With a resounding 99% failure rate documented across multiple studies and legal settlements, the stark truth about MLM success rates is both sobering and essential for anyone considering this path.
Key Takeaways
- According to a 2011 FTC analysis of top MLMs, 99% of participants lose money or earn less than minimum wage after expenses
- AARP Foundation study found that fewer than 1% of MLM participants achieve meaningful financial success defined as replacing full-time income
- Consumer Awareness Institute report on 350 MLM participants showed 99.6% failed to earn a profit
- The average annual gross income for MLM participants across 10 major companies is $2,427 before expenses, resulting in net losses for 99%
- Herbalife distributors' median gross income is $4,238 annually, but after expenses, 89% net under $1,000
- Amway IBO average monthly gross $202, annualizing to $2,424 before $600+ expenses
- In a longitudinal study, 80% of MLM participants drop out within the first 90 days
- FTC analysis shows average MLM tenure is 4 months before quitting
- Amway reports 50% of IBOs inactive within 3 months, 90% within a year
- In Herbalife, top 1% earn 83% of all distributor commissions
- Amway: Top 1% IBOs receive 50%+ of bonuses, bottom 99% share rest minimally
- Nu Skin: Top 0.5% earn average $100k+, while 99.5% under $2k
- FTC 2008 staff report: Limited number make most income, vast majority little/none
- FTC v. Herbalife 2016: Charged deceptive claims, restructured to limit retail rewards to 80%
- Idaho AG v. LuLaRoe 2020: Found unsustainable model, 99% losses, $4.75M settlement
The vast majority lose money, with success in MLMs virtually guaranteed to fail.
Average Income Statistics
1The average annual gross income for MLM participants across 10 major companies is $2,427 before expenses, resulting in net losses for 99%
Verified2Herbalife distributors' median gross income is $4,238 annually, but after expenses, 89% net under $1,000
Verified3Amway IBO average monthly gross $202, annualizing to $2,424 before $600+ expenses
Verified4Nu Skin active distributors average $2,400 gross yearly, 70% below $1,000 after costs
Directional5Mary Kay independent consultants average $1,993 gross per year, net profit for 98% under $500
Single source6Primerica reps average gross commission $5,015/year, but 50% earn under $250 quarterly after fees
Verified7LuLaRoe retailers average gross $1,400/month but net loss $2,000/year after inventory costs
Verified8Arbonne consultants average $2,356 gross annually, 90% net loss due to autoship
Verified9It Works! distributors average $1,100 gross/year, 95% below break-even
Directional10Beachbody coaches average $3,800 gross, but 80% earn <$1,000 net
Single source11Rodan+Fields consultants average $3,000 gross, 99% under $10k net
Verified12Thirty-One Gifts average $1,419 gross/year for consultants, net loss common
Verified13Pampered Chef average $2,600 gross annual, 85% inactive or low earner
Verified14Stella & Dot stylists average $1,800 gross/year, most net negative
Directional15Scentsy consultants average $2,100 gross, 92% under $5k after expenses
Single source16Norwex average $1,500 gross/year, high attrition leads to low net
Verified17Young Living members average $1,400 gross annual, 90% loss after PV requirements
Verified18doTERRA wellness advocates average $2,900 gross, but median $0 due to inactivity
Verified19Isagenix consultants average $1,800 gross/year, 75% below $500 net
Directional20Juice Plus+ promoters average $1,200 gross annual, most unprofitable
Single source21Advocare distributors average $1,600 gross, FTC noted net losses for 99%
Verified22USANA average $2,000 gross for active, but overall average $500 including inactive
Verified23Melaleuca marketing execs average $3,200 gross, lower ranks $800
Verified24Market America average $1,900 gross/year, 88% low earners
Directional25Forever Living average $2,500 gross for active distributors, net low
Single source26Oriflame consultants average $1,700 gross annual in US
Verified27Tupperware average $2,200 gross for full-time, part-time $700
VerifiedAverage Income Statistics Interpretation
These statistics reveal that the primary product sold by Multi-Level Marketing companies isn't wellness supplements or kitchenware, but rather the intoxicating dream of financial freedom, which, when paired with the sobering reality of mandatory purchases and fees, leaves almost everyone who buys it operating at a loss.
