GITNUXSOFTWARE ADVICE
HR In IndustryTop 10 Best Online Employee Schedule Software of 2026
Top 10 ranking of online employee schedule software for managers, including Connecteam, When I Work, and Deputy with tradeoffs and pricing notes.
How we ranked these tools
Core product claims cross-referenced against official documentation, changelogs, and independent technical reviews.
Analyzed video reviews and hundreds of written evaluations to capture real-world user experiences with each tool.
AI persona simulations modeled how different user types would experience each tool across common use cases and workflows.
Final rankings reviewed and approved by our editorial team with authority to override AI-generated scores based on domain expertise.
Score: Features 40% · Ease 30% · Value 30%
Gitnux may earn a commission through links on this page — this does not influence rankings. Editorial policy
Connecteam is the best pick when deskless teams need scheduling tied to attendance, tasks, and internal updates in one mobile workspace, whereas When I Work works best for multi-location managers who plan shifts and message staff on the go, and if you’re budget-tight, Planday is the controlled-approval rota fit.
Editor’s top 3 picks
Three quick recommendations before you dive into the full comparison below — each one leads on a different dimension.
Connecteam
Operations Hub links roster management with time clocks, forms, checklists, tasks, and employee communication.
Built for fits when deskless teams need scheduling, attendance, tasks, and communication in one mobile workspace..
When I Work
Editor pickSchedule-linked team messaging keeps shift announcements, employee replies, and manager updates beside the relevant work schedule.
Built for fits when multi-location managers need mobile scheduling, attendance tracking, and direct staff communication..
Deputy
Editor pickDeputy’s demand-aware auto-scheduling engine builds shifts around labor targets, employee availability, qualifications, and forecast demand.
Built for fits when multi-location managers need scheduling, attendance capture, and payroll integration in one system..
Comparison Table
Connecteam
SMBWorkforce app with scheduling, time tracking, task management, and internal communication.
Operations Hub links roster management with time clocks, forms, checklists, tasks, and employee communication.
Managers can build schedules from recurring patterns, assign locations and roles, publish changes, and review employee availability in one workspace. Employees view assignments, request schedule changes, and receive updates through the mobile app. Permission controls let owners separate manager access by team or location.
Connecteam ties attendance records to GPS restrictions, job notes, checklists, forms, and payroll exports. The tradeoff is breadth because teams needing advanced demand modeling, intricate union rules, or deep enterprise API governance may need another workforce system.
- +Scheduling, time tracking, forms, and communication share one employee app.
- +Location restrictions support attendance verification.
- +Recurring schedule patterns reduce repeated manual entry.
- +Built-in task and checklist workflows extend beyond roster management.
- –Advanced labor forecasting is less developed than in specialist workforce suites.
- –Payroll connectivity depends on supported providers and export workflows.
- –Large organizations may need more granular administrative structures.
Field service managers
Multi-site service visits
Fewer disconnected work apps
Restaurant operators
Location-based attendance
Cleaner attendance records
Show 1 more scenario
Small business owners
Recurring weekly rosters
Faster weekly publishing
Saved schedule patterns reduce repeated entry while employees receive mobile changes and requests.
Best for: Fits when deskless teams need scheduling, attendance, tasks, and communication in one mobile workspace.
When I Work
SMBOnline employee scheduling software focused on shift planning, attendance, and team messaging.
Schedule-linked team messaging keeps shift announcements, employee replies, and manager updates beside the relevant work schedule.
When I Work gives restaurants, retailers, healthcare teams, and service businesses a visual drag-and-drop schedule builder with recurring templates and mobile access. Employees can view shifts, submit availability, claim open work, request swaps, and communicate with managers from the mobile application. Managers can compare scheduled hours with clocked time and review attendance activity from the same account.
The product has less depth for organizations needing advanced labor forecasting, complex union rules, or detailed demand-driven scheduling. It fits multi-location operators that need managers to publish schedules quickly and keep shift changes visible to hourly staff. API access and integrations with payroll and POS systems support custom data flows, but complex governance still requires careful configuration.
