 more scenario
Security awareness owners
Template-based spear-phishing scenarios
Better user response trends
Selects and manages phishing email template scenarios with structured timing and follow-through.
Best for: Fits when security governance teams need managed phishing simulations with controlled rollout and consistent reporting.
CyberCX
enterprise_vendorRuns phishing and social engineering assessments for organizations across multiple regions.
Managed phishing scenario delivery with client-coordinated approval and execution workflow.
CyberCX runs simulated phishing campaigns that fit incident-response and security-awareness engagements, not just generic email testing. Its delivery focuses on scenario design and controlled execution, with reporting that ties user response patterns to follow-up actions.
- +Scenario design tailored to client security priorities
- +Structured stakeholder coordination for campaign approvals
- +Response-focused reporting for remediation planning
- +Strong managed execution suitable for constrained internal teams
- –Limited transparency into self-serve automation workflows
- –Integration depth can depend on the engagement scope
- –Less suited for teams wanting fully DIY campaign authoring
- –Campaign iteration speed depends on scheduling with consultants
Enterprise security teams
Controlled phishing tests across departments
Higher-quality user risk signals
Security awareness owners
Baseline versus follow-up measurement
Measurable reporting trendlines
Show 1 more scenario
Incident response program leads
Phishing tests before tabletop exercises
Better readiness for reporting
CyberCX runs realistic email lures to validate report-phish behavior before broader response rehearsals.
Best for: Fits when security teams need managed simulated phishing delivery with disciplined governance and measurement.
Rapid7
enterprise_vendorProvides penetration testing services that can include phishing and other social engineering scenarios.
Campaign reporting that feeds follow-up training measurement aligned to broader risk and exposure workstreams.
Rapid7 fits security awareness and human-risk teams that want simulated phishing campaigns tied to wider exposure context across their vulnerability and risk work. Rapid7 supports controlled phishing exercises with click-through and report behavior tracking, plus the training state needed to close the loop after each campaign.
- +Campaign reporting supports both click behavior and reporting outcomes
- +Plays well with teams already using Rapid7 exposure and vulnerability programs
- +Reusable campaign operations support repeatable measurement cycles
- +Centralized administration supports consistent oversight across multiple campaigns
- –Phishing execution workflows depend on setup choices made by awareness owners
- –Automation depth for custom campaign logic can be limited versus developer-first platforms
Security awareness teams
Run credential-harvesting themed simulations
Reduced repeat exposure
Vulnerability management teams
Prioritize remediation using exposure context
Remediation ordered by exposure
Show 1 more scenario
Security operations teams
Support incident triage after user reports
Faster structured investigations
Analysts use report outcomes from phishing campaigns to route suspected events into defined investigation and escalation steps.
Best for: Fits when security teams want simulated phishing reporting connected to broader exposure-driven remediation priorities.
A-LIGN
enterprise_vendorOffers social engineering testing and phishing assessments within cybersecurity compliance services.
Engagement debriefs that translate phishing outcomes into a repeatable follow-up test plan.
A-LIGN is distinguished by its managed simulated phishing engagements tied to a broader security assessment practice, not just a self-serve campaign tool. It runs controlled phishing scenarios across email workflows and measures user response through structured reporting and review.
- +Engagement-led phishing execution reduces day-to-day campaign management load
- +Structured debriefs tie observed behaviors to follow-up testing plans
- +Security-focused reporting supports stakeholder review and remediation alignment
- +Operational scoping helps avoid overly broad exposure during testing
- –Automation and API extensibility are limited compared with product-led platforms
- –Turnaround depends on engagement scheduling rather than on-demand campaign publishing
- –Complex identity-provider integrations may require coordination beyond typical setup
- –Advanced customization beyond the managed workflow can be constrained
Security assessment teams
Measure reporting and click behavior
Clear exposure baselines
GRC and risk owners
Document user-risk evidence
Stronger risk documentation
Show 1 more scenario
Security operations
Plan follow-up campaigns
More actionable remediation
Deconflicted campaign scope and outcome interpretation feed subsequent testing rounds.
Best for: Fits when enterprises want a managed phishing exercise with controlled scope and security stakeholder reporting.
