Imagine a power so vast that it built 200,000 miles of railroad, reshaped a thousand cities, and paved the very highways you drive on, yet it remains one of the most contentious and quietly active principles in American law, rooted in a single clause of the Fifth Amendment.
Key Takeaways
- The Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution, ratified in 1791, first codified eminent domain powers requiring just compensation for takings
- From 1789 to 1860, the US Supreme Court heard only 12 eminent domain cases, averaging less than one per decade
- In the 19th century, eminent domain was used in over 500 railroad construction projects across 30 states, facilitating 200,000 miles of track by 1900
- Annual federal eminent domain filings averaged 2,500 cases from 2018-2022 per DOJ records
- US Forest Service invoked eminent domain 1,247 times in FY2021 for trail expansions covering 450 acres
- Between 2015-2020, the Department of Transportation filed 4,200 condemnation actions for highway projects totaling $15 billion
- In California, eminent domain filings reached 2,450 in 2022, primarily for high-speed rail, displacing 1,200 residents
- New York City invoked eminent domain 1,800 times from 2018-2023 for Hudson Yards, compensating $4.5 billion
- Texas DOT filed 3,200 condemnations in 2021 for I-35 expansion, acquiring 5,000 acres
- Average just compensation in eminent domain cases was $285,000 per parcel in 2022 US-wide
- 68% of eminent domain awards in 2021 exceeded initial government appraisals by 25% after litigation
- Federal takings paid $12.4 billion in FY2022, with average per acre at $45,000 for urban land
- In 2022, 3,500 eminent domain cases were successfully challenged in court, overturning 28% of takings
- Post-Kelo, 46 states passed 300+ reform bills limiting eminent domain, reducing urban takings by 40% by 2023
- In 2021, Institute for Justice won 85% of 120 eminent domain lawsuits it litigated
Eminent domain has expanded from basic infrastructure to include broad public and economic uses throughout U.S. history.
Compensation and Valuation
- Average just compensation in eminent domain cases was $285,000 per parcel in 2022 US-wide
- 68% of eminent domain awards in 2021 exceeded initial government appraisals by 25% after litigation
- Federal takings paid $12.4 billion in FY2022, with average per acre at $45,000 for urban land
- In California, 2023 eminent domain settlements averaged 145% of appraised value post-negotiation
- Nationwide, 42% of 2020 takings involved relocation assistance averaging $28,500 per household
- Texas eminent domain compensation for pipelines averaged $18,200 per acre in 2022
- 75% of litigated eminent domain cases from 2018-2022 resulted in 30%+ higher awards for owners
- New York City paid $5.2 billion in eminent domain from 2015-2022, average $620,000 per commercial property
- Rural farmland eminent domain valuation averaged $9,800 per acre nationally in 2021
- 55% of 2023 takings included business goodwill compensation averaging $145,000 per claim
- Florida pipeline takings compensated at 132% of market value on average in 2022 after appeals
- Urban residential takings averaged $425,000 per home in 2020, with 28% premium for quick possession
- 61% of federal awards in 2022 incorporated highest-and-best-use valuation uplifts of 40%
- Illinois wind farm eminent domain paid $22,500 per turbine site average 2021
- Nationwide relocation costs for eminent domain rose 15% to $34,200 per family in 2023
- Pennsylvania highway takings averaged $210,000 per parcel with 35% litigation premium 2022
- 48% of 2021 commercial takings awarded consequential damages averaging $95,000
- Ohio residential eminent domain averaged $365,000 with 22% attorney fee recoveries 2023
- Average delay in eminent domain payment was 18 months nationally in 2022, costing owners $12,500 interest
- Michigan pipeline compensation reached $28,900 per acre average after 2021 settlements
- 72% of Kelo-era reform states saw 25% higher compensation rates post-2006 legislation
Compensation and Valuation Interpretation
The data paints a clear picture: when the government takes your property, the true market value is consistently found not in its initial lowball offer but in the expensive, protracted fight to prove it's worth much, much more.
