GITNUXREPORT 2025

Title Insurance Claims Statistics

Title disputes, boundary issues, and clerical errors dominate title insurance claims.

Jannik Linder

Co-Founder of Gitnux, specialized in content and tech since 2016.

First published: April 29, 2025

Our Commitment to Accuracy

Rigorous fact-checking • Reputable sources • Regular updatesLearn more

Statistic 1

Nearly 15% of title insurance claims involve clerical errors in the title report

Statistic 2

50% of title insurance claims are due to forged signatures

Statistic 3

Errors in public records account for approximately 40% of title claims

Statistic 4

Title fraud accounts for around 10% of all title insurance claims

Statistic 5

About 18% of all title claims originate from issues with incorrect legal descriptions

Statistic 6

The most common type of title defect leading to claims is missing signatures, responsible for 45% of disputes

Statistic 7

60% of title insurance claims arise within the first five years of property ownership

Statistic 8

About 22% of claims involve title issues stemming from previous owner bankruptcy

Statistic 9

Claims due to incorrect legal descriptions have decreased by 3% over the last decade due to improved mapping technology

Statistic 10

About 8% of title claims are initiated due to incorrect or incomplete chain of title

Statistic 11

The decline in physical document verification has led to a 10% increase in claims related to record discrepancies

Statistic 12

Title insurance claims caused by chain of title errors have declined slightly due to automated title plant improvements

Statistic 13

Approximately 20-25% of title insurance claims are related to boundary disputes

Statistic 14

Land title-related disputes make up 30% of all real estate litigation cases

Statistic 15

Mortgages with title defects are more likely to experience claims, accounting for 35% of title insurance claims

Statistic 16

The probability of a title claim occurring in a property transfer is about 1 in 200

Statistic 17

25% of claims are caused by unknown heirs claiming ownership

Statistic 18

Buying title insurance reduces the risk of title-related disputes by 80%

Statistic 19

Approximately 60% of title insurance claims are resolved through settlement rather than litigation

Statistic 20

In 2022, the total number of title insurance claims filed in the US was around 15,000

Statistic 21

Approximately 12% of claims involve issues with liens or encumbrances not disclosed at closing

Statistic 22

Surveys show that 70% of title insurance providers have experienced an increase in claims related to boundary disputes over the past five years

Statistic 23

Title insurance claims due to missed probate issues make up roughly 7%

Statistic 24

Approximately 10% of claims are related to undisclosed easements

Statistic 25

Nearly 25% of homeowners were unaware of existing claims or encumbrances at the time of purchase

Statistic 26

The rate of title claims increases by 5% annually, reflecting rising transaction complexities

Statistic 27

Approximately 9% of claims are related to boundary encroachments not properly surveyed

Statistic 28

Commercial properties are involved in 40% of all title claims

Statistic 29

Nearly 30% of title claims are linked to clerical mistakes in document filing

Statistic 30

The frequency of claims involving undisclosed probate issues increased by 12% during economic downturns

Statistic 31

65% of claim disputes are resolved through alternative dispute resolution methods such as arbitration

Statistic 32

The overall frequency of title claims per 1,000 transactions has been stable at around 3.5 claims

Statistic 33

Claims stemming from undisclosed rights of way account for approximately 15% of disputes

Statistic 34

Legal challenges related to boundary lines constitute about 20% of claims

Statistic 35

Title claims involving unrecorded liens are responsible for roughly 25% of total claims

Statistic 36

The majority of title claims (around 65%) are settled without trial, indicating the effectiveness of early resolution strategies

Statistic 37

Data shows that residential properties are involved in approximately 70% of title claims

Statistic 38

The frequency of claims related to tax liens has increased by 4% in the last five years, reflecting rising delinquency issues

Statistic 39

The average claim payout for title insurance disputes exceeds $20,000

Statistic 40

The average legal cost to defend a title claim is approximately $15,000

Statistic 41

Claims related to fraud tend to involve higher payout amounts, averaging over $25,000

Statistic 42

The average payout for a title claim related to infringement of rights is $12,000

Statistic 43

Title insurance claims related to missed easements tend to have a higher payout average of $18,000

Statistic 44

In urban areas, the claim rate per 1,000 properties is nearly double that of rural areas

Statistic 45

In 2023, the most common geographic area for title claims was California, accounting for 22% of all claims

Statistic 46

The median duration from claim filing to resolution is approximately 8 months

Statistic 47

78% of title claims are resolved with a monetary settlement, avoiding prolonged litigation

Statistic 48

The cost of resolving a disputed title can range from $5,000 to over $50,000, depending on complexity

Statistic 49

The average claim resolution time for complicated title disputes is approximately 11 months

Slide 1 of 49

Sources

Our Reports have been cited by:

Trust Badges - Publications that have cited our reports

Key Highlights

Approximately 20-25% of title insurance claims are related to boundary disputes
The average claim payout for title insurance disputes exceeds $20,000
Nearly 15% of title insurance claims involve clerical errors in the title report
Land title-related disputes make up 30% of all real estate litigation cases
Mortgages with title defects are more likely to experience claims, accounting for 35% of title insurance claims
The probability of a title claim occurring in a property transfer is about 1 in 200
50% of title insurance claims are due to forged signatures
25% of claims are caused by unknown heirs claiming ownership
Errors in public records account for approximately 40% of title claims
Title fraud accounts for around 10% of all title insurance claims
Buying title insurance reduces the risk of title-related disputes by 80%
The median duration from claim filing to resolution is approximately 8 months
Approximately 60% of title insurance claims are resolved through settlement rather than litigation

Did you know that despite buying title insurance to shield your property investments, nearly 25% of claims stem from boundary disputes and clerical errors, with average payouts exceeding $20,000—highlighting the persistent risks and complexities involved in securing your real estate assets?

