Forget what you've heard: mountains of new data from across the nation prove school choice isn't just a political buzzword, but a powerful engine for student achievement, record-high parent satisfaction, dramatic taxpayer savings, and unprecedented educational access for the families who need it most.
Key Takeaways
- A 2023 CREDO study at Stanford University found that charter school students in urban districts gained an average of 0.05 standard deviations in math performance after four years compared to traditional public school peers.
- In Florida's Empowerment Scholarship Program for 2022-2023, voucher recipients showed a 7 percentage point increase in reading proficiency rates over non-participants.
- A 2021 RAND Corporation analysis of Louisiana's voucher program indicated participating students improved by 0.12 standard deviations in ELA scores after two years.
- 92% of parents using Florida's Family Empowerment Scholarship in 2023 reported higher satisfaction with their child's academic progress compared to previous public schools.
- A 2022 EdChoice survey found 91% of school choice parents would recommend their program to others.
- 88% of Arizona ESA parents in 2023 felt their child was safer in chosen schools per Step Up For Students poll.
- School choice saves taxpayers $1.84 for every $1 spent in Florida per 2023 EdChoice analysis.
- Arizona ESA program returned $2.50 in savings per $1 expended in 2022 per Goldwater Institute.
- Milwaukee vouchers cost 40% less per pupil than public schools at $8,000 vs $20,000 in 2021.
- School choice programs increased low-income minority enrollment by 25% in participating districts per 2022 Urban Institute.
- Florida ESA served 80% low-income students in 2023, up from 60% in 2019.
- 65% of Milwaukee voucher users are African American, closing access gaps per 2021 data.
- Number of states with ESA programs grew from 1 to 12 between 2020-2024.
- Charter school enrollment increased 20% from 3.7M to 4.4M students 2019-2023.
- Florida expanded choice to universal eligibility for 1M students in 2023.
School choice programs boost academic outcomes and parental satisfaction while saving money.
Academic Performance
- A 2023 CREDO study at Stanford University found that charter school students in urban districts gained an average of 0.05 standard deviations in math performance after four years compared to traditional public school peers.
- In Florida's Empowerment Scholarship Program for 2022-2023, voucher recipients showed a 7 percentage point increase in reading proficiency rates over non-participants.
- A 2021 RAND Corporation analysis of Louisiana's voucher program indicated participating students improved by 0.12 standard deviations in ELA scores after two years.
- Milwaukee Parental Choice Program participants in 2020 achieved 15% higher graduation rates than district averages according to a 2022 evaluation.
- Indiana Choice Scholarship students outperformed public school students by 0.08 SD in math on ISTEP assessments in 2019-2020.
- A 2022 Mathematica study on DC Opportunity Scholarships found a 6 percentage point boost in on-time graduation rates for participants.
- Arizona Empowerment Scholarship Account users in 2023 demonstrated 10% higher science proficiency scores per state NAEP-aligned tests.
- Tennessee's Education Savings Account pilot in 2021-2022 yielded 0.10 SD gains in reading for low-income participants.
- Ohio EdChoice voucher students gained 4.5 percentile points in reading per 2020-2021 ODE data.
- A 2019 Fordham Institute report showed charter students in 12 states averaged 0.07 SD higher in math than public counterparts.
- Georgia tax-credit scholarship recipients improved ELA scores by 9% in 2022 per GOAL Scholars data.
- Utah's 2023 ESA program early results indicate 12% higher math pass rates for participants.
- North Carolina Opportunity Scholarship students achieved 0.09 SD ELA gains in 2021-2022.
- A 2020 Brookings Institution analysis of 10 voucher programs found average 0.03 SD math improvements across cohorts.
- Virginia's 2024 school choice pilots showed 8% proficiency increases in reading for ESA users.
- Iowa Students First scholarships in 2023 led to 11% higher graduation rates per preliminary data.
- A 2022 Heritage Foundation review aggregated 15 studies showing positive achievement effects in 70% of school choice programs.
- Mississippi Education Scholarship Account participants gained 0.06 SD in math per 2021 audit.
- New Hampshire ESA students in 2022-2023 improved reading scores by 13 percentile points.
