Quick Overview
- 1#1: Proton Mail - End-to-end encrypted email service with zero-access encryption, open-source apps, and strong privacy protections.
- 2#2: Tuta - Fully client-side encrypted email service that secures subjects, calendars, and contacts automatically.
- 3#3: Mailbox.org - Secure email hosting with PGP encryption, unlimited aliases, and integrated calendar and drive.
- 4#4: Posteo - Privacy-focused email service with automatic encryption, no tracking, and anonymous payment options.
- 5#5: Mailfence - Secure email with OpenPGP.js encryption, group features, and alias support for enhanced privacy.
- 6#6: StartMail - PGP-encrypted email service with unlimited disposable aliases and easy key management.
- 7#7: Runbox - Eco-friendly secure email from Norway with strong encryption and no ads or tracking.
- 8#8: CounterMail - Ultra-secure email using PGP encryption and diskless servers for maximum privacy.
- 9#9: Hushmail - Secure email tailored for professionals with e-signatures and compliance features.
- 10#10: Kolab Now - Secure groupware suite including encrypted email, calendar, and collaborative tools.
We evaluated tools based on encryption strength, ease of use, comprehensive privacy protections (such as anti-tracking and anonymous options), and overall value, ensuring a balanced ranking that prioritizes both security and practicality.
Comparison Table
In an era where digital communication security is critical, selecting the right secure email software is essential for protecting sensitive information and privacy. This comparison table examines tools like Proton Mail, Tuta, Mailbox.org, Posteo, Mailfence, and more, detailing key features, privacy practices, and user experience to guide informed choices.
| # | Tool | Category | Overall | Features | Ease of Use | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Proton Mail End-to-end encrypted email service with zero-access encryption, open-source apps, and strong privacy protections. | specialized | 9.7/10 | 9.9/10 | 9.2/10 | 9.6/10 |
| 2 | Tuta Fully client-side encrypted email service that secures subjects, calendars, and contacts automatically. | specialized | 9.2/10 | 9.5/10 | 8.8/10 | 9.4/10 |
| 3 | Mailbox.org Secure email hosting with PGP encryption, unlimited aliases, and integrated calendar and drive. | enterprise | 8.7/10 | 9.2/10 | 7.8/10 | 9.0/10 |
| 4 | Posteo Privacy-focused email service with automatic encryption, no tracking, and anonymous payment options. | specialized | 8.7/10 | 8.2/10 | 8.5/10 | 9.4/10 |
| 5 | Mailfence Secure email with OpenPGP.js encryption, group features, and alias support for enhanced privacy. | specialized | 8.3/10 | 8.6/10 | 7.7/10 | 8.5/10 |
| 6 | StartMail PGP-encrypted email service with unlimited disposable aliases and easy key management. | specialized | 8.4/10 | 8.6/10 | 9.1/10 | 7.9/10 |
| 7 | Runbox Eco-friendly secure email from Norway with strong encryption and no ads or tracking. | specialized | 8.6/10 | 8.4/10 | 8.1/10 | 9.2/10 |
| 8 | CounterMail Ultra-secure email using PGP encryption and diskless servers for maximum privacy. | specialized | 8.2/10 | 8.5/10 | 7.2/10 | 8.0/10 |
| 9 | Hushmail Secure email tailored for professionals with e-signatures and compliance features. | enterprise | 8.1/10 | 8.7/10 | 7.8/10 | 7.3/10 |
| 10 | Kolab Now Secure groupware suite including encrypted email, calendar, and collaborative tools. | enterprise | 7.9/10 | 8.4/10 | 7.4/10 | 7.3/10 |
End-to-end encrypted email service with zero-access encryption, open-source apps, and strong privacy protections.
Fully client-side encrypted email service that secures subjects, calendars, and contacts automatically.
Secure email hosting with PGP encryption, unlimited aliases, and integrated calendar and drive.
Privacy-focused email service with automatic encryption, no tracking, and anonymous payment options.
Secure email with OpenPGP.js encryption, group features, and alias support for enhanced privacy.
PGP-encrypted email service with unlimited disposable aliases and easy key management.
Eco-friendly secure email from Norway with strong encryption and no ads or tracking.
