GITNUXSOFTWARE ADVICE
Sports RecreationTop 10 Best Membership Club Software of 2026
Discover top membership club software solutions to streamline operations and boost engagement.
How we ranked these tools
Core product claims cross-referenced against official documentation, changelogs, and independent technical reviews.
Analyzed video reviews and hundreds of written evaluations to capture real-world user experiences with each tool.
AI persona simulations modeled how different user types would experience each tool across common use cases and workflows.
Final rankings reviewed and approved by our editorial team with authority to override AI-generated scores based on domain expertise.
Score: Features 40% · Ease 30% · Value 30%
Gitnux may earn a commission through links on this page — this does not influence rankings. Editorial policy
Editor picks
Three quick recommendations before you dive into the full comparison below — each one leads on a different dimension.
Circle
Gated community access with memberships that control who can view posts and content
Built for coaches and creators running subscription communities with live events and gated content.
Mighty Networks
Branded community hubs with integrated events and livestreaming inside membership spaces
Built for creators and brands building community memberships with basic course delivery.
Patreon
Tiered memberships with patron perks and gated posts inside the Patreon app
Built for creators needing recurring membership tiers, perks, and engagement in one system.
Related reading
Comparison Table
This comparison table benchmarks Membership Club Software platforms such as Circle, Mighty Networks, Patreon, Kajabi, and Memberful across core capabilities. You can scan key differences in memberships, community and content tools, payments and payout workflows, and moderation features to match each platform to your use case.
| # | Tool | Category | Overall | Features | Ease of Use | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Circle Runs community and membership spaces with subscriptions, content areas, and built-in engagement tools. | community membership | 8.9/10 | 8.8/10 | 8.6/10 | 8.3/10 |
| 2 | Mighty Networks Creates membership communities with paid subscriptions, courses, and member content areas in one platform. | community platform | 8.4/10 | 8.7/10 | 8.0/10 | 7.9/10 |
| 3 | Patreon Manages recurring memberships with creator subscriptions, tiers, member messaging, and access controls. | creator membership | 8.1/10 | 8.4/10 | 8.0/10 | 7.7/10 |
| 4 | Kajabi Provides membership products with paid funnels, course content access, and subscription billing. | all-in-one | 8.1/10 | 8.4/10 | 7.9/10 | 7.6/10 |
| 5 | Memberful Adds membership subscriptions, paywalls, and content access controls to websites via checkout and integrations. | membership payments | 7.6/10 | 8.0/10 | 7.4/10 | 7.8/10 |
| 6 | MemberSpace Delivers membership sites with paid tiers, gated content, and community features for small teams. | membership site | 7.6/10 | 7.8/10 | 7.2/10 | 7.7/10 |
| 7 | Tilda Builds subscription landing pages and membership funnels that connect to payment and content delivery tools. | conversion builder | 7.2/10 | 7.0/10 | 8.3/10 | 7.1/10 |
| 8 | WordPress VIP Hosts WordPress with enterprise performance and security while enabling membership features through the WordPress ecosystem. | enterprise hosting | 7.8/10 | 7.2/10 | 7.0/10 | 7.9/10 |
| 9 | ThriveCart Processes one-time and subscription payments for member access using customizable checkout flows. | checkout subscriptions | 7.4/10 | 7.6/10 | 7.2/10 | 7.8/10 |
| 10 | Thinkific Offers paid programs with subscription-style access controls that support memberships around learning content. | course membership | 8.1/10 | 8.6/10 | 7.8/10 | 7.5/10 |
Runs community and membership spaces with subscriptions, content areas, and built-in engagement tools.
Creates membership communities with paid subscriptions, courses, and member content areas in one platform.
Manages recurring memberships with creator subscriptions, tiers, member messaging, and access controls.
Provides membership products with paid funnels, course content access, and subscription billing.
Adds membership subscriptions, paywalls, and content access controls to websites via checkout and integrations.
Delivers membership sites with paid tiers, gated content, and community features for small teams.
Builds subscription landing pages and membership funnels that connect to payment and content delivery tools.
Hosts WordPress with enterprise performance and security while enabling membership features through the WordPress ecosystem.
Processes one-time and subscription payments for member access using customizable checkout flows.
Offers paid programs with subscription-style access controls that support memberships around learning content.
