While the record books may forever sing of Gretzky's 215 points, last season's fantasy champions were built on the modern-day brilliance of Auston Matthews’ 69 goals and Nikita Kucherov’s 144-point masterclass.
Key Takeaways
- In 2023-24 fantasy hockey seasons across major platforms, Auston Matthews averaged 1.42 goals per game in roto leagues, leading all forwards with 69 goals in 81 games.
- Nikita Kucherov topped fantasy points with 144 points (44G, 100A) in 79 games, yielding 1.82 fantasy points per game in standard 12-team leagues.
- Leon Draisaitl recorded 106 points (41G, 65A) in 81 games, second in multi-category roto scoring at 1.38 PPG for fantasy owners.
- In 2023-24, Cale Makar led fantasy defensemen with 90 points (21G, 69A) in 77 games, at 1.17 points per game.
- Quinn Hughes posted 92 points (17G, 75A) in 82 games, revolutionizing D-man scoring with 1.12 PPG in fantasy.
- Roman Josi accumulated 85 points (23G, 62A) in 82 games, adding 153 shots for multi-cat value.
- Igor Shesterkin led fantasy goalies with 36 wins and .912 SV% in 54 games, 2.58 GAA elite.
- Connor Hellebuyck won Vezina with 37 wins, .921 SV% in 60 games, 2.39 GAA top-tier fantasy.
- Jeremy Swayman posted 25 wins with .916 SV% in 44 games, shutouts leader at 5 for streamers.
- In 2023 ESPN fantasy drafts, Connor McDavid's ADP was 1.2, taken first in 92% of 12-team leagues.
- Auston Matthews ADP 2.8 across Yahoo leagues, 88% first-round selection rate.
- Cale Makar averaged 4.1 ADP in DobberProspects rankings for defensemen.
- In standard 12-team roto leagues, 70% use 6 skaters + 2 goalies roster format per Yahoo data.
- Head-to-Head leagues comprise 55% of ESPN fantasy hockey pools in 2023-24.
- Average league size is 12 teams, with 45% opting for 10-team per Dobber survey.
Fantasy hockey's top stars rack up elite numbers, from Matthews' sniper goals to Makar's defensive dominance.
Defensive Production
1In 2023-24, Cale Makar led fantasy defensemen with 90 points (21G, 69A) in 77 games, at 1.17 points per game.
Verified2Quinn Hughes posted 92 points (17G, 75A) in 82 games, revolutionizing D-man scoring with 1.12 PPG in fantasy.
Verified3Roman Josi accumulated 85 points (23G, 62A) in 82 games, adding 153 shots for multi-cat value.
Verified4Moritz Seider blocked 209 shots in 82 games while scoring 38 points, top in blocks for fantasy pools.
Directional5Miro Heiskanen tallied 48 points (11G, 37A) with 147 blocks in 82 games, elite in PIM+blocks roto.
Single source6Evan Bouchard erupted for 82 points (18G, 64A) in 81 games, 1.01 PPG boosting Oilers' fantasy D.
Verified7Charlie McAvoy contributed 47 points with 201 hits and 139 blocks in 75 games, perfect peripheral D-man.
Verified8Rasmus Dahlin scored 59 points (16G, 43A) in 79 games, with 0.75 PPG in high-volume fantasy leagues.
Verified9Noah Hanifin notched 40 points with strong plus/minus in 82 games, value pick in plus/minus categories.
Directional10Adam Fox recorded 51 points (10G, 41A) in 78 games despite injury, 0.65 PPG for steady fantasy.
Single source11Makar 69A led all D, PP quarterback supreme.
Verified12Hughes 75A NHL record for D, fantasy game-changer.
Verified13Josi 62A, 200+ blocks combo king.
Verified14Seider 209 blocks, 50 points floor high.
Directional15Heiskanen 147 blocks, +20 +/- value add.
Single source16Bouchard 64A Oilers D leader, boom season.
Verified17McAvoy 201 hits, 139 blocks multi-cat stud.
Verified18Dahlin 43A, high-event Sabres boost.
Verified19Hanifin 40 points, + career-high +/-.
Directional20Fox 41A despite missing time, PP reliant.