- +Schedule changes reach employees through mobile notifications and in-app messaging
- +Recurring schedule templates reduce repetitive manager work
- +Integrated time clock connects planned shifts with recorded attendance
- +API and payroll integrations support external workforce data flows
- –Advanced labor forecasting is less developed than in enterprise workforce suites
- –Complex compliance policies may require manual configuration
- –Reporting depth may be limited for organizations with intricate labor structures
Multi-location restaurant managers
Publish weekly schedules across locations
Fewer missed schedule updates
Retail store supervisors
Coordinate availability and shift changes
Faster shift coordination
Show 1 more scenario
Service business operators
Connect schedules with payroll
Less duplicate data entry
Time-clock records and schedule data can flow into payroll systems through supported integrations and API connections.
Best for: Fits when multi-location managers need mobile scheduling, attendance tracking, and direct staff communication.
Deputy
SMBEmployee scheduling software with time tracking, shift planning, and labor compliance tools.
Deputy’s demand-aware auto-scheduling engine builds shifts around labor targets, employee availability, qualifications, and forecast demand.
Deputy connects schedule creation with clock-in records, leave approvals, compliance settings, and payroll exports. Employees can view shifts, submit availability, request leave through a time-off request workflow, and use mobile shift swapping. Built-in connectors cover payroll, POS, HR, and accounting systems, while a public API supports custom integrations.
The broad feature set requires careful configuration for different locations, roles, pay rules, and approval permissions. Deputy fits retail and hospitality groups that need one operational record linking planned hours with recorded attendance across multiple sites.
- +Payroll, POS, and HR integrations reduce duplicate employee and hours records.
- +Mobile apps support schedule access, leave requests, and shift changes.
- +Time tracking connects scheduled hours with actual attendance data.
- +Public API supports custom integrations beyond built-in payroll and POS connectors.
- –Complex rule sets require careful configuration across locations and employment types.
- –Demand forecasts depend on clean historical and operational inputs.
- –Custom reporting may require exported data and external analysis.
Multi-location retail managers
Weekly rosters across stores
Consistent multi-site staffing
Hospitality operations teams
Variable demand coverage
Closer staffing-to-demand alignment
Show 1 more scenario
Franchise administrators
Centralized workforce oversight
More consistent operating controls
Regional administrators can connect site-level schedules, attendance data, approvals, and payroll exports through shared controls.
Best for: Fits when multi-location managers need scheduling, attendance capture, and payroll integration in one system.
Homebase
SMBScheduling, time clocks, hiring, and payroll tools for hourly teams.
Shift swap requests route through manager approval inside the scheduling workflow, not via separate messaging.
Homebase brings online employee scheduling with built-in shift management and manager approval workflows aimed at reducing manual schedule changes. It supports employee self-service for availability, shift swaps, and time-off request handling while keeping schedule publishing and change notifications within one operational flow.
Homebase also connects scheduling to workforce operations by tying shifts to labor tracking workflows that show up in day-to-day shift edits and staffing decisions. For teams that want to run schedule updates with fewer back-and-forth messages, the core value comes from how quickly changes can move from manager review to employee view.
- +Shift swapping workflow keeps employee requests inside the schedule tool
- +Time-off request handling reduces off-schedule email coordination
- +Mobile-first schedule viewing supports same-day staff changes
- +Schedule change notifications keep employees aligned after edits
- –Advanced coverage rules and schedule fairness controls feel limited
- –Complex approval chains can require extra manager steps
- –Labor forecasting depth does not match enterprise scheduling suites
- –API extensibility is not as visible as scheduling-heavy competitors
Best for: Fits when managers need self-service availability and controlled shift changes with clear notifications.
Planday
SMBStaff scheduling platform with rotas, time tracking, and communication features.
Manager approval plus schedule publication flow that routes shift and time-off changes through a governed workflow before release.
Planday publishes employee schedules with a drag-and-drop builder and shift templates that reduce manual rework. The system supports approvals and time-off request workflows, including employee self-service availability and schedule browsing from mobile.
Scheduling decisions connect to labor cost views for day-level planning and to coverage checks that flag conflicts before publication. Integration options include payroll and time clock connectors so schedule data can flow into downstream processes.
- +Drag-and-drop schedule builder speeds weekly schedule edits
- +Shift templates and recurring patterns reduce repeated planning work
- +Manager approval workflow keeps changes controlled before publish
- +Coverage conflict detection highlights issues before schedule release
- –Advanced automation setups require careful configuration of rules and templates
- –Shift swap workflows can feel rigid when coverage rules are complex
- –Bulk schedule changes are available but may require multiple steps
- –Some integrations depend on specific connector availability per system
Best for: Fits when multi-location teams need controlled approvals and template-driven scheduling with conflict checks.