NCC Group
enterprise_vendorProvides social engineering assessments covering phishing, impersonation, and employee response.
Services-led scoping that ties simulation execution and reporting to security operations and remediation workflows.
NCC Group runs phishing simulation engagements with a services-first delivery model that pairs campaign execution with reporting intended for security teams. It supports multiple simulation formats through engagement scoping that includes email template work, targeting rules, and post-send measurement on user behavior.
- +Services-led campaign setup reduces internal coordination overhead
- +Reporting focus aligns with security-team decision cycles
- +Engagement scoping supports tailored targeting and measurement goals
- +Remediation guidance supports follow-through after simulations
- –Less self-serve automation than platforms with full admin tooling
- –Integration and workflow tailoring can be engagement dependent
- –Mail-client add-in depth may be limited versus specialist SaaS tools
- –Rapid iteration depends on turnaround from the delivery team
Security awareness leaders
Role-based simulated phishing exercises
Role-specific training results
Software procurement legal teams
Escrow-linked continuity planning
Service continuity assurance
Show 2 more scenarios
OT security leaders
Simulated phishing for industrial risk review
Feasible OT security upgrades
Assessments translate findings into compensating controls and hardening plans with assigned implementation steps.
Product security teams
Emerging tech risk reviews
Actionable design guidance
Security assessments alongside adversarial testing and cryptography consulting inform safer deployment recommendations.
Best for: Fits when security teams want managed phishing simulations and stakeholder-ready reporting, with integration shaped by the engagement.
Schellman
specialistConducts social engineering penetration tests to assess phishing resistance and control effectiveness.
Governance and evidence packaging that connects campaign results to control remediation artifacts.
Schellman delivers simulated phishing as part of broader security and compliance engagements, pairing campaign design with governance-focused assessment work. Its coverage typically includes phishing content development, controlled execution across an organization, and management reporting tied to security control improvement priorities.
- +Phishing exercises mapped to security governance and remediation priorities
- +Audit-friendly documentation approach for control evidence and closure packages
- +Engagement-led campaign design that fits complex enterprise contexts
- +Reporting aimed at leadership decision-making, not just end-user results
- –Iteration speed depends on consultancy scheduling and campaign change requests
- –Less hands-on automation depth than specialized phishing simulation platforms
- –User-risk scoring outputs may not be as granular as dedicated simulation tools
- –Depends on engagement scope to cover advanced workflows like report-phish automation
Security program owners
Turn phishing findings into governance actions
Actionable governance artifacts
Compliance and audit teams
Close open control findings
Traceable closure packages
Show 2 more scenarios
Payment security stakeholders
Validate control boundaries for phishing risk
Documented control closure
Schellman helps define relevant scope and assembles documentation that supports control closure across payment systems.
AI governance teams
Assess related governance readiness
Readiness gap documentation
Schellman supports readiness documentation work when governance reviews must include security control execution evidence.
Best for: Fits when security and compliance teams need simulated phishing tied to audit evidence and governance improvements.
Conclusion
After evaluating 9 simulated phishing, GuidePoint Security stands out as our overall top pick — it scored highest across our combined criteria of features, ease of use, and value, which is why it sits at #1 in the rankings above.
Use the comparison table and detailed reviews above to validate the fit against your own requirements before committing to a tool.
Frequently Asked Questions About Simulated Phishing
How do A-LIGN and Coalfire handle administrator governance during a simulated phishing campaign?
Which provider models focus on credential-harvesting simulations with controlled follow-up outcomes?
How do Rapid7 and Kroll connect phishing results to broader risk or identity workflows after the campaign ends?
When do CyberCX and NCC Group fit better than self-serve phishing simulation tools?
What breaks if an organization needs rapid campaign iteration without operational coordination?
How do identity-provider integration and directory synchronization typically show up in managed delivery?
Which providers include audit-oriented evidence handling as part of the phishing simulation workflow?
How do onboarding and execution models differ across Optiv and NCC Group when teams run recurring programs?
Which provider is most aligned for organizations that need behavior-focused remediation reporting tied to follow-up actions?
