
GITNUXSOFTWARE REVIEW
Cybersecurity & Information SecurityTop 10 Best Cyber Security Rating Services of 2026
Compare cyber security rating services for due diligence and risk reviews, with practical notes on EY, Deloitte, and Kroll options.
How we ranked these tools
Vendors set the topic, but our editors set the inclusion criteria and the evaluation framework before research starts.
Search agents gather the source set and the review record, including transcriptions of video reviews and podcasts.
Framework: Features 40% · Ease 30% · Value 30%
Gitnux may earn a commission through links on this page. This does not influence our reviews. Editorial policy
EY is the best pick for enterprise teams that need audit-ready cyber risk ratings, because its evidence-first rating packs translate findings into remediation accountability rather than just a scorecard, while Kroll fits teams coordinating procurement, security, and compliance since it standardizes evidence-to-rating decisions.
Editor’s top 3 picks
Three quick recommendations before you dive into the full comparison below — each one leads on a different dimension.
EY
Evidence handling and rating-pack outputs designed to support audit narratives and remediation accountability, not just a scorecard.
Best for: Fits when enterprise teams need audit-ready cyber risk ratings for procurement and vendor governance.
Deloitte
Editor pickFramework-mapped evidence review that turns questionnaire artifacts into scored narratives aligned to audit and procurement decisioning.
Best for: Fits when regulated programs need consistent, evidence-based vendor risk ratings and audit trails across many suppliers.
Kroll
Editor pickEvidence-to-scorecard packaging that standardizes vendor cyber risk decisions across procurement, security, and compliance teams.
Best for: Fits when enterprise programs need consistent vendor cyber risk ratings and managed evidence collection.
Comparison Table
EY
enterprise_vendorEY provides cyber risk consulting, third-party assessments, control reviews, and resilience advisory services.
Evidence handling and rating-pack outputs designed to support audit narratives and remediation accountability, not just a scorecard.
EY fits organizations that need evidence-based cyber risk ratings tied to governance, not just questionnaires or one-off scoring. Assessment delivery is oriented around security posture evaluation and control effectiveness reporting that can be converted into audit narratives and vendor risk decisions.
A key tradeoff is that EY ratings are largely engagement-driven rather than self-serve scoring automation inside a resident product UI. EY works best when risk teams must manage complex scope boundaries, coordinate evidence requests, and produce auditable documentation for procurement and internal audit.
- +Assessment-to-audit translation with evidence-first reporting structure
- +Methodology driven rating logic mapped to enterprise governance needs
- +Strong support for third-party risk workflows and remediation expectations
- +Consistent documentation packages for internal and external audit use
- –Less self-serve automation for continuous rating updates
- –Requires structured input to maintain scope consistency across vendors
Enterprise procurement risk teams
Rate vendors for security questionnaire decisions
Faster, documented vendor approvals
Internal audit leaders
Support audit evidence for cyber risk
Reduced audit remediation churn
Show 2 more scenarios
Security program owners
Standardize ratings across business units
Comparable risk views
EY applies consistent assessment logic and reporting structure across multiple vendor and internal scopes.
Compliance and control management
Link assessment results to control frameworks
Clearer control effectiveness accountability
EY organizes findings to align with control expectations used in governance reporting.
Best for: Fits when enterprise teams need audit-ready cyber risk ratings for procurement and vendor governance.
Deloitte
enterprise_vendorDeloitte provides cyber risk management, third-party risk assessments, and security control advisory services.
Framework-mapped evidence review that turns questionnaire artifacts into scored narratives aligned to audit and procurement decisioning.
Deloitte delivers cyber security ratings used for evidence-based third-party risk assessments and audit support. Its methodology work centers on control effectiveness mapping to widely used frameworks like NIST Cybersecurity Framework, CIS Controls, and ISO 27001 alignment, then translating findings into structured scoring narratives.