7shifts
vertical specialistRestaurant team scheduling software with labor tools, forecasting, and team communication.
Manager approval gates around employee shift swaps and time-off requests, with change notifications tied to the publishing workflow.
7shifts is an employee scheduling system for multi-location and hourly operations that rely on published rosters and tight shift change control. It supports schedule building with recurring shift templates, manager approvals, and employee self-service actions like swap requests and time-off requests.
Admin tooling focuses on role-based access and store-level governance so managers can act without broad account control. Automation features center on schedule publishing workflows and notifications for changes that affect staffing coverage.
- +Recurring templates speed up repeat weekly roster creation
- +Approval workflows add control over swap and time-off requests
- +Store-level operations fit multi-location scheduling teams
- +Employee mobile access supports shift updates away from the manager desk
- –Advanced labor forecasting and cost modeling are limited compared with top tier tools
- –Open-shift claiming and bidding workflows can require extra configuration effort
- –Coverage-rule complexity is less granular than systems built for complex unions
- –Third-party integration coverage is narrower than broader workforce-management suites
Best for: Fits when multi-location hourly teams need repeatable schedule templates plus controlled shift change workflows.
Shiftboard
enterpriseWorkforce scheduling software for complex shift operations and compliance-heavy environments.
Shiftboard’s approval-gated publication workflow coordinates manager review with employee-facing schedule updates to reduce churn.
Shiftboard targets roster management with a focus on meeting operational needs like schedule change notifications, shift swapping workflows, and manager approvals. It supports recurring shift templates and coverage-rule based building so schedules can be published and adjusted with less manual rework.
Automation features cover common workflows such as availability management and time-off request handling tied to staffing gaps. Admin governance centers on controlling who can publish, approve changes, and enforce consistent schedule behaviors.
- +Shift swapping and open shift claiming flows reduce manager back-and-forth
- +Recurring shift templates speed recurring schedule patterns and training rotations
- +Schedule change notifications keep employees and managers aligned on updates
- +Manager approval gates help enforce schedule adherence before publication
- –Complex coverage rules can require careful setup to avoid unintended gaps
- –Automation coverage depends on configured workflows rather than full out-of-box demand modeling
- –Advanced constraints can add steps when handling edge-case labor rules
- –Admin governance is strong but can feel dense for smaller teams
Best for: Fits when mid-size to enterprise teams need approval-gated scheduling workflows with shift swap and notification controls.
ZoomShift
SMBOnline employee scheduling software with time-off management and shift reminders.
Approval-based schedule publishing with configurable notifications for shift changes.
ZoomShift is an online employee schedule solution built around manager workflows like schedule publishing and change management, not just shift templates. It supports common shift operations such as swapping and recurring schedules, plus coverage checks that reduce gaps when labor demand changes. Admin controls and integrations with time clock and payroll systems connect schedules to downstream reporting instead of keeping scheduling data isolated.
- +Schedule change notifications keep teams aligned after approvals
- +Recurring shift templates reduce setup time for repeat weeks
- +Shift swapping workflow supports self-service by employees
- +Integrations connect schedules to time clock and payroll data
- –Coverage rules are less granular than enterprise labor compliance suites
- –Managing many locations can require extra role discipline and review steps
- –Advanced fairness and schedule adherence policies may need process workarounds
- –Reporting for schedule changes is workable but not as deep as dedicated analytics tools
Best for: Fits when multi-location managers need shift templates, approvals, and downstream time tracking connections.
Findmyshift
SMBEmployee rota software for scheduling shifts, tracking attendance, and managing leave.
Swap workflow ties employee shift change requests to manager approval and live schedule updates in the same calendar view.
Findmyshift publishes shift schedules through a drag-and-drop calendar workflow and employee self-service pages for viewing assignments. It supports shift swapping and open shift claiming so employees can request coverage without a manager rebuilding schedules from scratch.
The admin side centers on approval steps, recurring schedule templates, and schedule change notifications tied to update events. It also provides reporting for schedule adherence and labor coverage patterns to support day-to-day staffing decisions.
- +Drag-and-drop schedule builder reduces time spent on manual edits.
