Quick Overview
- 1#1: Samsara - Delivers AI-powered telematics with GPS tracking, dashcams, and fleet safety analytics to optimize TMS operations.
- 2#2: Motive - Provides ELD compliance, AI dashcams, and real-time fleet insights for driver safety and TMS integration.
- 3#3: Geotab - Offers an open telematics platform for vehicle tracking, fuel efficiency, and custom TMS data integrations.
- 4#4: Verizon Connect - Cloud-based fleet management with GPS, routing optimization, and reporting to enhance TMS visibility.
- 5#5: Lytx - Video telematics solution offering driver coaching, event detection, and safety metrics for TMS fleets.
- 6#6: Rand McNally - Supplies ELD systems, truck-specific routing, and fleet tracking software compatible with TMS workflows.
- 7#7: Teletrac Navman - Telematics platform for fleet optimization, compliance monitoring, and performance analytics in TMS environments.
- 8#8: Zonar Systems - Connected vehicle gateway providing ELDs, DVIR inspections, and real-time data for TMS integration.
- 9#9: Netradyne - AI vision-based safety system with driver monitoring and predictive insights for TMS safety enhancements.
- 10#10: EROAD - ELD and logistics platform for HOS compliance, fuel management, and operational reporting in TMS setups.
We selected and ranked these tools based on key features, operational performance, user-friendliness, and overall value, ensuring a list of trusted solutions that deliver measurable benefits for TMS workflows.
Comparison Table
For businesses seeking to optimize logistics workflows, a reliable TMS enterprise software is essential, and this comparison table evaluates leading platforms like Samsara, Motive, Geotab, Verizon Connect, Lytx, and more. It breaks down key features, usability, and integration capabilities to help readers identify the best tool for their specific operational needs.
| # | Tool | Category | Overall | Features | Ease of Use | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Samsara Delivers AI-powered telematics with GPS tracking, dashcams, and fleet safety analytics to optimize TMS operations. | enterprise | 9.7/10 | 9.8/10 | 9.3/10 | 9.2/10 |
| 2 | Motive Provides ELD compliance, AI dashcams, and real-time fleet insights for driver safety and TMS integration. | enterprise | 9.2/10 | 9.5/10 | 8.7/10 | 8.9/10 |
| 3 | Geotab Offers an open telematics platform for vehicle tracking, fuel efficiency, and custom TMS data integrations. | enterprise | 8.7/10 | 9.2/10 | 8.5/10 | 8.3/10 |
| 4 | Verizon Connect Cloud-based fleet management with GPS, routing optimization, and reporting to enhance TMS visibility. | enterprise | 8.2/10 | 8.7/10 | 7.8/10 | 7.9/10 |
| 5 | Lytx Video telematics solution offering driver coaching, event detection, and safety metrics for TMS fleets. | enterprise | 7.2/10 | 6.8/10 | 8.1/10 | 7.4/10 |
| 6 | Rand McNally Supplies ELD systems, truck-specific routing, and fleet tracking software compatible with TMS workflows. | specialized | 7.8/10 | 8.4/10 | 7.2/10 | 7.5/10 |
| 7 | Teletrac Navman Telematics platform for fleet optimization, compliance monitoring, and performance analytics in TMS environments. | enterprise | 8.4/10 | 9.1/10 | 7.6/10 | 8.0/10 |
| 8 | Zonar Systems Connected vehicle gateway providing ELDs, DVIR inspections, and real-time data for TMS integration. | enterprise | 7.8/10 | 7.5/10 | 8.2/10 | 7.6/10 |
| 9 | Netradyne AI vision-based safety system with driver monitoring and predictive insights for TMS safety enhancements. | specialized | 7.1/10 | 8.2/10 | 7.8/10 | 6.5/10 |
| 10 | EROAD ELD and logistics platform for HOS compliance, fuel management, and operational reporting in TMS setups. | enterprise | 8.2/10 | 8.7/10 | 7.8/10 | 7.9/10 |
Delivers AI-powered telematics with GPS tracking, dashcams, and fleet safety analytics to optimize TMS operations.
Provides ELD compliance, AI dashcams, and real-time fleet insights for driver safety and TMS integration.
Offers an open telematics platform for vehicle tracking, fuel efficiency, and custom TMS data integrations.
Cloud-based fleet management with GPS, routing optimization, and reporting to enhance TMS visibility.
Video telematics solution offering driver coaching, event detection, and safety metrics for TMS fleets.
Supplies ELD systems, truck-specific routing, and fleet tracking software compatible with TMS workflows.