Deloitte also supports security questionnaire automation workflows through standardized request intake and evidence review cycles that feed security posture score outputs for vendor and supply chain decisions. Delivery tends to be consultative, with governance and audit trail expectations suited to regulated environments and large vendor programs rather than self-serve rating production.
- +Evidence review anchored to recognized control frameworks and audit-ready documentation
- +Structured rating narratives designed for vendor risk and procurement workflows
- +Delivery governance supports repeatable assessment cycles across many suppliers
- +Security questionnaire intake processes reduce back-and-forth on evidence requests
- –Rating output depends on engagement delivery rather than self-serve configuration
- –Automation depth for questionnaire and scoring can be limited without tailored workflow design
- –Scoring transparency can feel documentation-heavy for internal teams seeking quick views
- –External data sources for exploitability style enrichment are not a native focus
Third-party risk teams
Evidence scoring for vendor risk decisions
Consistent vendor posture scores
Compliance and audit teams
Audit-ready cyber security rating evidence
Defensible audit documentation
Show 2 more scenarios
Security questionnaire owners
Automated evidence intake and review
Faster rating cycle throughput
Standardizes intake and evidence review cycles so rating outputs can feed supply chain decisions.
Vendor supply chain managers
Structured scoring for portfolio decisions
Actionable supply chain ratings
Uses framework alignment and scoring narratives to inform decisions across a supply chain vendor portfolio.
Best for: Fits when regulated programs need consistent, evidence-based vendor risk ratings and audit trails across many suppliers.
Kroll
specialistKroll provides cyber risk assessments, third-party risk reviews, and incident readiness consulting.
Evidence-to-scorecard packaging that standardizes vendor cyber risk decisions across procurement, security, and compliance teams.
Kroll’s core strength is converting review artifacts into consistent rating scorecards that can be shared across procurement, compliance, and security teams without reinterpreting results per stakeholder. The delivery model is built around controlled assessment steps that support repeatability across vendor populations and reduce ad hoc evidence requests during security reviews. Kroll also supports the third-party risk cycle with structured reporting packages that can feed ongoing reassessment workflows and remediation tracking.
A tradeoff appears in implementation effort when buyers need strict mapping to internal security frameworks or custom questionnaire logic, which can require coordination with Kroll during onboarding. Kroll fits best for organizations that run frequent vendor onboarding and periodic reassessments and need consistent evidence standards across geographies and vendor tiers.
- +Evidence-to-rating workflows reduce score interpretation drift across stakeholders
- +Security questionnaire automation supports faster vendor onboarding cycles
- +Structured remediation tracking improves follow-through on identified gaps
- +Governance-oriented reporting supports consistent board-level risk communication
- –Tailoring rating criteria to internal control mapping takes coordination effort
- –Rating delivery depends on evidence quality from reviewed vendors
- –API and data export depth varies by engagement scope
- –Less suited for teams seeking fully self-serve scoring without project involvement
Third-party risk teams
Reassess high-volume supplier portfolio risk
More consistent vendor risk decisions
Security governance leaders
Standardize rating reporting for audits
Faster audit support cycles
Show 2 more scenarios
Procurement and vendor managers
Automate questionnaire evidence collection
Shorter onboarding timelines
Reduces back-and-forth by structuring requests and accepted evidence submissions.
Security program owners
Track remediation across rating cycles
Higher remediation completion rates
Organizes findings into follow-up work streams tied to rating results.
Best for: Fits when enterprise programs need consistent vendor cyber risk ratings and managed evidence collection.
Optiv
agencyOptiv provides cyber advisory, third-party risk, vulnerability management, and security assessment services.
Managed assessment-to-score workflow that converts client artifacts into governance-grade rating reports mapped to customer frameworks.
Optiv operates a cyber security rating and advisory service built around evidence-based assessments tied to customer security goals and audit expectations. The rating work is commonly delivered as an assessment and scoring workflow that feeds vendor risk decisions and remediation planning for security controls.
