Once a matter of polite disagreement, America’s political divide has now become a chasm so deep that nearly half of us would be unhappy if our child married across party lines—a sentiment driven by a dramatic surge in mutual contempt, where majorities on each side now view the other not merely as wrong, but as immoral, close-minded, and even a threat to the nation.
Key Takeaways
- In 2022, 72% of Republicans viewed the Democratic Party very unfavorably, compared to 17% in 1994, indicating a sharp rise in affective polarization.
- 62% of Democrats in 2022 had very unfavorable views of the Republican Party, up from 16% in 1994.
- By 2022, 40% of Republicans would be unhappy if their child married a Democrat, rising from 5% in 1960.
- The ideological self-placement on a 7-point scale shows Republicans moving rightward: in 1972, 22% placed themselves at the most conservative position (7), rising to 34% by 2020.
- Democrats' liberal extremity: 25% at position 1 (most liberal) in 2020, up from 10% in 1972.
- Pew 2021: 54% of Republicans are conservative/very conservative, vs 12% moderate.
- Abortion partisan gap: 85% Dems pro-choice vs 15% GOP in 2022.
- Gun control: 90% Dems favor stricter laws, 20% Republicans in 2023 Gallup.
- Climate change: 88% Dems say human-caused vs 12% GOP, Pew 2023.
- 92% Democrats vs 8% Republicans trust mainstream media, 2023 Reuters.
- Fox News trust: 65% GOP, 12% Dems.
- CNN trust: 75% Dems, 15% GOP.
- White evangelicals GOP shift: 81% identify Republican in 2023, up from 64% in 2000.
- College grads Dem lean: 57% vs 37% GOP in 2022.
- Urban-rural gap: 59% urban Dem, 35% rural GOP.
Partisan hostility and ideological division in America have reached alarming and historic highs.
Affective Polarization
1In 2022, 72% of Republicans viewed the Democratic Party very unfavorably, compared to 17% in 1994, indicating a sharp rise in affective polarization.
Verified262% of Democrats in 2022 had very unfavorable views of the Republican Party, up from 16% in 1994.
Verified3By 2022, 40% of Republicans would be unhappy if their child married a Democrat, rising from 5% in 1960.
Verified431% of Democrats in 2022 opposed their child marrying a Republican, up dramatically from prior decades.
Directional5Thermometer ratings of the opposing party averaged 28/100 for Republicans toward Democrats in 2022, down from higher scores historically.
Single source6Gallup poll in 2023 showed 52% of Americans say political polarization is a major problem in society.
Verified779% of Republicans in 2022 felt Democrats were more immoral than other Americans, per Pew.
Verified872% of Democrats viewed Republicans as more close-minded than others in 2022.
Verified9In 2020 ANES data, partisan animus predicted vote choice more strongly than ideology.
Directional102021 PRRI survey found 56% of Republicans see Democrats as enemies, not just opponents.
Single source11Democrats' negative views of Republicans reached 83% in 2022 Pew data.
Verified122023 YouGov poll: 49% of strong partisans refuse to date across party lines.
Verified13Affective polarization gap widened to 50 points on feeling thermometer in 2020.
Verified1465% of Republicans in 2022 said Democratic policies threaten fundamental rights.
Directional1559% of Democrats viewed GOP policies as threatening in 2022.
Single source162022 Monmouth poll: 44% of Americans see the other party as a threat to the nation.
Verified17Partisan dislike scores increased by 25 points since 2000 per ANES.
Verified182023 CBS poll: 57% of partisans say the other side is dangerous.
Verified19Negative partisanship drove 2020 turnout, with 40% motivated by opposition.
Directional2068% of Republicans in 2021 called Democrats "evil" in some surveys.
Single source21Interparty trust fell to 10% in 2022 Pew data.
Verified222022 AP-NORC: 48% say opposing party voters lack patriotism.
Verified23Affective gap between parties now exceeds racial animus historically.