Circle
community membershipRuns community and membership spaces with subscriptions, content areas, and built-in engagement tools.
Gated community access with memberships that control who can view posts and content
Circle stands out for turning your membership site into a simple, product-like experience using a modern community space plus paid access controls. It combines discussions, categories, and announcements with built-in memberships so members can access gated content without custom engineering. The platform also supports livestreams and recordings to run live events inside the same community. Creator-focused workflows like onboarding emails and member directory tools help clubs operate like ongoing programs, not static webpages.
Pros
- Strong memberships and gated access built directly into the community experience
- Discussion, announcements, and categories support consistent member engagement
- Live events and replay content keep membership activities centralized
- Clean UI reduces setup friction for club owners and moderators
- Member onboarding and communications help reduce early churn
Cons
- Customization options can feel limiting versus full custom community stacks
- Advanced automation and integrations are narrower than broader SaaS platforms
- Content and community management tools may need add-ons for complex needs
Best For
Coaches and creators running subscription communities with live events and gated content
More related reading
Mighty Networks
community platformCreates membership communities with paid subscriptions, courses, and member content areas in one platform.
Branded community hubs with integrated events and livestreaming inside membership spaces
Mighty Networks stands out with a community-first membership experience that blends events, courses, and community spaces in one branded home. It supports member profiles, groups, posts, and discussions alongside gated content and basic automation for onboarding and announcements. The platform includes livestreaming and events for live engagement and uses subscriptions to monetize access to communities and content. Its learning management features are usable for simple course delivery but are less robust than dedicated LMS platforms for advanced curriculum management.
Pros
- Community spaces, discussions, and member profiles support strong engagement
- Gated memberships and subscriptions monetize access to groups and content
- Built-in events and livestreams reduce reliance on third-party tools
- Brandable pages help create a consistent community storefront
Cons
- Advanced LMS workflows like complex prerequisites are limited
- Customization depth for themes and templates is constrained
- Reporting focuses more on engagement than deep learning analytics
- Higher tiers are often required for granular features
Best For
Creators and brands building community memberships with basic course delivery
Patreon
creator membershipManages recurring memberships with creator subscriptions, tiers, member messaging, and access controls.
Tiered memberships with patron perks and gated posts inside the Patreon app
Patreon stands out for monetizing ongoing creator work with membership tiers and built-in patron engagement. It supports recurring payments, tier-based perks, and membership goals that link audience actions to creator progress. The platform also includes messaging tools, comment moderation, and content posting for members only. Reporting and analytics cover earnings and subscriber trends, but advanced community tooling remains lighter than dedicated membership club systems.
Pros
- Tier-based membership perks connect payments directly to member access
- Built-in recurring billing simplifies churn-prone membership management
- Member messaging and comment controls support ongoing community engagement
- Earnings and patron analytics make it easier to track growth
Cons
- Membership ownership and customization are limited versus standalone club platforms
- Advanced event, scheduling, and CRM-style workflows need external tools
- Content gating depends on Patreon’s system, not deep custom rules
Best For
Creators needing recurring membership tiers, perks, and engagement in one system
More related reading
Kajabi
all-in-oneProvides membership products with paid funnels, course content access, and subscription billing.
Membership access controls combined with course delivery and funnel-based marketing in one system
Kajabi stands out with an all-in-one workflow for building memberships, courses, and marketing funnels inside a single dashboard. It supports subscription-based access with gated content, flexible landing pages, and email automation tied to member events. Its learning and community stack is strongest for selling and delivering structured programs rather than running heavy discussion forums. You can manage members, automate onboarding, and track performance through built-in analytics without assembling multiple tools.
Pros
- Gated membership access with subscriptions for courses and content
- Built-in email automation for member onboarding and lifecycle nudges
- Drag-and-drop landing pages for funnels tied to offers
- One dashboard to manage products, members, and marketing assets
Cons
- Community features are lighter than dedicated forum platforms
- Advanced customization can require workarounds in templates
- Reporting and attribution are less detailed than specialized analytics
- Automation logic is less flexible than workflow-first tools
Best For
Creators selling subscription learning programs with built-in marketing automation
Memberful
membership paymentsAdds membership subscriptions, paywalls, and content access controls to websites via checkout and integrations.
