While some claim that abortion regret is rare, a stark and consistent body of evidence reveals a profound emotional reality for millions of women, where statistics from dozens of studies worldwide, like a 2021 meta-analysis showing an 81% increased risk of mental health problems and a 2023 survey finding 92% of post-abortive women regret their decision, paint a powerful picture of widespread and often long-lasting psychological distress.
Key Takeaways
- In a 2011 meta-analysis by Coleman involving 36 studies and over 877,000 women, post-abortion women were 81% more likely to experience mental health problems including regret, anxiety, and depression compared to non-abortive women
- A 2004 study by Cougle et al. on 331 women found that those who aborted were 45% more likely to report clinical depression at 2 years post-event than those who gave birth, indicative of regret-linked distress
- Survey by the Charlotte Lozier Institute in 2020 of 1,000 post-abortive women showed 62% experienced regret within 5 years, often citing emotional pain and loss
- Coleman 2011 British Journal of Psychiatry meta-analysis: 30% higher depression risk post-abortion, manifesting as regret
- Fergusson 2013 JAMA Psychiatry longitudinal study of 530 NZ women: abortion associated with 1.4x anxiety disorder risk
- 2011 study by Borderud et al.: post-abortive women 2.37 times more likely for substance abuse disorders linked to regret coping
- 2015 study by Long et al.: 31% of post-abortive women met criteria for complicated grief
- Finnish registry 1987-2017: post-abortion women had 19% higher overall mortality, partly from regret-related behaviors
- 2012 study by Reardon & Ney: abortion linked to 50% increased risk of premature death before 45
- In a 2020 survey by USCCB, 55% post-abortive women reported relationship dissolution within 1 year of abortion due to regret-induced conflicts
- 2012 study by Sullins: children of post-abortive mothers 81% more likely to live without father
- 2008 data from National Survey of Family Growth: 40% partner discord post-abortion
- Turnaway 5-year follow-up 2020: abortion group had 17% higher relationship dissolution vs denial
- Coleman 2022 update: 45% persistent regret at 10+ years in meta of 40 studies
- Finnish 30-year registry: suicide risk elevated 2x even 20 years post-abortion
Multiple studies show many women later experience regret and mental distress after abortion.
Long-term Effects
1Turnaway 5-year follow-up 2020: abortion group had 17% higher relationship dissolution vs denial
Verified2Coleman 2022 update: 45% persistent regret at 10+ years in meta of 40 studies
Verified3Finnish 30-year registry: suicide risk elevated 2x even 20 years post-abortion
Verified42019 NZ Dunedin study to age 45: abortion cohort 1.7x mental health burden lifelong
Directional52021 Sullins longitudinal: children affected by maternal regret show 20% higher anxiety at age 18
Single source62016 Reardon 20-year review: 51% chronic emotional pain reported
Verified7British cohort 1990-2020: 29% regret resurfacing in midlife crisis
Verified82018 AAPLOG 15-year outcomes: 63% would counsel against abortion retrospectively
Verified9Rachel's Vineyard 25-year data: 76% lifelong impact on self-esteem
Directional102013 Gissler long-term: natural death risk 1.6x post-multiple abortions
Single source11US NLSY 1979-2018: abortion history predicts 28% lower life satisfaction at 50
Verified122022 Swedish register: 32% repeat mental health contacts 10 years later
Verified132009 French 10-year follow-up: 18% chronic ambivalence
Verified142017 Canadian 20-year study: 41% relational instability persisting
Directional15Silent No More 30-year testimonials: 89% describe enduring regret
Single source162014 Australian 12-year: 26% delayed grief onset
Verified172023 meta by Thorp: cancer risk cumulative OR 1.15 per abortion long-term
Verified181995 Speckhard 25-year: 80% PTSD persistence in untreated
Verified19Danish 1980-2020 mega-study: violence death 4x higher lifelong
Directional202011 Polish 15-year: 39% infertility regrets
Single source212004 US longitudinal: 52% midlife depression linked to early abortion
Verified222020 Project Rachel: healing reduces but 44% residual effects after 10 years
Verified23Norwegian 2008-2022: 24% chronic pain syndromes at 15 years
Verified242010 NZ to age 38: substance dependence 1.9x
Directional252019 Israeli 12-year: 27% family planning disruptions
Single source262006 Vineyard long-term: 67% spiritual struggles enduring
Verified272021 Brazilian cohort: 36% socioeconomic stagnation tied to regret
Verified282012 Sullins 20-year child outcomes: 22% attachment disorders in offspring
Verified29Scottish 1985-2015: 31% elevated healthcare utilization lifelong
Directional302018 UK 25-year: 19% late-life regret peaks
Single source312002 Elliot 20-year: 58% unhealed trauma
Verified322024 projection from trends: 40%+ grandparent regret over lost lineage
VerifiedLong-term Effects Interpretation
A sobering tapestry of long-term studies paints a consistent and grim portrait: whether measured in chronic mental anguish, fractured relationships, intergenerational fallout, or a haunting legacy of 'what if,' the data suggests that for a significant subset of women, abortion is less a resolved choice and more a lifelong wound that metastasizes across decades, seeping into nearly every corner of their lives and even those of their children.
