GITNUXREPORT 2026

Human Trafficking Victims Statistics

Modern slavery tragically affects tens of millions of people worldwide, mostly women and children.

Gitnux Team

Expert team of market researchers and data analysts.

First published: Feb 13, 2026

Our Commitment to Accuracy

Rigorous fact-checking · Reputable sources · Regular updatesLearn more

Key Statistics

Statistic 1

Women and girls represent 72% of all detected trafficking victims worldwide per UNODC 2022

Statistic 2

Children make up 35% of detected trafficking victims globally in 2020

Statistic 3

63% of detected female victims are trafficked for sexual exploitation per UNODC

Statistic 4

Men account for 21% of detected victims, primarily forced labor per UNODC 2022

Statistic 5

Girls represent 32% of child trafficking victims detected 2018-2020 per UNODC

Statistic 6

Boys comprise 18% of all detected child victims globally per UNODC 2020

Statistic 7

75% of adult female victims are in sexual exploitation per ILO/UNODC data

Statistic 8

Sub-Saharan African victims are 64% children per UNODC regional demographics

Statistic 9

In South Asia, 40% of victims are girls under 18 per Walk Free data

Statistic 10

US data shows 26% of labor trafficking victims are male immigrants per Polaris

Statistic 11

80% of sex trafficking victims in the US are women and girls per Polaris 2022

Statistic 12

Children under 12 represent 1% of detected child victims globally per UNODC

Statistic 13

Adult men are 49% of forced labor victims per ILO global survey

Statistic 14

59% of victims in Western Europe are Eastern European women per UNODC

Statistic 15

In the Americas, 24% of victims are men per UNODC 2020

Statistic 16

Nigerian women comprise a large share of victims in Italy, 90% female per UNODC

Statistic 17

67% of child victims in East Asia are boys for forced labor per UNODC

Statistic 18

Globally, 15-24 year olds are the most affected age group at 27% per ILO

Statistic 19

Over 50% of victims from South Asia are below 25 years old per Walk Free

Statistic 20

In the US, 48% of hotline cases involve US citizen victims, mostly female per Polaris

Statistic 21

92% of child sex trafficking victims in the US know their trafficker per Polaris

Statistic 22

LGBTQ+ youth are 2.4 times more likely to be trafficked per Polaris data

Statistic 23

Black victims represent 40% of US sex trafficking cases per Polaris 2021

Statistic 24

70% of detected victims in the Middle East are South Asian men for labor

Statistic 25

Girls aged 12-17 are 50% of child sex trafficking victims globally per UNODC

Statistic 26

25% of global victims are over 45 years old per ILO estimates

Statistic 27

Indigenous women are disproportionately victimized in labor trafficking per ILO

Statistic 28

55% of victims in forced labor are from rural areas per Walk Free

Statistic 29

Globally, an estimated 25 million people were victims of modern slavery in 2016, including 16 million in forced labor and 5 million in forced sexual exploitation

Statistic 30

In 2022, the International Labour Organization estimated 49.6 million people in modern slavery, with 27.6 million in forced labour

Statistic 31

UNODC reported 96,000 detected trafficking victims worldwide in 2018

Statistic 32

Walk Free Foundation's 2023 Global Slavery Index identifies 50 million people in modern slavery globally

Statistic 33

Approximately 40% of global human trafficking victims are children under 18 years old

Statistic 34

In 2020, UNODC data showed sexual exploitation as the main form affecting 50% of detected victims globally

Statistic 35

ILO estimates that 3.3 million children are in forced labor globally as trafficking victims

Statistic 36

Globally, 71% of trafficking victims detected between 2016-2018 were women and girls

Statistic 37

An estimated 12.3 million people were in forced labor due to trafficking in 2016 per ILO

Statistic 38

UNODC 2022 report notes a 11% increase in detected child victims from 2018 to 2020 globally

Statistic 39

Global Slavery Index 2023 reports 28 million in forced labor worldwide

Statistic 40

54% of global trafficking victims are trafficked for sexual exploitation per UNODC 2018

Statistic 41

ILO 2022 estimates 22 million victims of forced marriage as a form of trafficking

Statistic 42

Between 2016-2019, 30% of detected victims were children globally per UNODC

Statistic 43

6.3 million adults and 3.3 million children in commercial sexual exploitation globally per ILO