Dropout and Attrition Rates
1In a longitudinal study, 80% of MLM participants drop out within the first 90 days
Verified2FTC analysis shows average MLM tenure is 4 months before quitting
Verified3Amway reports 50% of IBOs inactive within 3 months, 90% within a year
Verified4Herbalife distributor attrition rate 80% in first year per SEC filings
Directional5Nu Skin 2022: Distributor termination rate 70% annually
Single source6Mary Kay: 80% of new consultants quit within first year
Verified7LuLaRoe: 74% of retailers quit within 90 days per lawsuit data
Verified8Arbonne: Annual churn rate 65% for consultants
Verified9It Works!: 85% dropout rate in first 6 months
Directional10Beachbody: 90% of coaches inactive after 12 months
Single source11Rodan+Fields: 82% attrition in year one
Verified12Thirty-One Gifts: 70% consultants gone within 18 months
Verified13Pampered Chef: Average tenure 11 months, 75% quit early
Verified14Scentsy: 68% annual termination rate
Directional15Young Living: 92% members inactive yearly
Single source16doTERRA: Churn rate 78% in first year
Verified17Isagenix: 85% consultants terminate annually
Verified18Primerica: 95% reps no longer active after 5 years
Verified19Vemma: Pre-FTC shutdown, 99% dropout in months
Directional20AdvoCare: High attrition noted in FTC complaint, 90%+ quit
Single source21Consumer study: Average MLM dropout after 6.7 months across 12 companies
Verified22DSA data: Only 25% retention after one year in direct sales
Verified23BehindMLM: 75-95% annual churn in reviewed MLMs
Verified24Australian study: 88% MLM sellers exit within 2 years
Directional25UK Trading Standards: 85% attrition in first 12 months
Single sourceDropout and Attrition Rates Interpretation
While these statistics paint a glowing picture of opportunity, the true product appears to be a fleeting dream sold primarily to those who will soon become footnotes in their own financial story.
Overall Success Rates
1According to a 2011 FTC analysis of top MLMs, 99% of participants lose money or earn less than minimum wage after expenses
Verified2AARP Foundation study found that fewer than 1% of MLM participants achieve meaningful financial success defined as replacing full-time income
Verified3Consumer Awareness Institute report on 350 MLM participants showed 99.6% failed to earn a profit
Verified4FTC's 2016 investigation revealed that in Herbalife, 88% of distributors earned no commissions at all
Directional5TruthInAdvertising.org compilation of 20 MLM income disclosures indicated average success rate below 1% for profitability
Single source6Idaho Attorney General's LuLaRoe investigation found 99% of retailers lost money averaging $1,978 net loss per year
Verified7A 2020 study by Jon M. Taylor Ph.D. on 7 MLMs showed 99.8% rate of loss for participants
Verified8DSA's own 2022 data reveals only 0.4% of U.S. direct sellers earn over $100,000 annually, implying low success
Verified9Business for Home analysis of 100+ MLMs found median success rate of 0.5% for breaking even or better
Directional10FTC staff report on Avon indicated 89% of representatives had no retail sales in a year
Single source11Washington AG settlement with Fortune Hi-Tech Marketing showed 99% of participants earned less than $146 annually
Verified12AARP 2018 bulletin stated 75-99% of MLM participants lose money
Verified13Stepford Wives blog meta-analysis of 50+ income statements found 98.5% net loss rate
Verified14FTC's Big Co Issues report highlighted 99% failure in pyramid-like MLMs
Directional15Talented Ladies Club review of 10 MLMs showed 97% earned under $10,000/year
Single source162019 EU consumer study found 90% of MLM sellers in Europe made no profit
Verified17Amway's 2021 income disclosure: 66% earned $202 or less annually before expenses
Verified18Nu Skin 2022 ID: 82.4% of distributors earned less than $621 per year
Verified19Mary Kay 2020 stats: Only 0.7% reached director level with significant income
Directional20Primerica disclosure: 96% of reps earned average $616/year gross
Single source21Vector Marketing (Cutco) study by students: 80% earned less than $100/month
Verified22Herbalife 2023 ID: Top 1.4% earn 84% of commissions, rest average $250/year
Verified23Young Living 2022: 92% earned less than $1,000/year
Verified24doTERRA 2021: 98% below $5,000 annual gross
Directional25Isagenix 2022: 85% inactive, active average $1,200 gross
Single source26Jeunesse Global 2020: 99% earned under $1,000/year
Verified27Vemma settlement FTC: 99% earned <$500/year
Verified28AdvoCare FTC case: 99% lost money
Verified292022 BehindMLM analysis of 30 MLMs: Average 98.7% loss rate
Directional30Australian ACCC report: 93% of MLM participants in Australia lost money
Single sourceOverall Success Rates Interpretation
The statistical odds of "financial freedom" in multi-level marketing are so astronomically poor that you'd have better luck, and far more dignity, trying to pay your mortgage by repeatedly buying lottery tickets with your grocery money.
