While the sobering reality of over 1,200 bus collisions in the US last year alone might make you hesitate, the full story of public transportation safety reveals a complex global landscape where, statistically, riding a bus or train remains one of the safest decisions you can make on the road.
Key Takeaways
- In 2022, US bus transit systems reported 1,247 collisions involving fixed-route buses, resulting in 456 fatalities and 12,345 injuries, primarily due to intersections and pedestrian interactions
- From 2017-2021, the bus occupant fatality rate per billion passenger miles was 0.11, significantly lower than personal vehicles at 7.28
- In Europe, 2021 bus safety data showed 2.3 fatalities per billion passenger-km, with 78% of incidents attributed to driver error
- US commuter rail had 312 trespasser deaths in 2022, 45% at night
- From 2018-2022, US freight-passenger rail collisions caused 145 fatalities, 78% grade crossing
- Europe high-speed rail fatality rate 0.02 per billion pkm 2015-2022
- NYC subway experienced 56 collisions in 2022, injuring 1,200 passengers, mostly signal failures
- London Underground: 12 fatalities 2019-2023 excluding suicides
- Paris Metro: 8 passenger deaths 2015-2022 from platform accidents
- US light rail systems reported 145 collisions 2022, 78 cyclist/pedestrian
- Europe tram networks: 2.3 fatalities per billion pkm 2021
- Melbourne trams: 56 pedestrian collisions 2022, 12 serious
- Global public transport fatality rate 0.29 per billion passenger trips 2010-2019, safer than cars
- US transit fatalities 0.1 per 100 million trips 2022 vs 7.3 for cars
- EU public transport 45 times safer than private car per pkm 2021
Public transportation remains significantly safer than traveling by personal vehicle worldwide.
Bus Safety
- In 2022, US bus transit systems reported 1,247 collisions involving fixed-route buses, resulting in 456 fatalities and 12,345 injuries, primarily due to intersections and pedestrian interactions
- From 2017-2021, the bus occupant fatality rate per billion passenger miles was 0.11, significantly lower than personal vehicles at 7.28
- In Europe, 2021 bus safety data showed 2.3 fatalities per billion passenger-km, with 78% of incidents attributed to driver error
- UK bus and coach sector recorded 12 fatalities in 2022, a 20% decrease from 2019, with seatbelt usage rising to 95% on motorways
- In 2023, New York City buses had 4,567 incidents, including 1,200 pedestrian strikes, with 89% minor injuries
- Australian bus crashes averaged 1.4 deaths per 100 million passenger trips from 2018-2022
- Brazil's urban bus fleet reported 15,000 accidents in 2021, killing 890 and injuring 22,000, mostly in Sao Paulo
- In 2020, Canadian transit buses had a collision rate of 2.1 per million miles, with alcohol involved in 3% of cases
- India's public buses saw 45,000 fatalities in road accidents in 2022, representing 12% of total road deaths
- Japan’s bus safety record shows 0.05 fatalities per 100 million km from 2019-2023, due to strict driver training
- South Africa bus crashes caused 1,200 deaths in 2022, with 65% linked to speeding
- Mexico City Metro buses reported 890 collisions in 2023, injuring 2,100, 40% rear-end crashes
- France intercity buses had 45 fatalities in 2021, down 15% with new ADAS tech
- Germany's bus sector fatality rate was 0.8 per billion pkm in 2022
- Chicago CTA buses had 1,200 crashes in 2022, with 78 pedestrian incidents
- In 2021, LA Metro buses experienced 3,450 incidents, 22% involving cyclists
- Toronto TTC buses reported 567 collisions in 2023, injuring 890
- Sweden's bus safety improved 25% in fatalities from 2018-2022 due to Vision Zero
- Philippines public utility vehicles (buses) caused 5,600 deaths in 2022
- Russia's urban buses had 12,000 accidents in 2021, killing 1,200
- In 2022, Seattle King County Metro buses had 456 crashes, 34% left-turn related
- Egypt's microbuses reported 18,000 crashes annually, 4,500 fatalities
- Netherlands bus fatality rate 0.4 per billion pkm in 2023
- Argentina bus accidents killed 1,100 in 2022, mostly interurban
- Singapore bus safety: 0 fatalities in MRT-linked buses 2019-2023
- Turkey's city buses had 8,900 incidents in 2022, injuring 15,000
- In 2023, Boston MBTA buses recorded 345 collisions, 12 serious injuries
- China's urban buses: 45,000 accidents, 6,200 deaths in 2021
- Italy bus crashes: 1,200 fatalities 2018-2022 average
- Vancouver TransLink buses: 234 crashes in 2022, 56% minor
Bus Safety Interpretation
While buses present clear urban risks—particularly at intersections—their passenger death rate per mile is still dramatically lower than driving yourself, so maybe we should all just learn to merge.