Telematics platform for fleet optimization, compliance monitoring, and performance analytics in TMS environments.
Connected vehicle gateway providing ELDs, DVIR inspections, and real-time data for TMS integration.
AI vision-based safety system with driver monitoring and predictive insights for TMS safety enhancements.
ELD and logistics platform for HOS compliance, fuel management, and operational reporting in TMS setups.
Samsara
enterpriseDelivers AI-powered telematics with GPS tracking, dashcams, and fleet safety analytics to optimize TMS operations.
AI Dash Cams with real-time safety coaching and event detection for unparalleled driver behavior insights
Samsara is a leading IoT-powered Connected Operations Cloud platform designed for enterprise fleet and transportation management. It provides real-time GPS tracking, telematics, ELD compliance, dynamic routing, dispatch optimization, and AI-driven safety features to streamline TMS operations. Enterprises use it to gain full visibility into fleets, reduce costs, ensure regulatory compliance, and improve driver performance across large-scale operations.
Pros
- Comprehensive real-time visibility and AI analytics for proactive decision-making
- Seamless ELD, DVIR, and compliance tools with automatic HOS logging
- Robust integrations with ERPs, CRMs, and third-party TMS systems
Cons
- High initial hardware and setup costs for full deployment
- Pricing scales steeply for very large fleets
- Steeper learning curve for advanced custom configurations
Best For
Large enterprises managing thousands of vehicles that require integrated telematics, routing, and compliance in a single TMS platform.
Pricing
Subscription starts at $25-50 per vehicle/month plus one-time hardware costs ($200-500 per unit); custom enterprise pricing available.
Motive
enterpriseProvides ELD compliance, AI dashcams, and real-time fleet insights for driver safety and TMS integration.
AI-powered Motive Camera with automated violation detection and driver coaching
Motive (gomotive.com) is an enterprise-grade Transportation Management System (TMS) platform designed for fleet operations, integrating telematics, ELD compliance, GPS tracking, dynamic routing, and dispatch automation. It provides real-time visibility into fleet performance, driver safety via AI-powered dash cams, and predictive maintenance to optimize transportation workflows. Ideal for scaling businesses, it combines compliance tools with advanced analytics to reduce costs and improve efficiency across large-scale logistics operations.
Pros
- Comprehensive ELD and HOS compliance with seamless integration
- AI-driven dash cams and safety coaching for proactive risk management
- Scalable real-time routing and dispatch for enterprise fleets
Cons
- Custom pricing can be steep for smaller operations
- Advanced features may require training for full utilization
- Occasional integration challenges with legacy systems
Best For
Large trucking and logistics enterprises seeking an all-in-one TMS with embedded telematics and safety analytics.
Pricing
Custom enterprise quotes; typically $25-40 per vehicle/month base, plus add-ons for dash cams ($10-20/vehicle) and premium analytics.
Geotab
enterpriseOffers an open telematics platform for vehicle tracking, fuel efficiency, and custom TMS data integrations.
Geotab's ACE AI analytics engine, leveraging the world's largest telematics dataset for predictive insights and benchmarking.
Geotab is a leading telematics platform specializing in fleet management for enterprises, providing real-time GPS tracking, vehicle diagnostics, driver behavior analytics, and compliance reporting. It optimizes transportation operations through data-driven insights on fuel efficiency, maintenance scheduling, and route performance via the intuitive MyGeotab dashboard. While not a full end-to-end TMS, it excels in visibility and integrates deeply with core TMS systems like SAP, Oracle, and Manhattan for enhanced enterprise logistics.
Pros
- Unmatched telematics data depth with AI-powered analytics
- Scalable for fleets of 100+ vehicles with global coverage
- Extensive marketplace of 250+ integrations for TMS ecosystems
Cons
- Lacks native advanced TMS functions like load optimization or carrier tendering
- Initial hardware installation and setup can be time-intensive
- Pricing scales up quickly with premium add-ons and large fleets
Best For
Large enterprises with existing TMS platforms needing superior telematics visibility and fleet analytics.
Pricing
Hardware device ~$100-200 upfront per vehicle; SaaS subscription $20-50/vehicle/month based on features and volume, with custom enterprise plans.
Verizon Connect
enterpriseCloud-based fleet management with GPS, routing optimization, and reporting to enhance TMS visibility.