- +Evidence-led rating outputs that map to customer control frameworks
- +Engagement workflows align rating findings to remediation planning and ownership
- +Governance-ready reporting for audits and third-party risk processes
- +Delivery experience supports complex environments with multiple evidence sources
- –Automation depth and API access depend on engagement scope and tooling handoff
- –Scoring workflows require structured evidence collection from stakeholders
- –Rating customization can increase effort when frameworks and questionnaires conflict
- –Throughput for frequent vendor scoring depends on analyst capacity and intake quality
Security governance teams
Cyber security rating for vendor risk
Vendor risk scoring package
Cloud security teams
Cyber security rating for cloud controls
Coordinated cloud remediation plan
Show 2 more scenarios
Application security teams
Evidence-backed cyber security rating validation
Retest-ready vulnerability evidence
Runs scoped adversary-focused assessments to provide evidence about exploitability and remediation effectiveness.
SOC and risk leaders
Cyber security rating aligned operations governance
More consistent audit support
Aligns evidence capture, escalation paths, and executive reporting so rating outputs remain audit-supportable.
Best for: Fits when security teams need evidence-based vendor risk ratings with audit-ready documentation and guided remediation alignment.
KPMG
enterprise_vendorKPMG conducts cybersecurity maturity reviews, third-party risk assessments, and security governance consulting.
Evidence traceability from scoring criteria to documented artifacts that supports audit and third-party decision records.
KPMG typically fits organizations that need cyber risk assessments aligned to recognized control frameworks and vendor due-diligence processes. Deliverables emphasize traceability from rating criteria to supporting artifacts, which reduces gaps during security questionnaire reviews and internal audit preparation. The engagement model supports handling multiple vendor profiles without forcing teams to invent an evaluation rubric from scratch.
- +Control-to-evidence mapping supports audit and procurement documentation needs
- +Engagement execution brings consistency across multi-vendor assessment cycles
- +Structured rating criteria fits security questionnaire and vendor risk reviews
- +Governance focus improves clarity of rating assumptions and constraints
- –Engagement-driven delivery limits speed for frequent rating updates
- –Evidence collection requires vendor participation and internal coordination
- –API-first automation and self-serve workflows are not the core interaction
- –Rating methodology usage depends on engagement scoping and assessment design
Security governance teams
Create audit-ready cyber risk ratings
Reduced audit evidence gaps
Third-party risk managers
Standardize supplier risk questionnaire scoring
Consistent vendor risk decisions
Show 2 more scenarios
Internal audit leaders
Verify rating methodology coverage
Faster audit walkthroughs
Deliverables provide traceability and assumptions so audit teams can validate assessment completeness.
CISO office
Prioritize remediation based on assessment findings
More targeted remediation focus
Engagement outputs support remediation planning tied to control effectiveness evidence gaps.
Best for: Fits when audit-ready vendor risk ratings are needed for governance and procurement cycles.
GuidePoint Security
agencyGuidePoint Security provides cyber advisory, risk assessments, penetration testing, and managed security services.
Evidence-first security rating methodology that converts questionnaire inputs into a consistent scorecard deliverable for third-party reviews.
GuidePoint Security delivers cyber risk rating support focused on third-party risk and audit-ready security evidence, then maps findings into a consistent scorecard workflow. Its core work centers on collecting organization-specific security data, validating control claims, and producing defensible security posture outputs for vendor risk decisions.
- +Third-party risk workflow supports security questionnaire evidence collection
- +Rating outputs tie to a defined scorecard approach for vendor risk decisions
- +Remediation-oriented findings translate audit requirements into next actions
- +Engagement evidence packages support repeatable security posture comparisons
- –Admin overhead increases with large vendor sets and recurring reviews
- –Depth of control validation depends on the quality of provided evidence
Cloud security architects
Cyber security rating for cloud posture review
Prioritized cloud control improvements
Security governance and compliance
Cyber security rating with remediation prioritization
Documented gap priorities
Show 2 more scenarios
Security testing teams
Cyber security rating from targeted testing evidence
Actionable corrective priorities
Uses targeted testing to identify exploitable weaknesses and generate remediation guidance for rating documentation.