Gated access control that automatically unlocks member-only content after subscription payment
Memberful stands out for its focus on paid membership experiences delivered through a simple membership storefront and automated access control. It supports subscriptions, memberships tiers, and recurring billing workflows that connect membership purchases to site access. The platform also includes marketing tools like email sending and deal-style promotions alongside integrations for websites and community tools.
Pros
- Strong subscription and membership tier management with recurring billing workflows
- Built-in access control ties purchases to member entitlements
- Marketing tools include emails and promotional offers for converting leads
- Good integration options for embedding membership experiences into existing sites
Cons
- Limited advanced community feature depth compared with dedicated community platforms
- Customization beyond themes and settings often requires technical effort
- Reporting granularity is less robust than enterprise billing analytics tools
Best For
Small to mid-sized memberships needing subscription billing and gated content
MemberSpace
membership siteDelivers membership sites with paid tiers, gated content, and community features for small teams.
Tier-based membership access that gates content and features by plan.
MemberSpace focuses on building member communities with a club-style membership portal, payment handling, and gated content. It includes tools for tiers, membership approvals, and automated messaging around membership status changes. The platform also supports events and basic admin workflows for managing members and access. Strong emphasis on subscription-to-community operations makes it a better fit for membership clubs than for general website CMS needs.
Pros
- Membership portal includes tiered access and member management in one system
- Subscription billing workflows are built around membership status changes
- Events and gated content support common club membership use cases
Cons
- Customization options can feel limited versus fully flexible community platforms
- Advanced automation and integrations require more effort than boutique systems
- Reporting depth is not as strong as dedicated analytics-focused products
Best For
Membership clubs needing tiered access, member workflows, and subscriptions in one place
More related reading
Tilda
conversion builderBuilds subscription landing pages and membership funnels that connect to payment and content delivery tools.
Visual drag-and-drop page builder for membership onboarding and delivery experiences
Tilda stands out with a visual page builder that lets you design membership-facing landing pages and onboarding screens without code. It supports gated content via membership-style access patterns, plus email and marketing integrations for delivering value after checkout. You can organize community and program content into clear page sections and funnels, which works well for content-first membership businesses. It is less focused on full community automation and native member management workflows than dedicated membership platforms.
Pros
- Visual builder enables fast, brand-consistent membership page and course layouts
- Flexible content pages support onboarding, program delivery, and upsells
- Integrations help automate email and marketing for member lifecycle messaging
- Strong landing page tooling reduces dependence on a separate front-end
Cons
- Membership-specific features lag behind dedicated membership systems
- Member management workflows are limited for complex cohorts and permissions
- Gated access and tracking require more setup than built for community platforms
- Community tools are not as robust as forum-first membership products
Best For
Content-led memberships needing custom design and simple gating
WordPress VIP
enterprise hostingHosts WordPress with enterprise performance and security while enabling membership features through the WordPress ecosystem.
VIP managed hosting with enterprise-grade security and support for WordPress member experiences
WordPress VIP stands out by offering managed WordPress hosting tightly integrated with enterprise-grade performance, security, and support. It supports membership functionality through WordPress plugins and VIP-compatible configurations rather than a dedicated membership engine. You get scalable infrastructure, SSO-compatible workflows through common enterprise integrations, and operational guardrails for large sites that need reliable member access. Best fit is teams that want membership features inside WordPress with strong managed hosting and clear operational ownership.
Pros
- Managed WordPress infrastructure with strong performance tuning for high-traffic membership sites
- Enterprise support model with operational ownership for uptime, security, and incident response
- Scales well with large WordPress-based member experiences and complex page architectures
Cons
- No native membership club platform included, so capabilities rely on plugins and integrations
- Setup and migrations can be complex because the stack is tightly managed
- Costs can be high for small sites that only need basic memberships
Best For
Large WordPress membership sites needing managed reliability and security
More related reading
ThriveCart
checkout subscriptionsProcesses one-time and subscription payments for member access using customizable checkout flows.
Subscription checkout with built-in upsells, downsells, and order bumps
ThriveCart stands out for selling memberships through its conversion-first checkout and payment flows. It supports subscription billing with integrations that connect member access to purchase outcomes. It also provides upsells, downsells, and order bumps that help turn one-time purchases into ongoing access. As a membership club platform, it is stronger for monetization than for full community features.
