Quick Overview
- 1#1: QuickBooks Time - Tracks employee hours with GPS verification, automatic overtime calculations, and seamless payroll integrations.
- 2#2: Hubstaff - Monitors remote teams with screenshots, activity tracking, and customizable overtime rules and alerts.
- 3#3: Clockify - Provides free unlimited time tracking for teams with detailed overtime reports and export options.
- 4#4: Toggl Track - Offers simple one-click time tracking with overtime categorization and comprehensive reporting dashboards.
- 5#5: Deputy - Combines scheduling and time clocking with overtime forecasting, approvals, and labor compliance features.
- 6#6: When I Work - Manages shifts and tracks time punches with real-time overtime notifications and payroll exports.
- 7#7: Homebase - Delivers free time tracking, scheduling, and overtime alerts for small business hourly teams.
- 8#8: Time Doctor - Tracks productivity and time with automatic overtime detection, screenshots, and detailed timesheets.
- 9#9: Everhour - Integrates time tracking with project tools for overtime budgeting, forecasting, and invoicing.
- 10#10: Harvest - Captures billable and overtime hours with timers, reports, and invoicing for teams and freelancers.
Tools were ranked based on functionality (like automated calculations and reporting), usability (intuitive interfaces and minimal setup), and value (integration capabilities and pricing models), ensuring a comprehensive overview of software that delivers on performance and practicality.
Comparison Table
Overtime tracking is essential for balancing labor costs and employee workloads, making the right software choice key to efficiency. This comparison table explores features, usability, and pricing of popular tools like QuickBooks Time, Hubstaff, Clockify, Toggl Track, Deputy, and more, equipping readers to find the best fit for their operational needs.
| # | Tool | Category | Overall | Features | Ease of Use | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | QuickBooks Time Tracks employee hours with GPS verification, automatic overtime calculations, and seamless payroll integrations. | specialized | 9.5/10 | 9.8/10 | 9.2/10 | 9.0/10 |
| 2 | Hubstaff Monitors remote teams with screenshots, activity tracking, and customizable overtime rules and alerts. | specialized | 8.9/10 | 9.3/10 | 8.4/10 | 8.7/10 |
| 3 | Clockify Provides free unlimited time tracking for teams with detailed overtime reports and export options. | specialized | 8.7/10 | 8.5/10 | 9.4/10 | 9.8/10 |
| 4 | Toggl Track Offers simple one-click time tracking with overtime categorization and comprehensive reporting dashboards. | specialized | 7.8/10 | 7.5/10 | 9.2/10 | 8.5/10 |
| 5 | Deputy Combines scheduling and time clocking with overtime forecasting, approvals, and labor compliance features. | enterprise | 8.2/10 | 8.5/10 | 8.0/10 | 7.8/10 |
| 6 | When I Work Manages shifts and tracks time punches with real-time overtime notifications and payroll exports. | specialized | 7.8/10 | 7.5/10 | 8.5/10 | 8.0/10 |
| 7 | Homebase Delivers free time tracking, scheduling, and overtime alerts for small business hourly teams. | specialized | 8.1/10 | 8.2/10 | 9.0/10 | 8.5/10 |
| 8 | Time Doctor Tracks productivity and time with automatic overtime detection, screenshots, and detailed timesheets. | specialized | 8.1/10 | 8.8/10 | 7.7/10 | 7.5/10 |
| 9 | Everhour Integrates time tracking with project tools for overtime budgeting, forecasting, and invoicing. | specialized | 7.8/10 | 8.2/10 | 8.7/10 | 7.4/10 |
| 10 | Harvest Captures billable and overtime hours with timers, reports, and invoicing for teams and freelancers. | specialized | 7.8/10 | 7.5/10 | 9.2/10 | 7.2/10 |
Tracks employee hours with GPS verification, automatic overtime calculations, and seamless payroll integrations.
Monitors remote teams with screenshots, activity tracking, and customizable overtime rules and alerts.
Provides free unlimited time tracking for teams with detailed overtime reports and export options.
Offers simple one-click time tracking with overtime categorization and comprehensive reporting dashboards.
Combines scheduling and time clocking with overtime forecasting, approvals, and labor compliance features.
Manages shifts and tracks time punches with real-time overtime notifications and payroll exports.