Infrastructure security owners
Cyber security rating for zero-trust segmentation rollout
Documented lateral movement reduction
Analyzes workload dependencies before testing to support phased segmentation enforcement decisions for ratings.
Best for: Fits when organizations need defensible security ratings for vendor risk decisions with evidence-led control validation.
Orange Cyberdefense
specialistOrange Cyberdefense provides cyber advisory, managed security, threat intelligence, and exposure assessment services.
Control-to-evidence scorecard mapping that ties rating outcomes to auditable assessment artifacts across audit and vendor workflows.
Orange Cyberdefense delivers cyber security rating services built around evidence-led assessments and repeatable rating methodology. It focuses on translating security posture evidence into a structured rating scorecard used for audits and third-party risk decisions.
- +Evidence-led rating scorecards support consistent audit and vendor comparisons
- +Questionnaire and evidence collection workflows reduce manual chase cycles
- +Control-to-evidence mapping supports traceability for audit-ready reporting
- +Governance outputs align well with third-party risk assessments
- –Rating outputs depend on disciplined input quality from assessed parties
- –API and automation surface details are less clear than questionnaire workflow depth
- –Standalone internet-facing discovery coverage is not a primary focus in most engagements
- –Deep remediation tracking can require tighter process ownership than ratings alone
Vendor risk teams
Cyber security rating from questionnaire evidence
Comparable audit-ready ratings
Security operations teams
Cyber security rating supported by managed SOC
More consistent investigations
Show 2 more scenarios
Cloud operations teams
Cyber security rating with cloud monitoring linkage
Cloud alerts tied to fixes
Connects cloud telemetry investigation and remediation workflows to rating scorecard evidence handling.
Detection engineering teams
Cyber security rating evidence for investigation playbooks
More relevant security investigations
Connects telemetry sources and detection logic to support structured investigations that feed rating evidence.
Best for: Fits when regulated audit cycles and third-party risk decisions require evidence mapping into comparable ratings.
Coalfire
specialistCoalfire performs cybersecurity assessments, compliance reviews, penetration tests, and risk advisory work.
Evidence traceability from collected artifacts to rating outputs for audit-ready governance and third-party risk decisions.
Coalfire delivers cyber security rating and assessment work focused on evidence-based scoring for organizations that must answer vendor risk and audit scrutiny with documented methods. Its teams map findings to established control frameworks and produce rating artifacts designed for third-party and internal governance workflows.
- +Evidence-based rating artifacts tailored for security questionnaires and vendor risk decisions
- +Control framework mapping supports consistent governance across audits and third parties
- +Repeatable assessment workflows support ongoing vendor risk reviews
- +Engagement delivery emphasizes traceability from evidence to scoring outcomes
- –Automation and API surfaces are less prominent than services built fully for self-serve workflows
- –Scoring rigor depends on access to required evidence and system documentation
- –Integration depth into existing tooling varies by engagement scope and data formats
- –Admin and governance controls are constrained by project-based engagement delivery
Application owners
Cyber security rating from scoped penetration findings
Evidence for remediation work
Industrial security teams
Cyber security rating for OT and ICS safeguards
Governance-ready OT improvements
Show 2 more scenarios
Healthcare compliance teams
Cyber security rating with HIPAA-linked evidence
Audit-ready security evidence
Connects HIPAA-focused assessments with evidence collection and security operations for audit-ready rating outputs.
Supply-chain risk managers
Cyber security rating for vendor evidence workflows
Actionable vendor rating findings
Reviews third-party security evidence and supports remediation planning for vendor risk reviews.
Best for: Fits when security and compliance teams need evidence-backed cyber risk ratings for vendor risk and audit-facing documentation.
Accenture
enterprise_vendorAccenture provides cyber risk consulting, exposure assessments, resilience planning, and security transformation services.
Evidence-based assessment delivery that turns questionnaire inputs into traceable findings mapped to control requirements.