Pros
- Conversion-focused checkout designed for subscriptions and membership renewals
- Subscription billing plus flexible order bumps and upsells
- Integrations can automate access provisioning based on purchases
Cons
- Community features like forums and built-in messaging are not its core strength
- Membership workflows rely on integrations for access control
- Setup complexity rises with advanced funnels and multiple offers
Best For
Creators selling subscription access with optimized checkouts and upsell funnels
Thinkific
course membershipOffers paid programs with subscription-style access controls that support memberships around learning content.
Drip content scheduling tied to member access periods
Thinkific stands out by combining membership-style gated content with a full course creation and delivery system. It supports paid subscriptions, drip scheduling, and community-style engagement through its integrated course and messaging experiences. Membership management is strongest when your “club” is primarily educational content with recurring access rather than pure event-first memberships. You also get marketing tools like landing pages and email capture to drive enrollments.
Pros
- Built-in course and membership gating for recurring access
- Drip scheduling supports structured onboarding for club members
- Landing pages and conversion tools help drive membership signups
- Strong analytics for learning activity and engagement signals
- Works well for cohorts where content access follows a calendar
Cons
- Community and membership tooling feels secondary to course delivery
- Advanced club workflows need more setup than event-only membership platforms
- Theme customization options can require design effort for unique branding
- Automation flexibility is less robust than dedicated membership workflow tools
Best For
Educators and creators selling recurring gated learning communities
Conclusion
After evaluating 10 sports recreation, Circle stands out as our overall top pick — it scored highest across our combined criteria of features, ease of use, and value, which is why it sits at #1 in the rankings above.
Use the comparison table and detailed reviews above to validate the fit against your own requirements before committing to a tool.
How to Choose the Right Membership Club Software
This buyer’s guide walks you through how to evaluate membership club software using the actual capabilities of Circle, Mighty Networks, Patreon, Kajabi, and Thinkific. It also covers supporting tools like Memberful, MemberSpace, Tilda, ThriveCart, and WordPress VIP for specific club workflows that don’t fit a single product shape.
What Is Membership Club Software?
Membership club software lets you gate content by member status and run ongoing member experiences in one place. It solves the operational problem of coordinating recurring access, member communications, and member-only posts or learning without stitching together fragile custom work. Many teams also use it to centralize engagement through discussions, livestreams, events, or course delivery. Circle and Mighty Networks are built around community-first membership experiences with gating and engagement inside the same platform.
Key Features to Look For
The right features determine whether your club feels like a consistent program or a set of disconnected tools.
Gated access controlled by memberships
Look for membership rules that control who can view posts, content, and member-only areas. Circle excels with gated community access where subscriptions control who can see posts and content, and Memberful focuses on automatic unlocking of member-only content after subscription payment.
Community engagement primitives inside the membership space
Forum-style components and structured engagement reduce reliance on third-party tools for member participation. Circle includes discussions, announcements, and categories, while Mighty Networks supports community spaces with groups, posts, and discussions plus member profiles.
Built-in live events with recordings
If your membership includes recurring live sessions, native livestream support keeps events, access, and replay content centralized. Circle supports livestreams and replay content in the same community, and Mighty Networks also includes livestreams and events inside membership spaces.
Onboarding and member communications for churn prevention
Membership clubs need automated lifecycle nudges that make new members productive quickly. Circle provides onboarding emails and member communications, and Kajabi adds email automation tied to member events to support membership onboarding.
Course delivery with drip scheduling and learning-focused analytics
If your club is primarily education, learning workflows should run alongside access control. Thinkific provides drip scheduling tied to member access periods and strong analytics for learning activity, and Kajabi pairs gated membership access with course delivery and funnel-based marketing in one dashboard.
Conversion and storefront workflows for membership sales
If you need to sell access and immediately grant entitlements, checkout and funnel features matter more than deep forum tooling. ThriveCart delivers conversion-focused subscription checkouts with upsells, downsells, and order bumps, while Tilda focuses on visual membership onboarding and delivery flows with a drag-and-drop page builder.
How to Choose the Right Membership Club Software
Pick the tool that matches your club’s primary engine, which is usually community engagement, learning delivery, WordPress hosting, or checkout-driven access.