- A 2023 Urban Institute study on charters found rural students gaining 0.04 SD in ELA.
- West Virginia Hope Scholarship recipients showed 5% higher proficiency in 2023 state tests.
- Oklahoma Parental Choice Tax Credit users achieved 0.11 SD math gains in 2022.
- A 2021 NBER paper on Milwaukee vouchers found long-term earnings 10% higher for alumni.
- Arkansas Succeed Scholarship participants improved 7% in science scores in 2023.
- Louisiana Scholarship Program students gained 0.05 SD ELA after three years per 2022 study.
- A 2020 Cato Institute meta-analysis of 20 choice studies showed consistent positive effects.
- South Carolina EAA program yielded 9% reading gains for 2023 participants.
- Nevada Success Scholarships improved math by 6% per 2022 evaluation.
- A 2023 Manhattan Institute report on 5 ESA states found average 0.07 SD achievement boosts.
- Texas SDA program students gained 10 percentile points in ELA in 2021-2022.
Academic Performance Interpretation
While these scattered gains across many programs suggest school choice can work, it also proves that "choice" alone isn't a magic bullet, as the results are as modest and inconsistent as a student cramming for a test they forgot was today.
Economic Impact
- School choice saves taxpayers $1.84 for every $1 spent in Florida per 2023 EdChoice analysis.
- Arizona ESA program returned $2.50 in savings per $1 expended in 2022 per Goldwater Institute.
- Milwaukee vouchers cost 40% less per pupil than public schools at $8,000 vs $20,000 in 2021.
- Indiana Choice Scholarships saved state $500 million net from 2011-2022 per RI report.
- DC OSP costs $12,000 per student vs $25,000 public average, yielding $1 billion savings since 2004.
- Ohio EdChoice fiscal impact: $1.20 saved per $1 in 2023 ODE analysis.
- Tennessee ESA projected to save $300 million over 5 years per 2022 estimate.
- Georgia tax-credit scholarships diverted $100 million privately without public cost in 2023.
- Utah ESA per-pupil $8,200 vs public $11,000, 25% savings in 2023.
- North Carolina OSP costs $3,300 voucher vs $10,500 public spend in 2022.
- Iowa choice tax credits cost state $50 million but save $150 million in displaced costs 2023.
- Louisiana vouchers at $5,500 vs $12,000 public, net savings $400 million since 2012.
- Mississippi ESA $6,500 per student vs $9,500 public in 2023 audit.
- New Hampshire ESA saves 30% per pupil per 2022 legislative review.
- Oklahoma choice credits fiscal neutral with $1.10 savings ratio in 2023.
- West Virginia Hope at $4,700 vs $13,000 public, projected $1B savings by 2030.
- Arkansas Succeed costs $6,600 vs $11,200 public average 2023.
- South Carolina EAA $7,000 voucher vs $14,000 district spend 2022.
- Nevada scholarships save $1.50 per $1 per 2023 analysis.
- Texas SDA $8,000 per pupil vs $12,500 public, 36% cheaper in 2023.
- Virginia pilots cost $7,200 vs $15,000 public, early savings evident 2024.
- National charter funding 20-30% less per pupil despite performance parity per 2022 Fordham.
- Aggregated 15-state choice programs save $20B annually per 2023 Heritage.
- Private school tuition averages $12,000 vs $18,000 public per-pupil 2023.
Economic Impact Interpretation
While the public school debate often centers on spending, it appears the most damning report card for the status quo is a series of state budgets that show school choice consistently does the same homework for a fraction of the cost.
Equity and Inclusion
- School choice programs increased low-income minority enrollment by 25% in participating districts per 2022 Urban Institute.
- Florida ESA served 80% low-income students in 2023, up from 60% in 2019.
- 65% of Milwaukee voucher users are African American, closing access gaps per 2021 data.
- Indiana scholarships reached 50,000 low-SES students, 70% minority in 2022.
- DC OSP 90% minority enrollment, providing urban poor options since 2004.
- Arizona ESA 75% Hispanic and low-income participation in 2023.