Accenture delivers cyber security rating services that prioritize audit-grade evidence, structured scoring, and supplier risk reporting.
- +Questionnaire automation and evidence collection support vendor risk cycles
- +Structured scoring outputs align to common controls frameworks used in audits
- +Delivery practices emphasize audit-ready documentation and traceable findings
- +Governance reporting supports remediation follow-ups across stakeholders
- –Lower reliance on a self-serve ratings portal limits day-to-day admin independence
- –Assessment timelines can feel heavyweight for small vendor reviews
- –Tight rubric tailoring requires active stakeholder participation from both sides
- –Integration depth with internal tooling depends on engagement scope and implementation
CISO and risk leaders
Cyber security rating for governance target model
Clear operating model direction
Mobile product security teams
Cyber security rating across release remediation
Repeatable security improvements
Show 2 more scenarios
Enterprise innovation teams
Cyber security rating for governed pilot readiness
Documented readiness decisions
Plans and coordinates emerging technology pilots with a governed path to operational readiness.
Digital platform architects
Cyber security rating for portal access controls
Coordinated access governance
Develops governed portal experiences with enterprise access controls that support rating evidence needs.
Best for: Fits when audit-grade vendor risk assessments need evidence traceability and framework-aligned scoring across multiple suppliers.
NCC Group
specialistNCC Group delivers cybersecurity assessments, attack surface reviews, and technical risk advisory services.
Rating methodology work paired with evidence pack operations for security questionnaires and follow-up validation cycles.
NCC Group delivers cyber security rating services that turn evidence from technical testing and control assessments into auditable rating outputs for enterprises and vendors. The offering is built around end-to-end risk methodology work, including security questionnaire support for third parties and evidence-focused scoring.
- +Evidence-based assessment workflow designed for audit and third-party risk contexts
- +Security questionnaire handling reduces manual chase for control evidence
- +Assessment output packaging supports internal review and customer-facing evidence needs
- +Remediation and validation support connects findings to follow-up assurance work
- –Managed delivery model shifts setup effort onto the customer for evidence and access
- –Automation depth is more service-led than tool-led for continuous scoring updates
Product security teams
Cyber security rating for AI and model risk
Risk findings for design
Security architecture groups
Cyber security rating for architecture weaknesses
Remediation roadmap and controls
Show 2 more scenarios
Security awareness leaders
Cyber security rating supported role training evidence
Role-specific training evidence
Delivers targeted learning and simulations and produces evidence of exercise participation for rating programs.
OT security leaders
Cyber security rating for OT and ICS risk reduction
Feasible OT risk controls
Assesses industrial environments and converts findings into compensating controls with assigned implementation steps.
Best for: Fits when audits and vendor risk depend on evidence packs and methodology-driven security ratings.
Conclusion
After evaluating 10 cyber security rating, EY stands out as our overall top pick — it scored highest across our combined criteria of features, ease of use, and value, which is why it sits at #1 in the rankings above.
Use the comparison table and detailed reviews above to validate the fit against your own requirements before committing to a tool.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cyber Security Rating
How do Kroll and Coalfire convert evidence into a cyber risk rating scorecard for vendor oversight?
What rating methodology and evidence handling differences show up between Deloitte and EY for audit-ready supplier assessments?
Which providers are best suited for security questionnaire automation when the goal is evidence-based scoring for third-party risk?
How does Orange Cyberdefense structure control-to-evidence mapping into comparable audit ratings across vendors?
When onboarding a new vendor questionnaire, what data migration or evidence intake steps differ across KPMG and NCC Group?
How do these services handle access controls and RBAC-like governance for internal reviewers and auditors during rating production?
What breaks if evidence traceability is weak when generating audit-facing ratings, as seen in KPMG and Orange Cyberdefense delivery models?
Where does Optiv fall short compared to Kroll when the main requirement is operational scale for continuing vendor monitoring?
What technical requirements typically affect throughput for security questionnaire intake and evidence validation in Accenture and NCC Group?