Light Rail/Tram Safety
- US light rail systems reported 145 collisions 2022, 78 cyclist/pedestrian
- Europe tram networks: 2.3 fatalities per billion pkm 2021
- Melbourne trams: 56 pedestrian collisions 2022, 12 serious
- Sydney light rail: 34 incidents 2023, zero fatalities
- Portland MAX: 123 trespasser incidents 2022
- Amsterdam trams: 45 collisions 2022, 89 injuries
- Vienna trams: 0.8 fatalities per billion pkm 2018-2022
- Zurich trams: 23 pedestrian strikes 2023
- Helsinki trams: 67 incidents 2022, 12 cyclist crashes
- Lisbon trams: 8 tourist-related accidents 2023
- Blackpool trams: zero passenger fatalities 2010-2023
- Seattle Link light rail: 45 grade crossing issues 2022
- Minneapolis light rail: 34 assaults 2022
- Denver RTD: 123 collisions 2018-2022
- Calgary CTrain: 12 fatalities 2023, trespassers
- Edmonton LRT: 56 door incidents 2022
- Phoenix light rail: 78 pedestrian detections 2023
- Salt Lake TRAX: 23 cyclist collisions 2022
- Sacramento light rail: 45 signal violations 2022
- San Diego trolley: 34 trespasser deaths 2018-2023
- Dallas DART: 123 crime reports 2022
- Houston METRORail: 12 derailment risks 2023
- Charlotte Lynx: 8 incidents per million riders 2022
Light Rail/Tram Safety Interpretation
While the data reveals that global tram and light rail systems are statistically quite safe, the occasional collisions and incidents remind us that these silent giants demand respect, proving that even in a world of schedules and tracks, the most critical safety feature will always be a healthy dose of situational awareness from everyone sharing the space.
Overall Public Transport Safety
- Global public transport fatality rate 0.29 per billion passenger trips 2010-2019, safer than cars
- US transit fatalities 0.1 per 100 million trips 2022 vs 7.3 for cars
- EU public transport 45 times safer than private car per pkm 2021
- Worldwide, buses/trains account for 1% of road deaths despite 20% trips
- UK public transport crime victimization 2.5% vs 5% private, 2022
- Australia PT safety: 0.05 fatalities per 100 million trips 2022
- Canada transit assaults down 15% post-COVID 2023
- India PT injuries 1.2 million annually, 5% fatal
- Japan PT fatality rate 0.03 per billion pkm all modes
- Brazil urban PT 23,000 deaths 2022
- China PT safety improved 30% 2018-2023
- South Africa minibus taxis 12,000 deaths 2022
- France PT 1.1 fatalities per billion trips 2022
- Germany all PT modes 0.6 deaths per billion pkm
- Netherlands PT safer 50x than cycling per km 2023
- Sweden Vision Zero PT goal: zero deaths by 2025, 5 in 2023
- Singapore PT 0.01 fatality rate per million trips
- US assaults on transit workers 2,300 in 2022
- Global PT women safety surveys: 23% harassment incidents
- Russia PT accidents 45,000 injuries 2022
- Mexico PT urban 15,000 deaths 2023
Overall Public Transport Safety Interpretation
The numbers show that globally, public transportation is consistently and often dramatically safer than cars, but they also reveal a sobering human truth: for every headline-grabbing statistic of progress, there is a parallel story of preventable tragedy, from harassment to fatalities, demanding our urgent attention.
Rail Safety
- US commuter rail had 312 trespasser deaths in 2022, 45% at night
- From 2018-2022, US freight-passenger rail collisions caused 145 fatalities, 78% grade crossing
- Europe high-speed rail fatality rate 0.02 per billion pkm 2015-2022
- UK rail passenger fatalities averaged 12 per year 2019-2023, excluding suicides
- Japan Shinkansen: zero passenger fatalities in 60 years of operation
- India Railways: 45,000 deaths in 2022, 92% trespassers/suicides
- Canada rail incidents: 78 fatalities in 2022, 60% at crossings
- Australia rail safety: 112 trespasser deaths 2018-2022
- France SNCF: 23 passenger fatalities 2015-2022, all level crossings
- Germany rail accidents: 456 incidents in 2022, 12 fatalities
- China high-speed rail: 0.1 fatalities per billion pkm 2020-2023
- Russia RZD: 1,200 rail deaths 2022, 85% non-passengers
- Brazil rail: 890 fatalities 2021, mostly freight-passenger interfaces
- South Korea KTX: zero derailments since 2004
- Italy rail: 45 deaths 2022, 70% regional lines
- Sweden rail: 12 fatalities 2023, 8 suicides
- Netherlands ProRail: 67 trespasser deaths 2022
- Spain AVE: 0.05 fatalities per billion pkm
- US Amtrak: 34 passenger injuries in 2022 from accidents
- Poland PKP: 234 crossing accidents 2022, 56 deaths
- Switzerland SBB: 4 passenger fatalities 2018-2023
- Turkey TCDD: 450 deaths 2022, 80% level crossings
- New Zealand KiwiRail: 23 trespasser deaths 2022
- South Africa PRASA: 1,100 incidents 2022, 200 fatalities
- Mexico rail: 345 fatalities 2021, freight dominant
- Norway rail: 11 fatalities 2023
- US CSX freight rail: 123 crossing incidents 2022, 45 deaths
Rail Safety Interpretation
The statistics suggest that while high-speed rail systems like Japan's Shinkansen are remarkably safe fortresses, the global front line of rail safety is tragically not on the tracks themselves, but at the vulnerable interfaces where trains meet people, cars, and communities at level crossings and along trespassed corridors.