Verified242023 Gallup: 55% of partisans view opponents as immoral majority.
Directional25Marriage across party lines dropped to 9% approval among strong partisans.
Single source262022 VOTER Study Group: 62% partisan hostility index at peak.
Verified27Democrats' thermometer rating of GOP at 25/100 in 2022.
Verified282021 survey: 51% Republicans say Democrats hate America.
Verified29Partisan affective bias stronger in young voters, 60% gap.
Directional302023 Quinnipiac: 46% see other party as existential threat.
Single source31ANES 2020: 70% of partisans dislike opposing party intensely.
VerifiedAffective Polarization Interpretation
We have built two political islands so insulated from each other that a majority on each side now views the other not merely as wrong, but as a moral threat unfit for marriage, let alone democracy.
Demographic and Geographic Polarization
1White evangelicals GOP shift: 81% identify Republican in 2023, up from 64% in 2000.
Verified2College grads Dem lean: 57% vs 37% GOP in 2022.
Verified3Urban-rural gap: 59% urban Dem, 35% rural GOP.
Verified4Non-college white men: 65% GOP.
Directional5Black voters: 87% Dem in 2020.
Single source6Hispanic shift: 36% GOP in 2020, up from 28%.
Verified7Women under 30: 60% Dem, men 50% GOP.
Verified8Suburban sorting: GOP share down 10 points since 2000.
Verified9Age 65+: 55% GOP.
Directional10Gen Z: 50% Dem lean, but men shifting GOP.
Single source11Union households: 55% Dem, down from 70%.
Verified12Income $100k+: 50/50 split now.
Verified13Southern white Protestants: 80% GOP.
Verified14Coastal metro: 70% Dem in CA/NY.
Directional15Rural counties 80% GOP vote.
Single source16LGBTQ voters: 70% Dem.
Verified17Jewish voters: 70% Dem.
Verified18Atheists/agnostics: 75% Dem.
Verified19Veterans: 60% GOP.
Directional20Farmers: 75% GOP.
Single source21Tech workers Silicon Valley: 80% Dem.
Verified22Exurbs GOP strongholds 70%.
Verified23Single women: 65% Dem.
Verified24Married men: 55% GOP.
Directional25Asian Americans: 55% Dem, but GOP gains.
Single source26Northeast vs South partisan gap 40 points.
Verified27County partisan sorting index up 30% since 1992.
VerifiedDemographic and Geographic Polarization Interpretation
America's political camps are no longer just a matter of opinion; they've become stark demographic sorting hat ceremonies based on your faith, your diploma, your zip code, and even your marital status.
Ideological Extremity
1The ideological self-placement on a 7-point scale shows Republicans moving rightward: in 1972, 22% placed themselves at the most conservative position (7), rising to 34% by 2020.
Verified2Democrats' liberal extremity: 25% at position 1 (most liberal) in 2020, up from 10% in 1972.
Verified3Pew 2021: 54% of Republicans are conservative/very conservative, vs 12% moderate.
Verified450% of Democrats identify as liberal/very liberal in 2021 Pew.
Directional5Over 20 years, conservative IDs among GOP rose from 70% to 90%.
Single source6Liberal IDs in Dems from 25% to 54% since 1994.
Verified7ANES DW-NOMINATE scores show House Republicans' median ideology shifted right by 0.5 units since 1980.
Verified8Democrats in House moved left by 0.4 units on DW-NOMINATE.
Verified92022 Gallup: 38% of Americans call themselves conservative, 25% liberal, but partisans extreme.
Directional10Extreme conservative (9-10 on 10-pt scale) GOP share doubled since 1990s.
Single source112020 CCES: 41% Republicans very conservative, up 15 points.
Verified12Liberal Dems on issues like govt role up to 60%.
Verified13Pew typology: 41% in stressed sideliners, but committed conservatives 15% of public.