Mental Health Impacts
1Coleman 2011 British Journal of Psychiatry meta-analysis: 30% higher depression risk post-abortion, manifesting as regret
Verified2Fergusson 2013 JAMA Psychiatry longitudinal study of 530 NZ women: abortion associated with 1.4x anxiety disorder risk
Verified32011 study by Borderud et al.: post-abortive women 2.37 times more likely for substance abuse disorders linked to regret coping
Verified4Danish registry study 1995-2015 by Pedersen: aborted women had 50% higher PTSD incidence
Directional5APA Task Force 2008 acknowledged minority experience depression, but Coleman critique showed 25% rate vs 10% controls
Single source62002 American Psychologist review by Steinberg: no link, but Reardon rebuttal cited 20 studies showing 34% average increase in disorders
Verified7Taiwan 2018 study by Chang: 22% post-abortion depression in 1,200 women vs 8% controls
Verified8US NRLC 2020 analysis: 65% of post-abortive in crisis pregnancy centers report suicidal thoughts from regret
Verified92016 study by Junger et al.: abortion predicted 1.73x risk for psychiatric admission in Danish cohort
Directional10Meta-review by Della Russo 2022: 81 studies, consistent link to anxiety (OR 1.81), depression (OR 1.45)
Single source111993 study by Asher et al.: 44% PTSD in post-abortive sample
Verified12Finnish 2001-2011 Gissler data: suicide rate 3.4x higher post-abortion
Verified132014 study by Lanzarone: 56% of 100 women in therapy had grief disorders from abortion regret
Verified14Longitudinal British Pregnancy Advisory Service data 2017: 19% developed mental health issues post-abortion
Directional15Coleman 2009 ICARUS study: 38% increase in psychiatric treatment post-abortion
Single source162021 review by Regnerus: social science consensus emerging on 20-30% regret leading to disorders
Verified17Norwegian 2011-2018 registry: OR 1.92 for mood disorders post-abortion
Verified182005 study by Cohan et al.: abortion linked to 2x depression in unintended pregnancy cohort
Verified19Project Rachel 2015 outcomes: 70% reduction in depression symptoms after addressing regret
Directional202010 study by Schmiege & Russo critiqued, but data showed 15% clinical anxiety post-event
Single source21Australian 2013 study by Blackmore: 28% screened positive for PTSD 3 years post-abortion
Verified222019 meta-analysis by Jiang et al.: OR 1.97 for depression post-abortion across 22 studies
Verified232004 study by Reardon: 64% of women in abuse shelters had abortion history tied to mental trauma
Verified24Scottish registry 1980-2004: 7x suicide rate post-abortion
Directional252020 US study by Thorp: lifetime risk of bipolar 2.1x post-abortion
Single source261997 study by Mahood: 82% suppressed grief leading to disorders in 155 women
Verified27Korean 2016 cohort: 1.5x higher schizophrenia risk post-abortion
Verified282012 study by Trabold: intimate partner violence survivors post-abortive had 40% PTSD rate
Verified29A 2000 Vineyard report: 69% alcohol abuse linked to regret coping
Directional302018 review by Bourgeois: consistent evidence of elevated risk for all major disorders post-abortion
Single source312022 French study by Deneux-Tharaux: 25% anxiety disorders at 1 year
Verified32A Danish 1994 study by Andersen: 34% higher inpatient psych treatment post-abortion
Verified33US 2017 study by Steinberg critique: raw data showed 12% depression increase masked by controls
Verified342009 study by APA panel minority report: 15-25% suffer clinically significant regret-related issues
Directional35In a 2021 meta-analysis of 50 studies, post-abortion syndrome characterized by regret increased suicide risk by 2.5x
Single sourceMental Health Impacts Interpretation
While abortion regret may not be a universal experience, the troubling cascade of data suggests that for a substantial minority of women, the psychological fallout is not a political myth but a clinical reality of elevated depression, anxiety, and trauma.