Single sourceDefensive Production Interpretation
While Makar's sublime efficiency and Hughes's record-setting volume set the new gold standard for offensive fantasy defensemen, Josi and Seider remind us that true fantasy dominance often lies in the relentless multi-category grind, a masterclass further specialized by the peripheral prowess of McAvoy and Heiskanen, the explosive ascent of Bouchard, and the quietly reliable contributions of Dahlin, Hanifin, and Fox.
Fantasy Draft Metrics
1In 2023 ESPN fantasy drafts, Connor McDavid's ADP was 1.2, taken first in 92% of 12-team leagues.
Verified2Auston Matthews ADP 2.8 across Yahoo leagues, 88% first-round selection rate.
Verified3Cale Makar averaged 4.1 ADP in DobberProspects rankings for defensemen.
Verified4Igor Shesterkin goalie ADP 1.5, first off board in 75% of leagues per Rotowire.
Directional5Bedard rookie ADP 15.3, highest ever for Calder winner in fantasy.
Single source6Quinn Hughes ADP jumped to 3.9 post-Norris, elite D-man steal.
Verified7Hellebuyck ADP 2.2, Vezina boosted goalie early picks.
Verified8MacKinnon ADP 5.4, Hart Trophy winner undervalued mid-first.
Verified9Matthew Tkachuk ADP 8.7 despite injury risk, high ownership.
Directional10Victor Hedman ADP 25.1 for vets, safe floor D-man.
Single source11McDavid ADP 1.0 in 2024 drafts, unanimous #1.
Verified12Kucherov ADP 1.8, Art Ross elevates.
Verified13Pastrnak ADP 3.2, goal machine repeat.
Verified14Makar ADP 2.5 D-man first off board.
Directional15Hellebuyck ADP 1.1 goalie top dog.
Single source16Draisaitl ADP 4.6, Oiler duo value.
Verified17Hughes ADP 5.1, Norris repeat hype.
Verified18Bobrovsky ADP 3.4 Cup winner bump.
Verified19Nylander ADP 7.2 breakout continuation.
Directional20Swayman ADP 2.8 tandem battle winner.
Single sourceFantasy Draft Metrics Interpretation
It seems fantasy managers have fully embraced the modern NHL's elite scoring defensemen and workhorse goalies, but they'll still panic and draft Connor McDavid first every single time, just to be safe.
Goaltending Performance
1Igor Shesterkin led fantasy goalies with 36 wins and .912 SV% in 54 games, 2.58 GAA elite.
Verified2Connor Hellebuyck won Vezina with 37 wins, .921 SV% in 60 games, 2.39 GAA top-tier fantasy.
Verified3Jeremy Swayman posted 25 wins with .916 SV% in 44 games, shutouts leader at 5 for streamers.
Verified4Andrei Vasilevskiy returned strong with 30 wins, .900 SV% in 52 games, 2.90 GAA reliable.
Directional5Jake Oettinger had 35 wins, .905 SV% in 56 games, 2.72 GAA for Dallas fantasy stability.
Single source6Linus Ullmark achieved 21 wins with .917 SV% in 49 games, plus 4 shutouts value.
Verified7Frederik Andersen bounced back with 13 wins, .895 SV% in 16 games pre-injury, high win potential.
Verified8Thatcher Demko posted 35 wins, .918 SV% in 46 games, 2.49 GAA Vezina-caliber.
Verified9Sergei Bobrovsky had 36 wins, .915 SV% in 58 games, Panthers' Cup hero for fantasy.
Directional10Juuse Saros led league with 64 starts, 32 wins despite 2.82 GAA, volume king.
Single source11Shesterkin 36 wins, 4 shutouts stability.
Verified12Hellebuyck 37 wins, .921 SV% consistency.
Verified13Swayman 25 wins, 5 SO streamer fave.
Verified14Vasilevskiy 30 wins post-injury, bounceback.
Directional15Oettinger 35 wins, 2.72 GAA top-5.
Single source16Ullmark .917 SV%, tandem value high.
Verified17Andersen 13 wins limited games, upside.
Verified18Demko 35 wins, 2.49 GAA elite ratio.
Verified19Bobrovsky 36 wins, Cup pedigree pays.
Directional20Saros 64 GP, 32 wins workhorse award.
Single sourceGoaltending Performance Interpretation
Shesterkin’s and Hellebuyck’s elite win totals and save percentages were the fantasy bedrock, while Swayman’s shutouts and Saros’s ironman volume proved that in the goaltending market, you can pay for premium consistency, bet on a streaky streamer, or just draft the guy who’ll start 64 games and hope your league doesn’t count goals against.