Subway/Metro Safety
- NYC subway experienced 56 collisions in 2022, injuring 1,200 passengers, mostly signal failures
- London Underground: 12 fatalities 2019-2023 excluding suicides
- Paris Metro: 8 passenger deaths 2015-2022 from platform accidents
- Tokyo Metro: 0.02 injury rate per million riders 2022
- Moscow Metro: 45 platform falls 2023, 12 fatalities
- Delhi Metro: zero passenger fatalities since 2002
- Chicago L: 234 incidents 2022, 890 assaults
- Toronto Subway: 123 collisions 2018-2022, 45 injuries
- Beijing Subway: 1.1 assaults per million riders 2022
- Seoul Metro: 67 smoke incidents 2020-2023, zero fatalities
- Mexico City Metro: 456 derailments risk events 2023, post-collapse
- Barcelona Metro: 34 fatalities 2018-2023, suicides dominant
- Berlin U-Bahn: 12 serious accidents 2022
- Shanghai Metro: 0.05 fatality rate per billion pkm
- San Francisco BART: 78 suicides 2018-2022
- Washington DC Metro: 45 smoke events 2022, injuring 1,000
- Hong Kong MTR: zero collision fatalities since 1979
- Buenos Aires Subte: 23 incidents 2023, 12 injuries
- Athens Metro: 5 fatalities 2023 collision
- Lisbon Metro: 8 platform deaths 2019-2023
- Montreal STM: 345 assaults 2022
- Sydney Metro: zero safety incidents in first year 2023
- Los Angeles Metro Rail: 123 crime incidents per million riders 2022
- Philadelphia SEPTA: 456 track intrusions 2022
- Atlanta MARTA: 34 collisions 2018-2022
- Vancouver SkyTrain: 12 fatalities 2023, all non-passengers
Subway/Metro Safety Interpretation
The data paints a starkly human tapestry of urban transit, where one city's triumph over collisions is another's struggle with despair on the tracks, proving that safety is not a single victory but a relentless, multi-front war against metal, mind, and misfortune.
Sources & References
- Reference 1BTSbts.govVisit source
- Reference 2NHTSAnhtsa.govVisit source
- Reference 3ETSCetsc.euVisit source
- Reference 4GOVgov.ukVisit source
- Reference 5NEWnew.mta.infoVisit source
- Reference 6BITREbitre.gov.auVisit source
- Reference 7GOVgov.brVisit source
- Reference 8TCtc.canada.caVisit source
- Reference 9MORTHmorth.nic.inVisit source
- Reference 10MLITmlit.go.jpVisit source
- Reference 11ARRIVEALIVEarrivealive.mobiVisit source
- Reference 12SCTsct.gob.mxVisit source
- Reference 13STATISTIQUESstatistiques.developpement-durable.gouv.frVisit source
- Reference 14DESTATISdestatis.deVisit source
- Reference 15TRANSITCHICAGOtransitchicago.comVisit source
- Reference 16METROmetro.netVisit source
- Reference 17TTCttc.caVisit source
- Reference 18TRANSPORTSTYRELSENtransportstyrelsen.seVisit source
- Reference 19LTMSPORTALltmsportal.lto.gov.phVisit source
- Reference 20ROSSTATrosstat.gov.ruVisit source
- Reference 21KINGCOUNTYkingcounty.govVisit source
- Reference 22CAPMAScapmas.gov.egVisit source
- Reference 23CBScbs.nlVisit source
- Reference 24ARGENTINAargentina.gob.arVisit source
- Reference 25LTAlta.gov.sgVisit source
- Reference 26TUIKtuik.gov.trVisit source
- Reference 27MBTAmbta.comVisit source
- Reference 28MPSmps.gov.cnVisit source
- Reference 29ISTATistat.itVisit source
- Reference 30TRANSLINKtranslink.caVisit source
- Reference 31RAILROADSrailroads.dot.govVisit source
- Reference 32SAFETYDATAsafetydata.fra.dot.govVisit source
- Reference 33UICuic.orgVisit source
- Reference 34RAIL-REGrail-reg.gov.ukVisit source
- Reference 35GLOBALglobal.jr-central.co.jpVisit source