Seamless integration with Verizon's nationwide cellular network for unmatched GPS accuracy and real-time data connectivity in remote areas
Verizon Connect is a robust enterprise fleet management and TMS solution that delivers real-time GPS tracking, dynamic route optimization, telematics data analytics, and compliance tools like ELD and HOS logging. It enables large-scale transportation operations to manage dispatching, maintenance, driver safety, and fuel efficiency through an integrated platform. The software leverages Verizon's extensive cellular network for reliable connectivity and scalability across thousands of vehicles.
Pros
- Superior telematics integration with Verizon's reliable 4G/5G network for accurate tracking
- Comprehensive compliance and reporting tools tailored for enterprise fleets
- Advanced analytics for cost savings in fuel, maintenance, and routing
Cons
- Steep learning curve and complex interface for new users
- Custom enterprise pricing can be expensive without clear ROI visibility
- Occasional customer support delays reported in reviews
Best For
Large enterprises managing extensive fleets that require integrated telematics, compliance, and TMS capabilities for nationwide operations.
Pricing
Custom enterprise pricing, typically $25-60 per vehicle/month depending on features and scale, with hardware and installation fees.
Lytx
enterpriseVideo telematics solution offering driver coaching, event detection, and safety metrics for TMS fleets.
AI-driven Video Telematics with automatic risk detection from dashcam footage
Lytx is a video telematics and fleet safety platform that leverages dash cameras, GPS tracking, and AI analytics to monitor driver behavior, detect risks, and ensure compliance in transportation operations. It provides real-time alerts, coaching tools, and performance reports to improve safety and efficiency, integrating with some TMS systems for enhanced visibility. While excelling in safety monitoring, it lacks comprehensive TMS features like advanced route optimization, load tendering, or carrier management.
Pros
- AI-powered video event detection for proactive safety coaching
- Real-time GPS tracking and compliance reporting
- Seamless integration with ELDs and some TMS platforms
Cons
- Limited native TMS capabilities like order management or freight optimization
- Requires hardware installation, adding upfront costs
- Reporting can be overwhelming for non-safety focused users
Best For
Mid-to-large fleets prioritizing driver safety and risk mitigation within a broader TMS ecosystem.
Pricing
Custom enterprise pricing, typically $25-60 per vehicle/month plus one-time hardware costs of $300-500 per unit.
Rand McNally
specializedSupplies ELD systems, truck-specific routing, and fleet tracking software compatible with TMS workflows.
Precision truck routing engine with proprietary database of over 5 million miles of road restrictions and real-time updates
Rand McNally provides enterprise-grade Transportation Management System (TMS) solutions tailored for trucking and fleet operations, focusing on advanced route optimization, compliance management, and telematics integration. Their platform, including tools like Rand McNally Connect and Fleet Management, enables dispatchers to plan efficient routes while adhering to DOT regulations, truck restrictions, and load requirements. It supports real-time tracking, fuel optimization, and electronic logging for large-scale fleets, bridging navigation hardware with software analytics.
Pros
- Superior truck-specific routing accounting for restrictions like weight limits, low bridges, and hazmat zones
- Seamless integration with ELDs, telematics, and Rand McNally's durable GPS hardware
- Strong compliance tools for HOS logging and IFTA reporting
Cons
- Primarily focused on trucking with limited multimodal support
- User interface can feel dated compared to modern cloud-native TMS platforms
- Custom integrations with broader ERP systems require additional development
Best For
Mid-to-large trucking fleets prioritizing route accuracy, regulatory compliance, and hardware-software synergy over full-spectrum supply chain management.
Pricing
Custom enterprise subscriptions, typically $20-50 per vehicle/month plus hardware costs; volume discounts available.
Teletrac Navman
enterpriseTelematics platform for fleet optimization, compliance monitoring, and performance analytics in TMS environments.
AI-powered Video Telematics with proactive coaching alerts
Teletrac Navman offers TN360, a robust enterprise TMS platform specializing in fleet telematics and transportation management for large-scale operations. It provides real-time GPS tracking, ELD compliance, driver behavior monitoring via AI analytics, and video telematics with dash cams for enhanced safety and efficiency. The solution optimizes routes, manages maintenance, and delivers benchmarking reports to reduce costs and improve regulatory adherence.
Pros
- Comprehensive compliance tools including ELD and HOS logging
- Advanced AI-driven insights and video telematics for safety
- Scalable for thousands of vehicles with strong integrations
Cons
- Steep initial setup and learning curve
- Premium pricing without transparent quotes
- Occasional reports of customer support delays
Best For
Large enterprises managing extensive fleets that require advanced telematics, compliance, and safety features.