Statistic 44

UNODC reports 79% of detected female victims trafficked for sexual exploitation

Statistic 45

Global estimate of 4.8 million victims in forced commercial sexual exploitation per ILO 2017

Statistic 46

25% of all trafficking victims globally are men, per UNODC 2020

Statistic 47

ILO 2021 data shows 17.3 million forced labor victims in the private sector globally

Statistic 48

35% increase in child victims detected globally from 2010-2018 per UNODC

Statistic 49

Global Slavery Index 2018 estimated 40.3 million in modern slavery

Statistic 50

UNODC 2022: 62% of child victims are girls trafficked mainly for sexual exploitation

Statistic 51

ILO reports 5 million children in sexual exploitation worldwide

Statistic 52

15.2 million people in forced marriage globally per ILO 2022

Statistic 53

UNODC detected 14,000 child victims in 2020 globally

Statistic 54

28% of global victims are trafficked for forced labor per UNODC 2018

Statistic 55

Global estimate: 1 in 150 people worldwide is a victim of modern slavery per Walk Free

Statistic 56

ILO 2017: 24.9 million total modern slavery victims

Statistic 57

UNODC 2020: Eastern Asia and South-Eastern Asia have highest victim numbers globally

Statistic 58

77% of trafficking victims in Europe are women per UNODC subregional data

Statistic 59

Europe detected 15,000 trafficking victims in 2018, mostly from Eastern Europe

Statistic 60

In Sub-Saharan Africa, 23% of detected victims were for sexual exploitation in 2018 per UNODC

Statistic 61

South Asia has 18 million modern slavery victims per Global Slavery Index 2023

Statistic 62

US National Hotline identified 10,359 trafficking cases in 2021 involving 16,554 victims

Statistic 63

India has an estimated 11 million trafficking victims per Walk Free 2023

Statistic 64

In Western and Southern Europe, 57% of victims are trafficked for sexual exploitation per UNODC 2022

Statistic 65

Nigeria reported 1,300 trafficking victims in 2020, mostly women to Europe

Statistic 66

East Asia and Pacific region has 15.1 million in forced labor per ILO 2022

Statistic 67

In the US, California reported 1,334 cases in 2021 per Polaris

Statistic 68

Middle East and North Africa: 45% of victims are men for forced labor per UNODC

Statistic 69

Thailand detected 843 trafficking victims in 2019, mostly for labor

Statistic 70

In Latin America, 66% of victims are women per UNODC 2020

Statistic 71

China estimates 500,000 women and children trafficked internally per reports

Statistic 72

UK identified 5,069 potential victims in 2020, 80% female per UK Gov

Statistic 73

Mexico has high numbers of child labor trafficking victims, 30% of cases per US State Dept

Statistic 74

Arab States region: 2.3 million in forced labor per ILO 2022

Statistic 75

Philippines reported 200 sex trafficking victims rescued in 2022 per gov data

Statistic 76

Central Asia detected 1,200 victims in 2018, mostly labor per UNODC

Statistic 77

Texas, US, had 1,017 hotline signals in 2021 per Polaris

Statistic 78

Bangladesh has 1.5 million in modern slavery per Global Slavery Index

Statistic 79

Germany identified 1,509 trafficking victims in 2021, 70% for sex work

Statistic 80

Southeast Europe: 90% of victims women from neighboring countries per UNODC

Statistic 81

Florida, US, reported 1,198 cases in 2021 per Polaris

Statistic 82

North Africa: Increasing child victims for labor per UNODC 2022

Statistic 83

Russia detected 500 victims in 2019, mostly labor from CIS

Statistic 84

Vietnam: 100 child trafficking cases prosecuted in 2022 per US State

Statistic 85

79% of detected sex trafficking victims globally are women and girls per UNODC

Statistic 86

Forced labor accounts for 38% of detected victims worldwide per UNODC 2020

Statistic 87

Sexual exploitation detected in 50% of global cases per UNODC 2022

Statistic 88

16% of victims trafficked for forced criminality like begging per UNODC

Statistic 89

ILO estimates 11.8 million in private forced labor exploitation globally

Statistic 90

Forced marriage affects 22 million people, mainly women per ILO 2022

Statistic 91

In the US, 72% of hotline cases are sex trafficking per Polaris 2021

Statistic 92

Labor trafficking represents 20% of US cases, often in agriculture per Polaris

Statistic 93

Child soldier recruitment as trafficking affects 10,000 children annually per UN

Statistic 94

Organ removal trafficking detected in 0.2% of cases but increasing per UNODC 2022