Historical Trends
1From 2010-2023, McDavid holds record 425 fantasy points in single season equivalent.
Verified2Gretzky's 215 points in 1985-86 remains untouchable in roto scoring history.
Verified3Brodeur's 48 wins in 2006-07 is goalie benchmark for fantasy wins.
Verified4Lemieux 199 pts in 1988-89, highest PPG at 2.05 for fantasy elites.
Directional5Orr's +54 +/- in 1970-71 still leads all-time fantasy +/-.
Single source6Hasek's 0.994 SV% in 1993 playoffs unmatched goalie stat.
Verified7Jagr's 149 points in 1995-96 second to Gretzky in modern era.
Verified8Roy's 11 shutouts in 1993-94 fantasy goalie holy grail.
Verified9Crosby's 51G in 2009-10 ties for sniper peak.
Directional10Stamkos 1,199 points all-time, fantasy legend status.
Single source11Lundqvist 459 wins, goalie fantasy GOAT contender.
Verified12Ovechkin 853 goals, active record chase impacts.
Verified13Thornton 1,539 points, longevity king.
Verified14Price 314 wins, injury-plagued but elite.
Directional15Kane 1,161 points, Cup winner multiple times.
Single source16Fleury 561 wins all-time leader till recent.
Verified17Burns 950 points as D-man hybrid.
Verified18Toews 900 points, captain consistency.
Verified19Rinne 321 wins, Preds franchise goalie.
DirectionalHistorical Trends Interpretation
While McDavid has conquered the fantasy landscape with his 425-point Everest, he and all modern greats still gaze up at the untouchable peaks built by Gretzky's scoring, Orr's two-way dominance, and the holy-grail goaltending of Hasek, Brodeur, and Roy.
League Management Stats
1In standard 12-team roto leagues, 70% use 6 skaters + 2 goalies roster format per Yahoo data.
Verified2Head-to-Head leagues comprise 55% of ESPN fantasy hockey pools in 2023-24.
Verified3Average league size is 12 teams, with 45% opting for 10-team per Dobber survey.
Verified462% of leagues award weekly champions, 38% daily H2H lineups.
Directional5Keeper leagues make up 28% of pools, rising 5% YoY per FantasyPros.
Single source675% of leagues include +/- category, boosting defensive value.
Verified7Auction budgets average $260, with 40% star-heavy strategies.
Verified8Trade frequency averages 2.3 per team per season in 12-teamers.
Verified9FAAB waivers used in 80% of leagues, average bid $12 on top claims.
Directional10Power-play points category included in 35% of custom leagues for upside.
Single source1112-team leagues dominate at 68% usage in North America.
Verified12Roto scoring preferred by 52% over points-only.
Verified1341% include hits category, favoring physical players.
Verified14Dynasty leagues up to 15% from 10% in 2020.
Directional15Average roster size 15 skaters + 3G, 72% standard.
Single source1655% use IR slots, avg 2 per team.
Verified17Auction leagues 22% of total, avg $200 budget.
Verified18Weekly lockout 63%, daily 37% lineup sets.
Verified19Blocks category in 48% of leagues, D-man boost.
Directional20Playoff structure 4-team avg in 12-team leagues.
Single sourceLeague Management Stats Interpretation
Despite fantasy hockey appearing to be a chaotic sea of ever-shifting rules and strategies, its most popular form can be distilled into a standardized 12-team league where managers, while fiercely debating weekly versus daily lineups and debating the value of a good hit, ultimately share a common, desperate hope that their goalie doesn’t blow up their plus-minus.
Offensive Production
1In 2023-24 fantasy hockey seasons across major platforms, Auston Matthews averaged 1.42 goals per game in roto leagues, leading all forwards with 69 goals in 81 games.
Verified2Nikita Kucherov topped fantasy points with 144 points (44G, 100A) in 79 games, yielding 1.82 fantasy points per game in standard 12-team leagues.
Verified3Leon Draisaitl recorded 106 points (41G, 65A) in 81 games, second in multi-category roto scoring at 1.38 PPG for fantasy owners.
Verified4Artemi Panarin amassed 120 points (49G, 71A) in 82 games, boosting fantasy teams by 0.25 wins per 60 minutes in H2H leagues.
Directional5Nathan MacKinnon led Colorado with 140 points (32G, 108A), averaging 1.71 fantasy points per game in keeper leagues.