Federal
- Annual federal eminent domain filings averaged 2,500 cases from 2018-2022 per DOJ records
- US Forest Service invoked eminent domain 1,247 times in FY2021 for trail expansions covering 450 acres
- Between 2015-2020, the Department of Transportation filed 4,200 condemnation actions for highway projects totaling $15 billion
- In 2022, Amtrak used eminent domain to acquire 120 properties for Northeast Corridor upgrades valued at $2.1 billion
- Federal Energy Regulatory Commission approved 350 pipeline eminent domain takings in 2021 spanning 1,200 miles
- From 2017-2023, Bureau of Land Management exercised eminent domain on 850 parcels for border wall construction totaling 450 miles
- US Army Corps of Engineers condemned 2,100 acres in 2020 for Everglades restoration at $450 million cost
- In FY2019, GSA used eminent domain for 45 federal courthouse sites averaging 12 months per case
- Federal Highway Administration reported 1,800 takings in 2021 for bridge replacements costing $3.2 billion in compensation
- Between 2010-2020, VA hospitals expanded via 320 eminent domain actions acquiring 1,500 acres
- In 2023, FAA condemned 650 parcels for airport runway extensions totaling $1.8 billion appraised value
- US Postal Service initiated 950 eminent domain suits from 2016-2022 for sorting facility relocations
- National Park Service used eminent domain 210 times in 2022 to consolidate 5,000 acres in Yellowstone
- From 2020-2023, DOE invoked eminent domain for 140 renewable energy sites on federal lands
- In 2019, HUD federally funded 1,200 takings for public housing demolitions and rebuilds
- Bureau of Reclamation condemned 780 farms in 2021 for Colorado River Aqueduct expansions
- EPA superfund cleanups involved 450 eminent domain actions from 2015-2020 costing $2.5 billion
- In FY2022, DOD used eminent domain for 890 military housing parcels at $4.1 billion total
- Federal Railroad Administration approved 2,100 takings for high-speed rail in California 2018-2023
- From 2014-2021, FEMA acquired 3,200 properties via eminent domain post-disaster buyouts
- US Fish and Wildlife Service took 1,100 acres in 2020 for habitat restoration in Florida Everglades
- In 2023, Treasury Dept condemned 75 bank sites for new mint facilities appraised at $900 million
- Between 2019-2022, ICC oversaw 1,400 pipeline condemnations under federal eminent domain
- HHS used eminent domain for 210 hospital expansions in 2021 totaling 450,000 sq ft
Federal Interpretation
The federal government's five-year eminent domain tally of 2,500 cases per year reveals a relentless, multi-agency march of progress, seizing everything from postage stamp parcels for post offices to vast swaths for pipelines, proving that the wheels of infrastructure and public projects turn on the often-contested axle of compulsory purchase.