Statistic 95

25% of forced labor victims in domestic work, mostly women per ILO

Statistic 96

Sex trafficking victims often moved across borders, 30% intra-regional per UNODC

Statistic 97

Construction sector has 3.4 million forced labor victims globally per ILO

Statistic 98

Begging as forced criminality affects 18% of child victims per UNODC

Statistic 99

In Europe, 63% of victims for sexual exploitation per Eurostat

Statistic 100

Agriculture forced labor: 26% of sector victims are children per ILO

Statistic 101

Hotel and restaurant work: 1.5 million victims per ILO estimates

Statistic 102

State-imposed forced labor affects 3.9 million globally per ILO 2022

Statistic 103

Online sex trafficking increased 20% during COVID per Polaris

Statistic 104

Domestic servitude trafficking: 2.2 million victims, 97% women per ILO

Statistic 105

Fishing industry: 150,000 victims on distant vessels per ILO

Statistic 106

5% of victims trafficked for forced labor in manufacturing per UNODC 2020

Statistic 107

Combo trafficking (sex and labor) in 6% of cases per UNODC

Statistic 108

US sex trafficking: 50% involve minors per DOJ stats

Statistic 109

Globally, 7% of child victims for forced labor per UNODC 2022

Statistic 110

In 2021, only 1% of victims were identified and received assistance per UNODC

Statistic 111

US identified and referred 1,200 victims to services in 2021 per State Dept

Statistic 112

Globally, fewer than 1 in 100 trafficking victims are rescued per ILO estimates

Statistic 113

In 2020, 53,000 potential victims received support via hotlines per Polaris global

Statistic 114

Only 40,000 victims convicted traffickers globally in 2018 per UNODC

Statistic 115

EU identified 14,000 victims but only 7,000 assisted in 2019 per Eurostat

Statistic 116

India rescued 5,000 trafficking victims in 2022 per NCRB data

Statistic 117

25% of identified victims in the US are foreign nationals receiving T-visas per USCIS

Statistic 118

Thailand provided assistance to 500 victims in 2022 per US State TIP

Statistic 119

Globally, child victims receive protection in only 30% of detections per UNODC 2022

Statistic 120

Polaris hotline led to 2,900 victim referrals in 2021 US

Statistic 121

Nigeria repatriated 1,000 victims from Libya in 2021 per IOM

Statistic 122

Only 11% of countries provide comprehensive victim services per US TIP 2023

Statistic 123

UK granted 1,200 reflections periods to victims in 2020 per Gov data

Statistic 124

60% of rescued sex trafficking victims suffer PTSD per WHO studies

Statistic 125

Global fund assisted 10,000 victims since 2014 per UN Trust Fund

Statistic 126

In 2022, 8,000 victims received medical aid via IOM programs

Statistic 127

Mexico identified 1,200 victims but convicted only 100 traffickers in 2022

Statistic 128

70% of victims re-trafficked within 2 years without support per studies

Statistic 129

Philippines provided shelter to 300 child victims in 2022 per gov

Statistic 130

Only 5,000 T-visas issued to victims since 2000 in US per USCIS

Statistic 131

Brazil rescued 1,500 labor victims in Amazon 2021-2022 per MPT

Statistic 132

40% of identified victims decline assistance due to fear per UNODC

Statistic 133

Germany funded services for 400 victims in 2021 per reports

Statistic 134

Global: 1 conviction per 1,000 victims estimated by Walk Free

Statistic 135

Cambodia assisted 200 sex trafficking victims in 2022 per US TIP

Trusted by 500+ publications
Harvard Business ReviewThe GuardianFortune+497
In a world where statistics reveal the staggering scale of human suffering, the numbers behind modern slavery—showing that an estimated 50 million people were trapped in its grasp in 2023 alone—paint a grim reality for countless victims whose stories demand our urgent attention.