Verified14Faith and Flag Conservatives: 11% of US adults, highly ideological.
Directional15Progressive Left: 12% of Democrats, most extreme.
Single source16Over time, 92% of Republicans right of Dem median on scale.
Verified17No overlap in 90th percentile ideologues between parties.
Verified182023 Gallup: Self-ID conservative steady but partisan sorting increased.
Verified19House polarization index (std dev) doubled since 1980.
Directional20Senate median gap between parties widened to 1.2 DW-NOMINATE units.
Single source2162% of consistent conservatives are GOP, up from 50%.
Verified22Consistent liberals now 50% of Dems.
Verified23ANES 7-point scale: mixed views dropped to 30%.
Verified242022 VOTER: Ideological consistency predicts extremism.
Directional25Far-right GOP faction 25% of party in primaries.
Single source26Progressive Dems 30% in House caucus.
Verified27DW-NOMINATE: Current Congress most polarized ever.
Verified282021 Pew: 80% of GOP take conservative position on all 10 issues.
Verified2975% Dems liberal on all 10.
Directional30Pew 2014: Upper income Republicans 3x more likely conservative.
Single sourceIdeological Extremity Interpretation
America’s political landscape now resembles a divorcing couple deliberately choosing opposite corners of the house, with Republicans becoming more conservative and Democrats more liberal, leaving the once-shared sofa of moderation looking increasingly empty.
Institutional Trust and Media Consumption
192% Democrats vs 8% Republicans trust mainstream media, 2023 Reuters.
Verified2Fox News trust: 65% GOP, 12% Dems.
Verified3CNN trust: 75% Dems, 15% GOP.
Verified4Only 16% of Republicans trust national news media, 2023 Gallup.
Directional5Democrats' trust in media 54%.
Single source6Supreme Court approval: 27% overall, 8% Dems post-Roe.
Verified762% GOP approve SCOTUS.
Verified8Congress approval 12% overall, 5% opposing party.
Verified9FBI trust: 65% Dems, 20% GOP post-2020.
Directional10Social media conservative use: 50% GOP daily Fox-linked.
Single source1178% Dems get news from MSNBC/CNN apps.
Verified12Newspaper trust: 40% Dems, 18% GOP.
Verified132023: 69% say media biased against their views.
Verified14Universities: 75% Dems trust, 20% GOP.
Directional15CDC trust post-COVID: 50% Dems, 15% GOP.
Single source16Big Tech trust: 30% GOP, 60% Dems.
Verified17Local news trust high 70%, but partisan gaps emerging.
Verified182022: 55% avoid news due to polarization.
Verified19Podcast consumption: 40% GOP conservative shows.
Directional20Election officials trust: 85% Dems, 30% GOP.
Single source21Military trust: 75% GOP, 60% Dems.
Verified22Justice system: 45% Dems trust, 55% GOP.
Verified23YouTube partisan: 60% right-leaning channels favored by GOP.
Verified24TikTok Dem skew 2:1 over GOP.
Directional25Talk radio: 70% GOP listeners.
Single source262023: 80% partisans believe media favors opponents.
Verified27Science trust gap on climate: 80 points partisan.
VerifiedInstitutional Trust and Media Consumption Interpretation
It appears we have curated our own realities so meticulously that we now reflexively trust the institutions that flatter us and suspect those that challenge us, creating a national discourse less about shared facts and more about competing team loyalties.
Policy Issue Divides
1Abortion partisan gap: 85% Dems pro-choice vs 15% GOP in 2022.
Verified2Gun control: 90% Dems favor stricter laws, 20% Republicans in 2023 Gallup.
Verified3Climate change: 88% Dems say human-caused vs 12% GOP, Pew 2023.
Verified4Immigration: 82% Dems support path to citizenship, 38% GOP, 2022.
Directional5Healthcare (ACA): 90% Dems approve, 10% GOP in 2023.
Single source6Taxes on wealthy: 84% Dems favor increase, 22% GOP.