Delivers free time tracking, scheduling, and overtime alerts for small business hourly teams.
Tracks productivity and time with automatic overtime detection, screenshots, and detailed timesheets.
Integrates time tracking with project tools for overtime budgeting, forecasting, and invoicing.
Captures billable and overtime hours with timers, reports, and invoicing for teams and freelancers.
QuickBooks Time
specializedTracks employee hours with GPS verification, automatic overtime calculations, and seamless payroll integrations.
Customizable overtime rules engine that auto-calculates pay rates and sends alerts before thresholds are exceeded
QuickBooks Time is a robust time tracking solution designed for businesses needing precise overtime management, automatically calculating overtime hours based on customizable rules like daily, weekly, or state-specific thresholds. It integrates seamlessly with QuickBooks Payroll for effortless overtime pay processing and offers mobile GPS tracking to verify employee hours and locations. Comprehensive reporting provides insights into overtime trends, helping managers control labor costs effectively.
Pros
- Automatic overtime calculation with customizable rules and real-time alerts
- Seamless integration with QuickBooks for payroll processing
- GPS-enabled mobile app for accurate time tracking on the go
Cons
- Higher cost for advanced features without QuickBooks ecosystem
- Initial setup of overtime rules can be complex for non-HR users
- Limited customization for highly unique overtime policies
Best For
Small to medium-sized businesses using QuickBooks that require automated, compliant overtime tracking integrated with payroll.
Pricing
Starts at $20/user/month for Premium (plus $8 base fee) and $40/user/month for Elite, with a free Solo plan for individuals; annual discounts available.
Hubstaff
specializedMonitors remote teams with screenshots, activity tracking, and customizable overtime rules and alerts.
Activity-level monitoring with timed screenshots that provide irrefutable proof of work during overtime periods
Hubstaff is a robust time tracking and employee monitoring platform designed for precise hour logging, including automatic overtime detection and calculation. It captures time through desktop, mobile, and web apps, supplemented by screenshots, activity levels (keystrokes and mouse movements), and GPS tracking for field workers. The software integrates with payroll systems to streamline overtime payments and offers customizable rules, reports, and alerts to ensure compliance with labor laws.
Pros
- Automatic overtime calculation with customizable rules and thresholds
- Activity screenshots and levels verify legitimate overtime work
- Seamless payroll integrations for quick overtime pay processing
Cons
- Screenshots and monitoring can raise privacy concerns among employees
- Full features require higher-tier plans, increasing costs
- Desktop app installation mandatory for accurate tracking
Best For
Remote or distributed teams requiring verifiable overtime tracking integrated with payroll to minimize disputes and ensure compliance.
Pricing
Free for 1 user; paid plans start at $7/user/month (Basic, billed annually) up to $12/user/month (Elite); add-ons for GPS and scheduling available.
Clockify
specializedProvides free unlimited time tracking for teams with detailed overtime reports and export options.
Unlimited free time tracking for teams of any size, with no caps on users or projects
Clockify is a robust time tracking application designed for teams and individuals to log work hours accurately using a one-click timer, manual entries, or integrations with calendars and project tools. It provides detailed reports and timesheets that make it straightforward to monitor total hours worked, categorize overtime, and export data for payroll or compliance. While not exclusively an overtime tool, its flexibility in tagging and reporting overtime hours positions it well for businesses needing precise hour logging beyond standard shifts.
Pros
- Unlimited free time tracking for any number of users and projects
- Intuitive one-click timer and mobile app for effortless logging
- Customizable reports and exports ideal for overtime analysis
Cons
- No automatic overtime pay rate calculations (requires manual setup)
- Advanced reporting and invoicing locked behind paid plans
- Limited built-in payroll integrations for direct overtime processing
Best For
Small teams, freelancers, and agencies tracking overtime hours on a budget without complex payroll needs.
Pricing
Free plan with unlimited tracking and basic reports; Pro at $3.99/user/month (annual) for unlimited projects, invoicing, and advanced features.
Toggl Track
specializedOffers simple one-click time tracking with overtime categorization and comprehensive reporting dashboards.