- +Shift swapping and open shift claiming support real-time coverage requests.
- +Recurring schedule templates cut rework for repeating weekly patterns.
- +Schedule notifications keep managers and staff informed after edits.
- –Labor forecasting and cost projection controls are less granular than top-tier schedulers.
- –Advanced rules for edge cases like minor labor constraints need careful configuration.
- –POS integration and payroll integration coverage can be limited depending on stack.
- –Audit logging depth for every schedule change is harder to validate in daily operations.
Best for: Fits when managers need a calendar-first scheduling workflow plus staff coverage swaps and approvals.
PioneerWorks
SMBEmployee scheduling and labor management software for hourly workforces.
Approval-oriented scheduling publication keeps changes gated by managers instead of relying on self-service edits.
PioneerWorks fits organizations that need scheduling support tied to operational programs rather than only shift templates. It offers an online employee schedule workflow with shift assignment, manager review, and schedule publication to keep staffing visible for teams.
The tool supports recurring scheduling patterns for repeatable staffing needs and manages schedule changes through an approval-oriented process. PioneerWorks also focuses on operational administration so changes and access stay controlled for managers and staff.
- +Manager-first scheduling flow supports approval before schedule publication
- +Recurring scheduling templates reduce repetitive manual shift entry
- +Staff can view published schedules from a centralized online workspace
- +Schedule change handling fits teams that require managed updates
- –Limited evidence of deep labor forecasting and schedule adherence analytics
- –Shift swap and open claiming workflows are not a primary strength
- –Integration breadth for time clock, payroll, and POS is unclear
- –Setup for policies and roles requires careful admin configuration discipline
Best for: Fits when program-based staffing needs recurring schedules with manager approval and controlled updates.
Conclusion
After evaluating 10 hr in industry, Connecteam stands out as our overall top pick — it scored highest across our combined criteria of features, ease of use, and value, which is why it sits at #1 in the rankings above.
Use the comparison table and detailed reviews above to validate the fit against your own requirements before committing to a tool.
How to Choose the Right online employee schedule software
Online employee schedule software centralizes shift creation, employee shift access, and change workflows so managers can publish schedules with controlled approvals. This guide covers Connecteam, When I Work, Deputy, Homebase, Planday, 7shifts, Shiftboard, ZoomShift, Findmyshift, and PioneerWorks, and each tool review focuses on the scheduling workflow mechanics.
Connecteam connects roster management with time clocks, forms, checklists, and employee communication in one mobile workspace. When I Work adds schedule-linked team messaging, Deputy adds demand-aware auto-scheduling tied to labor targets and availability, and Homebase routes shift swaps through manager approval inside the scheduling workflow.
Online employee schedule software for publishing shift calendars with swaps, approvals, and schedule-linked notifications
Online employee schedule software is a scheduling system that lets managers build shift templates, publish schedules to mobile or staff-facing views, and run shift change workflows with approvals and notifications. These workflows typically include employee time-off request handling, shift swapping, and open shift claiming that updates a live schedule view.
Deputy is built around demand-aware auto-scheduling that generates shifts from labor targets, employee availability, qualifications, and forecast demand. Planday emphasizes drag-and-drop weekly schedule edits with a manager approval plus schedule publication flow that routes shift and time-off changes through a governed workflow before release.
Evaluation focus: governed schedule edits, notifications, and attendance-linked workflows
Online employee schedule software changes daily work through two control points. First, it governs how schedules get built and published. Second, it routes shift changes, swaps, and time-off handling so teams receive the right updates tied to the correct work shifts.
This guide prioritizes tools where schedule edits and approvals stay inside the scheduling workflow. It also favors products that connect scheduling to attendance or labor signals through named integrations or mobile operations workflows, since those reduce duplicate data entry and mismatch errors.
Schedule change governance with manager approval gates
Planday routes shift and time-off changes through a manager approval plus schedule publication flow before release. Shiftboard and ZoomShift both coordinate manager review with employee-facing updates using an approval-gated publication workflow.
Operational workflows that connect scheduling to time tracking and field execution
Connecteam links roster management with time clocks, forms, checklists, and employee communication in one mobile workspace. Deputy couples scheduling with payroll, POS, and HR integrations so hours and employee records stay aligned.