Ultra-secure email using PGP encryption and diskless servers for maximum privacy.
Secure email tailored for professionals with e-signatures and compliance features.
Secure groupware suite including encrypted email, calendar, and collaborative tools.
Proton Mail
specializedEnd-to-end encrypted email service with zero-access encryption, open-source apps, and strong privacy protections.
Zero-access end-to-end encryption by default for all Proton-to-Proton emails
Proton Mail is a privacy-focused email service based in Switzerland that provides end-to-end encryption for all emails by default, ensuring that only the sender and recipient can read the messages. It employs zero-access encryption, meaning even Proton Mail cannot access user data, and benefits from Switzerland's strict privacy laws. The service offers a user-friendly web app, mobile apps, and desktop clients, with additional integrated tools like calendar, drive, and VPN in premium plans.
Pros
- Unparalleled end-to-end and zero-access encryption
- Open-source apps with no ads or tracking
- Swiss jurisdiction for superior privacy protections
Cons
- Limited free plan (1GB storage, 150 messages/day)
- Non-Proton recipients require password sharing for encryption
- No standard IMAP/SMTP on free tier
Best For
Privacy-conscious individuals, journalists, activists, and businesses prioritizing maximum email security over unlimited storage.
Pricing
Free (1GB storage); Mail Plus $4.99/mo (15GB); Unlimited $12.99/mo (500GB + full suite).
Tuta
specializedFully client-side encrypted email service that secures subjects, calendars, and contacts automatically.
Default end-to-end encryption for all emails—even to non-Tuta users via password-protected messages—with quantum-resistant cryptography
Tuta (formerly Tutanota) is a privacy-centric email service that automatically applies end-to-end encryption to emails, calendars, and contacts, ensuring only the sender and recipient can access content. Based in Germany, it adheres to strict EU data protection laws, operates on a zero-knowledge architecture, and is fully open-source for transparency. It offers a seamless web and mobile experience without ads or tracking.
Pros
- Automatic end-to-end encryption for emails, calendars, and contacts
- Open-source apps with zero-knowledge privacy
- Generous free plan and affordable premium tiers
Cons
- No IMAP/SMTP support for third-party clients
- Encrypted search is less precise and slower
- Limited integrations compared to mainstream providers
Best For
Privacy-conscious individuals and small teams prioritizing unbreakable encryption over ecosystem integrations.
Pricing
Free (1GB storage, 1 calendar); Premium €3/month (20GB storage, unlimited calendars, 10 aliases, 1 custom domain); Team plans from €6/user/month.
Mailbox.org
enterpriseSecure email hosting with PGP encryption, unlimited aliases, and integrated calendar and drive.
Seamless automatic PGP encryption in the web client without requiring user-managed keys or plugins
Mailbox.org is a German-based privacy-focused email provider offering secure email hosting, calendar, contacts, tasks, and cloud storage in a single platform. It supports OpenPGP encryption with automatic key management in the web client, two-factor authentication, and strict no-logs policies under GDPR protections. Designed for users prioritizing data sovereignty, it allows custom domains and integrates seamlessly with standard IMAP/SMTP clients without tracking or ads.
Pros
- Robust OpenPGP encryption with automatic webmail support
- Integrated productivity suite (email, calendar, drive, office)
- Affordable plans with custom domains and strong GDPR compliance
Cons
- Web interface feels somewhat dated and less intuitive
- Limited storage on entry-level plans (2GB email)
- No official native mobile apps; relies on third-party clients
Best For
Privacy-conscious professionals needing a secure, all-in-one email and productivity suite without ads or tracking.
Pricing
Starts at €1/month (2GB email + 2GB drive), €3/month Premium (25GB email + 10GB drive); annual discounts available, 30-day trial.
Posteo
specializedPrivacy-focused email service with automatic encryption, no tracking, and anonymous payment options.
Court-proven zero-knowledge privacy with no user data logs and fully anonymous signup/payment options
Posteo is a privacy-oriented email service provider based in Berlin, Germany, emphasizing data protection, sustainability, and user anonymity without ads or tracking. It offers secure email hosting with support for IMAP, SMTP, and POP3 protocols, allowing seamless integration with third-party clients, alongside webmail, calendar, and contacts features. Posteo uses TLS encryption for transit, supports PGP for end-to-end encryption, logs no IP addresses, and runs on 100% renewable energy.