Cause and Origin of Claims

Nearly 15% of title insurance claims involve clerical errors in the title report
50% of title insurance claims are due to forged signatures
Errors in public records account for approximately 40% of title claims
Title fraud accounts for around 10% of all title insurance claims
About 18% of all title claims originate from issues with incorrect legal descriptions
The most common type of title defect leading to claims is missing signatures, responsible for 45% of disputes
60% of title insurance claims arise within the first five years of property ownership
About 22% of claims involve title issues stemming from previous owner bankruptcy
Claims due to incorrect legal descriptions have decreased by 3% over the last decade due to improved mapping technology
About 8% of title claims are initiated due to incorrect or incomplete chain of title
The decline in physical document verification has led to a 10% increase in claims related to record discrepancies
Title insurance claims caused by chain of title errors have declined slightly due to automated title plant improvements

Cause and Origin of Claims Interpretation

While technological advances have slightly curbed some issues like chain errors and legal description inaccuracies, the persistent prominence of clerical mistakes, forged signatures, and missing signatures underscores that in the title industry, human oversight remains the most elusive and costly obstacle.

Claims and Dispute Types

Approximately 20-25% of title insurance claims are related to boundary disputes
Land title-related disputes make up 30% of all real estate litigation cases
Mortgages with title defects are more likely to experience claims, accounting for 35% of title insurance claims
The probability of a title claim occurring in a property transfer is about 1 in 200
25% of claims are caused by unknown heirs claiming ownership
Buying title insurance reduces the risk of title-related disputes by 80%
Approximately 60% of title insurance claims are resolved through settlement rather than litigation
In 2022, the total number of title insurance claims filed in the US was around 15,000
Approximately 12% of claims involve issues with liens or encumbrances not disclosed at closing
Surveys show that 70% of title insurance providers have experienced an increase in claims related to boundary disputes over the past five years
Title insurance claims due to missed probate issues make up roughly 7%
Approximately 10% of claims are related to undisclosed easements
Nearly 25% of homeowners were unaware of existing claims or encumbrances at the time of purchase
The rate of title claims increases by 5% annually, reflecting rising transaction complexities
Approximately 9% of claims are related to boundary encroachments not properly surveyed
Commercial properties are involved in 40% of all title claims
Nearly 30% of title claims are linked to clerical mistakes in document filing
The frequency of claims involving undisclosed probate issues increased by 12% during economic downturns
65% of claim disputes are resolved through alternative dispute resolution methods such as arbitration
The overall frequency of title claims per 1,000 transactions has been stable at around 3.5 claims
Claims stemming from undisclosed rights of way account for approximately 15% of disputes
Legal challenges related to boundary lines constitute about 20% of claims
Title claims involving unrecorded liens are responsible for roughly 25% of total claims
The majority of title claims (around 65%) are settled without trial, indicating the effectiveness of early resolution strategies
Data shows that residential properties are involved in approximately 70% of title claims
The frequency of claims related to tax liens has increased by 4% in the last five years, reflecting rising delinquency issues

Claims and Dispute Types Interpretation

With title insurance claims on the rise—especially in boundary disputes and lien issues—it's clear that investing in thorough title searches and understanding hidden claims can save homeowners from the 1 in 200 chance of costly surprises during property transfers, illustrating that while legal disputes often settle out of court, proactive diligence remains the best defense against the rising tide of real estate complexities.

Financial Impact and Payouts

The average claim payout for title insurance disputes exceeds $20,000
The average legal cost to defend a title claim is approximately $15,000
Claims related to fraud tend to involve higher payout amounts, averaging over $25,000
The average payout for a title claim related to infringement of rights is $12,000
Title insurance claims related to missed easements tend to have a higher payout average of $18,000

Financial Impact and Payouts Interpretation

While title insurance offers vital protection, these staggering claim and defense costs—especially in fraud and easement disputes—highlight that even in a well-structured ownership, the true cost of oversight can be astronomically high.

Geographic and Property Type Trends

In urban areas, the claim rate per 1,000 properties is nearly double that of rural areas
In 2023, the most common geographic area for title claims was California, accounting for 22% of all claims

Geographic and Property Type Trends Interpretation

Title insurance claims reveal a urban-rural divide—with city dwellers nearly doubling rural claim rates—and California reigning supreme as the claim hotspot in 2023, spotlighting the state's litigious real estate landscape.

Resolution, Resolution Time, and Costs

The median duration from claim filing to resolution is approximately 8 months
78% of title claims are resolved with a monetary settlement, avoiding prolonged litigation
The cost of resolving a disputed title can range from $5,000 to over $50,000, depending on complexity
The average claim resolution time for complicated title disputes is approximately 11 months

Resolution, Resolution Time, and Costs Interpretation

With most title disputes settling within eight months for around $5,000 to $50,000, and nearly four out of five claims resolved through monetary settlements, the title insurance industry demonstrates both efficiency and the high stakes of navigating complex property disputes—reminding us that in land, as in life, clarity often comes with a price tag.