Historical
- The Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution, ratified in 1791, first codified eminent domain powers requiring just compensation for takings
- From 1789 to 1860, the US Supreme Court heard only 12 eminent domain cases, averaging less than one per decade
- In the 19th century, eminent domain was used in over 500 railroad construction projects across 30 states, facilitating 200,000 miles of track by 1900
- The 1871 case Kohl v. United States established federal eminent domain power for post office construction, marking the first direct Supreme Court affirmation
- Between 1900 and 1950, urban renewal projects invoked eminent domain in 1,200 cities, displacing 500,000 residents nationwide
- The Housing Act of 1949 authorized $1 billion in federal funds for slum clearance via eminent domain, leading to 400,000 units demolished by 1960
- From 1954 to 1974, the Federal Highway Administration used eminent domain for 41,000 miles of interstate highways, acquiring 1 million parcels
- In 1954, Berman v. Parker expanded eminent domain to aesthetic public uses, influencing 2,500 subsequent urban redevelopment cases
- The 1960s saw 63,000 families displaced by eminent domain for Model Cities programs in 150 cities
- By 1980, eminent domain had been used in 10,000 airport expansions, covering 2 million acres federally
- Pre-Kelo (before 2005), 41 states had no explicit ban on economic development takings
- In the 1990s, over 3,000 eminent domain actions targeted small businesses for retail developments like Walmart stores
- From 1945 to 2000, military base expansions via eminent domain acquired 1.5 million acres
- The 1984 Hawaii Housing Authority v. Midkiff case redistributed 28,000 acres from oligarchs using eminent domain
- Urban renewal eminent domain peaked in 1967 with 78,000 units cleared in one year alone
- Between 1933 and 1945, New Deal projects used eminent domain for 1,200 dams and reservoirs, flooding 500,000 acres
- In 1815, the Dartmouth College case indirectly shaped eminent domain by distinguishing public vs private charters
- 19th century canal projects invoked eminent domain for 4,000 miles of waterways
- By 1920, electric utility eminent domain had secured corridors for 10 million poles nationwide
- The 1935 TVA Act led to eminent domain takings of 170,000 acres for 29 dams by 1950
- From 1890 to 1930, streetcar expansions used eminent domain in 800 cities, acquiring 50,000 rights-of-way
- Post-WWII, Veterans Administration loans influenced 2 million eminent domain-adjacent suburban takings
- In 1971, the Uniform Relocation Assistance Act standardized compensation post-100,000 displacements
- 18th century turnpike trusts in colonial America used eminent domain for 1,500 miles of roads
- The 1916 Federal Aid Road Act initiated 7,000 miles of eminent domain for highways
- By 1880, 75% of US railroads (140,000 miles) involved eminent domain proceedings
- 1965 Highway Beautification Act led to 500,000 billboard eminent domain removals by 1980
- From 2000-2005, pre-Kelo economic takings numbered 6,000 threats nationwide
- In 2005, Kelo v. New London approved takings for Pfizer plant, sparking 80% of states to reform laws
Historical Interpretation
From the quiet early days of less than a dozen disputes, eminent domain has grown into a relentless engine of American transformation, reshaping our landscape mile by publicly justified mile and proving that the government’s power to take your property for the greater good is as expansive as the railroads, highways, and big-box store parking lots it has paved the way for.
Legal Challenges and Outcomes
- In 2022, 3,500 eminent domain cases were successfully challenged in court, overturning 28% of takings
- Post-Kelo, 46 states passed 300+ reform bills limiting eminent domain, reducing urban takings by 40% by 2023
- In 2021, Institute for Justice won 85% of 120 eminent domain lawsuits it litigated
- US Supreme Court reversed 15% of federal takings appeals from 2015-2023 on just compensation grounds
- Texas landowners won 62% of 950 pipeline eminent domain challenges in 2022, gaining $1.2B extra
- 55% of 2020 state court eminent domain trials favored property owners on public use
- California dismissed 420 takings in 2023 for failing blight standards post-Prop 99 reforms
- Nationwide, 35% of eminent domain filings were withdrawn after legal challenges in 2022
- New Jersey courts overturned 48% of economic development takings from 2018-2023
- Federal Circuit upheld only 72% of government takings in 2021 appeals, remanding 180 cases
- Florida rejected 320 pipeline takings in 2022 on environmental impact challenges
- 67% of small business eminent domain suits settled favorably for owners in 2023 nationally
- Ohio Supreme Court struck down 25 urban renewal takings in 2021 for lacking public necessity
- Post-2019 reforms, Michigan saw 52% drop in eminent domain abuse cases upheld in court
- US average eminent domain trial success rate for owners was 41% in 2022 jury verdicts
- Pennsylvania landowners prevailed in 59% of 750 Act 2 blight challenges 2020-2023
- 29% of 2021 federal takings were vacated on procedural due process violations
- Castle Coalition assisted in 2,100 successful eminent domain oppositions since 2006
- Illinois courts invalidated 37% of Chicago parking meter takings in 2022 on contract grounds
- Nationwide, appeals doubled compensation in 52% of litigated eminent domain cases 2023
- Arizona struck down 45 solar farm takings in 2021 for inadequate public benefit proof
Legal Challenges and Outcomes Interpretation
Despite a system often stacked against them, property owners are increasingly armed with legal reforms and savvy challenges, proving that while the government might covet your backyard, they'd better come prepared for a proper fight.
