While the juvenile justice system reaches historic lows in overall arrests, it continues to wear two faces: one of progress and another of persistent, glaring inequities.
Key Takeaways
- In 2020, the juvenile arrest rate for all offenses reached its lowest level since at least 1980
- Black youth are 4.4 times as likely to be arrested as white youth
- Female arrests accounted for approximately 30% of all juvenile arrests in 2020
- On a single day in 2019, 36,479 youth were held in residential placement facilities
- Youth of color represent 67% of the total population in juvenile residential placement
- Approximately 40% of youth in placement are held in private facilities
- Up to 70% of youth in the juvenile justice system have at least one mental health condition
- 20% of youth in the juvenile justice system have a serious mental illness
- 30% of youth in the system have a learning disability
- In 2019, juvenile courts handled 722,600 delinquency cases
- 52% of all delinquency cases were formally handled (petitioned) by the court
- The number of delinquency cases in 2019 was 56% lower than in 2005
- Recidivism rates within 3 years for youth released from residential care range from 70% to 80% in some states
- It costs an average of $214,620 per year to incarcerate a single youth in a state facility
- Community-based programs for youth cost approximately $75 per day compared to $588 for incarceration
While overall juvenile arrests have dramatically declined, significant racial disparities and deep systemic challenges persist.
Court Processing and Legal Reform
- In 2019, juvenile courts handled 722,600 delinquency cases
- 52% of all delinquency cases were formally handled (petitioned) by the court
- The number of delinquency cases in 2019 was 56% lower than in 2005
- Diversion was used in 48% of all delinquency cases in 2019
- Formal probation was the most common disposition (63%) for adjudicated cases
- 28% of adjudicated delinquency cases resulted in residential placement
- Transfer to adult criminal court occurred in less than 1% of all delinquency cases
- Approximately 3,400 cases were waived to adult court by judicial discretion in 2019
- 46 states have laws allowing juveniles to be prosecuted as adults for certain crimes
- The "Rise the Age" movement led 5 states to change their age of jurisdiction since 2015
- Black youth are 40% more likely to have their cases waived to adult court than white youth
- 77% of status offense cases involved truancy or liquor law violations
- 44% of status offense cases were handled informally
- Defense attorneys are appointed for 100% of indigent youth in most states but caseloads exceed 100 per attorney
- 20 states allow "direct file" by prosecutors into adult court without judicial review
- In 2019, 14% of delinquency cases were dismissed by the court
- Public order offenses accounted for 27% of all delinquency cases in 2019
- Drug law violations accounted for 13% of all delinquency cases
- Violent crime cases represented 28% of all delinquency cases in court
- The use of detention for youth awaiting court decreased by 42% since 2005
- Juvenile courts in the south handle 37% of all delinquency cases in the US
- Restitution was ordered in 9% of all adjudicated delinquency cases
- 80% of adjudicated youth receive a "community-based" sentence
- Cases involving Black youth are less likely to be diverted than those of White youth (41% vs 51%)
- In 2019, 17,900 delinquency cases involved youth age 10 or younger
- There are over 2,500 juvenile courts operating in the United States
- 24 states have eliminated "life without parole" for juveniles
- 31% of youth in court cases were female in 2019
- Judicial waiver cases for property crimes dropped by 80% since 1994
- Approximately 20% of youth cases result in a "transfer" to civil service or child welfare
Court Processing and Legal Reform Interpretation
This data paints a portrait of a system that, despite making encouraging strides like a 56% drop in caseloads and a 42% reduction in pre-court detention, remains a paradox—it has learned to incarcerate fewer children overall, but its enduring machinery of formal probation, racial disparity, and prosecutorial direct-file reveals a stubborn habit of treating the most vulnerable youth as miniature adults, not kids in need.