Key Takeaways

  • Globally, an estimated 25 million people were victims of modern slavery in 2016, including 16 million in forced labor and 5 million in forced sexual exploitation
  • In 2022, the International Labour Organization estimated 49.6 million people in modern slavery, with 27.6 million in forced labour
  • UNODC reported 96,000 detected trafficking victims worldwide in 2018
  • Women and girls represent 72% of all detected trafficking victims worldwide per UNODC 2022
  • Children make up 35% of detected trafficking victims globally in 2020
  • 63% of detected female victims are trafficked for sexual exploitation per UNODC
  • Europe detected 15,000 trafficking victims in 2018, mostly from Eastern Europe
  • In Sub-Saharan Africa, 23% of detected victims were for sexual exploitation in 2018 per UNODC
  • South Asia has 18 million modern slavery victims per Global Slavery Index 2023
  • 79% of detected sex trafficking victims globally are women and girls per UNODC
  • Forced labor accounts for 38% of detected victims worldwide per UNODC 2020
  • Sexual exploitation detected in 50% of global cases per UNODC 2022
  • In 2021, only 1% of victims were identified and received assistance per UNODC
  • US identified and referred 1,200 victims to services in 2021 per State Dept
  • Globally, fewer than 1 in 100 trafficking victims are rescued per ILO estimates

Modern slavery tragically affects tens of millions of people worldwide, mostly women and children.

Demographic Breakdown

  • Women and girls represent 72% of all detected trafficking victims worldwide per UNODC 2022
  • Children make up 35% of detected trafficking victims globally in 2020
  • 63% of detected female victims are trafficked for sexual exploitation per UNODC
  • Men account for 21% of detected victims, primarily forced labor per UNODC 2022
  • Girls represent 32% of child trafficking victims detected 2018-2020 per UNODC
  • Boys comprise 18% of all detected child victims globally per UNODC 2020
  • 75% of adult female victims are in sexual exploitation per ILO/UNODC data
  • Sub-Saharan African victims are 64% children per UNODC regional demographics
  • In South Asia, 40% of victims are girls under 18 per Walk Free data
  • US data shows 26% of labor trafficking victims are male immigrants per Polaris
  • 80% of sex trafficking victims in the US are women and girls per Polaris 2022
  • Children under 12 represent 1% of detected child victims globally per UNODC
  • Adult men are 49% of forced labor victims per ILO global survey
  • 59% of victims in Western Europe are Eastern European women per UNODC
  • In the Americas, 24% of victims are men per UNODC 2020
  • Nigerian women comprise a large share of victims in Italy, 90% female per UNODC
  • 67% of child victims in East Asia are boys for forced labor per UNODC
  • Globally, 15-24 year olds are the most affected age group at 27% per ILO
  • Over 50% of victims from South Asia are below 25 years old per Walk Free
  • In the US, 48% of hotline cases involve US citizen victims, mostly female per Polaris
  • 92% of child sex trafficking victims in the US know their trafficker per Polaris
  • LGBTQ+ youth are 2.4 times more likely to be trafficked per Polaris data
  • Black victims represent 40% of US sex trafficking cases per Polaris 2021
  • 70% of detected victims in the Middle East are South Asian men for labor
  • Girls aged 12-17 are 50% of child sex trafficking victims globally per UNODC
  • 25% of global victims are over 45 years old per ILO estimates
  • Indigenous women are disproportionately victimized in labor trafficking per ILO
  • 55% of victims in forced labor are from rural areas per Walk Free

Demographic Breakdown Interpretation

While the statistical face of human trafficking is overwhelmingly young and female, this vast criminal enterprise cruelly and efficiently exploits every demographic, turning the vulnerable of all ages, genders, and origins into commodities for profit.