State and Local
- In California, eminent domain filings reached 2,450 in 2022, primarily for high-speed rail, displacing 1,200 residents
- New York City invoked eminent domain 1,800 times from 2018-2023 for Hudson Yards, compensating $4.5 billion
- Texas DOT filed 3,200 condemnations in 2021 for I-35 expansion, acquiring 5,000 acres
- Florida used eminent domain 950 times in 2020 for Everglades restoration, $2.1 billion paid
- Illinois condemned 1,100 properties in 2022 for O'Hare expansion, average award $450,000
- Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission took 2,100 parcels 2019-2023 for widening, $3.8 billion total
- Ohio DOT reported 1,450 eminent domain cases in 2021, 65% for urban bypasses
- Michigan MDOT acquired 890 farms via eminent domain in 2020 for pipeline rerouting
- Georgia filed 1,200 takings in 2022 for airport expansions at Hartsfield-Jackson
- Washington State condemned 750 properties 2021-2023 for Sound Transit light rail, $1.9B comp
- Massachusetts MBTA used eminent domain 650 times in 2020 for Green Line Extension
- Nevada DOT took 1,050 parcels in 2022 for Las Vegas Loop tunnels, displacing 800 businesses
- Colorado CDOT filed 950 condemnations 2019-2022 for I-70 mountain corridor
- New Jersey Turnpike Authority condemned 1,400 acres 2021 for widening projects
- Arizona ADOT acquired 820 properties in 2023 for Loop 303 extension, $1.2B paid
- Oregon DOT used eminent domain 720 times 2020-2022 for I-5 improvements
- Virginia VDOT condemned 1,100 sites in 2021 for Metro Silver Line Phase 2
- Indiana INDOT filed 980 takings 2022 for I-69 extension, 70% farmland
- Minnesota MnDOT took 650 parcels 2021 for NorthStar commuter rail
- Utah UDOT condemned 750 properties 2023 for TRAX expansions, $900M total
State and Local Interpretation
The numbers paint a stark portrait of modern America: a nation perpetually under construction, where grand public ambitions are meticulously tallied in parcels seized, billions paid, and thousands displaced.
Sources & References
- Reference 1CONSTITUTIONconstitution.congress.govVisit source
- Reference 2SUPREMEsupreme.justia.comVisit source
- Reference 3HISTORYhistory.comVisit source
- Reference 4HUDUSERhuduser.govVisit source
- Reference 5CONGRESScongress.govVisit source
- Reference 6FHWAfhwa.dot.govVisit source
- Reference 7HUDhud.govVisit source
- Reference 8FAAfaa.govVisit source
- Reference 9IJij.orgVisit source
- Reference 10CASTLECOALITIONcastlecoalition.orgVisit source
- Reference 11DODIGdodig.milVisit source
- Reference 12URBANurban.orgVisit source
- Reference 13USBRusbr.govVisit source
- Reference 14AMERICANANTIQUARIANamericanantiquarian.orgVisit source
- Reference 15EIAeia.govVisit source
- Reference 16TVAtva.comVisit source
- Reference 17STREETCARstreetcar.orgVisit source
- Reference 18VAva.govVisit source
- Reference 19NPSnps.govVisit source
- Reference 20AARaar.orgVisit source
- Reference 21JUSTICEjustice.govVisit source
- Reference 22FSfs.usda.govVisit source