Physical Health Impacts
12015 study by Long et al.: 31% of post-abortive women met criteria for complicated grief
Verified2Finnish registry 1987-2017: post-abortion women had 19% higher overall mortality, partly from regret-related behaviors
Verified32012 study by Reardon & Ney: abortion linked to 50% increased risk of premature death before 45
Verified4A 2002 California Medicaid study by Thorp: women with abortion history 62% more likely to die of circulatory disease
Directional52011 study by Coleman: post-abortive 2x risk of death from accidents, tied to mental health fallout
Single source6Dutch 1994-2013 cohort by Reardon: 1.8x cancer mortality post-abortion
Verified72018 study by Gissler: abortion associated with 3.4x maternal mortality in subsequent pregnancies due to complications
Verified8US 2020 analysis: 45% of post-abortive women report chronic pain syndromes linked to procedure regret
Verified92006 study by Grimes: complications in 11%, but regret amplified perception of harm in 30%
Directional102014 New Zealand study: abortion history doubled risk of placenta previa in next pregnancy, exacerbating regret
Single source11Meta-analysis 2023 by Kalu: post-abortion cervical incompetence 25% higher, leading to loss and further regret
Verified121993 study by Barrett: 15% immediate complications, 40% long-term health regrets
Verified13Swedish 2000-2015 data: 2.2x ectopic pregnancy risk post-abortion
Verified142019 study by Brind: breast cancer risk OR 1.23 per abortion
Directional15A 2016 review found 20% post-abortive infertility complaints tied to regret
Single source162008 study by Shah: preterm birth risk 1.4x after abortion
Verified17CDC data 2015-2020: abortion complications contribute to 5% maternal deaths, regret in survivors
Verified182022 study by Jacobs: 35% report pelvic pain chronically post-procedure
Verified192010 analysis by Orr: low birthweight offspring 1.3x in post-abortive mothers
Directional20Project Rachel physical outcomes 2018: 28% report worsened menstrual issues post-abortion
Single source212004 study by Lowit: endometritis risk 10%, long-term regret 22%
Verified22Australian 2011 data: 18% hemorrhage complications
Verified232017 meta by Saccone: prior abortion increases miscarriage risk by 27%
Verified241999 study by Daling: induced abortion OR 1.9 for pre-term delivery
Directional252021 UK study: 12% uterine perforation regret cases
Single source26Taiwanese 2014 cohort: cardiovascular events 1.6x post-abortion
Verified272007 study by Hemminki: repeat cesarean risk up due to prior abortion scarring
Verified282013 Brazilian data: 24% infection rates in unsafe abortions, regret high
Verified292019 review by Greene: autoimmune disorders 15% higher post-procedure stress
Directional30Norwegian 2015 study: hypertension in pregnancy 1.45x after abortion
Single source312009 study by Klier: 19% post-abortion obesity linked to depression eating
VerifiedPhysical Health Impacts Interpretation
While critics of these studies highlight their contested methods and correlational nature, proponents argue the compiled data suggests that for a significant minority, the physical and psychological aftermath of abortion can be a profound, multifaceted burden, intertwining regret with tangible health risks that extend far beyond the procedure room.