Pros
- Exceptional privacy with no IP logging or user tracking
- Very affordable flat-rate pricing
- Eco-friendly operations using renewable energy
- Supports PGP and standard protocols for flexible client use
Cons
- No built-in end-to-end encryption (requires manual PGP setup)
- Lacks dedicated mobile apps
- Storage starts low at 2GB (expandable at extra cost)
- Germany-based (14 Eyes jurisdiction)
Best For
Privacy-focused individuals and small teams seeking an affordable, green email service with strong anonymity features.
Pricing
€1/month for 2GB (up to 20GB for €12/month), anonymous payments accepted, no free tier.
Mailfence
specializedSecure email with OpenPGP.js encryption, group features, and alias support for enhanced privacy.
Native OpenPGP support enabling seamless encrypted communication with any PGP-compatible service
Mailfence is a privacy-oriented email service based in Belgium, providing end-to-end encrypted email, calendar, documents, and contacts with OpenPGP standards for secure communication. It emphasizes data sovereignty under EU GDPR laws, offers password-protected emails to non-users, and includes features like aliases and group encryption. The service supports IMAP/SMTP access with limitations and provides a free tier for basic secure emailing.
Pros
- Strong OpenPGP encryption with interoperability and digital signatures
- Integrated secure calendar, documents, and contacts suite
- No ads, tracking, or data mining with EU-based privacy protections
Cons
- Dated web interface that feels less modern than competitors
- Limited mobile app functionality and IMAP encryption restrictions
- Free tier capped at 500MB storage with fewer advanced features
Best For
Privacy-focused professionals needing an all-in-one secure productivity suite with reliable encryption standards.
Pricing
Free (500MB); Entry (€2.50/mo, 5GB); Pro (€7.50/mo, 20GB); Ultrafast plans from €19/mo.
StartMail
specializedPGP-encrypted email service with unlimited disposable aliases and easy key management.
Unlimited disposable email aliases
StartMail is a privacy-focused email service provider based in the Netherlands, designed for users seeking secure and anonymous communication. It supports PGP encryption for end-to-end security, offers unlimited disposable email aliases, and maintains a strict no-logs policy with no tracking or ads. The service provides a clean web interface accessible from any device, prioritizing user control over data without requiring personal information to sign up.
Pros
- Unlimited disposable email aliases for enhanced privacy
- Strong PGP support for end-to-end encryption
- No-logs policy and privacy-friendly Dutch jurisdiction
Cons
- No free tier available
- Limited native mobile apps (primarily web-based)
- Not fully open-source or zero-knowledge by default
Best For
Privacy-conscious individuals or professionals needing anonymous aliases and PGP encryption without data tracking.
Pricing
Starts at $59.95/year for 1-year plan; $99.95 for 2 years; business plans from $5/user/month.
Runbox
specializedEco-friendly secure email from Norway with strong encryption and no ads or tracking.
Norwegian-based privacy jurisdiction with no data logging and full PGP/S/MIME integration for user-controlled encryption
Runbox is a privacy-oriented email service from Norway, providing secure email hosting with server-side encryption, PGP and S/MIME support for end-to-end encryption, and two-factor authentication. It emphasizes no ads, no tracking, and data protection under strict Norwegian privacy laws, with features like unlimited aliases on premium plans and sustainable server operations. Users access it via webmail, IMAP/POP3, or mobile clients for flexible, secure communication.
Pros
- Strong privacy protections from Norwegian jurisdiction outside major surveillance alliances
- Robust encryption options including PGP/S/MIME and data at rest encryption
- Affordable plans with generous storage and unlimited aliases on higher tiers
Cons
- Web interface appears dated and less modern than competitors
- Lacks built-in zero-knowledge end-to-end encryption (requires manual PGP setup)
- No free plan and limited native collaboration tools
Best For
Privacy-focused individuals and small teams needing cost-effective, secure email without ads or data mining.