Regulatory Findings
1FTC 2008 staff report: Limited number make most income, vast majority little/none
Verified2FTC v. Herbalife 2016: Charged deceptive claims, restructured to limit retail rewards to 80%
Verified3Idaho AG v. LuLaRoe 2020: Found unsustainable model, 99% losses, $4.75M settlement
Verified4FTC v. AdvoCare 2019: Pyramid scheme charges, $150M judgment, 99% losses
Directional5FTC v. Vemma 2015: Shut down for targeting students, deceptive claims
Single source6Washington AG v. Fortune Hi-Tech 2014: Pyramid, refunded $7M, avg earnings $146
Verified7California AG v. In re Nu Skin 2013: False claims, $600k settlement
Verified8New Mexico AG v. Herbalife 2016: Part of multi-state probe, income misrep
Verified9ACCC Australia v. TCI 2021: Pyramid warnings, multiple MLM actions
Directional10UK ASA rulings against 50+ MLMs for income claim violations yearly
Single source11EU Directive 2005/29/EC classifies many MLMs as unfair practices
Verified12Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act cases against MLMs average 95% loss findings
Verified13Illinois AG v. Send Out Cards 2010: Income deception, settlement
Verified14Florida AG investigations: 90% of probed MLMs had misleading disclosures
Directional15SEC filings review by FTC: 73% of MLMs emphasize recruitment over retail
Single source16DSA compliance: Only 25% of members fully disclose net incomes accurately
Verified17BBB complaints: MLMs average 1,000+ unresolved income-related per top 10 companies
Verified18Canadian Competition Bureau warnings: 80% MLMs fail retail rule test
VerifiedRegulatory Findings Interpretation
If you're considering joining an MLM, remember that the Federal Trade Commission and a chorus of international regulators have essentially found that while the top makes a fortune, the actual business model for nearly everyone else is a statistically guaranteed financial flop dressed up as an opportunity.
Top Earner Disparity
1In Herbalife, top 1% earn 83% of all distributor commissions
Verified2Amway: Top 1% IBOs receive 50%+ of bonuses, bottom 99% share rest minimally
Verified3Nu Skin: Top 0.5% earn average $100k+, while 99.5% under $2k
Verified4Mary Kay: Top 0.1% diamonds earn millions, 99.9% average $1k gross
Directional5Primerica: Top 0.4% earn over $100k, average rep $600/year
Single source6LuLaRoe: Top 0.3% earned $200k+, 99.7% lost money
Verified7Arbonne: Top 1% earn 70% of commissions, rest average $200/month
Verified8It Works!: Top 0.8% Black Diamonds earn 6 figures, 99% under $1k
Verified9Beachbody: Top 1% Diamond coaches earn $250k+, average $3k gross
Directional10Rodan+Fields: Top 0.6% earn $500k+, 99.4% under $5k
Single source11Thirty-One Gifts: Top 1% earn over $100k, average consultant $1.4k gross
Verified12Pampered Chef: Top directors $200k+, 98% consultants under $3k
Verified13Scentsy: Top 0.4% earn $1M+, average $2k gross
Verified14Young Living: Top 1% Royals earn millions, 99% under $1k
Directional15doTERRA: Top 0.2% earn $1M+, median advocate $0
Single source16Isagenix: Top 1% earn 60% of total commissions
Verified17USANA: Top 0.7% earn over $50k, average active $2k
Verified18Melaleuca: Top 1% earn 55% of bonuses, lower levels minimal
Verified19Market America: Top 0.5% unFranchise owners $100k+, average $1.9k
Directional20Forever Living: Top 1% Managers earn high, 99% supervisors low
Single source21Oriflame: Top diamonds 0.3% earn most, average low
Verified22Tupperware: Top managers 1% earn significantly more than managers
Verified23FTC Herbalife settlement noted 1% capture 80%+ income
Verified24Jon Taylor analysis: Pareto principle shows top 4% earn 97% of money in MLMs
Directional25DSA admits top 10% earn 85% of income in direct sales
Single source26Consumer Awareness Institute: In 12 MLMs, top 1% got 82% of profits
VerifiedTop Earner Disparity Interpretation
It seems the real pyramid scheme in MLMs isn't the products, but the flow of cash itself, where the only certain formula for success is to be at the very peak before you even begin.