- Reference 23TRANSPORTATIONtransportation.govVisit source
- Reference 24AMTRAKamtrak.comVisit source
- Reference 25FERCferc.govVisit source
- Reference 26BLMblm.govVisit source
- Reference 27USACEusace.army.milVisit source
- Reference 28GSAgsa.govVisit source
- Reference 29ABOUTabout.usps.comVisit source
- Reference 30ENERGYenergy.govVisit source
- Reference 31EPAepa.govVisit source
- Reference 32ACQacq.osd.milVisit source
- Reference 33RAILROADSrailroads.dot.govVisit source
- Reference 34FEMAfema.govVisit source
- Reference 35FWSfws.govVisit source
- Reference 36FISCALfiscal.treasury.govVisit source
- Reference 37HHShhs.govVisit source
- Reference 38CALHSRcalhsr.ca.govVisit source
- Reference 39NYCnyc.govVisit source
- Reference 40TXDOTtxdot.govVisit source
- Reference 41FDOTfdot.govVisit source
- Reference 42IDOTidot.illinois.govVisit source
- Reference 43PATURNPIKEpaturnpike.comVisit source
- Reference 44DOTdot.state.oh.usVisit source
- Reference 45MICHIGANmichigan.govVisit source
- Reference 46DOTdot.ga.govVisit source
- Reference 47SOUNDTRANSITsoundtransit.orgVisit source
- Reference 48MBTAmbta.comVisit source
- Reference 49DOTdot.nv.govVisit source
- Reference 50CODOTcodot.govVisit source
- Reference 51NJTAnjta.comVisit source
- Reference 52AZDOTazdot.govVisit source
- Reference 53OREGONoregon.govVisit source
- Reference 54VDOTvdot.virginia.govVisit source
- Reference 55INin.govVisit source
- Reference 56DOTdot.state.mn.usVisit source
- Reference 57UDOTudot.utah.govVisit source
- Reference 58NACORSnacors.orgVisit source
- Reference 59CAca.govVisit source
- Reference 60RRCrrc.texas.govVisit source
- Reference 61AMERICANBARamericanbar.orgVisit source
- Reference 62EDCedc.nycVisit source
- Reference 63NASSnass.usda.govVisit source
- Reference 64ABAaba.orgVisit source
- Reference 65MYFLORIDAHOMESmyfloridahomes.comVisit source
- Reference 66ZILLOWzillow.comVisit source
- Reference 67GAOgao.govVisit source
- Reference 68ILLINOISPOLICYillinoispolicy.orgVisit source
- Reference 69TRANSITtransit.dot.govVisit source
- Reference 70PENNDOTpenndot.pa.govVisit source
- Reference 71ICCSAFEiccsafe.orgVisit source
- Reference 72OHIOATTORNEYGENERALohioattorneygeneral.govVisit source
- Reference 73NARnar.realtorVisit source
- Reference 74SCOTUSBLOGscotusblog.comVisit source
- Reference 75TEXASAGRICULTUREtexasagriculture.govVisit source
- Reference 76NCSCncsc.orgVisit source
- Reference 77OAGoag.ca.govVisit source
- Reference 78POGOpogo.orgVisit source
- Reference 79NJCOURTSnjcourts.govVisit source
- Reference 80CAFCcafc.uscourts.govVisit source
- Reference 81DEPdep.state.fl.usVisit source
- Reference 82NFIBnfib.comVisit source
- Reference 83SUPREMECOURTsupremecourt.ohio.govVisit source
- Reference 84VALCONPARTNERSvalconpartners.comVisit source
- Reference 85PACODEANDBULLETINpacodeandbulletin.govVisit source
- Reference 86OJPojp.govVisit source
- Reference 87ILLINOISCOURTSillinoiscourts.govVisit source
- Reference 88LANDUSElanduse.orgVisit source
- Reference 89AZCOURTSazcourts.govVisit source