Demographic and Arrest Trends
- In 2020, the juvenile arrest rate for all offenses reached its lowest level since at least 1980
- Black youth are 4.4 times as likely to be arrested as white youth
- Female arrests accounted for approximately 30% of all juvenile arrests in 2020
- The number of arrests involving persons under 18 fell by 38% between 2019 and 2020
- For every 100,000 juveniles in the US population, 1,489 were arrested in 2020
- Indigenous youth are nearly 3 times more likely to be arrested than white youth
- Violent crime arrests for juveniles declined by 78% from the peak in 1994 to 2020
- Hispanic youth represent approximately 18% of all juvenile arrests nationally
- Youth under age 15 accounted for 29% of all juvenile arrests in 2020
- There were approximately 424,300 arrests of juveniles in the US in 2020
- Juvenile property crime arrest rates fell 74% between 2011 and 2020
- In 2020, the arrest rate for simple assault among juveniles was 228.6 per 100,000
- Weapon law violation arrests for juveniles decreased 45% between 2011 and 2020
- Drug abuse violation arrests for youth under 18 decreased 70% from 2011 to 2020
- In 2020, males accounted for 80% of juvenile arrests for violent crimes
- The juvenile arrest rate for murder was 3.1 per 100,000 in 2020
- High school dropout rates are 5 times higher for youth who have been arrested once compared to peers
- Enrollment in the juvenile justice system peak occurs at age 16 for most demographic groups
- Status offense arrests (like truancy) have declined by over 60% since 2005
- In 2020, the arrest rate for robbery among juveniles was 18.7 per 100,000
- Asian and Pacific Islander youth have the lowest arrest rate among all racial groups at 314 per 100,000
- 1 in 10 juvenile arrests in 2020 was for a violent crime
- Curfew and loitering arrests for juveniles dropped 82% between 2011 and 2020
- Runaway arrests for juveniles decreased 81% in the last decade
- Juvenile arrests for motor vehicle theft increased slightly against trends in 2019-2020
- Aggravated assault accounts for 58% of all juvenile violent crime arrests
- Larceny-theft accounts for 68% of all juvenile property crime arrests
- In 2020, 16% of all arrests for arson involved juveniles
- Jurisdictions with lower age limits of 7 exist in several US states for arrest capability
- Juvenile arrest rates in rural areas are often lower but declining slower than in urban areas
Demographic and Arrest Trends Interpretation
While overall juvenile arrests have plummeted to historic lows—a promising trend of systemic change and reduced youth crime—this progress is marred by the stark and persistent reality that justice is not colorblind, as Black youth are still over four times more likely to be arrested than their white peers.
Detention and Incarceration
- On a single day in 2019, 36,479 youth were held in residential placement facilities
- Youth of color represent 67% of the total population in juvenile residential placement
- Approximately 40% of youth in placement are held in private facilities
- The number of youth in placement has declined 70% from its peak in 1999
- 1 in 5 youth in placement is held for a status offense or technical violation of probation
- Black youth are 4.6 times more likely to be incarcerated than white youth
- Girls represent 15% of the total incarcerated juvenile population
- 44% of incarcerated girls are held for status offenses or technical violations
- The average length of stay in a juvenile facility is approximately 4 to 6 months
- Over 500 juveniles are held in adult jails on any given day in the US
- 92% of youth in placement are there for a delinquent offense
- Tribal youth are incarcerated at more than double the rate of white youth
- Around 30% of incarcerated youth are placed in facilities for property crimes
- 37% of youth in placement are held for offenses involving person-on-person violence
- 52% of youth in residential facilities are in locked, high-security settings
- 14% of youth in residential facilities are held in open settings with minimal locks
- Solitary confinement is still practiced in juvenile facilities in 25 states
- On a census day, 1,444 youth were being held for drug-related offenses
- Hispanic youth are 1.3 times more likely to be incarcerated than white youth
- 61% of youth in private facilities are youth of color
- Public facilities house 60% of incarcerated youth nationally
- Average daily population of youth in detention declined 14% between 2017 and 2019
- 3% of incarcerated youth are under the age of 13
- Residential facilities with more than 100 beds house 22% of incarcerated youth
- Overcrowding exists in 12% of juvenile residential facilities
- 6% of youth in placement are held for public order offenses
- Admission to detention occurs 652,000 times annually across the US
- Approximately 2,900 youth are in adult prisons on any given day
- Post-adjudication placement accounts for 73% of youth in residences
- Pre-adjudication detention accounts for 26% of youth in residences
Detention and Incarceration Interpretation
While celebrating a 70% decline since 1999, we must confront the system's stark, lingering engine of inequity, where plummeting overall numbers still mask a reality where youth of color are disproportionately funneled into locked facilities, often for minor missteps, while solitary confinement and adult jails remain in the playbook.
Health and Welfare
- Up to 70% of youth in the juvenile justice system have at least one mental health condition
- 20% of youth in the juvenile justice system have a serious mental illness
- 30% of youth in the system have a learning disability
- Suicide is a leading cause of death for youth in juvenile facilities
- 60% of youth in the system have a substance use disorder
- 90% of youth in the juvenile justice system report having experienced at least one traumatic event
- LGBTQ+ youth are overrepresented in the system at twice the rate of the general population
- 40% of girls in the juvenile justice system have been victims of sexual abuse
- Approximately 50% of youth in the system have been involved with the child welfare system
- 1 in 10 youth in juvenile facilities has a parent incarcerated
- Approximately 15% of youth in the system require special education services
- 75% of youth in the juvenile justice system have a history of trauma
- Youth in the system are 3 times more likely to have a developmental disability than the general population
- 50% of incarcerated girls report attempting suicide
- Substance abuse is identified in 80% of youth who recidivate
- Only 48% of juvenile facilities provide adequate mental health screening for all youth
- 33% of youth in placement report experiencing physical force from staff
- 7.1% of youth in juvenile facilities reported sexual victimization in 2018
- Transgender youth represent approximately 1% of the total juvenile justice population but face higher abuse rates
- 65% of youth with mental health disorders in the system are not receiving treatment
- 1 in 4 youth in detention has a chronic medical condition like asthma
- Youth in the system are 4 times more likely to have vision problems than the general population
- 25% of incarcerated youth have a father who has been incarcerated
- Over 70% of youth in the system have a history of school suspension
- 15% of youth in detention report they have no one to visit them
- Homelessness affects 10-20% of youth entering the juvenile justice system
- 80% of court-involved youth live in families with incomes below the poverty line
- 40% of youth in the system report food instability at home
- Youth with ADHD are 2-3 times more likely to be involved with the system
- Exposure to lead in childhood is correlated with a 10% increase in juvenile delinquency risk
Health and Welfare Interpretation
The juvenile justice system often seems less a place for correcting criminals and more a tragic, punitive warehouse for society's most vulnerable and traumatized children, as if we are punishing the invoice for damages we refused to pay when it was just a bill.