Tools reviewed
Primary sources checked during evaluation.
Referenced in the comparison table and product reviews above.
How to Choose the Right Simulated Phishing
In simulated phishing, the real differentiator is how well a tool controls and proves what happened in your tests. We focus on choices like reporting accuracy, scenario coverage, and automation that match your workflow.
Scenario type coverage
Why it matters
Scenario type coverage matters because simulated phishing only changes behavior when the scenarios resemble what users face. If link-only or credential-only tests dominate, your program may miss the real failure modes.
How to check
On a demo, filter the scenario library by common lures (links, attachments, and credential pages) and confirm what is available as ready-made content. Then ask whether you can create a custom scenario with the same mechanics and validate it in a sandbox run.
Targeting and scope controls
Why it matters
Targeting and scope controls matter because simulated phishing should reach the right groups without accidentally testing everyone. Good scoping also supports controlled baselines before you expand coverage.
How to check
Check how you choose recipients: group selection, exclusions, and scheduling windows. Ask how many overlapping audiences are supported and run a sample blast to confirm the audience preview matches the actual send log.
Reporting and audit log detail
Why it matters
Reporting and audit log detail matters because you need to verify outcomes, not just completion. With simulated phishing, missing timestamps or unclear event definitions make results hard to trust.
How to check
Generate a report for a recent simulated run and verify it includes events like delivery, open/click behavior (where applicable), and submission outcomes where used. Ask to export the underlying event history and confirm the dashboard numbers match the export.
API and automation surface
Why it matters
API and automation surface matter when simulated phishing must plug into existing identity, ticketing, or reporting workflows. Limited automation forces manual operations and increases the chance of configuration drift.
How to check
Request an API or automation demo: creating a run, pulling results, and updating configurations through scripts. Confirm authentication method and whether automation actions are reflected in the audit log.
Scenario configuration flexibility
Why it matters
Scenario configuration flexibility matters because you may need to match your brand, domains, user roles, and learning objectives. If settings are locked down, admins can’t correct content or flows without a redesign.
How to check
On the demo, modify one scenario end-to-end: sender identity, landing page wording, tracking options, and success/fail criteria. Then check whether changes create a new version you can trace back in reports.
Admin permissions and RBAC
Why it matters
Admin permissions and RBAC matter because simulated phishing affects real user accounts and outcomes. Without role separation, the wrong person can alter scenarios or view sensitive result data.
How to check
Ask to define at least two roles (for example, scenario manager vs. read-only viewer) and confirm what each role can change. Verify role actions appear in the audit log and that exports respect permissions.
Red flags
- Reports show outcomes but exports don’t match
- Scenario scoping preview doesn’t match the send log
- Admin roles change scenarios or view results without limits
Fit by situation
- If you need to cover multiple lure styles and custom flows, prioritize Scenario type coverage.
- If you must run controlled tests across departments, prioritize Targeting and scope controls.
- If multiple teams manage and review outcomes, prioritize Reporting and audit log detail.
Funding and competing interests
This study was co-funded by several of the vendors assessed in it. No single vendor funded it. Funders could propose the market studied.
They had no role in selecting vendors, setting or weighting criteria, analysing data or drawing conclusions, and they received the same factual-accuracy check as every other vendor assessed.
Market definition, inclusion rules and criteria weights were fixed by an editor before research began and did not change afterwards. Editorial process →
- Service review · 2026 · Cybersecurity & Information SecurityPhishing Protection
- Service review · 2026 · Cybersecurity & Information SecurityPhishing Testing
- Review · 2026 · Cybersecurity & Information SecurityPhishing Test Software
- Review · 2026 · General KnowledgeSimulated Trading Software
- Service review · 2026 · Cybersecurity & Information SecurityAdversary Simulation
Keep exploring
Comparing two specific tools?
Software Alternatives
See head-to-head software comparisons with feature breakdowns, pricing, and our recommendation for each use case.
Explore software alternatives→In this category
Cybersecurity & Information Security alternatives
See side-by-side comparisons of cybersecurity & information security tools and pick the right one for your stack.
Compare cybersecurity & information security tools→