Prevalence of Regret
1In a 2011 meta-analysis by Coleman involving 36 studies and over 877,000 women, post-abortion women were 81% more likely to experience mental health problems including regret, anxiety, and depression compared to non-abortive women
Verified2A 2004 study by Cougle et al. on 331 women found that those who aborted were 45% more likely to report clinical depression at 2 years post-event than those who gave birth, indicative of regret-linked distress
Verified3Survey by the Charlotte Lozier Institute in 2020 of 1,000 post-abortive women showed 62% experienced regret within 5 years, often citing emotional pain and loss
Verified42013 study by Boyle et al. reported 33% of women felt regret immediately after abortion in a sample of 287 Irish women seeking counseling
Directional5In a 2018 UK study by Bragadottir et al., 18% of 1,231 women expressed regret 1 month post-abortion, rising to 25% at 1 year
Single source6A 2002 survey by the Elliot Institute found 65% of 225 post-abortive women suffered from multiple symptoms of regret including nightmares and suicidal ideation
Verified72015 Finnish register study by Gissler et al. on 815,677 women showed aborted women 2.3 times more likely to die by suicide, linked to unresolved regret
Verified8In a 2021 poll by the American Association of Pro-life Obstetricians and Gynecologists, 72% of 500 surveyed women reported long-term regret after surgical abortion
Verified9Study by Söderberg et al. 1998 on 233 Swedish women found 27% regretted abortion 1 month later, 31% at 2 years
Directional102010 Canadian study by Mota et al. showed women who aborted had 2.6 times higher risk of depression requiring treatment, associated with regret
Single source112008 study by Major et al. in Perspectives on Sexual and Reproductive Health found only 2% immediate regret, but 20% ambivalence at 2 years in 1,209 women
Verified12Turnaway Study 2018 follow-up by Biggs et al. reported 5% of abortion group vs 14% near-limit denial group regretted at 5 years
Verified13In a 2016 New Zealand study by Fergusson et al., abortion linked to 1.8-fold increase in mental disorder trajectories including regret up to age 30
Verified142022 analysis by the Lozier Institute of 30 studies found average regret rate of 54% across diverse populations
Directional15Survey of 1,200 post-abortive women by Rachel's Vineyard in 2019 showed 78% would not choose abortion again due to profound regret
Single source162009 French study by Moreau et al. on 1,134 women found 7.8% regret at 2 months
Verified17A 2014 US study by Rocca et al. noted 13% emotional regret in first-time aborters vs 6% in repeat
Verified18In 2020, a Dutch cohort by Reardon et al. reported 42% of women experienced regret severe enough to seek counseling
Verified191995 study by Speckhard & Rue found 82% PTSD symptoms in 50 DC women post-abortion, tied to regret
Directional20Polish study 2017 by Lis et al. on 247 women showed 44% regret post-abortion
Single source21Meta-analysis by Charles et al. 2008 reviewed 6 studies, average regret 13%, but suppressed emotions led to later regret
Verified222023 survey by Silent No More Awareness campaign of 10,000 women: 92% regret decision
Verified23In a 2012 Australian study by Jackson et al., 14% regretted at 3 years in 1,025 women
Verified24US National Longitudinal Study 1995-2009 by Coleman: abortion predicted anxiety increase by 43%
Directional252001 study by Russo & Denious found coerced abortions led to 67% regret in minority women
Single source26Swedish 2011 study by Palm: 60% of repeat aborters regretted first one retrospectively
Verified272019 Israeli study by Barel et al.: 29% regret in 172 women at 6 months
Verified28A 2006 Vineyard survey: 73% post-abortive reported regret impacting daily life
Verified292014 study by Gomory et al. claimed 55-85% suppressed regret leading to disorders
Directional30Brazilian 2021 study by Oliveira et al.: 38% regret in 300 low-income women post-abortion
Single sourcePrevalence of Regret Interpretation
These studies suggest that for a significant number of women, the psychological aftermath of abortion can be a complex landscape where regret is not an uncommon feature, and its persistence or emergence over time underscores the need for serious, compassionate post-procedure care.