Visual Timeline view that provides a graphical breakdown of exact time usage throughout the day
Toggl Track is a versatile time tracking tool that enables users to log hours via timers, manual entries, or idle detection, making it suitable for monitoring total work time including overtime. It generates detailed reports on time spent per project, client, or task, helping teams identify excess hours worked beyond standard shifts. While not specialized in payroll calculations, it integrates with tools like QuickBooks for exporting data to compute overtime pay.
Pros
- Intuitive one-click timer for effortless start/stop tracking
- Comprehensive reports and visualizations for overtime analysis
- Cross-platform apps with offline support and idle detection
Cons
- Lacks built-in overtime pay calculations or labor law compliance
- Limited native integrations for direct payroll overtime processing
- Not optimized for shift-based employee scheduling or geofencing
Best For
Small teams and freelancers who need simple, accurate hour logging to manually track and review overtime.
Pricing
Free plan available; paid plans start at $9/user/month (Starter) and $18/user/month (Premium), billed annually.
Deputy
enterpriseCombines scheduling and time clocking with overtime forecasting, approvals, and labor compliance features.
Custom overtime rules engine that auto-calculates pay based on jurisdiction-specific thresholds and integrates directly with payroll systems
Deputy is a workforce management platform designed for shift-based businesses, offering robust time tracking and overtime management alongside scheduling and communication tools. It enables automatic overtime calculation based on customizable rules, real-time hour monitoring, and seamless payroll integrations to ensure compliance and cost control. Users can track employee hours via mobile clock-ins with GPS verification, generating detailed timesheets that highlight overtime accrual.
Pros
- Customizable overtime rules for automatic calculation and compliance with labor laws
- Real-time overtime alerts and forecasting to control labor costs
- GPS-enabled mobile time tracking for accurate clock-ins and geofencing
Cons
- Overtime features are bundled within broader scheduling tools, less specialized for pure time tracking
- Higher-tier plans required for advanced overtime reporting and integrations
- Pricing scales quickly for large teams with many active users
Best For
Shift-based businesses in retail, hospitality, or healthcare needing integrated overtime tracking with scheduling and payroll.
Pricing
Starts at $3.50 per active user/month (Essential plan), up to $5.25+ for Plus/Enterprise with custom options; billed monthly or annually.
When I Work
specializedManages shifts and tracks time punches with real-time overtime notifications and payroll exports.
Real-time overtime alerts that notify managers before shifts exceed limits
When I Work is a versatile employee scheduling and workforce management platform that includes time tracking capabilities to monitor hours worked, including overtime. It features a mobile time clock with GPS verification, shift swaps, and customizable reports for overtime analysis and payroll export. While primarily focused on scheduling, its overtime tools help businesses track compliance and costs effectively.
Pros
- Intuitive mobile app for easy clock-in/out with GPS and photo verification
- Automated overtime alerts and detailed hour reports for compliance
- Seamless integrations with payroll systems like QuickBooks for overtime processing
Cons
- Overtime tracking is secondary to scheduling; lacks advanced rule customization for complex scenarios
- Full overtime reporting requires premium plans starting at higher tiers
- Limited native support for multi-rate overtime without third-party integrations
Best For
Small to medium-sized businesses needing integrated scheduling with straightforward overtime tracking.
Pricing
Free for basic use; Premium starts at $2/user/month, Advanced at $3.50/user/month (billed annually).
Homebase
specializedDelivers free time tracking, scheduling, and overtime alerts for small business hourly teams.
Automatic labor law-compliant overtime tracking with manager alerts
Homebase is an all-in-one workforce management platform designed for hourly workers, offering robust time tracking with automatic overtime calculation based on local labor laws. It features mobile clock-in/out with geofencing to ensure accuracy, real-time overtime alerts to help managers stay compliant, and detailed reports for payroll processing. While strong in scheduling and communication, its overtime tools shine for small teams needing straightforward tracking without complex setups.
Pros
- Automatic overtime calculations compliant with state labor laws
- Real-time alerts to prevent overtime overruns
- Seamless integrations with payroll providers like Gusto and QuickBooks
Cons
- Advanced overtime reporting locked behind paid plans
- Geofencing limitations in poor GPS areas
- Less customizable for complex multi-state overtime rules
Best For
Small to medium businesses with hourly shift workers seeking affordable, user-friendly overtime tracking.