Choose your club’s primary experience: community, learning, or checkout
If members spend their time in discussions, announcements, and gated posts, Circle and Mighty Networks are designed around that community-first experience. If members primarily consume structured learning with recurring access, Thinkific and Kajabi combine membership access control with course delivery. If your priority is maximizing enrollment conversion and immediate access provisioning, ThriveCart and Memberful focus on selling subscriptions and unlocking content after purchase.
Map access control to actual entitlements you need
Circle is a strong fit when you want memberships to control who can view posts and content inside a community. MemberSpace and Memberful both emphasize tier-based access that gates content and features by plan, which helps when your club requires multiple member levels with different entitlements.
Verify engagement features match your event and interaction rhythm
For live programming, confirm native livestream support and replay handling in the same membership environment. Circle centralizes livestreams and replay content in the community, and Mighty Networks includes built-in livestreams and events inside membership spaces. If you rely on tier perks and member messaging inside a creators-first app, Patreon supports tier-based perks with patron messaging and comment controls.
Evaluate marketing and onboarding automation depth for your lifecycle
Membership clubs churn when onboarding and lifecycle messaging are inconsistent, so choose tools with onboarding workflows tied to member actions. Circle’s onboarding emails and member communications are built for ongoing program operations, and Kajabi uses email automation tied to member events to manage member lifecycle nudges.
Plan for customization and integrations based on your operational complexity
If you need deep community customization beyond themes, Circle can feel limiting versus full custom community stacks, and Mighty Networks can constrain theme and template customization. If you operate a large WordPress-based membership site, WordPress VIP delivers managed WordPress infrastructure and security while membership capabilities depend on plugins. If you need flexible conversion flows and entitlements through external integrations, ThriveCart and Memberful rely on integrations for access provisioning and advanced membership workflows.
Who Needs Membership Club Software?
Membership club software serves clubs that must combine gated access with ongoing engagement, recurring delivery, or reliable member operations.
Coaches and creators running subscription communities with gated posts and live sessions
Circle fits this audience because it combines gated community access with discussions, announcements, categories, and built-in livestreams plus replays. Mighty Networks also matches this motion with branded community hubs that include integrated events and livestreaming.
Creators and brands building community memberships with basic course delivery
Mighty Networks is built for community spaces with member profiles, groups, posts, and discussions paired with gated subscriptions. Kajabi is also a fit when you want membership access controls combined with course delivery and funnel-based marketing in one dashboard.
Creators focused on recurring patron tiers with perks and messaging
Patreon fits creators who want tier-based perks tied directly to membership access and engagement through messaging and comment moderation. It is best when you want membership monetization and member engagement in one creator-first system rather than heavy forum tooling.
Educators and creators delivering recurring gated learning with structured onboarding
Thinkific fits clubs where the learning calendar matters because it includes drip content scheduling tied to member access periods and learning activity analytics. Kajabi also supports membership access control with learning delivery and email automation tied to member events.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
The biggest failures happen when teams pick software for the wrong primary job or underestimate how access control and community tooling will affect day-to-day operations.
Choosing a course platform for an event-first community
Thinkific and Kajabi are strong when educational content is the center of gravity, and community tools feel secondary for event-first membership workflows. Circle and Mighty Networks reduce this mismatch by centralizing gated community engagement with livestreams and replays inside the membership environment.
Overbuilding custom community rules on a tool with limited customization depth
Circle can feel limiting when you need advanced customization beyond its built-in community experience, and Mighty Networks can constrain theme and template customization depth. MemberSpace and Tilda also lean toward membership portal patterns and visual page building, so complex forum-like customization often requires extra effort.
Relying on sales checkout tools as if they were full community platforms
ThriveCart is strongest for conversion-first subscription checkouts and upsell mechanics, and community forums and built-in messaging are not its core strength. Memberful similarly focuses on gated access control tied to purchases, so teams needing deep discussions and announcements usually outgrow these checkout-centric workflows without add-ons.
Forgetting that managed WordPress hosting still needs membership functionality through plugins
WordPress VIP provides enterprise performance, security, and support for WordPress member experiences, but it does not include a native membership club platform. Teams depending on WordPress VIP must design the membership engine through plugins and configurations to match their gating, messaging, and member portal requirements.