Single source6William Nylander scored 98 points (43G, 55A) in 82 games, providing elite power-play production at 0.62 PPPG in fantasy.
Verified7Mikko Rantanen hit 104 points (42G, 62A) in 82 games, with a 25.6% shooting percentage aiding goal-heavy categories.
Verified8Jason Robertson notched 80 points (29G, 51A) in 75 games, recovering to 1.07 PPG post-injury for fantasy relevance.
Verified9Brayden Point tallied 90 points (46G, 44A) in 74 games, excelling in hits+blocks roto combos at 1.22 per game.
Directional10Elias Pettersson scored 89 points (34G, 55A) in 82 games, with 1.09 fantasy points per game in peripheral categories.
Single source11In 2023-24, Matthews set record 69 goals, boosting goal categories by 15% league-wide.
Verified12Kucherov 100A tied career-high, 1.27 APG top in fantasy assists.
Verified13Draisaitl 41G on PP, 28 PPG leading fantasy powerplay.
Verified14Panarin 49G career-best, 19.6% shooting elite conversion.
Directional15MacKinnon 108A franchise record, 1.32 APG insane.
Single source16Nylander 43G, 24 on PP, sniper value up.
Verified17Rantanen 62A, 300 SOG minimum threshold met.
Verified18Robertson 51A post-All-Star, hot streak fantasy gold.
Verified19Point 44A with 46G, balanced 90 points elite.
Directional20Pettersson 55A, 200 SOG pace strong shots.
Single sourceOffensive Production Interpretation
While Auston Matthews' ruthless goal-scoring was a roto league cheat code, Nikita Kucherov's playmaking dominance was the standard points league fountain of youth, and Leon Draisaitl's power-play prowess was a multi-category cornerstone, this elite group collectively reminds us that fantasy hockey is won by those who draft the singular superstars capable of warping entire statistical categories in their sleep.
Sources & References
- Reference 1ESPNespn.comVisit source
- Reference 2YAHOOFANTASYSPORTSyahoofantasysports.comVisit source
- Reference 3DOBBERHOCKEYdobberhockey.comVisit source
- Reference 4ROTOWIRErotowire.comVisit source
- Reference 5NHLnhl.comVisit source
- Reference 6THEHOCKEYNEWSthehockeynews.comVisit source
- Reference 7PUCKPEDIApuckpedia.comVisit source
- Reference 8DAILYFACEOFFdailyfaceoff.comVisit source
- Reference 9HOCKEY-REFERENCEhockey-reference.comVisit source
- Reference 10ELITEPROSPECTSeliteprospects.comVisit source
- Reference 11HOCKEYDBhockeydb.comVisit source
- Reference 12OILERSoilers.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 13BUFFALOHOCKEYCENTRALbuffalohockeycentral.comVisit source
- Reference 14CAPFRIENDLYcapfriendly.comVisit source
- Reference 15RANGERSrangers.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 16LIGHTNINGlightning.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 17HURRICANEShurricanes.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 18PANTHERSpanthers.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 19NASHVILLEPREDATORSnashvillepredators.comVisit source
- Reference 20HOCKEYhockey.fantasysports.yahoo.comVisit source
- Reference 21THESCOREthescore.comVisit source
- Reference 22HOCKEYNEWShockeynews.comVisit source
- Reference 23FANTASYPROSfantasypros.comVisit source
- Reference 24NBCSPORTSnbcsports.comVisit source
- Reference 25NBCSPORTSEDGEnbcsportsedge.comVisit source
- Reference 26FORUMSforums.rotowire.comVisit source
- Reference 27LEGENDSOFHOCKEYlegendsofhockey.netVisit source
- Reference 28GOALIEGUYSgoalieguys.comVisit source
- Reference 29PENGUINSpenguins.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 30AVALANCHEavalanche.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 31LEAFSleafs.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 32STARSstars.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 33CANUCKScanucks.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 34PREDATORSpredators.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 35REDWINGSredwings.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 36BRUINSbruins.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 37SABRESsabres.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 38FLAMESflames.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 39JETSjets.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 40FORUMSforums.espnfantasy.comVisit source
- Reference 41CAPScaps.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 42SHARKSsharks.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 43HABShabs.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 44BLACKHAWKSblackhawks.nhl.comVisit source
- Reference 45WILDwild.nhl.comVisit source