Shift swapping and time-off request routing inside the scheduling tool
Homebase routes shift swap requests through manager approval inside the scheduling workflow rather than separate messaging. 7shifts uses approval gates around employee shift swaps and time-off requests with change notifications tied to the publishing workflow.
Recurring schedule templates and drag-and-drop editing for repeat weeks
7shifts accelerates weekly roster creation using recurring templates. Planday pairs a drag-and-drop schedule builder with shift templates and recurring patterns for faster weekly edits.
Demand and availability planning that supports labor targeting
Deputy uses a demand-aware auto-scheduling engine that builds shifts around labor targets, employee availability, and forecast demand. Connecteam and When I Work support scheduling and attendance workflows, but advanced labor forecasting is less developed than in specialist workforce suites.
Multi-location controls for rules, notifications, and configuration consistency
Deputy supports multi-location managers by combining mobile schedule access with integrations for payroll and POS. When I Work targets multi-location managers with recurring schedule templates and schedule-linked team messaging, but complex compliance policies can require manual configuration.
How to choose: approval model, automation surface, and integration depth for scheduling workflows
The first fork should match how schedule changes get approved in day-to-day operations. If manager sign-off must happen before employees see new shifts, choose a tool with a schedule publication flow that gates employee updates, like Planday or Shiftboard.
The second fork should match how much the system should generate or recommend shifts. If labor targeting and demand-aware generation matter, choose Deputy with its demand-aware auto-scheduling engine, and if a lightweight workflow is enough, choose tools centered on mobile scheduling plus communication and workflow routing like When I Work or Homebase.
Match the approval model to how teams actually publish schedules
Planday and Shiftboard run schedule and change through an approval-plus-publication workflow so shift and time-off updates release only after manager review. Homebase and 7shifts also gate shift swaps and time-off requests with manager approval, but they emphasize routing inside the scheduling tool rather than a publication-first coordination flow.
Decide whether scheduling should be generated from labor signals
Deputy builds shifts from labor targets, employee availability, and forecast demand using its demand-aware auto-scheduling engine. Connecteam and When I Work focus more on scheduling execution and communication workflows than on advanced labor forecasting depth.
Pick the mobile workflow that staff can follow on the floor
Connecteam combines scheduling access with time clocks, forms, checklists, and employee communication in one mobile workspace, which reduces task sprawl. When I Work keeps schedule-linked team messaging alongside relevant shift updates so employees can reply and managers can respond in context.
Validate how shift swaps and open shifts get handled under coverage rules
Homebase routes shift swapping through manager approval inside the scheduling workflow, which keeps swap activity tied to the schedule view. Shiftboard supports shift swapping and open shift claiming flows, but coverage rules can require careful setup to avoid unintended gaps.
Check multi-location configuration complexity against real staffing patterns
Deputy can handle multi-location scheduling tied to qualifications and rules, but complex rule sets require careful configuration across locations and employment types. When I Work and ZoomShift support multi-location managers with templates and approvals, but they can require role discipline and additional review steps when locations scale.
Assess the labor and cost controls needed for forecasting-heavy operations
If forecasting and cost modeling are part of daily planning, Deputy’s demand-aware engine is the clearest fit among these tools. 7shifts and Findmyshift have limited labor forecasting and cost projection controls compared with top-tier schedulers.
Who needs this category of online employee schedule software
Managers need online employee schedule software when shifts change frequently and the organization must control who can publish edits, swaps, and time-off updates. The right tool depends on whether the schedule must be coordinated through manager approvals and whether scheduling decisions depend on demand and availability signals.
Scheduling also needs to match how deskless teams interact with shift changes. Tools like Connecteam and When I Work focus on mobile workflows and schedule-linked communications, while Deputy and Planday focus more on automated planning and governed publication flows.
Multi-location retail and service managers coordinating rosters and attendance
When I Work supports multi-location mobile scheduling with schedule-linked team messaging and recurring schedule templates. Deputy extends that need with payroll, POS, and HR integrations plus demand-aware auto-scheduling tied to availability.
Workforces that require structured shift swapping and controlled time-off routing
Homebase routes shift swap requests through manager approval inside the scheduling workflow and reduces off-schedule email coordination for time-off. 7shifts and Shiftboard add manager approval gates tied to publishing and notification workflows.