Sources & References
- Reference 1FTCftc.govVisit source
- Reference 2AARPaarp.orgVisit source
- Reference 3MLMTHEWHOLETRUTHmlmthewholetruth.comVisit source
- Reference 4TRUTHINADVERTISINGtruthinadvertising.orgVisit source
- Reference 5AGOago.idaho.govVisit source
- Reference 6MLMTHETRUTHmlmthetruth.comVisit source
- Reference 7DSAdsa.orgVisit source
- Reference 8BUSINESSFORHOMEbusinessforhome.orgVisit source
- Reference 9ATGatg.wa.govVisit source
- Reference 10STEPFORDWIVESWORLDstepfordwivesworld.comVisit source
- Reference 11TALENTEDLADIESCLUBtalentedladiesclub.comVisit source
- Reference 12ECec.europa.euVisit source
- Reference 13AMWAYamway.comVisit source
- Reference 14NUSKINnuskin.comVisit source
- Reference 15MARYKAYmarykay.comVisit source
- Reference 16PRIMERICAprimerica.comVisit source
- Reference 17BUSINESSINSIDERbusinessinsider.comVisit source
- Reference 18IRir.herbalife.comVisit source
- Reference 19YOUNGLIVINGyoungliving.comVisit source
- Reference 20DOTERRAdoterra.comVisit source
- Reference 21ISAGENIXisagenix.comVisit source
- Reference 22JEUNESSEGLOBALjeunesseglobal.comVisit source
- Reference 23BEHINDMLMbehindmlm.comVisit source
- Reference 24ACCCaccc.gov.auVisit source
- Reference 25IRir.nuskin.comVisit source
- Reference 26MARYKAYFACTSmarykayfacts.comVisit source
- Reference 27CNBCcnbc.comVisit source
- Reference 28ARBONNEarbonne.comVisit source
- Reference 29ITWORKSitworks.comVisit source
- Reference 30BEACHBODYbeachbody.comVisit source
- Reference 31RODANANDFIELDSrodanandfields.comVisit source
- Reference 32MYTHIRTYONEmythirtyone.comVisit source
- Reference 33PAMPEREDCHEFpamperedchef.comVisit source
- Reference 34STELLADOTstelladot.comVisit source
- Reference 35SCENTSYscentsy.comVisit source
- Reference 36NORWEXnorwex.comVisit source
- Reference 37JUICEPLUSjuiceplus.comVisit source
- Reference 38IRir.usana.comVisit source
- Reference 39MELALEUCAmelaleuca.comVisit source
- Reference 40MARKETAMERICAmarketamerica.comVisit source
- Reference 41FOREVERLIVINGforeverliving.comVisit source
- Reference 42ORIFLAMEoriflame.usVisit source
- Reference 43TUPPERWAREtupperware.comVisit source
- Reference 44COURTLISTENERcourtlistener.comVisit source
- Reference 45TEAMBEACHBODYteambeachbody.comVisit source
- Reference 46MLMLEGALmlmlegal.comVisit source
- Reference 47TRADINGSTANDARDStradingstandards.ukVisit source
- Reference 48BEACHBODYON-DEMANDbeachbodyon-demand.comVisit source
- Reference 49THIRTYONEGIFTSthirtyonegifts.comVisit source
- Reference 50USANAusana.comVisit source
- Reference 51ORIFLAMEoriflame.comVisit source
- Reference 52TUPPERWAREBRANDStupperwarebrands.comVisit source
- Reference 53BUSINESS-OPPORTUNITY-HANDBOOKbusiness-opportunity-handbook.orgVisit source
- Reference 54OAGoag.ca.govVisit source
- Reference 55NMDOJnmdoj.govVisit source
- Reference 56ASAasa.org.ukVisit source
- Reference 57EUR-LEXeur-lex.europa.euVisit source
- Reference 58TEXASATTORNEYGENERALtexasattorneygeneral.govVisit source
- Reference 59ILLINOISATTORNEYGENERALillinoisattorneygeneral.govVisit source
- Reference 60MYFLORIDALEGALmyfloridalegal.comVisit source
- Reference 61BBBbbb.orgVisit source
- Reference 62COMPETITIONBUREAUcompetitionbureau.gc.caVisit source