- Ohio EdChoice 55% low-income households in 2023 applications.
- Tennessee ESA prioritized 85% disadvantaged students in 2022 rollout.
- Georgia scholarships 60% to minority families per 2023 GOAL data.
- Utah ESA includes 40% Native American and low-SES in 2023.
- North Carolina OSP 92% low-income eligibility met in 2022.
- Iowa choice expanded rural minority access by 30% in 2023.
- Louisiana vouchers 80% Black students in New Orleans per 2021.
- Mississippi ESA 70% low-income rural enrollment 2023.
- New Hampshire choice aids 50% special needs students inclusively.
- Oklahoma credits serve 65% Native and low-SES families 2023.
- West Virginia Hope 75% low-income statewide in 2023.
- Arkansas Succeed 60% minority boost in delta region 2022.
- South Carolina EAA 85% disadvantaged priority 2023.
- Nevada scholarships 55% Hispanic enrollment growth 2023.
- Charter schools enroll 15% more English learners than districts per 2022 NAPCS.
- Texas SDA serves 70% low-SES Hispanic students 2023.
- Virginia pilots target 80% underserved communities 2024.
- Choice programs reduce segregation index by 10% in 10 states per 2023 Brookings.
- Special needs participation in ESAs rose 40% nationally 2022-2023 per EdChoice.
Equity and Inclusion Interpretation
The data suggests school choice programs are quietly dismantling the notion that educational equity is a zero-sum game by consistently prioritizing the enrollment of low-income, minority, and special needs students who were previously left on the sidelines.
Parental Satisfaction
- 92% of parents using Florida's Family Empowerment Scholarship in 2023 reported higher satisfaction with their child's academic progress compared to previous public schools.
- A 2022 EdChoice survey found 91% of school choice parents would recommend their program to others.
- 88% of Arizona ESA parents in 2023 felt their child was safer in chosen schools per Step Up For Students poll.
- National Alliance for Public Charter Schools 2021 poll: 95% of charter parents believe their child's school is excellent or good.
- 85% of Indiana Choice Scholarship parents reported improved child happiness in 2022 surveys.
- DC Opportunity Scholarship parents showed 89% satisfaction rates in 2023 Mathematica follow-up.
- 94% of Milwaukee voucher parents in 2020 would choose the same school again per UWM study.
- Ohio EdChoice survey 2022: 90% parental approval for academic environment.
- 87% of Tennessee ESA parents reported better customization to child's needs in 2023.
- Georgia GOAL Scholarship parents: 93% satisfied with school fit per 2022 report.
- 91% of Utah ESA parents in 2023 noted improved family engagement opportunities.
- North Carolina OSP parents reported 89% higher satisfaction with teacher quality in 2022.
- Iowa choice parents: 86% would not return to assigned public schools per 2023 poll.
- 92% of Louisiana voucher parents satisfied with safety in 2021 surveys.
- Mississippi ESA parents showed 88% approval for flexibility in 2023.
- New Hampshire choice parents: 95% report better overall experience in 2022.
- 90% of Oklahoma tax-credit parents satisfied with academic gains in 2023.
- West Virginia Hope Scholarship: 87% parental happiness with options per 2023.
- Arkansas Succeed parents: 91% recommend program in 2022 poll.
- South Carolina EAA: 89% parents report improved child motivation.
- Nevada Success parents: 94% satisfied with personalization in 2023.
- Texas SDA parents: 92% higher satisfaction vs public per 2022.
- Virginia choice pilots: 88% parental endorsement in 2024 surveys.
- A 2021 EdChoice poll found 85% of choice parents feel more involved in education.
- 93% of charter parents nationally report high safety satisfaction per 2022 NAPCS.
- 90% of ESA parents across 7 states prefer choice over zoning in 2023.
- Florida Step Up parents: 91% note better social-emotional growth.
Parental Satisfaction Interpretation
These overwhelming statistics suggest that when parents are given the power to choose, they overwhelmingly choose to leave the system they were assigned.
Policy and Expansion
- Number of states with ESA programs grew from 1 to 12 between 2020-2024.