Which provider is most aligned to integrating rating outputs into existing supply chain risk and governance workflows?
Tools reviewed
Primary sources checked during evaluation.
Referenced in the comparison table and product reviews above.
How to Choose the Right Cyber Security Rating
We separate options by what they measure and how reliably they compute a cyber security rating from real signals. The biggest differences show up in evidence quality, update frequency, and how transparent the scoring logic is behind the rating.
Signal coverage across asset and risk inputs
Why it matters
Signal coverage determines whether the cyber security rating reflects what attackers actually see and what the business controls. If important inputs are missing, the rating can look stable while exposure changes.
How to check
Ask for a demo where the evaluator ingests a small set of assets and configurations, then run the rating with and without one input source. Confirm which sources contribute to the final rating and how clearly they’re listed in the UI or reports.
Scoring logic transparency and explainability
Why it matters
Scoring transparency matters because buyers need to trust the cyber security rating, not just view a number. Explainability also helps teams find what to fix first when the rating drops.
How to check
Request a sample rating report for a fictional scenario (for example, a critical service change). Check whether the report breaks the rating into understandable drivers and shows the evidence behind each driver, not only a single total.
Update frequency and time-to-recompute
Why it matters
Update frequency affects whether the cyber security rating reflects the current state or stale assessments. Short delays can turn the rating into a retrospective metric that misses urgent changes.
How to check
In the demo, change a configuration or permissions setting and then trigger a refresh. Ask how quickly the rating recomputes and whether automated schedules can be set to a defined interval.
Evidence trail for each rating driver
Why it matters
An evidence trail is what makes a cyber security rating actionable during reviews and incident follow-ups. Without it, teams can’t verify what caused a score shift.
How to check
Click through from the rating to at least two individual rating drivers and look for underlying artifacts (findings, logs, configuration snapshots, or scan results). Verify the product shows timestamps and retention for that evidence.
Automation and API surface for rating workflows
Why it matters
Automation and API surface determine whether the cyber security rating can fit into your existing workflows for continuous assessment. Governance controls also reduce the risk of unauthorized score changes or opaque runs.
How to check
Ask whether rating refresh can be triggered via API or job scheduler, and whether results can be pulled programmatically. Check for admin controls like RBAC and audit log visibility for who ran assessments and what inputs were used.
Red flags
- The rating changes, but the evidence trail doesn’t show what inputs or timestamps caused the shift.
- Scoring explanations are vague or only provide a total score without drivers tied to evidence.
- Refresh is manual-only or recomputation lags long enough to miss configuration changes you can reproduce.
Fit by situation
- If you need to prove what changed between reviews, prioritize evidence trail for each rating driver.
- If you run frequent configuration changes, prioritize update frequency and time-to-recompute.
- If you want to wire ratings into internal workflows, prioritize automation and API surface for rating workflows.
Funding and competing interests
This study was co-funded by several of the vendors assessed in it. No single vendor funded it. Funders could propose the market studied.
They had no role in selecting vendors, setting or weighting criteria, analysing data or drawing conclusions, and they received the same factual-accuracy check as every other vendor assessed.
Market definition, inclusion rules and criteria weights were fixed by an editor before research began and did not change afterwards. Editorial process →
- Service review · 2026 · Cybersecurity Information SecurityCyber Security It
- Service review · 2026 · Business FinanceCredit Rating
- Service review · 2026 · Cybersecurity Information SecurityCritical Infrastructure Cybersecurity
- Review · 2026 · Cybersecurity Information SecurityCyber Risk Software
- Review · 2026 · Finance Financial ServicesCredit Rating Software
Keep exploring
Comparing two specific tools?
Software Alternatives
See head-to-head software comparisons with feature breakdowns, pricing, and our recommendation for each use case.
Explore software alternatives→In this category
Cybersecurity & Information Security alternatives
See side-by-side comparisons of cybersecurity & information security tools and pick the right one for your stack.
Compare cybersecurity & information security tools→