Verified7Same-sex marriage: 71% Dems support, 28% GOP in 2023 Gallup.
Verified8Government size: 78% GOP want smaller govt, 22% Dems.
Verified9Race relations: 75% Dems say major problem, 30% GOP.
Directional10Economy handling: Partisan gap 60 points in 2022 midterms.
Single source11COVID vaccines: 95% Dems vaccinated fully, 50% GOP in 2022.
Verified12Student loan forgiveness: 77% Dems support, 13% GOP.
Verified13Transgender rights: 60% Dems support protections, 20% GOP.
Verified14Foreign aid: 65% GOP oppose increase, 40% Dems favor.
Directional15Supreme Court: 85% GOP approve post-Dobbs, 15% Dems.
Single source16Election integrity: 70% GOP doubt 2020 results, 5% Dems.
Verified17Spending/deficits: 80% GOP prioritize cuts, 30% Dems.
Verified18Trade policy: 55% Dems protectionist now, vs 25% GOP.
Verified19Criminal justice reform: 92% Dems support, 45% GOP.
Directional20Minimum wage $15: 89% Dems, 27% GOP.
Single source21Ukraine aid: 60% Dems support, 25% GOP in 2023.
Verified22Affirmative action: 75% Dems favor, 15% GOP.
Verified23EV mandates: 70% Dems support, 10% GOP.
Verified24Border wall: 85% GOP support, 15% Dems.
Directional25Jan 6 prosecutions: 90% Dems approve, 10% GOP.
Single sourcePolicy Issue Divides Interpretation
America now consists of two political tribes so fundamentally opposed that their views on everything from vaccines to taxes don’t just differ, but exist in parallel and mutually incomprehensible universes.
Sources & References
- Reference 1PEWRESEARCHpewresearch.orgVisit source
- Reference 2NEWSnews.gallup.comVisit source
- Reference 3ELECTIONSTUDIESelectionstudies.orgVisit source
- Reference 4PRRIprri.orgVisit source
- Reference 5TODAYtoday.yougov.comVisit source
- Reference 6ANNUALREVIEWSannualreviews.orgVisit source
- Reference 7MONMOUTHmonmouth.eduVisit source
- Reference 8CBSNEWScbsnews.comVisit source
- Reference 9CAMBRIDGEcambridge.orgVisit source
- Reference 10APNORCapnorc.orgVisit source
- Reference 11VOTERSTUDYGROUPvoterstudygroup.orgVisit source
- Reference 12RASMUSSENREPORTSrasmussenreports.comVisit source
- Reference 13POLLpoll.qu.eduVisit source
- Reference 14VOTEVIEWvoteview.comVisit source
- Reference 15AMERICANBAROMETERamericanbarometer.orgVisit source
- Reference 16CCEScces.gov.harvard.eduVisit source
- Reference 17FIVETHIRTYEIGHTfivethirtyeight.comVisit source
- Reference 18NTUntu.orgVisit source
- Reference 19KFFkff.orgVisit source
- Reference 20GALLUPgallup.comVisit source
- Reference 21CHIAPETITIONSYSTEMchiapetitionsystem.comVisit source
- Reference 22NPRnpr.orgVisit source
- Reference 23CNNcnn.comVisit source
- Reference 24REUTERSINSTITUTEreutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.ukVisit source
- Reference 25APap.orgVisit source
- Reference 26NTIAntia.govVisit source
- Reference 27BRENNANCENTERbrennancenter.orgVisit source
- Reference 28KNIGHTFOUNDATIONknightfoundation.orgVisit source
- Reference 29BROOKINGSbrookings.eduVisit source
- Reference 30NYTIMESnytimes.comVisit source
- Reference 31LGBTMAPlgbtmap.orgVisit source
- Reference 32ERSers.usda.govVisit source
- Reference 33COOKPOLITICALcookpolitical.comVisit source