Pricing
Custom enterprise quotes; typically $25-45 per vehicle/month plus hardware fees (sensors, dash cams).
Zonar Systems
enterpriseConnected vehicle gateway providing ELDs, DVIR inspections, and real-time data for TMS integration.
Integrated ELD, telematics, and multi-camera safety system with AI analytics for proactive driver risk management
Zonar Systems offers a fleet management and telematics platform tailored for enterprise transportation operations, emphasizing real-time GPS tracking, electronic logging devices (ELDs), and compliance tools. It provides driver safety monitoring via cameras and behavior analytics, vehicle maintenance alerts, and productivity reporting through the MyZonar dashboard. While excelling in operational visibility and regulatory adherence for fleets like trucking and school buses, it integrates well with broader TMS systems but lacks deep route optimization or multi-modal planning capabilities.
Pros
- Superior real-time telematics and GPS tracking for fleet visibility
- Comprehensive ELD and HOS compliance with automated reporting
- Robust safety features including AI-powered cameras and driver coaching
Cons
- Limited native route planning and optimization tools
- Pricing scales steeply for very large fleets
- Customization requires technical expertise
Best For
Regulated enterprise fleets such as trucking and public transit operators prioritizing compliance, safety, and telematics over advanced logistics optimization.
Pricing
Custom enterprise pricing, typically $25-60 per vehicle per month depending on modules and fleet size.
Netradyne
specializedAI vision-based safety system with driver monitoring and predictive insights for TMS safety enhancements.
Camera-only AI vision system that detects behaviors like drowsiness without GPS or additional sensors
Netradyne is an AI-powered vision-based fleet safety platform designed for transportation enterprises, using in-cab cameras to monitor driver behavior, detect safety events like distractions and harsh braking, and deliver real-time coaching and compliance insights. It provides video evidence for incidents, predictive analytics for risk reduction, and integrates with TMS systems for enhanced fleet oversight. While excelling in safety telematics, it lacks comprehensive TMS core functions such as route optimization, load planning, or carrier management.
Pros
- AI-driven event detection with 98% accuracy
- Automated driver coaching and performance reports
- Seamless integration with major TMS platforms
Cons
- Not a full TMS; limited logistics optimization tools
- Requires upfront hardware installation per vehicle
- Premium pricing may not justify for non-safety-focused fleets
Best For
Enterprise fleets prioritizing driver safety, compliance, and risk mitigation alongside an existing core TMS.
Pricing
Subscription-based at $35-60 per vehicle/month plus $500-800 one-time hardware per unit; enterprise custom quotes available.
EROAD
enterpriseELD and logistics platform for HOS compliance, fuel management, and operational reporting in TMS setups.
Automated IFTA fuel tax reporting and reconciliation directly from telematics data
EROAD is a cloud-based Transportation Management System (TMS) tailored for commercial fleets, providing real-time GPS tracking, electronic logging devices (ELDs), driver workflow management, and compliance tools like HOS and DVIR. It excels in fuel tax reporting (IFTA/IRF), route optimization, and integration with accounting systems for streamlined operations. Primarily serving Australia, New Zealand, and North America, EROAD combines hardware and software for end-to-end transport visibility and regulatory adherence.
Pros
- Superior compliance tools including automated ELD and fuel tax reporting
- Real-time fleet tracking and analytics for operational efficiency
- Seamless hardware-software integration with strong regional support
Cons
- Proprietary hardware increases upfront costs and vendor lock-in
- Interface feels dated compared to modern competitors
- Limited scalability for very large global enterprises outside key markets
Best For
Mid-sized trucking and logistics fleets in regulated markets like the US, Australia, and New Zealand that prioritize compliance and fuel management.
Pricing
Subscription starts at ~$35-60 per vehicle/month plus one-time hardware fees ($500-1000 per unit); enterprise quotes required.
Conclusion
The reviewed tools demonstrate a range of strengths in boosting TMS operations, with Samsara emerging as the top choice due to its AI-powered telematics, GPS tracking, and fleet safety analytics that streamline workflows. Motive and Geotab are strong alternatives, offering robust solutions—Motive leads in ELD compliance and real-time insights, while Geotab provides an open platform for custom integrations. Together, they highlight the best in the field, ensuring fleets of all types can find a tailored fit.
Transform your TMS with Samsara, the top-ranked tool, to unlock innovative optimization and enhanced safety. For specific needs, Motive and Geotab are excellent options, but Samsara remains the top pick for comprehensive performance.
Tools Reviewed
All tools were independently evaluated for this comparison