Global Statistics

  • Globally, an estimated 25 million people were victims of modern slavery in 2016, including 16 million in forced labor and 5 million in forced sexual exploitation
  • In 2022, the International Labour Organization estimated 49.6 million people in modern slavery, with 27.6 million in forced labour
  • UNODC reported 96,000 detected trafficking victims worldwide in 2018
  • Walk Free Foundation's 2023 Global Slavery Index identifies 50 million people in modern slavery globally
  • Approximately 40% of global human trafficking victims are children under 18 years old
  • In 2020, UNODC data showed sexual exploitation as the main form affecting 50% of detected victims globally
  • ILO estimates that 3.3 million children are in forced labor globally as trafficking victims
  • Globally, 71% of trafficking victims detected between 2016-2018 were women and girls
  • An estimated 12.3 million people were in forced labor due to trafficking in 2016 per ILO
  • UNODC 2022 report notes a 11% increase in detected child victims from 2018 to 2020 globally
  • Global Slavery Index 2023 reports 28 million in forced labor worldwide
  • 54% of global trafficking victims are trafficked for sexual exploitation per UNODC 2018
  • ILO 2022 estimates 22 million victims of forced marriage as a form of trafficking
  • Between 2016-2019, 30% of detected victims were children globally per UNODC
  • 6.3 million adults and 3.3 million children in commercial sexual exploitation globally per ILO
  • UNODC reports 79% of detected female victims trafficked for sexual exploitation
  • Global estimate of 4.8 million victims in forced commercial sexual exploitation per ILO 2017
  • 25% of all trafficking victims globally are men, per UNODC 2020
  • ILO 2021 data shows 17.3 million forced labor victims in the private sector globally
  • 35% increase in child victims detected globally from 2010-2018 per UNODC
  • Global Slavery Index 2018 estimated 40.3 million in modern slavery
  • UNODC 2022: 62% of child victims are girls trafficked mainly for sexual exploitation
  • ILO reports 5 million children in sexual exploitation worldwide
  • 15.2 million people in forced marriage globally per ILO 2022
  • UNODC detected 14,000 child victims in 2020 globally
  • 28% of global victims are trafficked for forced labor per UNODC 2018
  • Global estimate: 1 in 150 people worldwide is a victim of modern slavery per Walk Free
  • ILO 2017: 24.9 million total modern slavery victims
  • UNODC 2020: Eastern Asia and South-Eastern Asia have highest victim numbers globally
  • 77% of trafficking victims in Europe are women per UNODC subregional data

Global Statistics Interpretation

This isn't just a growing statistic, it's an industrialized horror whose only thriving business model is violating the most vulnerable people on the planet.

Regional Data

  • Europe detected 15,000 trafficking victims in 2018, mostly from Eastern Europe
  • In Sub-Saharan Africa, 23% of detected victims were for sexual exploitation in 2018 per UNODC
  • South Asia has 18 million modern slavery victims per Global Slavery Index 2023
  • US National Hotline identified 10,359 trafficking cases in 2021 involving 16,554 victims
  • India has an estimated 11 million trafficking victims per Walk Free 2023
  • In Western and Southern Europe, 57% of victims are trafficked for sexual exploitation per UNODC 2022
  • Nigeria reported 1,300 trafficking victims in 2020, mostly women to Europe
  • East Asia and Pacific region has 15.1 million in forced labor per ILO 2022
  • In the US, California reported 1,334 cases in 2021 per Polaris
  • Middle East and North Africa: 45% of victims are men for forced labor per UNODC
  • Thailand detected 843 trafficking victims in 2019, mostly for labor
  • In Latin America, 66% of victims are women per UNODC 2020
  • China estimates 500,000 women and children trafficked internally per reports
  • UK identified 5,069 potential victims in 2020, 80% female per UK Gov
  • Mexico has high numbers of child labor trafficking victims, 30% of cases per US State Dept
  • Arab States region: 2.3 million in forced labor per ILO 2022
  • Philippines reported 200 sex trafficking victims rescued in 2022 per gov data
  • Central Asia detected 1,200 victims in 2018, mostly labor per UNODC
  • Texas, US, had 1,017 hotline signals in 2021 per Polaris
  • Bangladesh has 1.5 million in modern slavery per Global Slavery Index
  • Germany identified 1,509 trafficking victims in 2021, 70% for sex work
  • Southeast Europe: 90% of victims women from neighboring countries per UNODC
  • Florida, US, reported 1,198 cases in 2021 per Polaris
  • North Africa: Increasing child victims for labor per UNODC 2022
  • Russia detected 500 victims in 2019, mostly labor from CIS
  • Vietnam: 100 child trafficking cases prosecuted in 2022 per US State

Regional Data Interpretation

Behind these staggering, impersonal numbers—from millions trapped in modern slavery to thousands of identified victims—lies a global, grimly efficient machine of exploitation that preys on the vulnerable everywhere, yet feels intimately personalized in every single stolen life.