Pricing
Starts at €1.66/month (billed annually) for 1GB storage; scales to €12.50/month for 50GB, custom domains, and advanced features.
CounterMail
specializedUltra-secure email using PGP encryption and diskless servers for maximum privacy.
Fully anonymous account creation with no personal data required and direct Tor onion site access
CounterMail is a privacy-centric email service based in Sweden, emphasizing end-to-end PGP encryption, zero-knowledge storage, and no logging of user activity or IP addresses. It supports anonymous account creation without requiring personal information and offers access via Tor onion service for maximum anonymity. The service provides secure webmail and IMAP/POP3 access with diskless servers to prevent data retention.
Pros
- Top-tier privacy with no logs, diskless servers, and Tor access
- Automatic end-to-end PGP encryption and perfect forward secrecy
- Anonymous sign-up and Bitcoin payments supported
Cons
- Dated web interface lacking modern polish
- No native mobile apps, relies on third-party clients
- Limited storage on entry-level plans (250MB starting)
Best For
Privacy extremists and journalists who need maximum anonymity and zero logs over user-friendly features.
Pricing
Plans start at €3/month (250MB storage), €4/month (500MB), up to €29/month (15GB); annual discounts available, no free tier.
Hushmail
enterpriseSecure email tailored for professionals with e-signatures and compliance features.
HIPAA-compliant encryption and secure web forms designed specifically for healthcare communications
Hushmail is a secure email service tailored for professionals in regulated industries like healthcare and law, offering end-to-end encryption for emails and attachments. It allows secure communication with non-Hushmail users via password-protected web links and includes features like secure forms and e-signatures. The service emphasizes compliance with standards such as HIPAA and PIPEDA, making it ideal for handling sensitive data.
Pros
- Robust end-to-end encryption and secure forms
- HIPAA and PIPEDA compliance for regulated industries
- Support for sending secure emails to non-users via web links
Cons
- Premium pricing without a robust free tier
- Limited integrations compared to mainstream email services
- Storage caps on lower plans (e.g., 10GB max)
Best For
Healthcare professionals and legal teams needing compliant secure email for sensitive client or patient communications.
Pricing
Solo plan at $9.99/month (10GB); Business from $12.99/user/month; Healthcare plans start at $19.99/user/month with compliance features.
Kolab Now
enterpriseSecure groupware suite including encrypted email, calendar, and collaborative tools.
Fully integrated open-source groupware (email + calendar/tasks/files) with Swiss data sovereignty
Kolab Now is a privacy-focused, hosted groupware platform based on open-source Kolab software, providing secure email, calendar, contacts, tasks, notes, and file storage. Hosted in Switzerland under strict privacy laws, it supports standard protocols like IMAP, SMTP, CalDAV, and CardDAV for seamless integration with desktop and mobile clients. It prioritizes data sovereignty, ad-free operation, and security features like TLS encryption and optional PGP/S/MIME support, without built-in end-to-end encryption for email.
Pros
- Swiss hosting with robust EU privacy protections and no data mining
- Comprehensive groupware suite beyond just email
- Open-source foundation for transparency and customizability
Cons
- Web interface appears dated and less intuitive than modern competitors
- Lacks native end-to-end encryption for email (requires client-side setup)
- Higher pricing for storage compared to basic secure email providers
Best For
Small teams or professionals needing an all-in-one, privacy-centric groupware solution hosted in Europe.
Pricing
Starts at €4.99/user/month (5GB, Freedom plan), €6.99 (15GB, Standard), €11.99 (50GB, Premium); annual billing offers discounts.
Conclusion
This review of secure email software highlights leading options for privacy protection, with Proton Mail emerging as the top choice, thanks to its robust end-to-end encryption and zero-access security. Tuta follows closely, offering fully client-side encryption that automatically secures subjects, calendars, and contacts, ideal for seamless privacy. Mailbox.org completes the top three, providing powerful PGP encryption, unlimited aliases, and integrated tools for versatile use. Each tool suits unique needs, but Proton Mail stands out as the best overall.
Don’t settle for less—start using Proton Mail today to experience the highest level of secure email protection available.
Tools Reviewed
All tools were independently evaluated for this comparison
