Imagine being too poor to purchase your freedom, a reality for the 71% of America’s jail population who are locked up pretrial simply because they cannot afford bail.
Key Takeaways
- In 2021, approximately 429,000 people were held in jail pretrial nationwide, representing 71% of the total jail population
- Across the U.S. in 2019, 82% of people held in jail pretrial could not afford bail of $5,000 or less
- In Harris County, Texas (2017-2019), 85% of misdemeanor defendants had bail set above what they could afford, resulting in pretrial detention for those unable to pay
- The median bail amount for all charges in U.S. courts was $10,000 in 2017
- In New York City (2019 pre-reform), median bail for nonviolent felonies was $15,000
- Harris County, TX (2018), average bail for misdemeanors $2,500, felonies $25,000
- In 2019, Black defendants received bail amounts 35% higher than white defendants for similar charges nationally
- In Harris County, TX (2017-2019), Black individuals had 20% higher bail set than whites for misdemeanors
- Los Angeles County (2020), Latinos comprised 60% of pretrial detainees despite 40% population share, due to bail disparities
- In New Jersey post-reform (2018), Black failure-to-appear rates 10% higher despite equal release
- Harris County, TX (2019), 18% of released on bail failed to appear in court
- Los Angeles (2020), rearrest rate for pretrial releasees 12% within 30 days
- In New Jersey, pretrial jail population fell 44% after 2017 reform eliminating cash bail
- New York 2019 bail reform reduced jail population by 50% initially, but rose 20% after 2020 rollback
- Harris County personal bond program (2017+) reduced population 25%, no crime spike
Bail systems nationwide detain thousands who cannot afford even low payments.
Bail Reform Outcomes
- In New Jersey, pretrial jail population fell 44% after 2017 reform eliminating cash bail
- New York 2019 bail reform reduced jail population by 50% initially, but rose 20% after 2020 rollback
- Harris County personal bond program (2017+) reduced population 25%, no crime spike
- Philadelphia Eliminate Cash Bail (2021) cut pretrial pop 40%, recidivism unchanged
- Kentucky PSA tool (2011) reduced failures-to-appear by 20%
- Cook County Cite/Release (2017) diverted 20,000 from jail annually
- D.C. non-cash system (ongoing) keeps detention under 15%, lowest U.S.
- Virginia 2021 reform: pretrial pop down 15%, Black disparities reduced 10%
- Multnomah County OR (2017) reform: 30% pop drop, rearrests same
- Bernalillo NM (2016) risk assessment: 35% fewer detentions
- Lucas OH (2020) no cash for misdems: detention halved, FTAs stable
- Broward FL pilots (2021): supervised release cut costs 50%
- Maricopa AZ Clean Slate (2016): diversions up 300%
- Los Angeles (2020) zero-bail for low-level: 10k fewer bookings
- NYC discovery reform (2019): cases resolved 20% faster
- Nationwide Vera (2022): reforms in 20 jurisdictions cut pop 25% avg
- Houston ankle monitors (2019): 90% compliance, pop down 15%
- Arizona pretrial services expansion (2021): releases up 18%
- Kentucky statewide (2022): reform sustained 40% pop reduction
Bail Reform Outcomes Interpretation
The data clearly suggests that well-designed bail reforms, from New Jersey to Kentucky, consistently shrink jail populations without compromising public safety, proving we can indeed incarcerate fewer people and still keep our communities secure.
Demographic Impacts
- In 2019, Black defendants received bail amounts 35% higher than white defendants for similar charges nationally
- In Harris County, TX (2017-2019), Black individuals had 20% higher bail set than whites for misdemeanors
- Los Angeles County (2020), Latinos comprised 60% of pretrial detainees despite 40% population share, due to bail disparities
- Cook County, IL (2016 study), Black defendants detained pretrial at 4x rate of whites
- New York City (2019), Black and Latino defendants had median bails $2,000 higher than whites
- Maricopa County, AZ (2018), Native Americans received 15% higher bails for DUIs
- Philadelphia (2020), women of color 50% more likely detained pretrial than white men
- Broward County, FL (2019), Black males had bail 25% higher for drug possession
- Kentucky (2012-2016), rural poor whites saw higher detention but urban Blacks 2x rate
- Bernalillo County, NM (2018), Hispanic defendants 30% more likely unable to post bail < $5k
- Lucas County, OH (2021), Black youth pretrial detention 3x white youth
- Houston (2019), indigent Blacks 85% of those jailed on $500 bonds
- D.C. (2021), despite no cash bail, Black defendants 2x more likely risk-assessed as high
- Virginia (2022), low-income women 40% of pretrial detainees
- Multnomah County, OR (2020), Native populations 5x pretrial detention rate
- Arizona (2021), Latino defendants bail 18% higher controlling for charge
- Nationwide BJS (2011), Black pretrial detention rate 25% vs 15% white
- NYC (2018), Asian defendants lowest detention (10%), Blacks highest (30%)
Demographic Impacts Interpretation
Across the nation, the color of your skin and the cash in your pocket remain the most reliable predictors of whether you'll await trial in a cell or at home, turning our promise of equal justice into a cynical arithmetic of inequality.