How We Selected and Ranked These Tools
We evaluated Circle, Mighty Networks, Patreon, Kajabi, Memberful, MemberSpace, Tilda, WordPress VIP, ThriveCart, and Thinkific across overall capability, feature depth, ease of use, and value for membership club operations. We separated Circle from lower-ranked tools by prioritizing gated access inside a community experience that includes discussions, announcements, categories, and built-in livestreams with replay content. We also rewarded tools that reduce operational assembly by combining core membership control with the engagement or delivery workflow you use most. Lower-ranked options tended to be strongest in a narrower job such as conversion-first checkout, managed WordPress hosting infrastructure, or learning-focused delivery rather than all-around club community operations.
Frequently Asked Questions About Membership Club Software
Which platform is best when I want gated community posts plus livestreams in the same place?
Circle supports gated community access where memberships control who can view posts and content, and it also runs livestreams and recordings inside the same community space. Mighty Networks provides livestreams and events inside branded membership hubs, but Circle’s access control is tightly linked to the community itself.
What should I choose if my membership club is mostly structured courses with recurring access rather than heavy forums?
Thinkific is strong when your club is primarily educational content because it pairs membership-style gated access with course creation, drip scheduling, and integrated messaging. Kajabi also combines subscription access controls with course delivery and analytics, but Thinkific’s “club as curriculum” design is more central.
How do I handle tier-based access and member onboarding workflows without building custom logic?
MemberSpace includes tier-based membership access plus approvals and automated messaging for membership status changes. Kajabi and Circle both support onboarding workflows like automated email sequences and member management, but MemberSpace focuses specifically on club-style member operations.
Which tools are better for a community-first experience with discussions, groups, and a branded hub?
Mighty Networks is built around a community-first membership experience with member profiles, groups, discussions, and gated content in one branded home. Circle also emphasizes a modern community space with discussions and categories, and it adds stronger paid access controls that gate what members can view.
If I want membership tiers with engagement features like messaging and moderated member comments, which option fits?
Patreon supports tier-based memberships with member messaging plus comment moderation and member-only posting. Circle and Mighty Networks also support community engagement, but Patreon’s standout strength is tiered patron perks tied to creator output rather than full community tooling.
What’s the best fit for a membership storefront that automatically unlocks content after checkout?
Memberful focuses on a paid membership storefront and automated access control that unlocks member-only content after subscription payment. ThriveCart is stronger for conversion-oriented checkout flows with subscription billing, upsells, downsells, and order bumps that drive ongoing access.
How do I compare Circle vs Mighty Networks for live engagement inside a membership community?
Circle combines gated membership access with livestreams and recordings in the same community environment. Mighty Networks also includes livestreams and events, but it emphasizes branded community hubs and course-like delivery more than tightly coupled gated access.
Which platform is safest for large WordPress membership sites that need managed hosting and security controls?
WordPress VIP is designed for large WordPress member experiences with managed hosting, enterprise-grade security, and support. It delivers membership functionality through WordPress plugins and VIP-compatible configurations rather than replacing the WordPress stack with a dedicated membership engine.
What’s a common failure mode when using a general page builder for membership delivery, and who avoids it best?
Tilda can be excellent for membership-facing landing pages and onboarding screens, but it is less focused on full community automation and native member management workflows. Kajabi and Circle reduce this risk by tying gated access and member operations directly into the core product experience.
Tools reviewed
Referenced in the comparison table and product reviews above.
Keep exploring
Comparing two specific tools?
Software Alternatives
See head-to-head software comparisons with feature breakdowns, pricing, and our recommendation for each use case.
Explore software alternatives→In this category
Sports Recreation alternatives
See side-by-side comparisons of sports recreation tools and pick the right one for your stack.
Compare sports recreation tools→FOR SOFTWARE VENDORS
Not on this list? Let’s fix that.
Our best-of pages are how many teams discover and compare tools in this space. If you think your product belongs in this lineup, we’d like to hear from you—we’ll walk you through fit and what an editorial entry looks like.
Apply for a ListingWHAT THIS INCLUDES
Where buyers compare
Readers come to these pages to shortlist software—your product shows up in that moment, not in a random sidebar.
Editorial write-up
We describe your product in our own words and check the facts before anything goes live.
On-page brand presence
You appear in the roundup the same way as other tools we cover: name, positioning, and a clear next step for readers who want to learn more.
Kept up to date
We refresh lists on a regular rhythm so the category page stays useful as products and pricing change.