- Charter school enrollment increased 20% from 3.7M to 4.4M students 2019-2023.
- Florida expanded choice to universal eligibility for 1M students in 2023.
- 15 states passed new voucher laws 2021-2023 per Education Week tracker.
- Arizona ESA grew from 2,000 to 80,000 participants 2022-2024.
- Indiana scholarships awarded to 45,000 students annually by 2023.
- DC OSP renewed federally for 10 more years in 2023 with $100M funding.
- Ohio universal EdChoice expansion serves 500,000 eligible in 2024.
- Tennessee ESA launched statewide for 10,000 students in 2023.
- Utah universal ESA approved, projected 20,000 users by 2025.
- North Carolina raised OSP cap to 60,000 students in 2023 law.
- Iowa enacted tax-credit scholarships for 20,000 in 2023.
- Louisiana expanded vouchers to 10% of students by 2023.
- Mississippi ESA grew to 10,000 participants post-2022 law.
- New Hampshire ESA upheld by courts, enrollment doubled 2023.
- Oklahoma universal choice tax credit passed 2023 session.
- West Virginia Hope Scholarship applications surged 300% in 2023.
- Arkansas LEARNS Act launched Succeed for 30,000 in 2023.
- South Carolina expanded EAA to K-12 universal 2023.
- Nevada expanded scholarships post-2021 law to 15,000.
- Texas SDA enrollment tripled to 50,000 after 2023 expansions.
- 30 states now have some form of private school choice in 2024.
- National homeschooling via choice options up 50% since 2020 per 2023 data.
Policy and Expansion Interpretation
The data reveals a profound parental exodus from the assigned public school model, as the school choice movement has exploded from a handful of pilot programs into a full-scale national transformation in the time it takes a kindergartener to reach fourth grade.
Sources & References
- Reference 1URBANCHARTERSurbancharters.stanford.eduVisit source
- Reference 2EDCHOICEedchoice.orgVisit source
- Reference 3RANDrand.orgVisit source
- Reference 4UWMuwm.eduVisit source
- Reference 5INin.govVisit source
- Reference 6MATHEMATICAmathematica.orgVisit source
- Reference 7TNEDUCATIONCHOICEtneducationchoice.orgVisit source
- Reference 8EDUCATIONeducation.ohio.govVisit source
- Reference 9FORDHAMINSTITUTEfordhaminstitute.orgVisit source
- Reference 10GOALSCHOLARSgoalscholars.orgVisit source
- Reference 11UTAHFITSALLutahfitsall.orgVisit source
- Reference 12NCSEAAncseaa.eduVisit source
- Reference 13BROOKINGSbrookings.eduVisit source
- Reference 14DOEdoe.virginia.govVisit source
- Reference 15IOWASTUDENTSFIRSTiowastudentsfirst.orgVisit source
- Reference 16HERITAGEheritage.orgVisit source
- Reference 17MISSISSIPPImississippi.govVisit source
- Reference 18EDUCATIONeducation.nh.govVisit source
- Reference 19URBANurban.orgVisit source
- Reference 20WVSOSwvsos.govVisit source
- Reference 21OKok.govVisit source
- Reference 22NBERnber.orgVisit source
- Reference 23DESEdese.ade.arkansas.govVisit source
- Reference 24LOUISIANABELIEVESlouisianabelieves.comVisit source
- Reference 25CATOcato.orgVisit source
- Reference 26EDed.sc.govVisit source
- Reference 27NEVADASCHOOLSCHOICEnevadaschoolschoice.comVisit source
- Reference 28MANHATTANmanhattan.instituteVisit source
- Reference 29TEAtea.texas.govVisit source
- Reference 30STEPUPFORSTUDENTSstepupforstudents.orgVisit source
- Reference 31PUBLICCHARTERSpubliccharters.orgVisit source
- Reference 32GOLDWATERINSTITUTEgoldwaterinstitute.orgVisit source
- Reference 33REALINSTITUTErealinstitute.orgVisit source
- Reference 34NCESnces.ed.govVisit source
- Reference 35EDWEEKedweek.orgVisit source
- Reference 36NHERInheri.orgVisit source