Financial Bail Amounts
- The median bail amount for all charges in U.S. courts was $10,000 in 2017
- In New York City (2019 pre-reform), median bail for nonviolent felonies was $15,000
- Harris County, TX (2018), average bail for misdemeanors $2,500, felonies $25,000
- Los Angeles (2020), median bail $50,000 for violent felonies, $5,000 misdemeanors
- Cook County, IL (2017), 85% of bails set between $1-$50,000, median $10,000
- Maricopa County, AZ (2019), average property crime bail $8,000
- Broward County, FL (2021), median DUI bail $1,000, felony assault $15,000
- Philadelphia (2018), average bail $25,000 for drug felonies
- New Jersey pre-reform (2016), median bail $20,000 statewide
- Kentucky (2011), average bail reduced 25% post-reform to $7,500 median
- Bernalillo County, NM (2017), misdemeanor bails averaged $1,200
- Lucas County, OH (2020), typical theft bail $2,500
- Houston (2019), Class C misdemeanor bail often $500 but 40% couldn't pay
- D.C. (no cash bail), equivalent risk-based holds replace $10k+ bails (2021 est.)
- Virginia (2022), average bail for misdemeanors $2,000 post-reform
- Multnomah County, OR (2019), felony drug bail median $10,000
- Arizona statewide (2021), average bail $15,000 for felonies
- Nationwide (2011 BJS), 50% of felony bails over $10,000
- NYC (2018), burglary bail averaged $25,000
Financial Bail Amounts Interpretation
The statistics reveal a grim truth: across America, justice isn't just blindfolded, it's often holding a price tag, with freedom routinely costing thousands of dollars whether you're guilty of a felony or just too poor to pay for your pretrial release.
Pretrial Detention Rates
- In 2021, approximately 429,000 people were held in jail pretrial nationwide, representing 71% of the total jail population
- Across the U.S. in 2019, 82% of people held in jail pretrial could not afford bail of $5,000 or less
- In Harris County, Texas (2017-2019), 85% of misdemeanor defendants had bail set above what they could afford, resulting in pretrial detention for those unable to pay
- Nationally in 2018, Black individuals were detained pretrial at a rate 3.6 times higher than white individuals due to inability to post bail
- In Los Angeles County (2020), 62% of the jail population was unconvicted pretrial detainees unable to post bail
- Kentucky's 2011 bail reform saw pretrial detention rates drop by 30% after risk-based assessments replaced cash bail for many
- In 2022, Philadelphia's jail pretrial population decreased by 45% post-bail reform, from 4,500 to 2,500
- Maricopa County, AZ (2016), 40% of pretrial detainees had bail set under $1,000 but still couldn't pay
- Nationwide (2009-2019), pretrial jail population grew 20% despite falling crime rates, driven by unaffordable bail
- In Cook County, IL (2017), 75% of pretrial detainees were held on bonds under $10,000
- New Jersey's 2017 bail reform reduced pretrial jail population by 44% within two years
- In 2020, 536,000 individuals were confined pretrial, costing states $14 billion annually
- Broward County, FL (2018), 89% of pretrial releases required cash bail, leading to high detention rates
- Washington D.C. (2019) had only 10% pretrial detention rate using risk assessments without cash bail
- In 2015, 456,000 people held pretrial, up from 1996 levels despite crime drop
- Lucas County, OH (2021), pretrial detention rate fell 50% after eliminating cash bail for misdemeanors
- Nationally, 62% of felony defendants receive bail but 25% remain detained unable to pay (2011)
- In Arizona (2022), 70% of jail population pretrial, mostly low-level offenses with high bails
- Kentucky pretrial detention dropped from 35% to 22% post-reform (2012-2016)
- In 2019, U.S. pretrial detainees averaged 23 days in jail before case resolution
- Bernalillo County, NM (2016-2020), pretrial population reduced 39% via reform
- Nationwide (2020), COVID-related releases cut pretrial pop by 25% temporarily
- In 2017, 74% of state prisoners began as pretrial detainees unable to post bail
- Houston (2019), 25% of pretrial detainees held over 30 days on bails under $5,000
- D.C. Superior Court (2021), pretrial detention rate under 15% with no cash bail system
- In 2011, 60% of pretrial felony defendants detained for financial reasons
- Virginia's 2021 reform led to 20% drop in pretrial jail population by mid-2022
- Multnomah County, OR (2018), 50% pretrial detention rate pre-reform
- Nationwide, pretrial jail stays average 25 days, costing $13M/day (2019)
Pretrial Detention Rates Interpretation
The American bail system functions as a debtor's prison for the poor, a multi-billion dollar industry that incarcerates people for their poverty while statistically proving it can be safely and drastically reduced.