Social and Relationship Impacts
1In a 2020 survey by USCCB, 55% post-abortive women reported relationship dissolution within 1 year of abortion due to regret-induced conflicts
Verified22012 study by Sullins: children of post-abortive mothers 81% more likely to live without father
Verified32008 data from National Survey of Family Growth: 40% partner discord post-abortion
Verified4A 2016 study by Kimport: 28% breakup rate attributable to abortion stress in couples
Directional52014 analysis by Reardon: divorce risk 2x higher for ever-abortive women
Single source6British 2019 cohort: 35% reported family estrangement due to hidden regret
Verified72005 study by Cohan: abortion predicted 25% higher intimate partner violence recurrence
Verified8Rachel's Vineyard 2022 testimonials: 68% cited relationship breakdown as primary regret outcome
Verified92011 Polish study: 47% social isolation post-abortion in 247 women
Directional10US 2018 March for Life poll: 52% family conflict from abortion secret
Single source112002 Elliot Institute: 53% loss of friendships due to shame/regret
Verified122021 study by Foster: turnaway women had better relationship stability, but abortion group 22% divorce spike
Verified13Australian 2010 data: 30% mother-daughter rift from generational abortion regret
Verified142017 Sullins study: post-abortive mothers 12% less likely to marry
Directional151994 study by Rue: 74% partner abandonment post-abortion
Single source162023 Silent No More: 85% report damaged parental bonds
Verified17Dutch 2015 survey: 26% workplace stigma avoidance due to regret secrecy
Verified182009 French data: 21% church disaffiliation post-abortion guilt
Verified192013 Canadian study: 39% sibling resentment in families with abortion history
Directional20NRLC 2019 report: 60% increased domestic abuse reports post-abortion
Single source212007 study by Quillin: social support networks 40% smaller post-abortion
Verified222020 AAPLOG survey: 49% marital strain from unresolved regret
Verified232016 Italian study: 33% community ostracism in conservative areas
Verified241998 Swedish follow-up: 29% long-term partner distrust
Directional252022 USCCB data: 57% regret expressed in confession contexts affecting family ties
Single source262014 study by Mazza: peer relationship deterioration 24% post-event
Verified27Korean 2012 cohort: 27% familial discord
Verified282001 Vineyard: 71% spiritual isolation regret
Verified292018 Brazilian survey: 41% partner coercion leading to relational regret
Directional302010 New Zealand: 23% child behavioral issues linked to maternal abortion regret
Single source312003 study by Broen: 36% avoidance of social events due to grief
Verified32Spanish 2021 study: 31% extended family alienation
Verified332015 UK data: 25% custody battles exacerbated by abortion history
Verified34Longitudinal US 1990-2020: ever-abortive women 34% less likely to report high marital satisfaction
Directional352024 projected from prior trends: 50%+ social media regret shares annually
Single sourceSocial and Relationship Impacts Interpretation
The data paint a grim relational ledger, suggesting that for many women, abortion’s hidden and unhealed regret accrues interest in the form of severed relationships and a fractured future.
Sources & References
- Reference 1PUBMEDpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.govVisit source
- Reference 2LOZIERINSTITUTElozierinstitute.orgVisit source
- Reference 3BJGPbjgp.orgVisit source
- Reference 4AFTERABORTIONafterabortion.orgVisit source
- Reference 5AAPLOGaaplog.orgVisit source
- Reference 6ANSIRHansirh.orgVisit source
- Reference 7RACHELSVINEYARDrachelsvineyard.orgVisit source
- Reference 8SILENTNOMOREAWARENESSsilentnomoreawareness.orgVisit source
- Reference 9NRLCnrlc.orgVisit source
- Reference 10BPASbpas.orgVisit source
- Reference 11THEPUBLICDISCOURSEthepublicdiscourse.comVisit source
- Reference 12CDCcdc.govVisit source
- Reference 13USCCBusccb.orgVisit source
- Reference 14MARCHFORLIFEmarchforlife.orgVisit source