Pricing
Free basic plan; paid Essentials plan starts at $29.99/month per location (billed annually).
Time Doctor
specializedTracks productivity and time with automatic overtime detection, screenshots, and detailed timesheets.
Screenshot capture with OCR for proof-of-work verification, ensuring accurate overtime hour validation
Time Doctor is a robust time tracking and employee monitoring software designed to capture exact hours worked, including overtime, through automatic timers, screenshots, and activity tracking. It generates detailed reports on total hours, overtime thresholds, and productivity levels, making it suitable for compliance with labor regulations. The tool integrates with payroll systems to streamline overtime payments and offers alerts for exceeding set hour limits.
Pros
- Precise automatic time tracking with screenshots for overtime verification
- Customizable overtime alerts and detailed hourly reports
- Seamless payroll integrations for easy overtime processing
Cons
- Invasive monitoring features raise privacy concerns
- Steep learning curve for advanced reporting setup
- Pricing scales up quickly for larger teams
Best For
Remote or distributed teams requiring verifiable overtime tracking and productivity oversight.
Pricing
Starts at $7/user/month (Basic), $10/user/month (Standard), $20/user/month (Premium); billed annually with free trial.
Everhour
specializedIntegrates time tracking with project tools for overtime budgeting, forecasting, and invoicing.
Seamless native integrations with 50+ PM tools that auto-populate tasks for precise overtime-eligible time tracking.
Everhour is a comprehensive time tracking and management platform that integrates seamlessly with over 50 project management tools like Asana, Jira, and Trello. It enables precise time logging on tasks via timers or manual entry, generates detailed reports on hours worked, billable time, and budgets to help identify overtime trends. While versatile for productivity and invoicing, it supports overtime tracking through customizable timesheets, approvals, and overage alerts rather than automated payroll calculations.
Pros
- Deep integrations with PM tools for effortless task-based tracking
- Robust reporting and budget alerts to flag potential overtime
- Offline tracking and visual timeline for accurate hour logging
Cons
- Lacks built-in payroll integration or automatic overtime pay calculations
- Advanced reporting requires setup and may overwhelm beginners
- Per-user pricing scales quickly for larger teams
Best For
Project-based teams using tools like Asana or Jira who need to monitor task hours and detect overtime without full payroll features.
Pricing
Free for up to 5 users; Team plan $10/user/month ($8.50 annually); Business plan $20/user/month ($17 annually).
Harvest
specializedCaptures billable and overtime hours with timers, reports, and invoicing for teams and freelancers.
Cross-device timer synchronization that automatically continues sessions for accurate overtime logging
Harvest is a versatile time tracking and invoicing platform that enables users to log hours via timers, manual entry, or integrations across web, desktop, and mobile apps. It excels in project-based time management with robust reporting to analyze total hours, budgets, and overruns, which can be adapted for overtime monitoring through custom categories and alerts. While primarily geared toward billable hours for agencies and freelancers, it provides solid data for payroll overtime calculations when paired with external tools.
Pros
- Intuitive interface with seamless cross-device timers
- Powerful reporting and budget alerts for overtime detection
- Strong integrations with calendars, payroll, and project tools
Cons
- No native overtime pay rate calculations or multipliers
- Project-centric focus limits pure employee scheduling features
- Pricing scales quickly for larger teams without advanced HR tools
Best For
Small agencies and freelance teams tracking billable project hours while monitoring overtime via reports.
Pricing
Free for solo users (limited projects); Pro at $12/user/month (annual); Elite at $18/user/month with advanced reporting.
Conclusion
The review of 10 leading overtime tracking tools reveals a standout in QuickBooks Time, which excels with GPS verification, automatic calculations, and smooth payroll links. Close behind, Hubstaff impresses with remote team monitoring and customizable rules, while Clockify shines with free unlimited tracking and detailed reports for varied needs. Each tool offers unique strengths, but QuickBooks Time leads as the top choice for its well-rounded, hassle-free approach.
Take control of overtime management—start with QuickBooks Time to track hours accurately, simplify payroll, and focus on what matters most for your team's success. Whether you're a small business or a growing team, it delivers the tools you need to stay efficient and compliant.
Tools Reviewed
All tools were independently evaluated for this comparison