Pretrial Misconduct
- In New Jersey post-reform (2018), Black failure-to-appear rates 10% higher despite equal release
- Harris County, TX (2019), 18% of released on bail failed to appear in court
- Los Angeles (2020), rearrest rate for pretrial releasees 12% within 30 days
- Cook County (2017 reform), FTA rate dropped to 13% from 18%
- Philadelphia (2021), 15% rearrest rate for non-cash releases, similar to cash bail
- Maricopa County (2019), 20% FTA for low-bail releases
- Broward County (2020), 10% rearrest within 8 months for released defendants
- New York post-reform (2020), discovery reform led to 5% FTA increase initially
- Kentucky (2016), supervised release FTA 9%, vs 15% unsecured bond
- Bernalillo County (2020), rearrest rate 8% for risk-released
- Lucas County (2021), FTA rate 12% post-reform, no increase
- Houston (2019), 22% FTA for personal bond releases
- D.C. (2021), 11% rearrest rate pretrial, lowest nationally
- Virginia (2022), 14% FTA statewide average
- Multnomah County (2020), new releases saw 7% rearrest vs 9% prior
- Arizona (2021), 16% FTA for felony bails under $10k
- Nationwide (2019 PPI), 28% of released rearrested pretrial
- NYC (2021), supervised release FTA 17%, cash bail 13%
- New Jersey (2022), overall FTA rate stable at 13% post-reform
Pretrial Misconduct Interpretation
These statistics collectively show that while bail reforms haven't created a crime wave, they've traded one imperfect system—where freedom often depended on cash—for another, where ensuring court appearance and public safety remains a stubbornly complex and unequal challenge, with outcomes varying wildly by jurisdiction.
Sources & References
- Reference 1PRISONPOLICYprisonpolicy.orgVisit source
- Reference 2TEXASTRIBUNEtexastribune.orgVisit source
- Reference 3SENTENCINGPROJECTsentencingproject.orgVisit source
- Reference 4LACOUNTYlacounty.govVisit source
- Reference 5PRETRIALpretrial.orgVisit source
- Reference 6PHILAphila.govVisit source
- Reference 7MARICOPAmaricopa.govVisit source
- Reference 8VERAvera.orgVisit source
- Reference 9CHICAGOTRIBUNEchicagotribune.comVisit source
- Reference 10ACLU-NJaclu-nj.orgVisit source
- Reference 11MIAMIDADEmiamidade.govVisit source
- Reference 12DCSCdcsc.govVisit source
- Reference 13BJSbjs.govVisit source
- Reference 14TOLEDOBLADEtoledoblade.comVisit source
- Reference 15BJSbjs.ojp.govVisit source
- Reference 16AZCOURTSazcourts.govVisit source
- Reference 17NMHEALTHYSTREETSnmhealthystreets.orgVisit source
- Reference 18COUNCILONCJcounciloncj.orgVisit source
- Reference 19DCCOURTSdccourts.govVisit source
- Reference 20VCSCvcsc.virginia.govVisit source
- Reference 21MULTCOmultco.usVisit source
- Reference 22NYCOURTSnycourts.govVisit source
- Reference 23HARRISCOUNTYTXharriscountytx.govVisit source
- Reference 24LACOURTlacourt.orgVisit source
- Reference 25COOKCOUNTYCOURTcookcountycourt.orgVisit source
- Reference 26SUPERIORCOURTsuperiorcourt.maricopa.govVisit source
- Reference 27BROWARDCLERKbrowardclerk.orgVisit source
- Reference 28PHILLYCOURTSphillycourts.govVisit source
- Reference 29NJCOURTSnjcourts.govVisit source
- Reference 30NMCOURTSnmcourts.govVisit source
- Reference 31COco.lucas.oh.usVisit source
- Reference 32HOUSTONPUBLICMEDIAhoustonpublicmedia.orgVisit source
- Reference 33CSADCcsadc.govVisit source
- Reference 34VADOGISTICSvadogistics.orgVisit source
- Reference 35COURTScourts.oregon.govVisit source
- Reference 36DATAdata.cityofnewyork.usVisit source
- Reference 37NYCLUnyclu.orgVisit source
- Reference 38ACLUAZacluaz.orgVisit source
- Reference 39SUN-SENTINELsun-sentinel.comVisit source
- Reference 40ABQJOURNALabqjournal.comVisit source
- Reference 41PROPUBLICApropublica.orgVisit source
- Reference 42WASHINGTONPOSTwashingtonpost.comVisit source
- Reference 43VIRGINIAMERCURYvirginiamercury.comVisit source
- Reference 44OREGONLIVEoregonlive.comVisit source
- Reference 45LAla.law.justia.comVisit source
- Reference 46COOKCOUNTYCLERKOFCOURTcookcountyclerkofcourt.orgVisit source
- Reference 47COUNCILcouncil.nyc.govVisit source
- Reference 48COOKCOUNTYSHERIFFILcookcountysheriffil.govVisit source
- Reference 49LATIMESlatimes.comVisit source