Teams where staff execution and scheduling must live in one mobile app
Connecteam links roster management with time clocks, forms, checklists, and employee communication in one mobile workspace. This reduces friction when shift edits and operational updates must reach staff in the same place.
Organizations using templates and recurring patterns to reduce weekly planning effort
7shifts uses recurring templates to speed repeat weekly roster creation. Planday pairs recurring shift templates with drag-and-drop weekly edits and a governed approval publication flow.
Operations that depend on demand-aware planning to align labor targets with forecasts
Deputy generates shifts from labor targets, employee availability, qualifications, and forecast demand using its auto-scheduling engine. Tools like ZoomShift and Findmyshift can publish approved schedules, but they provide less granular coverage for forecasting-driven decisioning.
Common mistakes when buying online employee schedule software
Many buying errors come from mismatch between how managers approve changes and how employees receive published updates. Another common mistake is selecting a system that looks good for schedule editing but lacks the labor signals or automation depth needed for planning workflows.
These pitfalls show up in real configuration and adoption issues, including brittle coverage rules and labor data quality gaps that break demand-aware planning.
Choosing a schedule editor without a publication gate for employee-facing changes
Planday and Shiftboard route shift and time-off changes through a governed manager approval plus schedule publication workflow. Tools like PioneerWorks also keep changes gated by managers, while Findmyshift ties swaps to live schedule updates that can increase the need for tight governance.
Expecting advanced labor forecasting from tools that focus more on workflow execution
Connecteam and When I Work use scheduling and communication workflows, but advanced labor forecasting is less developed than specialist workforce suites. 7shifts and Findmyshift also have limited labor forecasting and cost modeling compared with top-tier schedulers.
Overlooking configuration complexity for multi-location rules and employment types
Deputy can require careful configuration because complex rule sets must be defined across locations and employment types. Shiftboard notes that complex coverage rules can require careful setup to avoid unintended gaps.
Failing to prepare clean inputs when using demand-aware auto-scheduling
Deputy’s demand forecasts depend on clean historical and operational inputs, so missing or inconsistent labor history can degrade generation quality. Deputy’s auto-scheduling also depends on employee availability and qualifications, so stale availability records create coverage mismatches.
Treating recurring templates as a substitute for approval discipline
7shifts and Shiftboard use recurring templates to reduce planning effort, but they still rely on approval workflows for swaps and time-off requests. ZoomShift also uses approval-based schedule publishing, so governance still needs process owners to avoid change churn.
How We Selected and Ranked These Tools
We evaluated Connecteam, When I Work, Deputy, Homebase, Planday, 7shifts, Shiftboard, ZoomShift, Findmyshift, and PioneerWorks on scheduling workflow coverage, change governance, and how scheduling connects to operational signals. Features counted for 40% of the score because scheduling editors, template systems, swap and time-off routing, and approval-plus-notification mechanics drive day-to-day throughput.
Ease and value each counted for 30% because manager configuration complexity and workflow friction affect adoption and reduce schedule errors. Connecteam ranked first because scheduling, time clocks, forms, checklists, and employee communication share one mobile workspace with location restrictions for attendance verification.
Frequently Asked Questions About online employee schedule software
How do managers keep schedules and time-clock records aligned across When I Work and Deputy?
Which platforms handle shift swaps and open shift claiming with built-in approvals rather than side-channel messaging?
What breaks if shift publishing notifications are not configured for multi-location managers using Shiftboard and ZoomShift?
How do availability and time-off request workflows differ between Planday and Connecteam?
When demand-driven scheduling is required, where does Deputy fall short compared with manual-template builders like Planday?
How do integrations and APIs affect rollout for Connecteam versus When I Work when scheduling data must reach payroll and POS systems?
What admin controls matter most for role separation in 7shifts compared with Shiftboard?
How does schedule conflict detection show up in Planday versus Findmyshift during coverage planning?
When employees need mobile self-service for viewing and making shift changes, how do Findmyshift and Homebase differ?
Tools reviewed
Primary sources checked during evaluation.
Referenced in the comparison table and product reviews above.
Keep exploring
Comparing two specific tools?
Software Alternatives
See head-to-head software comparisons with feature breakdowns, pricing, and our recommendation for each use case.
Explore software alternatives→In this category
HR In Industry alternatives
See side-by-side comparisons of hr in industry tools and pick the right one for your stack.
Compare hr in industry tools→