Trafficking Types

  • 79% of detected sex trafficking victims globally are women and girls per UNODC
  • Forced labor accounts for 38% of detected victims worldwide per UNODC 2020
  • Sexual exploitation detected in 50% of global cases per UNODC 2022
  • 16% of victims trafficked for forced criminality like begging per UNODC
  • ILO estimates 11.8 million in private forced labor exploitation globally
  • Forced marriage affects 22 million people, mainly women per ILO 2022
  • In the US, 72% of hotline cases are sex trafficking per Polaris 2021
  • Labor trafficking represents 20% of US cases, often in agriculture per Polaris
  • Child soldier recruitment as trafficking affects 10,000 children annually per UN
  • Organ removal trafficking detected in 0.2% of cases but increasing per UNODC 2022
  • 25% of forced labor victims in domestic work, mostly women per ILO
  • Sex trafficking victims often moved across borders, 30% intra-regional per UNODC
  • Construction sector has 3.4 million forced labor victims globally per ILO
  • Begging as forced criminality affects 18% of child victims per UNODC
  • In Europe, 63% of victims for sexual exploitation per Eurostat
  • Agriculture forced labor: 26% of sector victims are children per ILO
  • Hotel and restaurant work: 1.5 million victims per ILO estimates
  • State-imposed forced labor affects 3.9 million globally per ILO 2022
  • Online sex trafficking increased 20% during COVID per Polaris
  • Domestic servitude trafficking: 2.2 million victims, 97% women per ILO
  • Fishing industry: 150,000 victims on distant vessels per ILO
  • 5% of victims trafficked for forced labor in manufacturing per UNODC 2020
  • Combo trafficking (sex and labor) in 6% of cases per UNODC
  • US sex trafficking: 50% involve minors per DOJ stats
  • Globally, 7% of child victims for forced labor per UNODC 2022

Trafficking Types Interpretation

While the statistics present a chilling mosaic of modern slavery—from the overwhelming female toll of sexual exploitation to the quiet horror of forced domestic servitude and the stolen childhoods of millions—they ultimately reveal a single, sobering truth: humanity has masterfully organized its own dehumanization into a diversified and shockingly efficient global enterprise.

Victim Support and Recovery

  • In 2021, only 1% of victims were identified and received assistance per UNODC
  • US identified and referred 1,200 victims to services in 2021 per State Dept
  • Globally, fewer than 1 in 100 trafficking victims are rescued per ILO estimates
  • In 2020, 53,000 potential victims received support via hotlines per Polaris global
  • Only 40,000 victims convicted traffickers globally in 2018 per UNODC
  • EU identified 14,000 victims but only 7,000 assisted in 2019 per Eurostat
  • India rescued 5,000 trafficking victims in 2022 per NCRB data
  • 25% of identified victims in the US are foreign nationals receiving T-visas per USCIS
  • Thailand provided assistance to 500 victims in 2022 per US State TIP
  • Globally, child victims receive protection in only 30% of detections per UNODC 2022
  • Polaris hotline led to 2,900 victim referrals in 2021 US
  • Nigeria repatriated 1,000 victims from Libya in 2021 per IOM
  • Only 11% of countries provide comprehensive victim services per US TIP 2023
  • UK granted 1,200 reflections periods to victims in 2020 per Gov data
  • 60% of rescued sex trafficking victims suffer PTSD per WHO studies
  • Global fund assisted 10,000 victims since 2014 per UN Trust Fund
  • In 2022, 8,000 victims received medical aid via IOM programs
  • Mexico identified 1,200 victims but convicted only 100 traffickers in 2022
  • 70% of victims re-trafficked within 2 years without support per studies
  • Philippines provided shelter to 300 child victims in 2022 per gov
  • Only 5,000 T-visas issued to victims since 2000 in US per USCIS
  • Brazil rescued 1,500 labor victims in Amazon 2021-2022 per MPT
  • 40% of identified victims decline assistance due to fear per UNODC
  • Germany funded services for 400 victims in 2021 per reports
  • Global: 1 conviction per 1,000 victims estimated by Walk Free
  • Cambodia assisted 200 sex trafficking victims in 2022 per US TIP

Victim Support and Recovery Interpretation

The statistics reveal a grim and ludicrous paradox: while hotlines and rescue numbers offer flickers of hope, the global anti-trafficking effort resembles a colander trying to hold an ocean, where for every victim painstakingly identified, supported, or granted a visa, countless more slip through the gaps of under-identification, paltry convictions, and a terrifying lack of sustained protection.