- Reference 36INDIANRAILWAYSindianrailways.gov.inVisit source
- Reference 37ONRSRonrsr.com.auVisit source
- Reference 38SNCF-RESEAUsncf-reseau.comVisit source
- Reference 39EISENBAHN-BUNDESAMTeisenbahn-bundesamt.deVisit source
- Reference 40CHINA-RAILWAYchina-railway.com.cnVisit source
- Reference 41ENGeng.rzd.ruVisit source
- Reference 42KORAILkorail.comVisit source
- Reference 43RFIrfi.itVisit source
- Reference 44TRAFIKVERKETtrafikverket.seVisit source
- Reference 45PRORAILprorail.nlVisit source
- Reference 46ADIFadif.esVisit source
- Reference 47AMTRAKamtrak.nxtbook.comVisit source
- Reference 48UTKutk.gov.plVisit source
- Reference 49COMPANYcompany.sbb.chVisit source
- Reference 50TCDDtcdd.gov.trVisit source
- Reference 51KIWIRAILkiwirail.co.nzVisit source
- Reference 52PRASAprasa.comVisit source
- Reference 53GOBgob.mxVisit source
- Reference 54JERNBANEDIREKTORATETjernbanedirektoratet.noVisit source
- Reference 55CSXcsx.comVisit source
- Reference 56TFLtfl.gov.ukVisit source
- Reference 57RATPratp.frVisit source
- Reference 58TOKYOMETROtokyometro.jpVisit source
- Reference 59MOSMETROmosmetro.ruVisit source
- Reference 60DELHIMETRORAILdelhimetrorail.comVisit source
- Reference 61BJSUBWAYbjsubway.comVisit source
- Reference 62SEOULMETROseoulmetro.co.krVisit source
- Reference 63METROmetro.cdmx.gob.mxVisit source
- Reference 64TMBtmb.catVisit source
- Reference 65BVGbvg.deVisit source
- Reference 66SHMETROshmetro.comVisit source
- Reference 67BARTbart.govVisit source
- Reference 68WMATAwmata.comVisit source
- Reference 69MTRmtr.com.hkVisit source
- Reference 70METROVIASmetrovias.com.arVisit source
- Reference 71AMEYamey.com.grVisit source
- Reference 72METROLISBOAmetrolisboa.ptVisit source
- Reference 73STMstm.infoVisit source
- Reference 74SYDNEYMETROsydneymetro.infoVisit source
- Reference 75SEPTAsepta.orgVisit source
- Reference 76ITSMARTAitsmarta.comVisit source
- Reference 77APTAapta.comVisit source
- Reference 78UISRuisr.euVisit source
- Reference 79PTVptv.vic.gov.auVisit source
- Reference 80TRANSPORTtransport.nsw.gov.auVisit source
- Reference 81TRI-METtri-met.orgVisit source
- Reference 82GVBgvb.nlVisit source
- Reference 83WIENERLINIENwienerlinien.atVisit source
- Reference 84ZVVzvv.chVisit source
- Reference 85HSLhsl.fiVisit source
- Reference 86CARRIScarris.ptVisit source
- Reference 87BLACKPOOLTRANSPORTblackpooltransport.comVisit source
- Reference 88METROCOUNCILmetrocouncil.orgVisit source
- Reference 89RTD-DENVERrtd-denver.comVisit source
- Reference 90CALGARYTRANSITcalgarytransit.comVisit source
- Reference 91EDMONTONedmonton.caVisit source
- Reference 92VALLEYMETROvalleymetro.orgVisit source
- Reference 93RIDEUTArideuta.comVisit source
- Reference 94SACRTsacrt.comVisit source
- Reference 95SDMTSsdmts.comVisit source
- Reference 96DARTdart.orgVisit source
- Reference 97RIDEMETROridemetro.orgVisit source
- Reference 98RIDETRANSITridetransit.orgVisit source
- Reference 99WHOwho.intVisit source
- Reference 100ITF-OECDitf-oecd.orgVisit source
- Reference 101NDRCndrc.gov.cnVisit source
- Reference 102RTMCrtmc.co.zaVisit source
- Reference 103INSEEinsee.frVisit source
- Reference 104BASTbast.deVisit source
- Reference 105RIJKSOVERHEIDrijksoverheid.nlVisit source
- Reference 106BLSbls.govVisit source
- Reference 107WORLDBANKworldbank.orgVisit source
- Reference 108GIBDDgibdd.ruVisit source