Recidivism and Economic Impacts
- Recidivism rates within 3 years for youth released from residential care range from 70% to 80% in some states
- It costs an average of $214,620 per year to incarcerate a single youth in a state facility
- Community-based programs for youth cost approximately $75 per day compared to $588 for incarceration
- Investing $1 million in rehabilitation programs for youth saves $7-$10 million in future costs
- 55% of youth released from juvenile facilities are rearrested within one year
- One year after release, 24% of former juvenile offenders are re-convicted
- Youth who have been incarcerated earn 10-30% less over their lifetime than non-incarcerated peers
- Education programs in juvenile facilities reduce recidivism by 13%
- 66% of youth who are incarcerated do not return to school after release
- Re-arrest rates among youth released from private facilities are 5% lower than state facilities in some studies
- High-intensity supervision programs (probation) cost about $10,000 per youth per year
- Family-based therapy for youth (Functional Family Therapy) has a return on investment of 1,300%
- Victim-offender mediation programs reduce re-offending by up to 26%
- 33% of states do not track long-term (multi-year) recidivism for juveile offenders
- Vocational training in facilities increases employment rates by 12% post-release
- The total national cost of juvenile incarceration is estimated at $5 billion annually
- Black youth are 50% more likely to be rearrested vs white youth within 2 years
- Recidivism is 15-20% lower for youth who receive community-based mental health treatment
- States that reduced juvenile incarceration by 50% also saw a 40% drop in juvenile crime
- 18% of youth released from residential placement return to a facility within one year
- Scared Straight programs actually increase recidivism by 13%
- Multisystemic Therapy (MST) decreases the risk of future incarceration by 64%
- 40% of incarcerated youth have no high school credits after 6 months in a facility
- Youth transferred to adult court are 34% more likely to be rearrested than those in juvenile court
- 75% of juvenile justice budgets are spent on residential costs despite community programs serving more youth
- Direct legal costs for a juvenile murder case average $40,000 for the state
- Juveniles on probation are required to pay fees/fines in 40 states, creating economic barriers
- Restorative justice programs result in 90% satisfaction rates for victims and offenders
- Taxpayers save $21,000 for every child diverted from the system into community care
- Formal labor market participation for youth in the system is 20% lower than peers 5 years post-release
Recidivism and Economic Impacts Interpretation
The system seems to be spending a fortune on a revolving door, meticulously funding its own failure while ignoring proven, cheaper, and more humane solutions that actually work.
Sources & References
- Reference 1OJJDPojjdp.ojp.govVisit source
- Reference 2OJJDPojjdp.govVisit source
- Reference 3FBIfbi.govVisit source
- Reference 4SENTENCINGPROJECTsentencingproject.orgVisit source
- Reference 5AECFaecf.orgVisit source
- Reference 6NCSLncsl.orgVisit source
- Reference 7PRISONPOLICYprisonpolicy.orgVisit source
- Reference 8BJSbjs.ojp.govVisit source
- Reference 9LOWENSTEINlowenstein.comVisit source
- Reference 10NAMInami.orgVisit source
- Reference 11NJDCnjdc.infoVisit source
- Reference 12JUSTICEjustice.govVisit source
- Reference 13DRUGABUSEdrugabuse.govVisit source
- Reference 14NCTSNnctsn.orgVisit source
- Reference 15MOVEMENTADVANCEMENTPROJECTmovementadvancementproject.orgVisit source
- Reference 16THEARCthearc.orgVisit source
- Reference 17CDCcdc.govVisit source
- Reference 18NN4YOUTHnn4youth.orgVisit source
- Reference 19FEEDINGAMERICAfeedingamerica.orgVisit source
- Reference 20CHADDchadd.orgVisit source
- Reference 21BROOKINGSbrookings.eduVisit source
- Reference 22JUSTICEPOLICYjusticepolicy.orgVisit source
- Reference 23WSIPPwsipp.wa.govVisit source
- Reference 24URBANurban.orgVisit source
- Reference 25OJPojp.govVisit source